HomeMy WebLinkAboutBoard of Water and Light Minutes 05.19.26Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 1 of 31
Approved by the Board of Commissioners 07-28-2026
MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS MEETING
LANSING BOARD OF WATER AND LIGHT
May 19, 2026
The Board of Commissioners met at the Lansing Board of Water and Light (BWL) Headquarters-
REO Town Depot located at 1201 S. Washington Ave., Lansing, MI, on Tuesday, May 19, 2026.
This meeting was publicly notified for 5:30 p.m.
Chairperson David Price called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Corporate Secretary, Lavella J. Todd, called the roll.
The following Commissioners were present: Chairperson David Price; Commissioners Beth
Graham, Chris Harkins, Semone James (Arrived at 5:50 p.m.), DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, Dale
Schrader, and Sandra Zerkle.
Absent: None.
Corporate Secretary Lavella Todd declared a quorum.
Chairperson David Price requested Commissioner DeShon Leek lead the pledge of allegiance.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion by Commissioner Chris Harkins, Seconded by Commissioner Tony Mullen to approve the
Regular Board Meeting minutes of March 24, 2026
Action: Motion Carried
PUBLIC COMMENT
Gary Fairfax proposed to the board a rebate program that would reduce electricity rates for
homeowners using groundwater heat pumps, air-to-air heat pumps, and baseboard heating
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 2 of 31
after 500 kWh. He stated that ground water heat pumps are the most efficient, as they use a
consistently warm source, and that lowering rates after 500 kWh would encourage the use of
electricity for heating.
COMMUNICATIONS
Electronic mail from Niesha Partee regarding BWL Customer Service Experience . Referred to
Management. Received and Placed on File.
Electronic mail from Calvin McClinton re: Request for Board Review. Received and Placed on File.
Electronic mail from Gary Fairfax regarding energy efficiency programs. Referred to
Management. Received and Placed on File.
Electronic mail from Anonymous re: Request for Board Explanation. Referred to Management.
Received and Placed on File.
COMMITTEE REPORTS
Committee of the Whole Chairperson Sandra Zerkle presented the Committee of the Whole
Meeting Report:
COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE
Meeting Minutes
May 7, 2026
The Committee of the Whole of the Lansing Board of Water and Light (BWL) met at the BWL
Headquarters-REO Town Depot located at 1201 S Washington Ave., Lansing, MI, on
Thursday, May 7, 2026.
Chairperson Sandra Zerkle called the Committee of the Whole Meeting to order at 5:32
p.m. and asked the Corporate Secretary to call the roll.
Present: Commissioners Sandra Zerkle, Beth Graham, Chris Harkins, Semone James,
DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, David Price, and Dale Schrader.
Absent: Commissioner Tony Mullen.
Corporate Secretary LaVella Todd declared a quorum.
Public Comments
There were no public comments.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 3 of 31
Approval of Minutes
Motion by Commissioner David Price, Seconded by Commissioner Beth Graham, to
approve the Committee of the Whole Meeting minutes of March 10, 2026.
Action: Motion carried. The minutes were approved.
Retirement Plan Committee (RPC) Update
Chief Financial Officer Scott Taylor presented the Retirement Plan Committee (RPC)
update. The RPC Committee added a US small-cap manager to further diversify the VEBA
portfolio. A minor asset-allocation change was approved by the committee for presentation
to the board and will be presented to the full board in July for final approval. Sage Advisory
Services was selected for the DB plan’s liability-driven strategy due to lower fees and a
more personalized service. Underperforming funds were identified and will be replaced to
strengthen the DC plan with a net-neutral fee impact. Two active participants remain in the
defined benefit plan.
Commissioner Chris Harkins questioned, without divulging personal details, how much
longer the remaining two participants plan to remain active in the defined benefit plan.
CFO Taylor stated the estimated range for those participants was five to ten years.
Additionally, CFO Taylor continued to provide an update on Nationwide. Nationwide loan
interest rates were incorrectly set to 0.25% higher, affecting 32 loans. The corrections
applied the proper rate and reallocated excess payments to principal, shortening future
loan terms. An automatic rate update process at Nationwide will replace the annual
manual update to prevent future errors. A BWL HRIS system error also occurred which mis-
populated new hire dates in Workday, causing premature 401 (a) contributions, but they
were corrected, and the participants were informed of the error.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle questions why Nationwide didn’t immediately correct the
interest rates. CFO Taylor confirmed that although it took Nationwide several months to
catch the error, but once it was discovered, it was corrected immediately.
Rate Strategy
General Manager Peffley introduced a proposed FY2027 rate strategy and associated utility
industry trends. He noted the proposed 2% electric rate increase is significantly lower than
the increases being experienced by many Michigan utilities, which are averaging
approximately 5% or higher, with some utilities seeking increases near 10%. It was
emphasized that the proposed strategy supports the BWL strategic goals while remaining
below inflation and reflects the organization’s philosophy of growing revenue through new
customer growth rather than placing additional burden on existing customers. He also
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 4 of 31
expressed expectations for minimal public opposition compared to prior years, noting
previous increases were partially attributable to delayed rate adjustments during the
COVID-19 pandemic. CFO Taylor introduced Rates Manager Bob Blank from Utility
Financial Solutions (UFS). UFS has been working with the BWL since 2017 and has worked
with many utilities across the world. He provided an overview of the rate study process,
industry trends, and cost-of-service analysis. He also explained the importance of long-
term financial planning, cost-of-service studies, and gradual movement toward equitable
rate structures across customer classes. Industry trends discussed included
electrification, energy efficiency programs, distributed energy resources, time-of-use
pricing, electric vehicle charging strategies, and infrastructure modernization. UFS Blank
also emphasized the importance of properly structured customer service charges to
ensure fixed utility costs are fairly recovered from all customers year-round.
CFO Taylor reviewed several major infrastructure and operational investments supported
by the proposed rates, including electric system reliability initiatives, the Lansing Energy
Tomorrow program, vegetation management, cybersecurity improvements, water
infrastructure upgrades, and environmental compliance efforts. Staff highlighted that
system reliability investments have provided measurable customer value and that
continued infrastructure replacement and modernization remain critical due to significant
inflationary increases in utility equipment and materials since 2019. Additional discussion
focused on the Board’s long-standing rate-making principles, including maintaining
financially self-supporting utilities and aligning rates with cost-of-service standards. CFO
Taylor explained that proposed rate increases vary by customer class to gradually move
rates closer to actual service costs while minimizing sudden impacts on customers.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle questions whether the BWL has a way of tracking the output
of street lighting. GM Peffley explained with the new conversion to LED lights they have a
good handle on the amount of energy used. CFO Taylor also discussed ongoing efforts to
modernize street lighting infrastructure through LED conversions and the importance of
balancing cost recovery with customer affordability.
Commissioner Chris Harkins noted difficulty tracking information between presentation
slides and asked for clarification regarding projected revenue numbers for the large
commercial and industrial category. Specifically, he questioned why projected revenues
shown on one slide did not align with totals reflected on another slide. CFO Taylor
explained that the discrepancy was due to the second sheet isolating only the standard
rate classifications, while additional revenues from time-of-use rates and high load factor
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 5 of 31
rates were included within the broader customer class totals. He also clarified that certain
smaller rate categories had been grouped into an “other” classification. Commissioner
Chris Harkins stated that it would be helpful to provide a clearer crosswalk between the
slides so the information could be more easily tracked line-by-line, particularly regarding
lighting and streetlight adjustments. CFO Taylor acknowledged and thanked Harkins for the
feedback and indicated that there would be multiple public hearings and additional
opportunities to revise, simplify and improve the presentation materials before public
release. Discussion continued regarding extra-large industrial customer rates.
Commissioner Dale Schrader questioned why extra-large industrial rates appeared to
increase by 4.4% while corresponding cost-of-service information was difficult to identify
in the presentation. CFO Taylor clarified that the first chart reflected the results of the cost-
of-service study only and did not represent actual proposed rate increases. The cost-of-
service study identified gaps between current revenue generation and target revenue
requirements. He explained that the second slide reflected the proposed rate design
adjustments informed by those findings. After further review, CFO Taylor acknowledged
that naming conventions between “commercial” and “industrial” categories allowed for
confusion and agreed that revisions were needed to improve clarity.
Commissioner Semone James asked what alternatives had been considered and what
factors led staff to recommend the proposed rate strategy. CFO Taylor explained that the
proposed approach was intended to achieve a balanced outcome. The Board had targeted
an overall utility increase of approximately 2%, while simultaneously working to align
customer classes more closely with cost-of-service targets. He also stated that the
process involved determining how far each customer class deviated from its cost-of-
service level and then allocating increases accordingly while maintaining the overall 2%
revenue target. GM Peffley further explained that the lower rate strategy reflected both
financial and political considerations. It was noted that the utility had previously pursued
aggressive renewable energy investments and that customers were increasingly focused
on affordability and reliability rather than exceeding environmental compliance
requirements. He stated that maintaining competitiveness with neighboring utilities and
recognizing economic pressures facing Lansing residents were significant considerations
in recommending a lower overall increase.
CFO Taylor then reviewed historical rate increases, noting that the utility had paused
increases for several years following COVID-19, followed by larger increases in 2024 and
2025 to recover costs. Proposed increases for 2026 included: Electric 2.04%, Water 2.3%,
Steam 5.51% and Chilled Water 0%.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 6 of 31
GM Peffley explained that steam rates remained elevated because the utility was currently
operating both the steam and hot water systems simultaneously during the transition
period. Once the conversion to hot water was complete, management anticipated
significantly lower operating costs and more attractive rates.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle asked whether the utility was still recovering from the period
of 31 months without rate increases. GM Peffley responded that recovery largely occurred
during 2024 and 2025 and acknowledged that those increases had been difficult for
customers. However, he emphasized that over the long term, the utility rate strategy had
historically remained below inflation.
CFO Taylor next reviewed customer bill impact analyses for electric, water, steam, and
chilled water customers. He explained that customer impacts varied depending on usage
patterns, fixed customer charges, and demand charges. Impact analyses were performed
across a broad range of customer profiles to ensure no customer group experienced
excessive increases outside acceptable ranges.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle asked whether the utility planned to communicate to major
corporations and small businesses that efforts were being made to minimize rate increases
given broader economic pressures. GM Peffley stated that formal communications had not
yet begun because approval from the governing body was still pending. However, he
expressed confidence that customers would recognize the utility’s comparatively lower
increases relative to neighboring utilities.
CFO Taylor emphasized that the proposed increases still allowed the utility to meet key
financial metrics and maintain operational reliability. Staff reviewed the residential electric
rate structure, including Standard residential time-of-use rates, Off-Peak Savers rates, and
Electric vehicle charging meter options.
Commissioner Chris Harkins asked whether the EV charging rate was also a time-of-use
rate and whether it offered lower pricing than the standard residential rate. CFO Taylor
confirmed that the EV charging option was a time-of-use rate with lower off-peak pricing
designed specifically for EV charging customers. He explained that customers installing a
dedicated EV charging meter would pay a lower kilowatt-hour rate than customers charging
through standard residential service.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 7 of 31
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle suggested moving the simplified rate structure slides toward
the beginning of the public presentation because they were easier to understand and
provided useful context early in the discussion. CFO Taylor agreed to consider reorganizing
the presentation accordingly.
CFO Taylor then reviewed summer and winter time-of-use pricing comparisons. It was
explained that the Off-Peak Savers rate offered customers substantial savings
opportunities if they shifted energy usage outside peak hours. He emphasized that the
utility was gradually transitioning customers toward rates more closely aligned with cost-
of-service realities while giving customers time to adapt their usage patterns.
During the presentation, commissioners identified an error on a slide where both peak and
off-peak periods were incorrectly labeled as “12.” Staff acknowledged the mistake and will
correct the issue for future presentations.
CFO reviewed renewable energy rate structures, including distributed generation and
legacy net metering programs. CFO Taylor explained that traditional net metering was not
sustainable long term because customers were previously credited at full retail rates for
excess energy generation, even though retail rates included costs beyond energy itself,
such as billing infrastructure and system maintenance. Under the new distributed
generation structure, customers are compensated based on the actual market value of the
energy supplied back to the system rather than the full retail rate.
Commissioner Semone James asked how customers were being educated regarding these
rate structures and associated charges. AGM Shawa stated that educational materials
were available through customer service representatives, online calculators, and utility
websites. She also noted that bill inserts and ongoing communications were regularly
distributed to customers regarding available programs and usage management tools.
Commissioner Chris Harkins cautioned against overemphasizing specialized rate
programs in public communications, noting that the vast majority of customers remained
on traditional time-of-use rates. CFO Taylor agreed that communications should remain
balanced and targeted appropriately.
CFO Taylor reviewed proposed updates related to the state-mandated Energy Optimization
program. It was explained that the State of Michigan increased annual energy optimization
requirements from 1% to 1.5%, making compliance more costly. He stated that because
many easy efficiency gains such as LED lighting conversions had already been achieved,
future compliance efforts would require more substantial investments. As a result, the
utility proposed reinstating a dedicated Energy Optimization surcharge to more
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 8 of 31
transparently recover compliance costs. CFO Taylor clarified that this surcharge was
already incorporated into the proposed overall rate increases and did not represent an
additional increase.
CFO Taylor reviewed the completion of the utility’s LED streetlight conversion project. The
conversion reduced the number of streetlight rate classifications from over 120 to nine,
simplifying administration and customer understanding. He then provided a detailed
overview of the steam-to-hot-water conversion project. Approximately 160 customers
currently remain on the steam system, with more than 100 expected to transition to hot
water service. Approximately 58 customers are expected to be disconnected because of
location limitations or building infrastructure constraints. To assist affected customers,
CFO Taylor proposed a “Steam-to-Electric Rate Transition Credit” program. The program
would provide qualifying customers with electric rate credits for up to 10 years to offset
costs associated with transitioning away from steam service.
Commissioner Chris Harkins asked why the program was structured as a 10-year credit
period.
CFO Taylor explained that 10 years approximately reflected the useful life of replacement
heating investments such as electric boilers or alternative heating systems.
Commissioner Semone James asked how the utility would recover the costs associated
with the transition credit. CFO Taylor responded that the transition costs were considered
part of the broader investment in converting to a more efficient hot water system, which
would ultimately reduce operational costs for the utility overall.
Commissioner Beth Graham asked about the number of residential customers affected by
the transition. AGM Shawa stated that only four or five residential customers remained on
the steam system, with most affected customers being commercial or institutional
entities. She further explained that all affected customers had already received direct
communication and that individualized transition meetings were ongoing.
CFO Taylor reviewed updates to water rates, including continued affordability measures for
customers using two CCF or less. He also proposed updates to bulk water rates for hydrant
permit holders and water haulers. It was explained that prior bulk water pricing only
recovered commodity costs and failed to account for broader system costs. Revised rates
would more accurately reflect the true cost of providing service. CFO Taylor introduced the
proposed hot water utility rate structure, which included contract demand charges,
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 9 of 31
commodity charges, fuel cost adjustment factors, and temperature differential adjustment
factors.
CFO Taylor explained that customers would be expected to return water at appropriate
temperatures to maximize system efficiency. Customers failing to sufficiently extract heat
before returning water would be subject to temperature differential penalties.
Commissioner Semone James asked questions regarding how customers-controlled
temperature differentials and system efficiency. CFO Taylor and GM Peffley explained that
customers-controlled heat extraction through building circulation systems and
maintenance of heat exchangers. Proper maintenance ensured efficient system operation
and prevented unnecessary costs from being shifted to all customers. CFO Taylor reviewed
ongoing customer assistance efforts, including Community resource fairs, Public Act 95
assistance, Flexible payment options, levelized billing programs, payment kiosks, and
pennies for power assistance programs. He stated that over $4 million had been secured
through community resource fairs and Public Act 95 programs to assist customers with
utility bills.
Commissioner David Price provided feedback regarding the upcoming public hearing
presentations. He recommended shortening and simplifying the presentation significantly
for the public audience. He stated that the public would primarily want to understand the
percentage rate increase, the estimated bill impact, a historical comparison, and
comparisons with neighboring utilities. CFO Taylor agreed and stated that the public
presentation would likely be condensed while still providing essential information.
Return on Equity
CFO Taylor next presented the negotiated Return on Equity agreement with the City of
Lansing. He reported that an agreement had been reached between BWL and City
management for a 6% return on equity for a two-year period and that it would now be up to
the BWL Board and City Council to approve. The agreement also excluded inter-utility sales
from the calculation and allowed the City of Lansing to receive 6% of any performance
exceeding budget projections. CFO Taylor noted that payment timing adjustments were
also included to assist the City with quarterly obligations. A resolution approving the
agreement was introduced.
Motion by Commissioner Semone James, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins, to
forward the Return on Equity Resolution to the full Board for consideration.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Policy Update
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 10 of 31
Vernon Woodley, Inclusion Manager, presented proposed revisions to the Corporate
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Policy. Inclusion Manager Woodley explained that the
existing policy has been operational since 2008 . He outlined eight primary updates
included in the revised policy. Updated language and alignment with current organizational
priorities. Addition of required scope and purpose statements. Strengthened commitment
to inclusion and respect. Alignment with equal opportunity, anti-discrimination, and anti-
harassment policies. Increased focus on workforce development and employee
advancement. Greater emphasis on community engagement. Establishment of ongoing
sustainability and maintenance requirements. Creation of a four-year policy review process
to ensure accountability. A resolution was presented to approve the updated policy.
Commissioner Semone James asked questions regarding implementation and
accountability measures associated with the revised policy. Inclusion Manager Woodley
explained that all new managers entering the organization are required to complete
diversity, equity and inclusion foundation for inclusive management training. He stated that
the utility currently offers several structured programs, including training for new
employees and the Emerging Leaders Program, and additional diversity and inclusion
development initiatives. Inclusion Manager Woodley also noted that the organization has
implemented tracking measures to ensure all new managers complete required training
within six months of assuming their positions. He further explained that the utility is
actively tracking participation and engagement metrics related to diversity, equity &
inclusion activities and programming.
Commissioner Semone James asked how frequently the Board would receive updates
regarding completion of diversity, equity, & inclusion related metrics and initiatives. Chief
of Staff Williams explained that DEI updates are included in the Board’s monthly highlights
and stated that staff would be willing to provide additional updates directly to the Board at
any frequency desired by the Board.
Commissioner Semone James then asked whether legal counsel had reviewed the revised
policy for compliance with federal and state law. Inclusion Manager Woodley confirmed
that the policy underwent legal review prior to executive review and committee
consideration. He stated that both internal and external legal counsel reviewed the policy
and provided feedback before it advanced through the approval process.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle referenced prior Board discussions regarding the utility’s
recognition within the community for its diversity and inclusion efforts. She stated that the
revised policy maintained the spirit of the organization’s prior commitments while
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 11 of 31
modernizing language and organizational alignment. Commissioner Sandra Zerkle
expressed appreciation for the continuation of those efforts.
Commissioner Semone James also acknowledged her appreciation for all the efforts made
by the staff. She stated that the political environment surrounding diversity, equity &
inclusion initiatives hasn’t been positive and expressed appreciation that the Board and
staff continued to support diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts and recognized the
positive results those programs provide.
Commissioner Semone James also asked how the organization had navigated recent
federal-level scrutiny regarding diversity, equity & inclusion programs, noting that some
organizations nationally had eliminated DEI initiatives out of concern for losing federal
funding or facing regulatory challenges.
Chief of Staff Williams responded that BWL was not directly impacted in that regard. She
emphasized that leadership support for diversity, equity, and inclusion culture remained
strong throughout the organization and that all current efforts remain fully compliant with
applicable laws.
Inclusion Manager Woodley further elaborated that all initiatives undertaken by the utility
are reviewed to ensure compliance. He emphasized that the organization’s programs are
designed to be inclusive of all employees and are intended to benefit the organization and
community broadly. He also highlighted several recent initiatives, including the launch of
the organization’s first Employee Business Resource Group focused on veterans. He
explained that although the group centers on veteran-related issues, participation is open
to all employees, including non-veteran allies. Inclusion Manager Woodley also announced
the launch of a new Diversity Champion Award program intended to recognize employees
for contributions to diversity and inclusion efforts both within the utility and throughout the
community. He acknowledged the broader political climate surrounding diversity, equity &
inclusion discussions nationally but reiterated that the organization’s efforts remain lawful,
inclusive, and aligned with organizational and community goals.
Motion by Commissioner David Price, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins, to
forward the Corporate Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Resolution to the full Board for
consideration.
Other
Motion by Commissioner David Price, Seconded by Commissioner Semone James, for
excused absences for Commissioner Tony Mullen.
Action: Motion Carried.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 12 of 31
Adjourn
Chairperson Sandra Zerkle adjourned the meeting at 7:35 p.m.
Finance Committee Chairperson Dale Schrader presented the Finance Committee Meeting
Report:
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Meeting Minutes
May 7, 2026
Finance Committee: Dale Schrader, Committee Chairperson; Beth Graham, Chris Harkins,
David Price; Alternates: Semone James, Tony Mullen.
The Finance Committee of the Board of Water and Light (BWL) met at the BWL Headquarters
– REO Town Depot, located at 1201 S. Washington Ave., Lansing, MI, on Thursday, May 7,
2026.
Finance Committee Chairperson Dale Schrader called the meeting to order at 7:45 p.m. and
asked the Corporate Secretary to call the roll.
Present: Commissioners Dale Schrader, Beth Graham, Chris Harkins and David Price; Also
Present: Commissioners Semone James, DeSon Leek and Sandra Zerkle.
Absent: Alternate: Tony Mullen
Corporate Secretary LaVella Todd declared a quorum.
Public Comments
There were no public comments.
Approval of Minutes
Motion by Commissioner David Price, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins, to
approve the Finance Committee Meeting minutes of March 10, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried. The minutes were approved.
YTD Financial Summary
CFO Taylor presented the year-to-date financial summary, reporting that days cash on hand
are in a good position at 212 days and that revenue performance for retail and wholesale
operations is favorable. He stated that operating spending is within 1% of the budget and that
the net income currently exceeds budget projections by approximately $17 million. CFO
Taylor projects ending the fiscal year at least $10 million above budgeted net income, barring
any major unforeseen events.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 13 of 31
CFO Taylor explained that the capital improvement budget remains largely unchanged from
prior updates. Key factors include turbine overhauls that pushed portions of the capital
budget beyond budgeted amounts, delays in battery and solar projects within the new
energy category, and steam and water projects that remained close to budget expectations.
CFO Taylor presented positive performance across several financial indicators. The
operating ratio remains strong due to favorable revenues and controlled expenses. The debt-
to-asset ratio remains an area requiring long-term improvement. Days sales outstanding
remain close to the target at 27, and bad debt performance continues to exceed
expectations. Employee count remains at 787 with a budget of 829.
Commissioner Chris Harkins requested additional detail regarding the capital budget
exceeding year-to-date projections. CFO Taylor explained that approximately $36 million in
turbine overhauls accounted for the overage. Excluding those unexpected repairs, spending
would be largely aligned with budget expectations.
Commissioner Semone James asked what portion of the favorable net income performance
was recurring versus one-time, weather-related, or market-driven. CFO Taylor stated that
additional analysis would be needed to fully separate those drivers and committed to
providing additional information.
Commissioner Semone James also raised questions regarding whether excess net income
should be used to reduce future rate pressure, increase reserves, accelerate capital
improvements, or reduce debt. CFO Taylor responded that these considerations are
incorporated into long-term forecasting and cash planning processes.
Commissioner Semone James asked about major risks affecting the days cash on hand and
debt service coverage ratios. CFO Taylor identified unplanned capital expenditures and
unforeseen revenue impacts as the largest risks but stated current forecasts remain stable.
FY2027-2032 Budget and Forecast
GM Peffley opened the FY2027 budget discussion by noting that departments were asked to
significantly reduce spending requests while still maintaining reliability, operational goals,
and strategic priorities. He acknowledged that the process was challenging due to
inflationary pressures and ongoing infrastructure needs but stated that departments believe
they can continue meeting organizational goals under the proposed budget if spending is
carefully managed. He also noted that the organization successfully managed prior budget
reductions while still producing surplus income and expressed optimism about future
revenue growth.
CFO Taylor then reviewed the organization’s strategic accomplishments and how the
proposed budget supports long-term priorities. He highlighted ongoing customer and
community initiatives, workforce development efforts, diversity and inclusion programs,
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 14 of 31
carbon neutrality planning, and infrastructure reliability improvements. CFO Taylor also
emphasized the importance of maintaining strong financial stability, including preserving
the organization’s credit rating, which helps reduce borrowing costs and reflects strong
governance and financial management practices.
He explained that the FY2027 budget continues to support key strategic priorities moving
forward, including infrastructure improvements, workforce development, environmental
initiatives, and long-term financial sustainability. Particular attention was given to
maintaining adequate cash reserves, debt service coverage, and return-on-asset targets.
CFO Taylor stated that the target return on assets for the period is 5.92%, which represents
an increase from the prior year as the organization continues refining its long-term financial
strategy.
Several major assumptions impacting the budget and forecast were discussed. CFO Taylor
reported that the LG battery plant still intends to reach its originally projected 80-megawatt
load; however, the timeline has shifted significantly, with full operations now projected for
June 2030. He described the continued commitment to the project as positive despite
delays and broader disruptions within the electric vehicle industry.
CFO Taylor also discussed the Moltke Ridge Wind Project, explaining that while the project
remains a key component of the organization’s carbon neutrality strategy, financial
assumptions related to the project were conservatively removed from the forecast due to
ongoing challenges involving transmission capacity, upgrade costs, and regulatory
considerations. He stressed that the project is still actively being pursued.
Additional discussion focused on the CTG-1 turbine unit. Following significant recent
overhaul expenses for CTG-2 and CTG-3, management stated that they intend to delay major
work on CTG-1 until the performance of the recently repaired units can be evaluated. The
organization is taking a cautious approach before committing to additional large capital
expenditures.
CFO Taylor also addressed General Motors’ stated intention to discontinue steam service by
December 2027 in favor of self-generation. Leadership explained that discussions with GM
remain ongoing and that the organization hopes to transition the customer to hot water
service instead. He described the negotiations as ongoing and indicated that the customer’s
long-term carbon neutrality goals may ultimately favor partnership with the utility.
Sales forecasts were then reviewed across all utilities. Electric sales are expected to
increase over time due to industrial growth, electrification trends, electric vehicle adoption,
and renewable energy expansion. Water sales are projected to remain relatively stable with
modest growth connected indirectly to industrial demand. Steam and hot water sales are
expected to decline due to the potential loss of General Motors steam service, customer
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 15 of 31
disconnections, and greater system efficiency associated with hot water conversion
projects. Chilled water sales are projected to remain stable.
CFO Taylor also reviewed several renewable energy investments included in the
organization’s long-term planning efforts. White Tail Solar was highlighted as a recently
launched project and an important component of the organization’s carbon neutrality goals.
Additional renewable projects, including solar and wind initiatives, remain under
development as part of the broader energy transition strategy.
The proposed operating budget was also discussed in greater detail. Labor and benefits
continue to represent the largest share of operating expenses. CFO Taylor noted that
purchased power costs are projected to decline due to operational changes at Belle River,
while fuel costs are expected to rise with the continued operation of Delta Energy Park.
Outside services, including information technology licensing, energy optimization
programs, and tree trimming services, also remain major budget components.
Commissioner Chris Harkins asked questions regarding the organization’s target rate of
return and how those targets may evolve over time. CFO Taylor explained that previous return
targets were considered unrealistic and difficult to achieve, prompting leadership several
years ago to establish more attainable and sustainable financial goals. Now that the
organization is approaching those revised targets, leadership believes future refinements
may include utility-specific return targets and varying targets across future fiscal years. CFO
Taylor paused his portion of the FY2027-2032 Budget and Forecast presentation for Director
of Internal Audit Elisha Franco and Corporate Secretary LaVella Todd to present their
respective departmental FY2027-2032 Budget and Forecast.
FY2027-2032 Department of Internal Audit Budget and Forecast
Director of Internal Audit Elisha Franco presented the budget and forecast for the
Department of Internal Audit, and explained that the proposed budget remains largely
consistent with prior forecasts and includes staffing costs, operating supplies, consulting
services, and support for annual risk assessments. She also plans to conduct an internal
quality assessment in accordance with professional auditing standards.
Commissioner Semone James asked about audit priorities for FY2027, and DIA Elisha
Franco explained that the risk assessment process is currently underway. Final audit
priorities and the formal audit work plan are expected to be presented to the Board in July.
Commissioner Sandra Zerkle questioned whether the labor numbers in the FY2027 budget
included benefits. CFO Taylor explained that the labor number only includes salary and PTO
or Sick Time; it does not include health benefits.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 16 of 31
FY2027-2032 Department of Corporate Secretary Budget and Forecast
Corporate Secretary LaVella J Todd then presented the operating budget and forecast for the
Office of Corporate Secretary and the Office of the Board of Commissioners for fiscal years
2027-2032. CS Todd reviewed budget categories, including travel and conference expenses,
training, office supplies, governance memberships, and professional development. She
explained that travel and conference expenses include participation in the Society of
Corporate Governance and related professional organizations. Training allocations also
included continuing education opportunities for both the Corporate Secretary and the
department’s Administrative Assistant.
CS Todd then reviewed the Board of Commissioners budget categories, including meeting
materials, office supplies, travel, outside services, professional photography fees, and
annual document storage expenses. She specifically highlighted the inclusion of a $35,000
placeholder allocation for a future document storage system upgrade to replace
Smartsheet. She explained that the placeholder was included to ensure funds would be
available once the replacement process moved forward.
Commissioner Semone James asked whether the Smartsheet replacement project was
being coordinated with Information Technology and how the $35,000 estimate had been
determined.
AGM Shawa responded that the estimate was based on preliminary research conducted by
the Chief Information Officer, Vern Myers, utilizing benchmarking data from Gartner. It was
explained that the amount represented a conservative, high-end estimate for first-year
implementation costs, with future annual maintenance costs expected as well. She further
clarified that an RFI process was being prepared to evaluate potential replacement systems.
Commissioner Semone James raised questions regarding governance training expenses and
whether future compliance requirements associated with the City Charter would create
additional costs. CS Todd stated that the proposed budget was intended to accommodate
future governance and compliance training opportunities for commissioners. She noted that
some trainings may carry fees depending on the delivery method, while others could
potentially be conducted internally at little or no additional cost.
FY2027-2032 Budget and Forecast (Continued)
CFO Taylor resumed presentation of the six-year budget forecast and reviewed projected
revenue growth across utility operations. CFO Taylor explained that electric, water, and
chilled water revenues were expected to increase steadily over the forecast period, while
steam and hot water revenues were projected to decline as the steam-to-hot-water
conversion project progresses and system efficiencies improve. He reviewed projected
return-on-equity payments to the City of Lansing and noted that forecasts assumed
continuation of the current agreement throughout the six-year period. He also discussed
projected net income growth, which is expected to increase significantly as utilities
approach their target return levels.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 17 of 31
Commissioner Chris Harkins asked what factors were driving increases in “other operating
expenses.” CFO Taylor explained that inflation was the primary driver, along with
environmental spending associated with remediation projects and compliance activities. He
noted that while the forecast utilized a 2.3% core Consumer Price Index assumption in some
areas, more specific inflation assumptions were applied where better data existed, including
healthcare costs and utility construction inflation.
Commissioner Semone James further asked whether stress testing had been performed
using higher inflation assumptions or increased capital costs. CFO Taylor stated that modest
stress testing had been conducted to evaluate different levels of capital spending and their
impacts on cash flow, although he did not have specific alternative inflation scenarios
immediately available.
CFO Taylor then reviewed the organization’s return-on-assets target, explaining that the
target had increased to 5.92% primarily due to the significantly higher inflation experienced
in utility infrastructure construction and replacement costs. He explained that the utility now
utilizes the Handy-Whitman Index, which tracks utility construction inflation, rather than
relying solely on general inflation metrics. According to CFO Taylor, the revised target, once
reached, would generate approximately $25 million annually for infrastructure reinvestment,
which is necessary to sustain the utility’s approximately $2 billion in infrastructure assets.
CFO Taylor emphasized that despite lower-than-target returns currently appearing in red on
financial projections, the utility is making steady progress toward the target and long-term
financial goals. CFO Taylor explained that the steam-to-hot-water conversion project
temporarily suppresses returns because both systems must operate simultaneously during
conversion while steam assets continue depreciating until removed from service.
CFO Taylor also highlighted organizational efforts to reduce forecasted spending by
approximately $7 million annually in order to support lower rate increases while still
improving returns. Examples included lower-than-expected tree trimming costs, healthcare
restructuring savings, pension funding adjustments, improved bad debt projections, and
refined operating cost estimates for new facilities. He noted that employees throughout the
organization contributed cost-saving ideas regardless of department size.
CFO Taylor stated that electric rate increases were forecasted at approximately 2.3%, while
water rates would require larger future adjustments because current rates remain further
below cost of service. He emphasized that rates presented within the budget and forecast
were not formal rate approvals and would still require separate public rate hearings.
Commissioner Chris Harkins complimented CFO Taylor’s presentation and asked why
management chose to maintain lower water rate increases in the early years despite larger
projected increases later. CFO Taylor responded that the strategy was intended in part to
reduce near-term rate pressure on customers.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 18 of 31
Commissioner Dale Schrader commented that understanding return on assets was initially
difficult from a traditional business perspective but acknowledged its importance for utilities
due to ongoing infrastructure replacement needs. He also asked why employee counts
remained relatively flat throughout the forecast period. GM Peffley responded that
technological advancements and artificial intelligence are expected to create efficiencies in
some areas of the organization, although staffing needs may still grow in operational areas
such as water and transmission and distribution.
CFO Taylor concluded the budget presentation by reviewing capital improvement projects,
including renewable energy investments, the steam-to-hot-water conversion, substation
upgrades, SAP system replacement planning, and ongoing infrastructure replacement
programs. He explained that proactive infrastructure replacement is significantly more cost-
effective than reactive emergency replacement after failures occur.
Following the completion of the presentation, a resolution was presented to be sent to the
full board for approval.
Motion by Commissioner David Price, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins, to
forward the FY2027-2032 Budget and Forecast Resolution to the full Board for
consideration.
Before moving to the next agenda item, CFO Taylor requested recognition of employees who
contributed to the rates and budget presentations. Staff members involved in the
preparation of the presentations stood and were acknowledged and thanked by the
committee.
FY2026 Billing Audit Results
Director of Internal Audit Elisha Franco presented the Fiscal Year 2026 Billing Audit Results.
DIA Franco thanked members of the Customer Experience Department, AMI management,
and supporting staff for their assistance throughout the audit process. DIA Franco explained
that the audit evaluated the effectiveness and accuracy of the billing process, with particular
focus on Advanced Meter Infrastructure (AMI), commonly referred to as smart meters. The
audit reviewed billing execution, exception management, rate accuracy, billing cycles,
adjustments, customer communications, and meter data validation for both AMI and non-
AMI customers. Ms. Franco clarified that audit sampling utilized a “haphazard”
methodology, explaining that the term is an internal auditing term meaning random
customer selection rather than a negative characterization of the process. The audit
reviewed whether bills were calculated correctly based on customer assignment, service
type, and billing cycles.
Audit findings included one medium-risk issue involving incorrect smart meter opt-out fees
for water-only customers due to an error in finalized rules and regulations. DIA Franco stated
that 12 customers were affected and were charged $15 rather than the intended $30 fee.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 19 of 31
One low-risk finding involved a customer being charged the incorrect fee due to a system
configuration issue, which has since been corrected.
DIA Franco also outlined several process improvement recommendations, including
formalizing performance metrics for billing inquiries and dispute resolution, implementing
recurring reviews of billing exception thresholds, formalizing complaint investigation
procedures, and strengthening vendor oversight through SOC 1 and SOC 2 report reviews.
The overall audit opinion was classified as “sufficient,” meaning controls were generally
effective with limited risk exposure and no critical or high-risk findings identified.
Commissioner David Price commented that the audit results were reassuring, particularly
given prior public concerns and social media claims regarding smart meter accuracy and
health concerns. Ms. Franco confirmed that the billing data and meter functionality
appeared accurate based on the audit work performed.
Internal Audit Status Report
Director of Internal Audit Elisha Franco then presented the Internal Audit Status Report and
departmental updates. She reviewed the status of ongoing audits, including billing,
environmental compliance, and information technology audits. She reported that the IT
audit procedures had been completed and discussed audit hours budgeted versus actual
hours utilizes. DIA Franco also reviewed the status of open corrective actions from prior
audits, noting that several items remain open but are progressing on schedule. She
discussed upcoming Fiscal Year 2027 risk assessments and work plan development,
explaining that management surveys were underway and that commissioners may also be
consulted regarding perceived organizational risks.
Additional updates included new board-level guidance principles issued under the COSO
internal control framework, plans for more frequent internal audit communications through
monthly “newsletter-style” updates, and the upcoming start date for the department’s
intern. DIA Franco also announced that she had been elected Senior Vice President of the
Lansing Chapter of the Institute of Internal Auditors for a two-year term. She noted that May
2026 had officially been proclaimed Internal Audit Awareness Month by Governor Gretchen
Whitmer, which she described as a significant recognition for the profession.
Commissioner Semone James asked whether the future Smartsheet replacement
dashboard would include tracking for audit findings, due dates, and outstanding items. DIA
Franco confirmed that the plan was to include those tracking capabilities within the system.
Other
No other business.
Adjourn
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 20 of 31
Chairperson Dale Schrader adjourned the meeting at 9:08 p.m.
Human Resources Chairperson Tony Mullen presented the Human Resources Meeting Report:
HUMAN RESOURCES COMMITTEE
Meeting Minutes
May 12, 2026
Human Resources Committee: Tony Mullen, Committee Chairperson; Commissioners
Semone James, DeShon Leek and Sandra Zerkle; Alternates: David Price, Chris Harkins
The Human Resources Committee of the Lansing Board of Water and Light (BWL) met at the BWL
Headquarters-REO Town Depot located at 1201 S. Washington Ave., Lansing, MI, at 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday,
May 12, 2026.
Vice Chairperson Sandra Zerkle called the meeting to order at 5:05 p.m. and asked the
Corporate Secretary to call the roll.
The following members were present: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, and
Sandra Zerkle; also present: Commissioner Dale Schrader.
Absent: Alternates: Commissioners David Price and Chris Harkins.
(HR Committee Chairperson Tony Mullen arrived at 5:24 p.m.)
The Corporate Secretary declared a quorum.
Public Comments
There were no public comments.
Approval of Minutes
Motion by Commissioner DeShon Leek; Seconded by Commissioner Semone James, to
approve the HR Committee meeting minutes of March 17, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
FY2026 Board Appointee Performance Reviews
General Manager
General Manager Richard R. Peffley requested to go into Closed Session for the purpose
of receiving his contractual year-end performance evaluation as permitted by Open
Meetings Act exemption MCL 15.268(a). He also requested Chief Human Resources Officer
Michael Flowers join him in closed session.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 21 of 31
Motion by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle; Seconded by Commissioner Semone James, to go
into closed session to discuss the contractual year-end performance evaluation of General
Manager, Richard R. Peffley. Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen,
Dale Scrader and Sandra Zerkle were present.
Roll Call Vote:
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek and Sandra Zerkle
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Human Resources Committee went into closed session at 5:08 p.m.
Each Board Member who was physically present had a chance to provide General Manager
Richard R. Peffley with comments and or questions related to the final evaluation
document/process. Commissioners were given as much time as they needed to make any
comments or ask questions of Mr. Peffley.
Motion by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle; Seconded by Commissioner Tony Mullen, to
reconvene into open session.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried
The Human Resources Committee reconvened to open session at 6:14 p.m.
Motion by Commissioner Semone James; Seconded by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle, to forward
the resolution reappointing Richard R. Peffley to the Charter position of General Manager for
FY2027 to the full Board for consideration.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Internal Auditor
Internal Auditor Elisha Franco requested to go into Closed Session for the purpose of
receiving her contractual year-end performance evaluation as permitted by Open Meetings
Act exemption MCL 15.268(a). She also requested Chief Human Resources Officer Michael
Flowers join her in closed session.
Motion by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle; Seconded by Commissioner DeShon Leek, to go
into closed session to discuss the contractual year-end performance evaluation of Internal
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 22 of 31
Auditor Elisha Franco. Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, Dale
Scrader and Sandra Zerkle were present.
Roll Call Vote:
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Human Resources Committee went into closed session at 6:15 p.m.
Each Board Member who was physically present had a chance to provide Internal Auditor Elisha
Franco with comments and or questions related to the final evaluation document/process.
Commissioners were given as much time as they needed to make any comments or ask questions
of Ms. Franco.
Motion by Commissioner DeShon Leek; Seconded by Commissioner Semone James to
reconvene into open session.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried
The Human Resources Committee reconvened to open session at 6:40 p.m.
Motion by Commissioner Semone James; Seconded by Commissioner DeShon Leek, to forward
the resolution reappointing Elisha Franco to the Charter position of Internal Auditor for FY2027
to the full Board for consideration.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Corporate Secretary
Corporate Secretary LaVella J. Todd requested to go into Closed Session for the purpose
of receiving her contractual year-end performance evaluation as permitted by Open
Meetings Act exemption MCL 15.268(a). She also requested Chief Human Resources Officer
Michael Flowers join her in closed session.
Motion by Commissioner Semone James; Seconded by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle, to go
into closed session to discuss the contractual year-end performance evaluation of
Corporate Secretary LaVella J. Todd. Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony
Mullen, Dale Scrader and Sandra Zerkle were present.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 23 of 31
Roll Call Vote:
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen and Sandra Zerkle
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Human Resources Committee went into closed session at 6:41 p.m.
Each Board Member who was physically present had a chance to provide Corporate Secretary
LaVella J. Todd with comments and or questions related to the final evaluation
document/process. Commissioners were given as much time as they needed to make any
comments or ask questions of Ms. Todd.
Motion by Commissioner DeShon Leek; Seconded by Commissioner Sanra Zerkle to
reconvene into open session.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
The Human Resources Committee reconvened to open session at 7:06 p.m.
Motion by Commissioner DeShon Leek; Seconded by Commissioner Semone James, to forward
the resolution reappointing LaVella J. Todd to the Charter position of Corporate Secretary for
FY2027 to the full Board for consideration.
Yeas: Commissioners Semone James, DeShon Leek, Tony Mullen, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
Other
No other business.
Adjourn
HR Chairperson Tony Mullen adjourned the meeting at 7:07 p.m.
MANAGERS RECOMMENDATION
There was no manager's recommendation.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
There was no unfinished business.
NEW BUSINESS
There was no new business.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 24 of 31
RESOLUTIONS
RESOLUTION 2026-05-01
Return on Equity (ROE) Renewal Amendment No. 9
WHEREAS, the City of Lansing has expressed a desire to continue the Agreement Between the
City of Lansing and the Board of Water & Light dated June 30, 1992 (the Agreement), which has
been subsequently extended by means of eight Amendments thereto in 2001, 2012, 2013,
2018, 2020, 2022, 2024, and 2025, respectively; and
WHEREAS, the City of Lansing and the Board of Water & Light agree that the recommended
amendment to the Agreement and the payment provided for therein represents a mutual
balancing of the financial burden of the payment on the Board of Water & Light’s ratepayers,
the financial burden of the use of services and property on the City of Lansing or its taxpayers,
and of the shared services and infrastructure between the Board of Water & Light and the City
of Lansing; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners Committee of the Whole (COW) considered the City of
Lansing’s request on May 7, 2026; and WHEREAS, the General Manager recommended the
Agreement be amended and extended for 2 years at a rate of 6% of total budgeted Board
operating revenues, excluding inter-utility sales, as is in effect at the start of each respective
fiscal year. If actual operating revenues are higher than budgeted operating revenues, the return
on equity payments will be calculated in the amount of 6% of actual operating revenues,
effective July 1, 2026, and will be memorialized as Amendment No. 9; and
WHEREAS, the COW has considered the proposed Amendment No. 9, agreed with the General
Manager’s recommendation and approved the Amendment, including authorization for the
General Manager to execute the Amendment, and the Amendment shall be forwarded to the
Board of Commissioners for approval at the May 19, 2026 Board meeting.
THEREFORE, be it: RESOLVED, the proposed Amendment No. 9 to the Agreement Between the
City of Lansing and The Board of Water & Light dated June 30, 1992 is approved, including
authorization for the General Manager to execute the Amendment.
Motion by Commissioner Dale Schrader, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins to approve
the Return on Equity (ROE) Renewal at a Regular Board Meeting held on May 19, 2026.
Action Motion Carried.
RESOLUTION 2026-05-02
Corporate Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Policy
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 25 of 31
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners (“Board”) adopted a Corporate Inclusion, Equity and
Diversity Policy (“Policy”) on March 28, 2008, which superseded the previously adopted
Corporate Diversity Policy effective April 23, 2002; and
WHEREAS, BWL staff has conducted a review of the Policy and determined revision to the Policy
would enhance understanding and compliance with the policy, and strengthen alignment with
BWL’s vision, values and strategic priorities; and
WHEREAS, the Policy title was changed to Corporate Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Policy to be
consistent with current standards;
THEREFORE, it is: RESOLVED, that the Board adopts and approves the revised Corporate
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Policy effective May 19, 2026, as presented.
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Corporate Inclusion, Equity and Diversity Policy, effective March
28, 2008, is superseded as of May 19, 2026.
Motion by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle, Seconded by Commissioner Beth Graham to adopt the
revised Corporate Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Policy at a Regular Board Meeting held on May
19, 2026. Action: Motion Carried.
RESOLUTION 2026-05-03
Fiscal Year 2027-2032 Budget and Forecast
RESOLVED, that the Annual Operating and Capital Budget covering Fiscal Year 2027 is hereby
approved as presented; and
RESOLVED, that the Operating and Capital Forecast for the Fiscal Years 2028-2032 is hereby
accepted as presented; and
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Corporate Secretary be directed to make the appropriate filings
with the Lansing City Clerk’s office in accordance with the Lansing City Charter regarding the
above actions.
Staff Comments: Staff recommends an operating and maintenance budget of $425.8M and a
capital budget of $113.1M for Fiscal Year 2027. The Operating and Capital Budget and Forecast
for Fiscal Years 2027-2032 includes forecasted rate increases. The forecasted rate increases are
subject to revision and, in any case, prior to implementation, must be subject to the BWL’s
formal rate setting process as per Lansing City Charter, Section 5-205 which refers to the BWL’s
authority to set just and reasonable rates and defines the public hearing process. In accordance
with the provisions of the Lansing City Charter, Article 5, Chapter 2, Section 5-203.5 and Section
5-203.6, staff recommends the Finance Committee approve the budget and forecast for
presentation and adoption by the Board at its May 19, 2026 board meeting.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 26 of 31
Motion by Commissioner Dale Schrader, Seconded by Commissioner Chris Harkins, to approve
the Resolution for the Fiscal Year 2027-2032 Budget and Forecast at a Regular Board Meeting
held on May 19, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
RESOLUTION 2026-05-04
Appointment of the Charter Position of Director and General Manager
WHEREAS, the Board’s Rules of Procedure specify that the Board is to appoint a Director and
General Manager, Internal Auditor, and Corporate Secretary, at its first regular meeting
following July 1st of each year or as soon as practicable thereafter.
RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners hereby appoints the following individual to the
Charter position of General Manager for fiscal year 2026-2027 or until a successor is appointed,
whichever last occurs: Richard R. Peffley, Director and General Manager
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Chairperson of the Board of Commissioners is authorized to
execute any and all contractual amendment documents which reflect merit adjustments
recommended by the Human Resources Committee for fiscal year 2026’s performance.
Motion by Commissioner Tony Mullen Seconded by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle to approve the
reappointment of the Charter Position of Director and General Manager for Fiscal Year 2026-
2027 at a Regular Board Meeting held on May 19, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
RESOLUTION 2026-05-05
Appointment of the Charter Position of Internal Auditor
WHEREAS, the Board’s Rules of Procedure specify that the Board is to appoint a Director and
General Manager, Internal Auditor, and Corporate Secretary, at its first regular meeting
following July 1st of each year or as soon as practicable thereafter.
RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners hereby appoints the following individual to the
Charter position of Internal Auditor for fiscal year 2026-2027 or until a successor is appointed,
whichever last occurs: Elisha Franco, Internal Auditor
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Chairperson of the Board of Commissioners is authorized to
execute any and all contractual amendment documents which reflect merit adjustments
recommended by the Human Resources Committee for fiscal year 2026’s performance.
Motion by Commissioner Tony Mullen, Seconded by Commissioner DeShon Leek, to approve
the reappointment of the Internal Auditor for Fiscal Year 2026-2027 at a Regular Board Meeting
held on May 19, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 27 of 31
RESOLUTION 2026-05-06
Appointment of the Charter Position of Corporate Secretary
WHEREAS, the Board’s Rules of Procedures specify that the Board is to appoint a Director and
General Manager, Internal Auditor, and Corporate Secretary, at its first regular meeting
following July 1st of each year or as soon as practicable thereafter.
RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners hereby appoints the following individual to the
Charter position of Corporate Secretary for fiscal year 2026-2027 or until a successor is
appointed, whichever last occurs: LaVella J. Todd, Corporate Secretary
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Chairperson of the Board of Commissioners is authorized to
execute any and all contractual amendment documents which reflect merit adjustments
recommended by the Human Resources Committee for FY 2026’s performance.
Motion by Commissioner Sandra Zerkle, Seconded by Commissioner Tony Mullen, to approve
the reappointment of the Corporate Secretary for Fiscal Year 2026-2027 at a Regular Board
Meeting held on May 19, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
RESOLUTION OF LANSING BOARD OF WATER & LIGHT
IN RECOGNITION OF FIFTY YEARS OF SERVICE BY RICHARD R. PEFFLEY
WHEREAS, Richard “Dick” Peffley has served the Lansing Board of Water & Light (BWL) with
exceptional dedication and commitment for half a century,
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley started his career at BWL in 1978 as a Temporary Laborer in General
Maintenance Department and was promoted through the following positions over his career:
Laborer Advanced, Electronics Technician, General Supervisor of Operations, Plant Manager,
Manager of Electric and Steam Production, Director of Production, Executive Director of
Operations and Executive Director of Water Operations and Special Projects;
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley served as the Interim General Manager in 2006 for approximately one
year during the job search for the position. Declining the permanent General Manager offer, he
returned to the Director of Production along with being the Interim Director of Operations. He
stepped in for a 2nd time as the Interim General Manager in 2015 and 8 months later accepted
the permanent position, which he holds at 50 years of service;
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley’s vision and leadership has achieved significant success and growth for
the Hometown People Hometown Power utility, and included among his many
accomplishments are the following:
• Project manager for the $23 million repair and refurbishment of the Wise Road Water
Conditioning Plant following a chemical accident in 2011;
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 28 of 31
• Project manager for the $20 million Chilled Water Plant, which came in on time and on budget
in 2009, named after his father, BWL retiree, Roy E. Peffley;
• Project manager for the $182 million natural gas-fired REO Cogeneration Plant and
Headquarters which came in on time and on budget in 2013;
• Led the Water Production and Distribution Departments’ efforts to produce and distribute
record-breaking one billion gallons of water in a single month to customers during the heat
wave in July 2013;
• Oversaw the completion to remove all lead water service lines in the BWL service territory in
2016, the second utility in the country to do so;
• Oversaw the development and construction of the $500 million natural gas-fired Delta Energy
Park in 2019;
• Successfully renegotiated a coal contract which resulted in $52 million of savings over two
years in 2021;
• Oversaw contract negotiations between General Motors and Ultium in 2022 to provide power
for a new battery cell manufacturing plant, a transformational $2.6 billion investment that will
support electric vehicle production in Lansing for the next generation;
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley’s leadership has led the Lansing Board of Water & Light to significant
growth and has shaped the company into the Utility of Today, Transforming Tomorrow.
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley’s leadership and contribution to Lansing Board of Water & Light have
translated to the Greater Lansing Area, ensuring the residents of Lansing Area benefit from
reliable and affordable public power.
WHEREAS, Dick Peffley’s 50-years of service to Lansing Board of Water & Light is an
extraordinary milestone, reflecting loyalty and dedication to our Hometown utility and its future
and the Lansing Board of Water & Light Board of Commissioners wish to recognize and thank
Dick Peffley for his many contributions to the company.
RESOLVED, that The Board of Commissioners of Lansing Board of Water & Light hereby extends
its deepest appreciation to Richard “Dick” Peffley for 50 years of distinguished service to Lansing
Board of Water & Light.
On Behalf of Lansing Board of Water & Light
Board of Commissioners
David Price, Chairperson
May 19, 2026
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 29 of 31
MANAGERS REMARKS
1. Storm on 5/18 took out power to 3k customers over 111 locations.
o Full restoration expected by 8pm 5/19
2. Held Community Resource Fair on 4/15 at Alfreda Schmidt
o About 150 individuals attended
o $4M raised for customers to date
3. Hosted MSU Visiting International Professional Program on 4/27
o Visitors are invited to the U.S. through the Department of State’s
International Visitor Leadership Program.
o 10 individuals from 10 different countries representing diverse industries
o Toured DEP
o Presentations on BWL’s carbon neutrality, smart meter technology,
economic development and community engagement
o Left very impressed by BWL
4. Welcomed 18 interns on 5/11.
o They will be with us through the summer
5. 16 1st STEP students graduated 5/13
o This year concluded our 18th year of 1st STEP program.
o Every student gets $2,000 tuition to attend any school in Michigan
6. Staff attended MMEA spring conference in Grand Rapids on 5/14/2026
7. Panel speaker at Chamber Economic Luncheon Thur., May 21 at 11:30 am
o Along with ITC and Consumers
o Topic: Powering Michigan’s Growth: Energy Infrastructure, Reliability and
Economic Competitiveness
8. Mackinac Policy Conference
o Staff attending Tuesday through Friday
9. Next Township Engagement meeting
o Meridian Township on June 2 at 6pm
10. Employee Picnic is coming up on June 23 at 6pm
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 30 of 31
COMMISSIONERS REMARKS
There are no commissioner remarks.
MOTION OF EXCUSED ABSENCE
There were no excused absences.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Elaine Fischhoff requested that detailed information be included on the BWL website, stating
the reasons and the data behind the new proposed rate increases. She noted that it would help
increase the company’s transparency with its customers. Elaine Fischhoff also requested the
BWL provide the same information as required by investor-owned utilities when filing with the
MPSC for proposed rate increases.
Closed Session pursuant to MCL 15.268(h) to consider a written Attorney/Client
Communication related to pending litigation.
Chairperson David Price requested a roll call vote to enter closed session to discuss a written
Attorney/Client Communication related to pending litigation. He also requested General Counsel
Mark Matus and Deputy General Counsel Jason Hawkins be present.
Roll Call Vote:
Yeas: Commissioners Beth Graham, Chris Harkins, Semone James, David Price, DeShon Leek,
Tony Mullen, Dale Schrader, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
The board entered into closed session at 5:55 p.m.
Chairperson David Price requested a roll call vote to reconvene after the closed session.
Roll Call Vote:
Yeas: Commissioners Beth Graham, Chris Harkins, Semone James, David Price, DeShon Leek,
Tony Mullen, Dale Schrader, and Sandra Zerkle.
Nays: None.
Action: Motion Carried.
The board reconvened at 6:14 p.m.
Regular Board Meeting Minutes
May 19, 2026 Page 31 of 31
A resolution was presented regarding the written Attorney/Client Communication related to
pending litigation.
RESOLUTION 2026-05-07
Delegation of Authority to Respond to Web Submission on Behalf of the Board of
Commissioners
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners received a web submittal from an employee of the
Lansing Board of Water & Light on April 30, 2026, and it is appropriate that the Board respond
to the submittal directly as opposed to referring the matter to Management;
WHEREAS, at a regular meeting of the Board on May 19, 2026, the Board considered the
matter, including a memorandum from counsel, and concluded it is both prudent and
efficient to delegate to the Chairperson the authority to respond to the web submission.
Therefore, it is:
RESOLVED, that the Chairperson is delegated authority to make a written response to the
web submission on behalf of the Board of Commissioners, and
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Chairperson is delegated authority to, with the advice of
counsel, respond to any additional correspondence from the employee addressing the same
or related issues presented by the April 30, 2026 web submittal.
Motion by Commissioner Beth Graham, Seconded by Commissioner Dale Schrader, to
approve the Resolution for Delegation of Authority to Respond to Web Submission on Behalf
of the Board of Commissioners at a Regular Board Meeting held on May 19, 2026.
Action: Motion Carried.
ADJOURNMENT
Chairperson David Price adjourned the meeting at 6:15 p.m.
LaVella J. Todd, Corporate Secretary
To be approved by the Board of Commissioners: 07-28-2026
Official Minutes filed (electronically) with Lansing City Clerk: 08-03-26