The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2005 Minutes BOR 2005 DECEMBER BOARD OF REVIEW DECEMBER 13, 2005 10:00 A.M. 3RD FLOOR ASSESSOR'S OFFICE MEMBERS PRESENT STAFF PRESENT Eddie Thomas, Chairperson David Tijerina, Assessor Curtis McKinnon Michael C. Payne Diane Lee Teressa Bowers Eddie Thomas, Chairperson, called the meeting to order at 10:15 a.m. The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2005 Curtis McKinnon moved to approve the agenda as submitted. Eddie Thomas supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. Attachment A The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2004 Curtis McKinnon moved to approve the agenda as submitted. Eddie Thomas supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. Attachment B The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2003 Curtis McKinnon moved to approve the agenda as submitted. Eddie Thomas supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. Attachment C The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2002 Curtis McKinnon moved to approve the agenda as submitted. Eddie Thomas supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. Attachment D Eddie Thomas adjourned the meeting at 11:20 a.m. 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW JULY 19, 2005 10:00 A.M. 3RD FLOOR ASSESSOR'S OFFICE MEMBERS PRESENT STAFF PRESENT Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. Mary Lou Andrews Sonya R. Moore Diane Lee Eddie Thomas (excused absence) Mike Payne Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. Vice- Chairperson, called the meeting to order at 10:10 a.m. The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2005 Sonya Moore moved to approve the agenda as submitted. Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. (Attachment 1) The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2004 Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. moved to approve the agenda as submitted with the noted corrections. Sonya Moore supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. (Attachment 2) The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2003 Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. moved to approve the agenda as submitted with the noted corrections. Sonya Moore supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. (Attachment 3) The Board reviewed the attached agenda for tax year 2002 Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. moved to approve the agenda as submitted.. Sonya Moore supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. (Attachment 4) Meeting adjourned at 10:55 a.m. Q,N S 1 CITY ASSESSOR'S OFFICE ti C 3rd Floor,City Hall 124 W.Michigan Ave. Lansing,MI 48933-1687 (517)483-4020 �ICHIGP� July 19, 2005 Tony Benavides,Mayor STATE OF MICHIGAN, COUNTY OF INGHAM, CITY OF LANSING This is to certify, in accordance with Section 221 . 53b Public Acts State of Michigan that the Board of Review met in the City Assessor 3rd Floor Conference Room, City Hall on July 19, 2005 at 10 : 00 a.m. and made the attached corrections to the real estate and personal property assessment rolls of 2002, 2003, 2004 and 2005 . BOARD OF REVIEW S CIJ T Eddie Thomas Curtis G. M on, Jr. S,onya R. oore "Equal Opportunity Employer" CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 1 of 32 1 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3710 SEAWAY DR 21 LANSING/EATON CO PARCEL NUMBER: 23-50-40-36-201-161 THILL JERRED L 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3710 SEAWAY DR ASSD: 53,200 53,200 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 42,641 42,641 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 2 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4214 GLENBURNE BLVD 21 LANSING/EATON CO PARCEL NUMBER: 23-50-40-36-402-061 STARKS CALVIN 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4214 GLENBURNE BLVD ASSD: 66,600 66,600 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 66,600 66,600 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 3 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 815 HARRIS ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-03-304-041 MOST GARY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 815 HARRIS ST ASSD: 29,900 9,100 -20,800 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 29,360 9,100 -20,260 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 4 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 414 HYLEWOOD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-102-131 WICKE CAROL A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 414 HYLEWOOD AVE ASSD: 30,600 30,600 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 30,600 30,600 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 5 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3233 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-106-211 PHILIPP CAROLYN 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3233 TURNER ST ASSD: 20,300 20,300 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 11,000 14,445 3,445 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 2 of 32 6 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2701 TAYLOR ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-301-137 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE LILLY EUGENE&RUTH ORIGINAL REVISED 2701 TAYLOR ST ASSD: 55,100 55,100 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 55,100 55.100 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 7 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 317 DOUGLAS AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-457-051 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE KLIMECKY KEVIN L& ORIGINAL AL REVISED 317 DOUGLAS AVE ASSD: 22,800 22,800 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 19,544 19,544 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: g RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1436 ROBERTSON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-206-131 01 LANSING FARR MAUD 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1436 ROBERTSON AVE ASSD: 27,200 27,200 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 27,200 27,200 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 9 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1336 N JENISON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-251-131 01 LANSING SEEKE RENEE S 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1336 N JENISON AVE ASSD: 34,800 34,800 0 LANSING,Mi.48915 TAXABLE: 17,308 17,308 0 HEV%: 100 0 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 914 W WILLOW ST 10 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-281-141 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE FLOURNOY SAMUEL&HATTIE ORIGINAL REVISED 914 W WILLOW ST ASSD: 50,500 50,500 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 47,262 17,677 -29,585 HEV%: 100 100 RECAP STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 3 of 32 11 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 731 PRINCETON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-481-211 CAMPBELL FREDERICK W 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 731 PRINCETON AVE ASSD: 46,600 11,500 -35,100 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 20,805 11,500 -9,305 HEV%: 100 100 HARDSHIP STATUS: 12 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: EMERSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-081 ROBINSON RUTH H 2O05 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 3,900 3,900 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 3,452 3,452 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 13 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1407 EMERSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-091 ROBINSON RUTH H 2O05 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 26,500 26,500 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 13,348 13,348 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 14 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 217 E DWIGHT ST 1 PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-205-041 01 LANSING MILKULCLK KAREN E 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 217 E DWIGHT ST 1 ASSD: 60,100 60,100 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 29,717 29,717 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 50 STATUS: 15 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1213 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-254-062 TERRY TERRY N 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6204 COLEMAN RD ASSD: 62,000 62,000 0 E LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 43,327 31,265 -12,062 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 4 of 32 16 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1361 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-258-002 BELANGER ANNETTE (NEZ) 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1361 TURNER ST ASSD: 119,800 7,500 -112,300 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 119,800 7.500 -112,300 TO NEZ HEV%a: 100 100 STATUS: 17 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 416 PEARL ST 1 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-278-321 FORSBERG PAUL 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1240 BOICHOT ASSD: 29,100 29,100 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 17,625 29,100 11,475 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%a: 0 100 STATUS: 18 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 714 BROOK ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-306-011 KELLEY KELLI 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1245 DELNORA DRIVE ASSD: 30,000 30,000 0 CHARLOTTE,MI.48813-8517 TAXABLE: 19,225 19,225 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 19 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 420 W KILBORN ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-308-081 SMITH LESTER C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 8454 BILLWOOD HWY ASSD: 30,900 30,900 0 CHARLOTTE,MI.488139337 TAXABLE: 15,031 15,031 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 20 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 204 W GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-327-091 GARZA MANUEL 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 204 W GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 42,700 42,700 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 23,868 23,868 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 5 of 32 21 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 825 N WALNUT ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-361-171 SPENCER LARRY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 786 OAKBROOK RDG ASSD: 31,300 31,300 0 ROCHESTER,MI.48307 TAXABLE: 20,819 26,597 5,778 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 22 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 726 N PINE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-363-011 RUDDICK TERRY A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 726 N PINE ST ASSD: 19,700 19,700 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 8,770 8,770 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 23 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1136 N PENNSYLVANIA AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-326-041 RANSHAW TODD M&SUTY DEBORA 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2420 N GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 36,200 36,200 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 15,873 36,200 20,327 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 24 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1217 PORTER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-328-141 BRIGGS TIMOTHY A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1217 PORTER ST ASSD: 35,300 35,300 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 29,564 29,564 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 25 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1127 CLEVELAND ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-328-221 ONKEN MERRY A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 798 E MONROE RD ASSD: 23,700 23,700 0 ST LOUIS, MI.48801 TAXABLE: 17,371 17,371 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 6 of 32 26 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1414 E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-409-381 PICKELLJOSETTE D 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1414 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 42,800 42,800 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 39,999 39,999 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 100 STATUS: 27 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 718 CLEVELAND ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-480-051 CLARK JEFFERY D 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 718 CLEVELAND ST ASSD: 29,100 5,900 -23,200 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 17,800 5,900 -11,900 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 28 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 215 N FOSTER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-154-351 PARKEY ALBERT 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 215 N FOSTER AVE ASSD: 25,900 25,900 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 25,165 25.165 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 29 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 213 S MAGNOLIA AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-304-092 HUMPHREY TOD 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 334 E HILLSDALE APT#301 ASSD: 40,200 40,200 0 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 30,076 30,076 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 30 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: S FRANCIS AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-326-381 MANGLES SALEM G&NICOLE D 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 6744 W BEARD RD ASSD: 5,600 5,600 0 SHAFTSBURG,MI.48882 TAXABLE: 1,381 5,600 4,219 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:46 PM Page 7 of 32 31 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 640 S MAGNOLIA AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-358-341 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE HAAS THOMAS R JR&MARY N ORIGINAL AL REVISED 1491 FRANKLIN ASSD: 13,400 13,400 0 HASLETT,MI.48840 TAXABLE: 9,449 13,400 3,951 HEV%: 0 0 LATE DISCOVERY STATUS: 32 RESIDENTIAL.PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 231 HORTON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-277-181 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE DETERING MICHELLE L ORIGINAL REVISED 231 HORTON AVE ASSD: 43.200 43,200 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 39,244 39,244 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 100 STATUS: 33 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 S EIGHTH ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-306-022 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE TAYLOR DAVID W&MARIAN ORIGINAL AL REVISED PO BOX 16099 ASSD: 36,000 36,000 0 LANSING,MI.48901 TAXABLE: 34,116 17,556 -16,560 HEV%: 0 0 RECAP STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 34 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 319 S EIGHTH ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-311-041 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE GREEN HOWARD&BRENDA ORIGINAL REVISED 319 S EIGHTH ST ASSD: 42,400 42,400 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 35,162 35,162 0 HEV%: 100 0 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 906 PROSPECT ST 35 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-311-252 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE MCCRACKEN LON&REBEKAH ORIGINAL REVISED 3997 RIDGEMOOR ASSD: 36,300 36,300 0 HOLT,MI.48842 TAXABLE: 33,304 33,304 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 8 of 32 36 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 207 BINGHAM ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-330-011 MAYS VIRGINIA C&GARCIA MARTHE 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 207 BINGHAM ST ASSD: 33,700 33,700 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 29,093 29,093 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 37 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 226 LESLIE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-432-341 SANDERS SHIRLEY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 226 LESLIE ST ASSD: 38,300 38,300 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 24,123 24,123 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 38 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 425 CLIFFORD ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-452-101 01 LANSING BARS LARRY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 216 S CHARLES ST ASSD: 18,900 18,900 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 12,102 18,900 6,798 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 39 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 524 E SHIAWASSEE ST 04 LANSING TIFA#4 PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-276-191 PARKS DAVID W&ELIZABETH 20 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINNAL REVISED 805 ROLFE RD ASSD: 38,500 38,500 0 MASON, MI.48854 TAXABLE: 27,203 36,828 9,625 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 40 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 505 E MICHIGAN AVE 04 LANSING TIFA#4 PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-276-801 LANSING LUGNUTS 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED TOM DICKSON 505 E MICHIGAN AVE ASSD: 519,700 373,500 -146,200 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 498,025 368,174 -129,851 HEV%: 0 0 CORRECTION STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 9 of 32 41 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 605 E MICHIGAN AVE 04 LANSING TIFA#4 PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-277-191 PURCELL INVESTMENT L L C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 605 E MICHIGAN AVE ASSD: 91.600 91,600 0 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 81,979 87,159 5,180 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 42 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 206 S WASHINGTON SQ 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-328-161 INFINITY COMPANIES L L C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 213 ANN ST ASSD: 297,900 231,400 -66,500 EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 197,124 197,124 0 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 43 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 425 S CHESTNUT ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-354-051 UNDERWOOD DELIAH 2O05 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 425 S CHESTNUT ST ASSD: 29,900 29,900 0 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 27,007 27,007 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 85 STATUS: 44 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 N JENISON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-184-071 LOCKHART CINDY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 211 N JENISON AVE ASSD: 57,200 57,200 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 52,953 52,953 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 45 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 516 BARTLETT ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-205-071 GREGORY DAMIAN K 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 516 BARTLETT ST ASSD: 60,900 60,900 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 39,068 39,068 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Pagel 0 of 32 46 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 319 HOWE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-252-131 LAMBRIGHT REID D 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 319 HOWE ST ASSD: 13,100 13,100 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 8,482 8,482 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 47 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1129 W IONIA ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-258-281 RAPHAEL MARDOCHE&MONTAS M 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1129 W IONIA ST ASSD: 62,700 3,700 -59,000 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 62,624 3,695 -58,929 TO NEZ HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 48 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: W KALAMAZOO ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-451-621 RUFFIN IMOGENE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1311 W OTTAWA ST ASSD: 71,100 4,600 -66,500 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 68,311 1,611 -66,700 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 49 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1317 W KALAMAZOO ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-451-632 REYNOLDS DARNELL L&SUMMER S 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1317 W KALAMAZOO ST ASSD: 4,300 71,000 66,700 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 882 67,582 66,700 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 50 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1005 W KALAMAZOO ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-476-341 MAHMOUD JAAMI J 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1005 W KALAMAZOO ST ASSD: 54,300 54,300 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 24,775 24,775 0 REZ COMPLIANT HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: REVISED RZ COMP CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 11 of 32 51 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 925 W LENAWEE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-478-363 DUKES KATHRYN C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 925 W LENAWEE ST ASSD: 98,100 98,100 0 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 56,317 56,317 0 REZ COMPLIANT HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: REVISED RZ COMP 52 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2201 W MAIN ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-103-182 HARBENSKI JAMES W II 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2201 W MAIN ST ASSD: 45,700 45,700 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 30,349 30,349 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 50 STATUS: 53 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1407 BOSTON BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-331-001 HALL AUDREY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 BOSTON BLVD ASSD: 54,800 54,800 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 48,872 48,872 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 54 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1740 PARK AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-453-251 NOVAKOSKI JUDITH KAY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1740 PARK AVE ASSD: 59,400 59,400 0 LANSING. MI.48910 TAXABLE: 46,981 46,981 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 55 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1304 BERTEN ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-454-061 STRUBLE CHERYL L 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1304 BERTEN ST ASSD: 70,500 70,500 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 54,073 54,073 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 75 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 12 of 32 56 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1127 GEORGE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-456-261 W 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE EBSTER MARILYN M& ORIGINAL REVISED 1127 GEORGE ST ASSD: 45,800 45,800 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 44,398 35,635 -8,763 HEV%: 100 100 RECAP STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 57 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 315 E MT HOPE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-21-461-013 WINTERS MICHAEL R 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 315 E MT HOPE AVE ASSD: 31,200 31,200 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 29,053 29,053 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 100 STATUS: 58 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1615 LINVAL ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-21-478-020 HAGAN KERRY D&SMORRA ADRIE� 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGIN AL REVISED 628 W BARNES AVE ASSD: 18,300 18,300 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 12,988 18,300 5,312 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 59 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1137 E MAIN ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-127-071 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE HUSTED JUDITH A ORIGINAL REVISED 1137 E MAIN ST ASSD: 26,500 8,700 -17,800 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 23,023 8,700 -14,323 HEV%: 100 100 HARDSHIP STATUS: 60 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1126E MAIN ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-129-321 GOINGS SHERRI L 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1126 E MAIN ST ASSD: 36,000 36,000 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 36,000 36,000 0 HEV%: 100 0 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 13 of 32 61 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1221 PARKDALE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-380-031 ADAMS FREDERICK S 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1221 PARKDALE ST ASSD: 77,600 75,900 -1,700 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 77,600 75,900 -1,700 HEV%: 100 100 10 STATUS: 62 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2200 ROBINSON RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-26-352-192 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE CENTENNIAL LAND L L C ORIGINAL AL REVISED 4525 WILLOUGHBY RD ASSD: 57,300 31,600 -25,700 LANSING,MI.48842 TAXABLE: 57,300 31,600 -25,700 HEV%: 0 0 10 STATUS: 63 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2915 TRUDY LANE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-26-405-081 01 LANSING BMW PROPERTIES NARRAGANSET L 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED %WIEGAND BELINDA 9415 WHIPPLE SHORES DR ASSD: 91,200 91,200 0 CLARKSTON,MI.48348 TAXABLE: 91,200 91,200 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 0 STATUS: 64 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 925 KENWOOD AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-108-081 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE DAMON BARRY&CATHY ORIGINAL REVISED 2240 S AURELIUS RD ASSD: 14,900 14,900 0 MASON, MI.48854 TAXABLE: 11,006 14,526 3,520 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 65 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3129 CEDARBROOK AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-351-041 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE SPENNY ERIE D JR&MARLENE R ORIGINAL AL REVISED 3129 CEDARBROOK AVE ASSD: 73,800 73,800 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 46,510 46,510 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 14 of 32 66 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 904 S DEXTER DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-356-121 SODERBERG MARJORIE J 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 904 S DEXTER DR ASSD: 85,600 85,600 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 49,084 49,084 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 67 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3326 AURELIUS RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-476-042 MAYER MELINDA 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3326 AURELIUS RD ASSD: 48,400 48,400 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 40,186 40,186 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 68 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 221 GREENCROFT RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-127-181 QUINN PATRICK T&JENNIFER M 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1015 MOORES RIVER DR ASSD: 37,800 37,800 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 37,800 37,800 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 69 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 708 LINCOLN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-289-191 RAMONT MONIQUE R 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 708 LINCOLN AVE ASSD: 35,000 8,900 -26,100 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 25,760 8,900 -16,860 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 70 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 622 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-352-191 PETERSON RICHARD L&ROBERTA 1 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3967 DELL RD ASSD: 22,300 22,300 0 HOLT,MI.48842 TAXABLE: 20,092 20,092 0 Exemption Chg HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 15 of 32 71 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 210 DENVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-405-441 SPENNY ERIE D JR&MARLENE R 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3129 CEDARBROOK AVE ASSD: 31,000 31,000 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 18,253 18,253 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 72 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2401 WELLINGTON RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-155-041 KOONS ARLENE M&KOONS EDWIN 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2401 WELLINGTON RD ASSD: 58,700 58,700 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 43,538 43,538 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 73 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2421 STIRLING AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-277-041 LAHAINE GILBERT&DOROTHY(TRU: 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGIN AL REVISED 2401 STIRLING AVE ASSD: 96,600 96,600 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 59,595 59.595 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 74 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2511 BEDFORD RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-251-011 FRANKOVICH BRIAN J 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2511 BEDFORD RD ASSD: 87,000 87,000 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 87,000 74,211 -12,789 RECAPPING HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 75 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3110 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-381-051 WARD DONALD R 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 130 HALBERT ST ASSD: 64,600 64,600 0 GRAND LEDGE,MI.488371228 TAXABLE: 48,982 48,982 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 50 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 16 of 32 76 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2806 CABOT DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-252-131 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE BREWER JAMES D&DONNA J ORIGINAL REVISED 2526 S HOOVER ASSD: 28,600 28,600 0 GLADWIN, Mi.48624 TAXABLE: 19,909 19,909 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 77 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2413 FIELDING DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-280-141 SELTZ ARDYTH 2O05 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2413 FIELDING DR ASSD: 19,800 6,700 -13.100 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 13,122 6,700 -6,422 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 78 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3610 JERREE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-305-051 MARTINEZ-MORIEL RAUL 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 3610 JERREE ST ASSD: 36,000 36,000 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 34,372 28,389 -5,983 HEV%: 100 100 RECAP STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 79 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3207 JERREE ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-329-191 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE KING DENISE M ORIGINAL REVISED 3207 JERREE ST ASSD: 45,200 45,200 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 30,044 30,044 0 HEV%: 100 100 HARDSHIP STATUS: 80 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4721 BALLARD RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-452-021 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE CARSON CHRISTINA M ORIGINAL REVISED 4721 BALLARD RD ASSD: 41,500 35,000 -6,500 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 41,500 35,000 -6,500 HEV%: 0 0 10 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 17 of 32 81 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1414 WARWICK DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-201-041 MATHEWS BEVERLY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1414 WARWICK DR ASSD: 41,800 36,900 -4,900 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 30,317 25,304 -5,013 HEV%: 100 100 10 STATUS: 82 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4113 WALTON DR PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-277-091 01 LANSING NGUYEN-VO TRICIA L 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4113 WALTON DR ASSD: 57,800 57,800 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 57,800 57,800 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 83 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4701 PLEASANT GROVE RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-351-002 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE GURU NANAK SIKH CENTER ORIGINAL REVISED 3434 PLEASANT GROVE RD ASSD: 95,100 0 -95,100 LANSING,Mi.48910 TAXABLE: 93,502 0 -93,502 HEV%: 0 0 EXEMPTION STATUS: 84 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 926 RED RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-427-141 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE WILSON-GIBBONS CARRIEIWILSON: ORIGINAL AL REVISED 926 REO RD ASSD: 9,500 9,700 200 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 9,500 6,904 -2,596 HEV%: 100 100 HARDSHIP STATUS: 85 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5020 DELBROOK AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-480-121 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE PLACE SANDRA K&KRING DEBORAI ORIGINAL AL REVISED 5020 DELBROOK AVE ASSD: 30,400 30,400 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 19,789 19,789 0 HEV%: 100 0 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 18 of 32 86 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 322 E CAVANAUGH RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-402-242 DEWITT LUKE J&CAROLYN A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 322 E CAVANAUGH RD ASSD: 31,300 31,300 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 31,300 31,300 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 87 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 115 E POTTER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-404-061 DENNY PHILLIP 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 115 E POTTER AVE ASSD: 42,900 42,900 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 42,900 42,900 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 88 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 611 EMILY AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-427-041 STUART005 2005 DIFFERENCE TUART MAYME LENORE ORIGINAL REVISED 611 EMILY AVE ASSD: 39,400 39,400 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 23,421 23,421 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 89 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3726 GLENWOOD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-34-109-241 LAFOREST SCOTT&LAFOREST MICI 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 3726 GLENWOOD AVE ASSD: 24,300 24,300 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 21,497 21,497 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: go RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 804 FENTON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-34-157-151 CAMP SUSAN A 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2316 MARION AVE ASSD: 44,900 44,900 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 36,441 36,441 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 19 of 32 91 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4010 DEVONSHIRE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-34-180-091 DARGE CARL A&DENISE M& 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 4010 DEVONSHIRE AVE ASSD: 50,500 50,500 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 49,709 49,709 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 92 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 719 JULIA ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-34-303-041 BUSS ELLA J&GRATKOWSKI CARL. 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 719 JULIE ST ASSD: 39,900 39,900 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 29,376 29,376 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 93 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 921 KENDON DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-34-306-071 ANDREW VERNERD&PATRICIA&Al' 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 9347 WALNUT RD ASSD: 53,200 53,200 0 DIMONDALE,MI.48821 TAXABLE: 35,209 35,209 0 Exemption Chg HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 94 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 531 ARMSTRONG RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-04-226-071 HOLMES TODD M 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6724 CONESTOGA ASSD: 29,600 29,600 0 LANSING,MI.48917 TAXABLE: 19,557 19,557 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 95 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5635 ELLENDALE DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-04-329-030 ZIELINSKI WIESLAW 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5635 ELLENDALE DR ASSD: 100,800 99,700 -1,100 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 100,800 99,700 -1,100 HEV%: 100 100 10 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 20 of 32 96 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5733 ANNAPOLIS DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-04-331-061 MORTON-DEITRICK JOANN 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 885 TANGLEWOOD LN ASSD: 54,100 54,100 0 E LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 54.100 54,100 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 97 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6034 HILLIARD RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-04-352-221 MAPLE TREE PROPERTIES L L C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 218 ASSD: 32,000 32,000 0 POTTERVILLE, MI.48876 TAXABLE: 32,000 32,000 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 98 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 933 W JOLLY RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-227-381 NORTH TED ED 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 933 W JOLLY RD ASSD: 45.200 45,200 0 LANSING, MI.48910-5379 TAXABLE: 31,235 31,235 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 50 50 STATUS: 99 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: W JOLLY RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-227-391 NORTH TED ED 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 933 W JOLLY RD ASSD: 20,600 20,600 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 9,388 9,388 0 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 100 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5525 MANOR DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-278-032 GARCIA-PROENZA TANIA 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5525 MANOR DR ASSD: 49,400 49,400 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 49,400 49,400 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 21 of 32 101 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5900 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-306-171 BITNER RUSSELL 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5900 S M L KING JR BLVD ASSD: 31,800 31,800 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 29,973 29,973 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 102 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5861 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-376-201 SNIDER DONALD&DOROTHY 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 16343 CENTER RD ASSD: 31,600 31,600 0 EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 19,241 19,241 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 103 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5725 MONTICELLO DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-06-348-001 PERKINS RUBY 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5725 MONTICELLO DR ASSD: 32,600 6,700 -25,900 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 18,880 6,700 -12,180 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 104 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5825 PHEASANT AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-06-434-033 CENTENO JUAN 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5825 PHEASANT AVE ASSD: 34,500 34,500 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 24,643 24,643 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 105 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6217 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-07-227-020 RORICK TIM 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 7064 WHITE PINE DR ASSD: 24,200 24,200 0 PERRY,MI.48872 TAXABLE: 24,200 24,200 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 22 of 32 106 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6115 YUNKER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-08-202-011 KOWALK TREVA MAE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6115 YUNKER ST ASSD: 30,100 5,200 -24,900 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 23,075 5,200 -17,875 HARDSHIP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 107 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: SOUTHFIELD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-08-204-191 KRING DEBORAH 2O05 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1107 SOUTHFIELD AVE ASSD: 9,200 9.200 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 1,495 4,091 2,596 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 108 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: DAFT ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-08-205-112 PATRICK DANIELLE M 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6244 DAFT ST ASSD: 10,600 10,600 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 3,176 10,600 7,424 LATE DISCOVERY HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 109 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6108 MARYWOOD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-08-226-392 BRISENO LAURIE J 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6108 MARYWOOD AVE ASSD: 61,200 61,200 0 LANSING,Mi.48911 TAXABLE: 61,200 61,200 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 110 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6250 SOMMERSET RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-09-126-191 COFFEY ERNEST&COFFEY EVELYf\ 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 6250 SOMMERSET RD ASSD: 30,800 30,800 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 30,800 21,767 -9,033 RECAP HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 23 of 32 111 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6230 COULSON CT 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-09-201-081 LYNCH MARK O 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6230 COULSON CT ASSD: 28,700 28,700 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 19,845 19,845 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 112 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6129 MARSCOT DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-204-031 POLLOCK JOHN R 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4792 SANDS PARK ASSD: 46,800 46,800 0 KALKASKA,MI.49646 TAXABLE: 35,479 35,479 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 113 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1933 DELL RD 06 HOLT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-276-212 DENNEN WILLIAM 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1933 DELL RD ASSD: 72,100 72,100 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 72,100 72,100 0 EXEMPTION CHG HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 114 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1912 BOWKER DR 06 HOLT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-428-051 GUERRERO SABAS D 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1912 BOWKER DR ASSD: 90,900 86,400 -4,500 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 90,476 86,400 -4,076 HEV%: 100 100 10 STATUS: 115 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-03-140-000 CITICAPITAL COMMERCIAL LEASING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED OPERATIONS TAX DEPT 8001 RIDGEPOINT DR ASSD: 360,200 169,200 -191,000 IRVING,TX.75063 TAXABLE: 360,200 169,200 -191,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 24 of 32 116 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 223 E MT HOPE AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-04-000-000 01 LANSING BAKER COMPUTER SERVICE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 8026 27TH AVE N ASSD: 6,600 0 -6,600 SAINT PETERSBURG,FL.33710-2802 TAXABLE: 6,600 0 -6,600 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: 117 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1723 E MICHIGAN AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-10-235-000 01 LANSING CAPITOL CITY TATTOOS 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 1723 E MICHIGAN AVE ASSD: 200 500 300 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 200 500 300 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 118 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3506 N EAST ST PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-12-343-000 01 LANSING REDLINE AUTO SALES/SERVICE 2 2- DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVIlSS ED 3506 N EAST ST ASSD: 2,800 5,200 2,400 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 2,800 5,200 2.400 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 119 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-14-391-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE HEWLETT PACKARD FINANCIAL SER ORIGINAL AL REVISED LEASING-TAX 333 LOGUE AVE MAIL STOP 2059 ASSD: 788,900 782,600 -6,300 MOUNTAIN VIEW,CA.94043 TAXABLE: 788,900 782,600 -6,300 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: 120 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 530 W WILLOW ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-14-630-000 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE CONSUMERS ENERGY CO ORIGINAL REVISED PROPERY ACCOUNTING EP9-282 ONE ENERGY PLAZA ASSD: 17,585,500 17,592,300 6,800 JACKSON,MI.49201-9938 TAXABLE: 17,585,500 17,592,300 6,800 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 25 of 32 121 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-14-633-000 CONSUMERS ENERGY CO 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED PROPERTY ACCTG EP9-282 ONE ENERGY PLAZA ASSD: 125,600 0 -125,600 JACKSON,MI.49201 TAXABLE: 125,600 0 -125,600 HEV%: 0 0 DOUBLE ASSESSED STATUS: 122 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-14-647-000 C 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE CONSUMERS ENERGY CO ORIGINAL REVISED PROPERTY ACCTG EP9-282 ONE ENERGY PLAZA ASSD: 417,800 0 -417,800 JACKSON, MI.49201 TAXABLE: 417,800 0 -417,800 DOUBLE ASSESSD HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 123 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-16-555-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE DANKA OFFICE IMAGING CO ORIGINAL AL REVISED TAX DEPT 11101 ROOSEVELT BLVD ASSD: 21,500 0 -21,500 SAINT PETERSBURG, FL.33716-2334 TAXABLE: 21,500 0 -21,500 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 124 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1200 E OAKLAND AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-17-400-000 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE DELTA PRINTING CO ORIGINAL REVISED 1200 E OAKLAND AVE ASSD: 244,800 202,400 -42,400 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 244,800 202,400 -42,400 MUTUAL MISTAKE HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 125 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 908 W MT HOPE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-21-460-000 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE EXPRESSIONS STUDIO 9000 ORIGINAL REVISED ANTHONY MCLOUD 3708 GLASGOW DR ASSD: 16,500 0 -16,500 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 16,500 0 -16,500 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 26 of 32 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6927 S CEDAR ST 126 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-22-600-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE FLAP JACK FAMILY RESTAURANT ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 36,500 0 -36,500 6927 S CEDAR ST LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 36,500 0 -36,500 HEV%: 0 0 DOUBLE ASSESS STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5136 S CEDAR ST 127 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-24-103-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE FURNITURE FIRST LLC ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 15,800 9,800 -6,000 5136 S CEDAR ST LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 15,800 9,800 -6,000 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5643 ENTERPRISE DR 128 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-26-293-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE GORDON FLESCH COMPANY INC ORIGINAL AL REVISED 2101 W BELTLINE HWY ASSD: 5,400 0 -5,400 TAXABLE: 5,400 0 -5,400 MADISON,WI.53713 HEV%: 0 0 CLERCIAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 129 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-28-904-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE HARBOR EQUIPMENT LEASING ORIGINAL AL REVISED 701 CATHEDRAL STREET ASSD: 5,000 0 -5,000 TAXABLE: 5,000 0 -5,000 BALTIMORE, MD.21201 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 130 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-32-744-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE KINETIC CONCEPTS INC ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 3,700 0 -3,700 P.O.BOX 160069 SAN ANTONIO,TX.78280-2269 TAXABLE: 3,700 0 3,700 HEV%: 0 0 DOUBLE ASSESSED STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 27 of 32 131 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-33-072-000 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE EQUANT US INC ORIGINAL REVISED LANSING SCHOOLS VARIOUS ASSD: 1,800 11,500 9,700 400 GALLERIA PKWY TOWER#400 ATLANTA,GA.30339 TAXABLE: 1,800 11,500 9,700 HEV%: 0 0 MISTAKE OF FACT STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 107 N WASHINGTON SQ 132 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-33-630-000 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE JUNIOR ACHIEVEMENT ORIGINAL REVISED 107 N WASHINGTON SQ 2ND FLO( ASSD: 1,000 0 -1,000 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 1,000 0 -1,000 HEV%: 0 0 EXEMPT STATUS: 133 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2025 S WASHINGTON AVE S PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-34-066-000 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE KELLAMS,W.R.,DO ORIGINAL REVISED 20321 GRANDE OAK BLVD#18 ASSD: 9,900 0 -9,900 ESTERO,FL.33928 TAXABLE: 9,900 0 -9,900 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 134 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-129-000 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE MARLIN LEASING CORP ORIGINAL REVISED PROPERTY ADMINISTRATION ASSD: 82,200 0 -82,200 124 GAITHER DRIVE SUITE 170 MOUNT LAUREL,NJ.08054 TAXABLE: 82,200 0 -82,200 HEV%: 0 0 DOUBLE ASSESSME STATUS: 135 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 800 W MILLER RD PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-39-052-000 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE LARRY AUTO SERVICE ORIGINAL REVISED 800 W MILLER RD ASSD: 10,200 4,600 -5,600 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 10,200 4,600 -5,600 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 28 of 32 136 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1200 KEYSTONE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-45-911-000 TEACHERS STORE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED THE TEACHERS STORE 1200 KEYSTONE AVE ASSD: 110,600 10,600 -100,000 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 110,600 10,600 -100,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 137 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 300 E MICHIGAN AVE STE 35 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-46-302-000 MICHIGAN SOC OF ASSN EXECUTIV 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 300 E MICHIGAN AVE STE 350 ASSD: 18,700 0 -18,700 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 18,700 0 -18,700 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 138 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2815 S PENNSYLVANIA AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-46-362-000 MICHIGAN STATE ADULT MEDICINE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2815 S PENNSYLVANIA,#2 ASSD: 10,000 0 -10,000 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 10,000 0 -10,000 EXEMPT PROPERTY HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 139 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5118 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-56-511-000 QUALEX INC-LEASE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED TAX DEPT 3404 NORTH DUKE STREET ASSD: 20,700 34,600 13,900 DURHAM, NC.27704 TAXABLE: 20,700 34,600 13,900 MUTUAL MISTAKE HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 140 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 214 E REASONER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-65-360-000 STANS QUALITY PRODUCE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 214 E REASONER ST ASSD: 0 3,000 3,000 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 0 3,000 3,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 29 of 32 141 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 424 ADAMS ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-67-211-000 S 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE TRANG TAX BUSINESS ORIGINAL REVISED STRANG THOMAS C III 424 ADAMS ST ASSD: 2,800 0 -2,800 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 2,800 0 -2,800 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 142 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 118 W OTTAWA ST 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-67-832-000 THE SWEETEST HEART OF MARY IN: 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 309 N WASHINGTON SQ ASSD: 2,200 0 -2,200 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,200 0 -2,200 EXEMPT HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 143 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 102 E MT HOPE AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-68-320-000 01 LANSING MT HOPE MARKET 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED JAY VEER COMPANY LLC 104 E MT HOPE AVE ASSD: 68,200 0 -68,200 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 68,200 0 -68,200 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 144 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 600 N CEDAR ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-68-643-000 AUTO ZONE 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED TAX DEPT 600 N CEDAR ST ASSD: 63,800 0 -63,800 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 63,800 0 -63,800 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 145 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 913 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-75-255-000 YANKEE APPRAISAL ASSOCIATES 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 913 W HOLMES RD ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 30 of 32 146 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-76-029-000 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED PROPERTY ACCOUNTING EP9-282 ONE ENERGY PLAZA ASSD: 36,300 18,100 -18,200 JACKON, MI.49201-9938 TAXABLE: 36,300 18,100 -18,200 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: 0 0 STATUS: 147 NBH ENTERPRISE CERT. PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1361 TURNER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 91-33-01-09-258-002 LANSING NEZ NEW BELANGER ANNETTE (NEZ) 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 1361 TURNER ST ASSD: 0 112,300 112,300 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 0 112,300 112,300 HEV%: 0 100 TO NEZ STATUS: 148 NBH ENTERPRISE CERT. PROPERTY ADDRESS: 201 LATHROP ST LANSING NEZ REHAB PARCEL NUMBER: 91-33-01-15-426-101 GRAU JENNIFER M&RUGE JOHN (P 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 201 LATHROP ST ASSD: 0 30,700 30,700 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 0 20.382 20,382 HEV%: 0 100 NEZ STATUS: 149 NBH ENTERPRISE CERT. PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1129 W IONIA ST LANSING NEZ NEW PARCEL NUMBER: 91-33-01-17-258-281 RAPHAEL MARDOCHE&MONTAS M 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 1129 W IONIA ST ASSD: 0 59,000 59,000 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 0 58.929 58,929 HEV%: 0 0 TO NEZ STATUS: 150 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 201 LATHROP ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-426-101 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE GRAU JENNIFER M&RUGE JOHN ORIGINAL AL REVISED 201 LATHROP ST ASSD: 39,900 3,600 -36,300 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 26,826 1,575 -25,251 HEV%: 100 100 TO NEZ STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 31 of 32 151 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 920 E GIER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-03-352-062 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE M&S CHILDERS L L C ORIGINAL REVISED 4696 TOLLAND AVE ASSD: 123,600 90,700 -32,900 TAXABLE: 123.600 90,700 -32,900 HOLT,MI.48842 HEV%: 0 0 CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: 152 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1922 THOMPSON ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-229-031 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE BUSH JAMES&DEJAEGHER TAMMY ORIGINAL AL REVISED 1922 THOMPSON ST ASSD: 43,800 43,800 0 TAXABLE: 43,800 43,800 0 LANSING,MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 153 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3006 MALONEY ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-476-472 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE FINNERTY TERRY ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 48,300 48,300 0 400 S MAIN ST E TAXABLE: 35,215 35,215 0 ATON RAPIDS,MI.48827 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 154 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 318 W JOLLY RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-377-261 01 LANSING 2005 2005 DIFFERENCE LYLE MARY L ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 38,300 38,300 0 318 W JOLLY RD LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 32,928 32,928 0 HEV%: 0 100 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 155 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5614 WISE RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-06-301-172 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE FUBARA EDWARD I&LAVERNE E& ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 86,100 86,100 0 2811 SUNDERLAND RD LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 56,182 56,182 0 HEV%: 0 50 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2005 7/19/2005 4:05:47 PM Page 32 of 32 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 910 RIVER ST 156 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-44-229-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE METROCALL INC MT 0008 ORIGINAL AL REVISED AD VALOREM SERVICES COMPANY ASSD: 1,900 0 -1,900 PO BOX 223507 BEDFORD,TX.76095 TAXABLE: 1,900 0 -1,900 HEV%: 0 0 DOUBLE ASSESSED STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 157 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-51-566-000 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE ALL PHAS GLASS&SCREEN CO ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 7,200 0 -7,200 3405 N EAST ST LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 7,200 0 -7,200 HEV%: 0 0 BUSINESS GONE STATUS: 158 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1206 CENTER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-279-041 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE PERRY PORTER L.L.C. ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 58,500 58,500 0 PO BOX 27264 LANSING,MI.489097264 TAXABLE: 58,208 58,208 0 HEV%: 0 25 EXEMPTION CHG STATUS: 159 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1120 LATHROP ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-254-163 01 LANSING 2 2005 DIFFERENCE SCHAEFER ARTHUR O ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 28,000 5,600 -22,400 1120 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 13,228 5,600 -7,628 HEV%: 0 100 PRE/POVERTY STATUS: TOTAL ASSD:j 26,216,100 24,374,100 -1,842,000 TOTAL TAXABLE: 25,108,175 23,436,090 -1,672,085 CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/1 9/2005 1 1:53:43 AM Page 1 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3629 SEAWAY DR 1001 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY 21 LANSING/EATON CO PARCEL NUMBER: 23-50-40-36-202-051 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE SCATES ARCHIE&LONNIE M ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 62,500 62,500 0 3629 SEAWAY DR LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 56,828 56,828 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3233 TURNER ST 1002 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-106-211 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE PHILIPP CAROLYN ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 19,200 19,200 0 3233 TURNER ST TAXABLE: 10,753 14,121 3,368 LANSING, MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100/LATE DI STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 609 W HOWE AVE 1003 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-155-071 01 LANSING WILLIAMS NATHAN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 27,400 27,400 0 609 W HOWE AVE TAXABLE: 23,733 23,733 0 LANSING,MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 345 FILLEY ST 1004 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-327-421 01 LANSING FINEIS GREGG R 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 28,900 28,900 0 11360 OLD BARN TRL TAXABLE: 18,104 18,104 0 EATON RAPIDS, MI.48827-9796 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 E JACKSON ST 1005 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-402-231 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE DAY DUANE&ANDREA L ORIGINAL AL REVISED 7555 E GRAND RIVER RD ASSD: 32,400 32,400 0 LAINGSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 28,308 28,308 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 2 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 237 E GIER ST 1006 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-405-111 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE FORBES ANTHONY&JENNIFER ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 57,500 57,500 0 237 E GIER ST LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 53,548 53,548 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1007 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY -PROPERTY ADDRESS: 317 DOUGLAS AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-457-051 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE KLIMECKY KEVIN L& ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 22,000 22,000 0 317 DOUGLAS AVE LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 19,105 19,105 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1008 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3706 GLENEDEN DR PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-06-301-181 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE BARNCARD NEAL A&KRISTINA W ORIGINAL AL REVISED 3706 GLENEDEN DR ASSD: 66,400 66,400 0 TAXABLE: 66,400 66,400 0 LANSING, MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1009 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2408 ARLINGTON RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-06-431-061 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE BOWMAN KIM A&DENISE K ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 85,300 82,600 -2,700 2408 ARLINGTON RD LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 65,244 65,244 0 HEV%: N/A N/A 10 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1510 LANSING AVE 1010 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-228-151 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE GOMEZ JOSEPHINE C ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 22,700 22,700 0 1633 NEW YORK AVE LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 17,581 17,581 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 3 of 28 loll RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1543 ROOSEVELT AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-228-551 STAFFORD DONALD A 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1543 ROOSEVELT AVE ASSD: 25,200 25,200 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 17,680 17,680 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1012 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1012 QUEEN ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-232-101 METOYER TEISHA 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1012 QUEEN ST ASSD: 24,300 24,300 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 14,375 24,300 9,925 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1013 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 914 W WILLOW ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-281-141 FLOURNOY SAMUEL&HATTIE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 914 W WILLOW ST ASSD: 46,200 46,200 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 46,200 17,280 -28,920 RECAP HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 1014 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 940 N M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-428-171 GARCIA RUBEN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 940 N M L KING JR BLVD ASSD: 27,200 27,200 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 18,690 18,690 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1015 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: EMERSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-081 ROBINSON RUTH H 2O04 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 3,600 3,600 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 3,375 3,375 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 4 of 28 1016 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1407 EMERSON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-091 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ROBINSON RUTH H ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 22,900 22,900 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 13,048 13,048 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1017 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1213 TURNER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-254-062 01 LANSING 1017 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE TERRY TERRY N ORIGINAL REVISED 6204 COLEMAN RD ASSD: 57,200 57,200 0 E LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 42,353 30,563 -11,790 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERCIAL ERROR STATUS: 1018 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 504 W GRAND RIVER AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-302-091 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE DUTCHER PAMELA K ORIGINAL REVISED 504 W GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 33,500 33,500 0 LANSING, MI.48906-4722 TAXABLE: 21,511 21,511 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1019 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: N CHESTNUT ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-303-031 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE SMITH KEVIN A&DANIELLE M ORIGINAL REVISED 1219 N WALNUT ST ASSD: 3,400 3,400 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 3,400 3,400 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1020 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1219 N WALNUT ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-303-161 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE SMITH KEVIN A&DANIELLE M ORIGINAL REVISED 1219 N WALNUT ST ASSD: 50,700 50,700 0 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 50,700 50,700 0 HEV%: 0 70 HEV-70 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 5 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 420 W KILBORN ST 1021 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-308-081 01 LANSING SMITH LESTER C 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 25,500 25,500 0 8454 BILLWOOD HWY TAXABLE: 14,694 14,694 0 CHARLOTTE,MI.488139337 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 621 BROOK ST 1022 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-352-211 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE GONZALEZ REYNALDO ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 29,800 29,800 0 621 BROOK ST TAXABLE: 25,268 25,268 0 LANSING,MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 619 BLUFF ST 1023 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-356-221 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE PFEIFER THOMAS M&MARY E ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 25,900 25,900 0 6900 PETERSEN DR TAXABLE: 13,870 13,870 0 ROCKFORD,MI.49341 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 508 W MADISON ST 1024 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-360-121 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE HALL RENEE M ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 50,700 50,700 0 508 W MADISON ST TAXABLE: 50,700 50,700 0 LANSING, MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 106 E GRAND RIVER AVE 1025 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-401-122 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE BURNS DIANE K ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 125,200 125,200 0 PO BOX 12025 TAXABLE: 65,296 65,296 0 LANSING,MI.48901 HEV%: 0 33 HEV-33 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 6 of 28 1026 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1623 VERMONT AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-132-211 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE DYER THOMAS C ORIGINAL REVISED 6915 VICTORIA SHORE ASSD: 15,600 15,600 0 LAINSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 14,536 14,536 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1027 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1635 ILLINOIS AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-133-211 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE WROE RUSSELL L&CHRISTINE M ORIGINAL AL REVISED 1635 ILLINOIS AVE ASSD: 21,300 21,300 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 15,347 15,347 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1028 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1229 VERMONT AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-181-311 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE MILLER EDMUND IF&GLENNA J ORIGINAL AL REVISED 4483 FIELDVIEW DR ASSD: 17,700 17,700 0 GRAND LEDGE,MI.48837-8114 TAXABLE: 16,476 16,476 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1029 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1107 N PENNSYLVANIA AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-304-181 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE RADEMACHER JOHN M&PEGGY A ORIGINAL REVISED 1107 N PENNSYLVANIA AVE ASSD: 33,700 33,700 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 18,658 18,658 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1030 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 901 CLARK ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-408-261 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE SNIDER LARRY J ORIGINAL REVISED 7404 S CHANDLER RD ASSD: 28,900 28,900 0 ST JOHNS,MI.48879 TAXABLE: 13,163 13,163 0 HEV%: 0 50 HEV-50 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 7 of 28 1031 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-271 KLEIN DAWN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 3,200 3,200 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,235 1,235 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1032 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-281 KLEIN DAWN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 3,400 3,400 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,462 1,462 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1033 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1444 E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-301 RIOS MERCEDES A 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1444 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 21,900 21,900 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 21,900 21,900 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1034 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2224 GROESBECK AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-11-104-151 GORVEATTE JOEL A&TRACY R 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2224 GROESBECK AVE ASSD: 71,000 71,000 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 71,000 71,000 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1035 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1918 KINGSWOOD DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-11-203-021 ALLEN VELMA P 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 10008 ASSD: 80,400 80,400 0 LANSING,MI.48908 TAXABLE: 62,737 62,737 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 8 of 28 1036 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 408 N CLEMENS AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-107-081 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE LOUNEY DENNIS&MARY ANN ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 59,300 59,300 0 408 N CLEMENS AVE LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 59,300 59,300 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 125 N HAYFORD AVE 1037 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-153-281 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE JACKSON NANCY ANN ORIGINAL AL REVISED 568 ARMSTRONG RD ASSD: 32,600 32,600 0 TAXABLE: 19,877 19,877 0 LANSING,MI.48911 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1038 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 215 N FOSTER AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-154-351 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE PARKEY ALBERT ORIGINAL REVISED 215 N FOSTER AVE ASSD: 24,600 24,600 0 TAXABLE: 24,600 24,600 0 LANSING,MI.48912 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1039 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-302-271 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE POTTER CHRISTOPHER J ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 37,700 37,700 0 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 22,782 22,782 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 205 S HAYFORD AVE 1040 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-305-101 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE MILLER DOUGLAS L ORIGINAL REVISED 205 S HAYFORD AVE ASSD: 29,600 29,600 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 20,398 20,398 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 9 of 28 1041 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 216 S MIFFLIN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-327-292 BRYANT DWIGHT 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 216 S MIFFLIN AVE ASSD: 21,500 21,500 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 21,500 21,500 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1042 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: S MIFFLIN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-327-302 BRYANT DWIGHT 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 216 S MIFFLIN AVE ASSD: 4,200 4,200 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 1,927 4,200 2,273 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100/UNCAP STATUS: 1043 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 209 N EIGHTH ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-153-132 01 LANSING WADE H E 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 209 N EIGHTH ST ASSD: 36,200 36,200 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 21,984 21,984 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1044 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 206 HORTON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-278-121 RITTER BRAD&ELAINE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 206 HORTON AVE ASSD: 46,800 46,800 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 46,800 46,800 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1045 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1800 JEROME ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-280-211 SAGOLLA TRACI L 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1800 JEROME ST ASSD: 42,300 42,300 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 33,525 33,525 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 10 of 28 1046 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 S EIGHTH ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-306-022 TAYLOR DAVID W&MARIAN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 16099 ASSD: 34,500 34,500 0 LANSING,MI.48901 TAXABLE: 34,500 17,162 -17,338 RECAP HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 1047 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 207 BINGHAM ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-330-011 MAYS VIRGINIA C&GARCIA MARTHA A 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 207 BINGHAM ST ASSD: 32,000 32,000 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 28,439 28,439 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 100 STATUS: 1048 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 425 S CHESTNUT ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-354-051 UNDERWOOD DELIAH 2O04 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 425 S CHESTNUT ST ASSD: 26,400 26,400 0 LANSING, Mi.48933 TAXABLE: 26,400 26,400 0 HEV-85 HEV%: 0 85 STATUS: 1049 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 N JENISON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-184-071 LOCKHART CINDY 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 211 N JENISON AVE ASSD: 54,300 54,300 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 51.763 51.763 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1050 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 917 W LAPEER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-228-331 FERGUSON JASON&ELIZABETH 2O04 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 917 W LAPEER ST ASSD: 40,300 40,300 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 40,300 40,300 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 50 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 11 of 28 1051 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 218 LAHOMA ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-258-031 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE WILSON ARTHUR ORIGINAL REVISED 53 WILLIAMSTOWNE CT APT#6 ASSD: 23,800 23,800 0 CHEEKTOWAGA,NY. 142272033 TAXABLE: 12,421 12,421 0 HEV%: 0 60 HEV-60 STATUS: 1052 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-68-970-000 01 LANSING TRANS LEASING INTERNATIONAL 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED GENERAL ELECTRIC CAPITAL 4151 BELTINE RD STE 124-308 ASSD: 6,000 0 -6,000 ADDISON,TX.75001 TAXABLE: 6,000 0 -6,000 DOUBLE ASSESS HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1053 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1119 CHELSEA AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-403-341 SMITH HOMER N&DORIS ANN 2 20-S DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 448 MCPHERSON AVE ASSD: 16,000 16,000 0 LANSING, Mi.489151158 TAXABLE: 7,900 7,900 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1054 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 228 S BUTLER BLVD 01 LANSING REZ COMPLIANT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-428-201 SEVEN BLOCK AREA DEVELOPMENT L C 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 2501 COOLIDGE RD STE#501 ASSD: 38,700 38,700 0 EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 20,902 20,902 0 HEV%: N/A N/A RZ COMPLIANT STATUS: 1055 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 919 W KALAMAZOO ST 01 LANSING REZ COMPLIANT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-476-322 D 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE VORAK MARY-PRANCES ORIGINAL REVISED 919 W KALAMAZOO ST ASSD: 57,300 57,300 0 LANSING, MI.48915 TAXABLE: 50,331 50,331 0 REZ COMPLIANT HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: REVISED RZ COMP CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 12 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1127 GEORGE ST 1056 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-20-456-261 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE WEBSTER MARILYN M& ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 43,400 43,400 0 1127 GEORGE ST LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 43,400 34,834 -8,566 HEV%: N/A N/A RECAP STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1726 TEEL AVE 1057 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-21-455-062 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE PACHECO ANGEL JR&AMY ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 34,500 34,500 0 1726 TEEL AVE TAXABLE: 32,429 32,429 0 LANSING,MI.48910 HEV%: 0 50 HEV-50 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1121 DAKIN ST 1058 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-253-061 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE MUNRO JEFFREY A&TINA S ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 35,000 35,000 0 1121 DAKIN ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 26,317 26,317 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1059 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1226 LATHROP ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-258-181 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE MENDOZA JUAN F&INEZ ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 17,800 17,800 0 1226 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 9,688 9,688 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1141 LATHROP ST 1060 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-276-091 01 LANSING JONES BONNIE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 40.500 40,500 0 1141 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 21,160 21,160 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 13 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: BAKER ST 1061 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-305-171 01 LANSING BLUBBER LINDA 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 2,900 2,900 0 1436 LYONS AVE TAXABLE: 2,659 2,659 0 LANSING, MI.48910 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1617 DONORA ST 1062 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-353-051 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE HAGAN KERRY D&SMORRA ADRIENNE M ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 15,800 15,800 0 628 W BARNES AVE LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 15,800 15,800 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100/LATE DI STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 925 KENWOOD AVE 1063 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-108-081 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE DAMON BARRY&CATHY ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 14,200 14,200 0 2240 S AURELIUS RD MASON,MI.48854 TAXABLE: 10,759 14,200 3,441 HEV%: N/A N/A LATE DISCOVERY STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3326 AURELIUS RD 1064 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-476-042 01 LANSING MAYER MELINDA 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 39,700 39,700 0 3326 AURELIUS RD TAXABLE: 39,283 39,283 0 LANSING,MI.48910 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 612 COOPER AVE 1065 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-105-091 01 LANSING JONES RAWLAIGH L 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 40,600 40,600 0 4815 DELBROOK AVE L TAXABLE: 19,007 19,007 0 LANSING,MI.48910-5313 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 14 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 713 PDXSON AVE 1066 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-108-131 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ARAMBULA JESUS P&ARAMBULA CARLOS ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 41,500 41,500 0 713 PDXSON AVE LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 29,038 29,038 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 619 TISDALE AVE 1067 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-283-081 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE STEVENS CHARLES K ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 32,000 32,000 0 937 OLD ERIN WAY TAXABLE: 19,155 19,155 0 LANSING,MI.48917 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1068 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 622 W HOLMES RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-352-191 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE PETERSON RICHARD L&ROBERTA L ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 20,700 20,700 0 3967 DELL RD TAXABLE: 19,641 19,641 0 HOLT,MI.48842 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1069 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2401 WELLINGTON RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-155-041 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE KOONS ARLENE M&KOONS EDWIN W ORIGINAL REVISED 2401 WELLINGTON RD ASSD: 56,600 56,600 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 42,560 42,560 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2421 STIRLING AVE 1070 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-277-041 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE LAHAINE GILBERT&DOROTHY(TRUSTEE) ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 90,400 90,400 0 2401 STIRLING AVE LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 58,256 58,256 0 HEV%: 100 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 15 of 28 1071 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3137 BOSTON BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-304-352 D 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE UNCAN CAL&JACKIE ORIGINAL REVISED 3137 BOSTON BLVD ASSD: 48,500 48,500 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 38,784 38,784 0 HEV%a: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1072 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3514 COOLEY DR 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-101-206 FREEMAN MARK E&JACQUELINE A 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 6450 W WILLOW HWY ASSD: 74,500 74,500 0 GRAND LEDGE, MI.48837 TAXABLE: 52,917 52,917 0 HEV-0 HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: 1073 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3110 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-381-051 WARD DONALD R 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 130 HALBERT ST ASSD: 56,100 56,100 0 GRAND LEDGE,MI.488371228 TAXABLE: 47,881 47,881 0 HEV%: 50 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1074 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2900 MALONEY ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-427-156 FRENDT DANIEL E 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2900 MALONEY ST ASSD: 26,400 26,400 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 17,869 26,393 8,524 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1075 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3706 WAINWRIGHT AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-131-401 TODD CYNTHIA 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3706 WAINWRIGHT AVE ASSD: 42,600 42,600 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 42,600 42,600 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 16 of 28 1076 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3610 JERREE ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-305-051 MARTINEZ-MORIEL RAUL 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3610 JERREE ST ASSD: 33,600 33,600 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 33,600 27,751 -5,849 RECAP HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: UNCAPPED RECAPPED 1077 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3421 MAYBEL ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-352-241 MAXIE CHRISTOPHER A 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3421 MAYBEL ST ASSD: 41,900 41,900 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 29,247 29,247 0 HEV-100 HEV%a: 0 100 STATUS: 1078 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4405 INGHAM ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-428-032 BRANKLIN RUTHIE J 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4405 INGHAM ST ASSD: 48,500 48,500 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 29,307 29,307 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1079 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4907 RICHMOND ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-479-121 WILLHEART CECIL&ALLIE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4907 RICHMOND ST ASSD: 35,200 35,200 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 25,871 28,449 2,578 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 0 100 STATUS: 1080 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3726 CHRISTIANSEN RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-102-221 SMITH HARRY 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5327 PLANTATION AVE ASSD: 41,200 41,200 0 VICKSBURG,MI.49097-9433 TAXABLE: 28,297 28,297 0 HEV-0 HEV%: 100 0 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 J U LY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 17 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4113 WALTON DR 1081 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-277-091 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE NGUYEN-VO TRICIA L ORIGINAL AL REVISED 4113 WALTON DR ASSD: 55,400 55,400 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 43,873 43,873 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1082 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4701 PLEASANT GROVE RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-32-351-002 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE GURU NANAK SIKH CENTER ORIGINAL REVISED 3434 PLEASANT GROVE RD ASSD: 91,400 0 -91,400 TAXABLE: 91,400 0 -91,400 LANSING,MI.48910 HEV%: N/A N/A EXEMPTION STATUS: 1083 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3702 SOUTHGATE AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-233-131 01 LANSING BEAN ROBERTA I 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4017 DEVONSHIRE AVE ASSD: 42,700 42,700 0 LANSING,MI.48910-4725 TAXABLE: 39,477 39,477 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1084 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 643 E CAVANAUGH RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-286-091 01 LANSING SARRELL CHARLIE B 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2926 W ST JOSEPH ST ASSD: 43,600 43,600 0 LANSING,MI.48917 TAXABLE: 42,240 42,240 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 646 SPOKANE AVE 1085 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-481-081 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE GIERA STEVEN J&KAREN J ORIGINAL AL REVISED 646 SPOKANE AVE ASSD: 76,200 64,900 -11,300 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 76,200 64,900 -11,300 HEV%: N/A N/A 10 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 18 of 28 1086 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5105 HUGHES RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-103-002 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE FLAGG NONA ORIGINAL REVISED 5105 HUGHES RD ASSD: 67,500 41,500 -26,000 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 65,826 41,500 -24,326 HEV%: N/A N/A 10 STATUS: 1087 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5900 S M L KING JR BLVD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-306-171 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE BITNER RUSSELL ORIGINAL REVISED 5900 S M L KING JR BLVD ASSD: 29,300 29,300 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 29,300 29,300 0 HEV%: 100 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 1088 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5861 S M L KING JR BLVD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-376-201 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE SNIDER DONALD&DOROTHY ORIGINAL AL REVISED 16343 CENTER RD ASSD: 29,600 29,600 0 EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 18,809 18.809 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1089 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5323 S WAVERLY RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-06-151-029 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE HEINRICH JOSHUA A ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 0 0 0 5323 S WAVERLY RD TAXABLE: 0 0 0 LANSING,MI.48911 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: logo RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: SOUTHFIELD AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-08-204-191 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE KRING DEBORAH ORIGINAL REVISED 1107 SOUTHFIELD AVE ASSD: 4,000 4,000 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 1,462 4,000 2,538 HEV%: N/A N/A LATE DISCOVERY STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 19 of 28 1091 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6230 COULSON CT 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-09-201-081 LYNCH MARK O 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6230 COULSON CT ASSD: 27,800 27,800 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 19,399 19,399 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1092 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6958 MEESE DR PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-09-351-091 06 HOLT RUNYON CASSIE&HUDDLE RYAN 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 6958 MEESE DR ASSD: 55,400 55,400 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 55,400 55,400 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1093 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6641 KINGDON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-426-211 06 HOLT RICHARDSON CHARLES A 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5307 FIERA ASSD: 70,100 70,100 0 LANSING,MI.48917 TAXABLE: 38,880 38.880 0 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 1094 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: GUINEA RD PARCEL NUMBER: 90-23-50-23-080-000 GRAND LEDGE TRIGEN/CINERGY-USFOS OF LANSING,LL 2 - DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVVIS]S ED ATTN:TAX DEPARTMENT 1000 EAST MAIN STREET ASSD: 400,000 0 -400,000 PLAINFIELD, IN.46168 TAXABLE: 400,000 0 -400,000 HEV%: N/A N/A DOUBLE ASSMT STATUS: 1095 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5540 S PENNSYLVANIA AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-01-278-000 01 LANSING ATI GROUP INTERGRATED ENVIRONMENTAL 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3419 PIERSON PL ASSD: 6,000 0 -6,000 FLUSHING,MI.48433-2413 TAXABLE: 6,000 0 -6,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 20 of 28 1096 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 914 MCKINLEY ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-01-630-000 PACE INTERNATIONAL UNION 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED LOCAL 6-1065 914 MC KINLEY ST ASSD: 6,000 0 -6,000 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 6,000 0 -6,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1097 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-03-606-000 AVAYA FINANCIAL SERVICE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED P.O.BOX 827 ASSD: 82,200 0 -82,200 PARSIPPANY,NJ.07054-0827 TAXABLE: 82,200 0 -82,200 DOUBLE ASSESSME HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 1098 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-06-608-000 BIG PIPE U S INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 630 3RD AVE S W STE 900 ASSD: 47,800 0 -47,800 CALGARY,ALBERTA,.T2P 41-4 TAXABLE: 47,800 0 -47,800 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1099 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 925 RIVER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-09-885-000 CAMPBELL INC PRESS REPAIR 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 925 RIVER ST ASSD: 138,900 105,100 -33,800 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 138,900 105,100 -33,800 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1100 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-10-010-000 CANON FINANCIAL SERV INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 158 GAITHER DR STE 200 PO BOX 5008 ASSD: 83,200 81,500 -1,700 MT LAUREL,NJ.08054 TAXABLE: 83,200 81,500 -1,700 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 21 of 28 1101 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5812 S CEDAR ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-13-003-000 CHENNAI VIDEO INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 27400 FRANKLIN RD APT 201 ASSD: 12,500 0 -12,500 SOUTHFIELD,MI.48034 TAXABLE: 12,500 0 -12,500 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1102 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-13-368-000 CITICORP DEL-LEASE INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 660237 ASSD: 65,000 0 -65,000 DALLAS,TX.75266-0237 TAXABLE: 65,000 0 -65,000 DOUBLE ASSESSED HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1103 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1120 KEYSTONE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-14-418-000 COMPUTER SYSTEMS CO INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED SHARON COY 6802 WEST SNOWVILLE RD ASSD: 189,200 0 -189,200 BRECKSVILLE,OH.44141 TAXABLE: 189,200 0 -189,200 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1104 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-19-951-000 UNIGRAPHICS SOLUTIONS INC 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED CORPORATE TAX 5400 LEGACY DR ASSD: 500 0 -500 PLANO,TX.75024 TAXABLE: 500 0 -500 DOUOBLE ASSESSE HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1105 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 908 E MT HOPE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-21-275-000 EXPRESSIONS SALON&SPA STUDIOS 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 207 ASSD: 4,000 0 -4,000 GRAND LEDGE, MI.48837 TAXABLE: 4,000 0 -4,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 22 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 908 W MT HOPE AVE 1106 PERSONALPROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-21-460-000 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE EXPRESSIONS STUDIO 9000 ORIGINAL REVISED ANTHONY MCLOUD 3708 GLASGOW DR ASSD: 15,000 0 -15,000 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 15,000 Q -15,000 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6927 S CEDAR ST 1107 PERSONALPROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-22-600-000 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE FLAP JACK FAMILY RESTAURANT ORIGINAL AL REVISED 6927 S CEDAR ST ASSD: 33,200 0 -33,200 TAXABLE: 33,200 0 -33,200 LANSING,MI.48911 HEV%: N/A N/A DOUBLE ASSESS STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5136 S CEDAR ST 1108 PERSONALPROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-24-103-000 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE FURNITURE FIRST LLC ORIGINAL REVISED 5136 S CEDAR ST ASSD: 17,000 11,000 -6,000 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 17,000 11,000 -6,000 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS 1109 PERSONALPROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-27-008-000 01 LANSING FNF CAPITAL INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 601 RIVERSIDE AVE ASSD: 35,000 0 -35,000 JACKSONVILLE,FL.32204 TAXABLE: 35,000 0 -35,000 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 900 W HOLMES RD 1110 PERSONAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-28460-000 01 LANSING MARYS NAILS 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED HAIR SHOPPE THE 900 W HOLMES RD ASSD: 5,000 1,500 -3,500 TAXABLE: 5,000 1,500 -3,500 LANSING,MI.48910 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERCIAL ERROR STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 23 of 28 1111 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-28-904-000 HARBOR EQUIPMENT LEASING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 701 CATHEDRAL STREET ASSD: 4,500 0 -4,500 BALTIMORE,MD.21201 TAXABLE: 4,500 0 -4,500 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERICAL ERROR STATUS: 1112 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-31-727-000 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE HPSC INC ORIGINAL REVISED TAX DEPT ONE BEACON ST,2ND FLR ASSD: 82,900 46,300 -36,600 BOSTON,MA.02108 TAXABLE: 82,900 46,300 -36.600 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1113 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-32-744-000 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE KINETIC CONCEPTS INC ORIGINAL REVISED P.O.BOX 160069 ASSD: 3,400 0 -3,400 SAN ANTONIO,TX.78280-2269 TAXABLE: 3,400 0 -3,400 DOUBLE ASSESSED HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 124 W ALLEGAN ST 1114 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-33-426-000 JOINT COMMITTEE ON ADMIN RULES 2 2004'S DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 124 W ALLEGAN ST ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERCIAL ERROR STATUS: 1115 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2025 S WASHINGTON AVE S PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-34-066-000 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE KELLAMS,W.R.,DO ORIGINAL REVISED 20321 GRANDE OAK BLVD#18 ASSD: 9,000 0 -9,000 ESTERO,FL.33928 TAXABLE: 9,000 0 -9,000 HEV%: N/A N/A CLERCIAL ERROR STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 24 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 124 W ALLEGAN ST 3RD FL 1116 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-001-000 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL ADMINISTRATOR 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 124 ALLEGAN ST 3RD FL ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 124 W ALLEGAN ST 1800 1117 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-002-000 LEGISLATIVE CORRECTION OMBUDSMAN 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 124 W ALLEGAN ST SUITE 1800 ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1118 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 124 W ALLEGAN ST 3RD FL 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-004-000 LEGISLATIVE BUREAU LEGAL DIVISION 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 124 W ALLEGAN ST 3RD FLOOR ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1119 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2025 W HOLMES RD STE 4 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-092-000 BURROUGHS TOOL TRUST 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED P.O.BOX 580 ASSD: 35,000 1,300 -33,700 HASLETT,MI.48840 TAXABLE: 35,000 1,300 -33,700 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1120 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-37-129-000 M 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE MARLIN LEASING CORP ORIGINAL REVISED PROPERTY ADMINISTRATION 124 GAITHER DRIVE SUITE 170 ASSD: 74,700 0 -74,700 MOUNT LAUREL,NJ.08054 TAXABLE: 74,700 0 -74,700 DOUBLE ASSESSME HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 25 of 28 1121 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-42-581-000 MARLIN LEASING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2009 CHENAULT DR,SUITE 100 ASSD: 54,500 74,700 20,200 CARROLLTON,TX.75006 TAXABLE: 54,500 74,700 20,200 DOUBLE ASSESSED HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1122 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2208 E MICHIGAN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-49-752-000 N R PATEL MD 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2208 E MICHIGAN AVE ASSD: 2,000 0 -2,000 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 2,000 0 -2,000 DOUBLE ASSESSED HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1123 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1216 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-55-370-000 PORTABLE FEAST&FRIENDS 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1216 TURNER ST ASSD: 200 0 -200 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 200 0 -200 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1124 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: VARIOUS LOCATIONS 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-55-994-000 PROJECT INNOVATIONS INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 22000 SPRINGBROOK STE 203 ASSD: 1,100 0 -1,100 FARMINGTON HILLS,MI.48336 TAXABLE: 1,100 0 -1,100 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1125 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1122 W HOLMES RD 22 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-57-785-000 RENT A CENTER#01667 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED P.O.BOX 22845 ASSD: 435,200 340.300 -94,900 OKLAHOMA CITY,OK.73123 TAXABLE: 435,200 340,300 -94,900 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 26 of 28 1126 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2208 E MICHIGAN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-59-662-000 S R BURTON MD 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2208 E MICHIGAN AVE ASSD: 2,000 0 -2,000 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 2,000 0 -2,000 DOUBLE ASSESS HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1127 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3101 TECHNOLOGY BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-61-593-000 SEQUOIA NET.COM 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3101 TECHNOLOGY BLVD ASSD: 15,000 0 -15,000 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 15,000 0 -15,000 DOUBLE ASSESS HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1128 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1115 N WASHINGTON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-64-100-000 SOUND EFX PRODUCTION 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 135 N MAIN ST ASSD: 45,000 4,500 -40,500 EATON RAPIDS,MI.48827 TAXABLE: 45,000 4,500 -40,500 CLERCIAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1129 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1146 S WASHINGTON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-64-373-000 SOUTH TOWN RESTAURANT 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1146 S WASHINGTON AVE ASSD: 25,000 5,000 -20,000 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 25,000 5,000 -20,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1130 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 301 S WASHINGTON SQ 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-65-029-000 SPIRIT OF DOWNTOWN LANSING LLC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 301 S WASHINGTON SQ ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,500 0 -2,500 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 27 of 28 1131 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3245 TECHNOLOGY BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-66-109-000 STRATEGIC INTERACTIVE INC 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3245 TECHNOLOGY BLVD ASSD: 174,500 0 -174,500 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 174,500 0 -174,500 DOUBLE ASSESSED HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1132 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4725 S CEDAR ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-66-508-000 SUN TRUST LEASING CORPORATION 2 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 9653 WENDELL RD ASSD: 4,000 0 -4,000 DALLAS,TX.75243 TAXABLE: 4,000 0 -4,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1133 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 424 ADAMS ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-67-211-000 S 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE TRANG TAX BUSINESS ORIGINAL REVISED STRANG THOMAS C III 424 ADAMS ST ASSD: 2,500 0 -2,500 LENSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 2.500 0 -2,500 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1134 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 118 W OTTAWA ST 02 LANSING TIFA#2 PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-67-832-000 THE SWEETEST HEART OF MARY INSTIT 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 309 N WASHINGTON SQ ASSD: 2,000 0 -2,000 LANSING,MI.48933 TAXABLE: 2,000 0 -2,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: 1135 PERSONAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 600 N CEDAR ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 90-33-01-68-643-000 AUTO ZONE 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED TAX DEPT 600 N CEDAR ST ASSD: 58,000 0 -58,000 LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 58,000 0 -58,000 CLERICAL ERROR HEV%: N/A N/A STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 J U LY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2004 7/19/2005 11:53:43 AM Page 28 of 28 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1922 THOMPSON ST 1136 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-229-031 01 LANSING 2 2004 DIFFERENCE BUSH JAMES&DEJAEGHER TAMMY ORIGINAL AL REVISED ASSD: 41,600 41,600 0 1922 THOMPSON ST TAXABLE: 8,616 8,816 0 LANSING, MI.48906 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1120 LATHROP ST 1137 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-254-163 01 LANSING 2004 2004 DIFFERENCE SCHAEFER ARTHUR O ORIGINAL REVISED ASSD: 24,600 24,600 0 1120 LATHROP ST TAXABLE: 12,931 12,931 0 LANSING,MI.48912 HEV%: 0 100 HEV-100 STATUS: TOTAL ASSD: 5,753,600 4,103,900 -1,649,700 TOTAL TAXABLE: 5,011,965 3,326,823 -1,685,142 CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Pagel of 10 2001 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3629 SEAWAY DR 21 LANSING/EATON CO PARCEL NUMBER: 23-50-40-36-202-051 SCATES ARCHIE&LONNIE M 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3629 SEAWAY DR ASSD: 57,800 57,800 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 55,551 55,551 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2002 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3233 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-106-211 PHILIPP CAROLYN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3233 TURNER ST ASSD: 17,000 17,000 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 10,512 13,804 3,292 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2003 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 345 FILLEY ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-327-421 FINEIS GREGG R 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 11360 OLD BARN TRL ASSD: 30,800 30.800 0 EATON RAPIDS,MI.48827-9796 TAXABLE: 17,697 17,697 0 HEV-0 HEV%: 0 STATUS: 2004 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 E JACKSON ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-402-231 DAY DUANE&ANDREA L 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 7555 E GRAND RIVER RD ASSD: 30,600 30,600 0 LAINGSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 27,672 27.672 0 HEV%: 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 2005 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1543 ROOSEVELT AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-228-551 STAFFORD DONALD A 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1543 ROOSEVELT AVE ASSD: 22,400 22,400 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 17,283 17,283 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 2 of 10 2006 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 940 N M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-08-428-171 GARCIA RUBEN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 940 N M L KING JR BLVD ASSD: 22,200 22,200 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 18,270 18,270 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2007 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: EMERSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-081 ROBINSON RUTH H 2O03 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 3,300 3,300 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 3,300 3,300 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2008 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1407 EMERSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-091 ROBINSON RUTH H 2O03 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE ASSD: 20,200 20.200 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 12,755 12,755 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2009 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1213 TURNER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-254-062 TERRY TERRY N 2009 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6204 COLEMAN RD ASSD: 53,900 53,900 0 E LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 41,401 29,876 -11,525 RECAP HEV%: N/A STATUS: 2010 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 621 BROOK ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-352-211 GONZALEZ REYNALDO 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 621 BROOK ST ASSD: 24,700 24,700 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 24,700 24,700 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 3 of 10 2011 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 106 E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-401-122 BURNS DIANE K 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED PO BOX 12025 ASSD: 121,300 121,300 0 LANSING,MI.48901 TAXABLE: 63,828 63,828 0 HEV%: 33 HEV-33 STATUS: 2012 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1623 VERMONT AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-132-211 DYER THOMAS C 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6915 VICTORIA SHORE ASSD: 15,200 15,200 0 LAINSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 14,210 14,210 0 HEV%: 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 2013 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1635 ILLINOIS AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-133-211 WROE RUSSELL L&CHRISTINE M 2 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 1635 ILLINOIS AVE ASSD: 20,300 20,300 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 15,002 15,002 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2014 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-271 KLEIN DAWN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 2,900 2,900 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,208 1,208 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2015 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-281 KLEIN DAWN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE ASSD: 3,100 3,100 0 LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,430 1,430 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 4 of 10 2016 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 125 N HAYFORD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-153-281 JACKSON NANCY ANN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 568 ARMSTRONG RD ASSD: 30,300 30,300 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 19,431 19,431 0 HEV-0 HEV%: 0 STATUS: 2017 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-302-271 POTTER CHRISTOPHER J 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE ASSD: 33,800 33,800 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 22,270 22.270 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2018 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 205 S HAYFORD AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-305-101 MILLER DOUGLAS L 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 205 S HAYFORD AVE ASSD: 27,000 27,000 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 19,940 19,940 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2019 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 216 S MIFFLIN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-327-292 BRYANT DWIGHT 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 216 S MIFFLIN AVE ASSD: 19,300 19,300 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 13,943 13,943 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2020 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: S MIFFLIN AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-327-302 BRYANT DWIGHT 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 216 S MIFFLIN AVE ASSD: 3,800 3,800 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 1,884 1,884 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 5 of 10 2021 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 209 N EIGHTH ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-153-132 WADE H E 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 209 N EIGHTH ST ASSD: 32,300 32,300 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 21,490 21,490 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2022 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 S EIGHTH ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-306-022 01 LANSING 2 2003 DIFFERENCE TAYLOR DAVID W&MARIAN ORIGINAL AL REVISED PO BOX 16099 ASSD: 32,600 32,600 0 LANSING,MI.48901 TAXABLE: 32,600 16,777 -15,823 HEV%: N/A RECAP STATUS: 2023 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 207 BINGHAM ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-330-011 01 LANSING 2 2003 DIFFERENCE MAYS VIRGINIA C&GARCIA MARTHA A ORIGINAL AL REVISED 207 BINGHAM ST ASSD: 27,800 27,800 0 LANSING, MI.48912 TAXABLE: 27,800 27,800 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2024 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 425 S CHESTNUT ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-16-354-051 01 LANSING 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE UNDERWOOD DELIAH ORIGINAL REVISED 425 S CHESTNUT ST ASSD: 21,700 21,700 0 LANSING, MI.48933 TAXABLE: 14,653 14,653 0 HEV%: 85 HEV-85 STATUS: 2025 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 N JENISON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-184-071 01 LANSING 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE LOCKHART CINDY ORIGINAL REVISED 211 N JENISON AVE ASSD: 50,600 50,600 0 LANSING,MI.48915 TAXABLE: 50,600 50,600 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 6 of 10 2026 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 218 LAHOMA ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-258-031 WILSON ARTHUR 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 53 WILLIAMSTOWNE CT APT#6 ASSD: 19,900 19,900 0 CHEEKTOWAGA,NY. 142272033 TAXABLE: 12,142 12,142 0 HEV%: 60 HEV-60 STATUS: 2027 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1119 CHELSEA AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-403-341 SMITH HOMER N&DORIS ANN 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 448 MCPHERSON AVE ASSD: 13,600 13,600 0 LANSING,MI.489151158 TAXABLE: 7,723 7,723 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2028 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1726 TEEL AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-21-455-062 PACHECO ANGEL JR&AMY 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1726 TEEL AVE ASSD: 31,700 31,700 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 21,918 31,700 9,782 HEV-50/LATE DI HEV%: 50 STATUS: 2029 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1226 LATHROP ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-258-181 MENDOZA JUAN F&INEZ 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1226 LATHROP ST ASSD: 14,800 14,800 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 9,471 9,471 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2030 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1141 LATHROP ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-276-091 JONES BONNIE 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1141 LATHROP ST ASSD: 35,300 35,300 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 20,685 20,685 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 7 of 10 2031 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: BAKER ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-305-171 BLUBBER LINDA 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1436 LYONS AVE ASSD: 2,600 2,600 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 2,600 2,600 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2032 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1617 DONORA ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-353-051 HAGAN KERRY D&SMORRA ADRIENNE M 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 628 W BARNES AVE ASSD: 14,500 14,500 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 12,641 12,641 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2033 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3326 AURELIUS RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-27-476-042 MAYER MELINDA 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3326 AURELIUS RD ASSD: 38,400 38,400 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 38,400 38,400 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2034 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 713 PDXSON AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-108-131 ARAMBULA JESUS P&ARAMBULA CARLOS 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 713 PDXSON AVE ASSD: 34,700 34,700 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 28,386 28,386 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2035 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 622 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-28-352-191 PETERSON RICHARD L&ROBERTA L 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 3967 DELL RD ASSD: 19,200 19,200 0 HOLT, MI.48842 TAXABLE: 19,200 19,200 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 8 of 10 2036 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2401 WELLINGTON RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-155-041 01 LANSING 2 2003 DIFFERENCE KOONS ARLENE M&KOONS EDWIN W ORIGINAL AL REVISED 2401 WELLINGTON RD ASSD: 51,400 51,400 0 LANSING, MI.48910 TAXABLE: 41,604 41,604 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2037 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2421 STIRLING AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-277-041 01 LANSING 2 2003 DIFFERENCE LAHAINE GILBERT&DOROTHY(TRUSTEE) ORIGINAL AL REVISED 2401 STIRLING AVE ASSD: 82,300 82,300 0 LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 56,947 56,947 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2038 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3110 W HOLMES RD PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-381-051 01 LANSING 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE WARD DONALD R ORIGINAL REVISED 130 HALBERT ST ASSD: 50,100 50,100 0 GRAND LEDGE, MI.488371228 TAXABLE: 46,805 46,805 0 HEV%: 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 2039 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2900 MALONEY ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-427-156 01 LANSING 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE FRENDT DANIEL E ORIGINAL REVISED 2900 MALONEY ST ASSD: 25,800 25,800 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 17,468 25,800 8,332 HEV%: 100 HEV-100/LATE DI STATUS: 2040 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3706 WAINWRIGHT AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-131-401 01 LANSING 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE TODD CYNTHIA ORIGINAL REVISED 3706 WAINWRIGHT AVE ASSD: 41,500 41,500 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 29,766 29,766 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 9 of 10 2041 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3421 MAYBEL ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-352-241 M 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE AXIE CHRISTOPHER A ORIGINAL REVISED 3421 MAYBEL ST ASSD: 38,100 38,100 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 28,590 28,590 0 HEV%a: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: 2042 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4907 RICHMOND ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-479-121 WILLHEART CECIL&ALLIE 2 — DIFFERENCE ORIGG ININ AL REVVISIS ED 4907 RICHMOND ST ASSD: 29,600 29,600 0 LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 25,290 27,810 2,520 HEV-100/LATE DI HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2043 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3702 SOUTHGATE AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-233-131 BEAN ROBERTA I 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 4017 DEVONSHIRE AVE ASSD: 42,000 42,000 0 LANSING,MI.48910-4725 TAXABLE: 38,590 38,590 0 HEV%: 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 2044 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 643 E CAVANAUGH RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-33-286-091 SARRELL CHARLIE B 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 2926 W ST JOSEPH ST ASSD: 43,000 43,000 0 LANSING, MI.48917 TAXABLE: 41,291 41,291 0 HEV%: 0 HEV-0 STATUS: 2045 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5861 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-376-201 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE SNIDER DONALD&DOROTHY ORIGINAL REVISED 16343 CENTER RD ASSD: 26,600 26,600 0 EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 18,387 18,387 0 HEV%: 100 HEV-100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2003 7/19/2005 12:11:37 PM Page 10 of 10 2046 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5125 WEXFORD RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-06-126-041 CAPOCCIA RICHARD L 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5125 WEXFORD RD ASSD: 18,800 18,800 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 18,800 18,800 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2047 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6230 COULSON CT 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-09-201-081 LYNCH MARK O 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 6230 COULSON CT ASSD: 26,700 26,700 0 LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 18,963 18,963 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2048 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6641 KINGDON AVE 06 HOLT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-426-211 RICHARDSON CHARLES A 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 5307 FIERA ASSD: 60,900 60,900 0 LANSING,MI.48917 TAXABLE: 38,006 38,006 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: 2049 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1120 LATHROP ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-254-163 SCHAEFER ARTHUR O 2003 2003 DIFFERENCE ORIGINAL REVISED 1120 LATHROP ST ASSD: 20,400 20,400 0 LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 12,641 12,641 0 HEV-100 HEV%: 100 STATUS: CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 1 of 6 3001 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3629 SEAWAY DR 21 LANSING/EATON CO PARCEL NUMBER: 23-50-40-36-202-051 SCATES ARCHIE&LONNIE M 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 3629 SEAWAY DR LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 13,253 13,253 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3002 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3233 TURNER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-106-211 01 LANSING PHILIPP CAROLYN 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 3233 TURNER ST LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 10,357 10,357 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3003 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 E JACKSON ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-04-402-231 01 LANSING DAY DUANE&ANDREA L 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 7555 E GRAND RIVER RD LAINGSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 27,264 27,264 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 100% 0% 3004 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1407 EMERSON AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-154-091 01 LANSING 2002 2002 ROBINSON RUTH H ORIGINAL REVISED 1407 EMERSON AVE LANSING, MI.48906 TAXABLE: 12,567 12,567 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3005 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1213 TURNER ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-254-062 01 LANSING 2 2002 TERRY TERRY N ORIGINAL AL REVISED 6204 COLEMAN RD E LANSING,Mi.48823 TAXABLE: 40,790 29,435 -11,355 REASON: RECAPPING HEV%: 0% 0% CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 2 of 6 3006 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 621 BROOK ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-352-211 GONZALEZ REYNALDO 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 621 BROOK ST LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 14,324 14,324 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3007 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 106 E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-09-401-122 BURNS DIANE K 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED PO BOX 12025 LANSING, MI.48901 TAXABLE: 55,890 55,890 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 33% 3008 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1623 VERMONT AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-132-211 01 LANSING DYER THOMAS C 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 6915 VICTORIA SHORE LAINSBURG,MI.48848 TAXABLE: 14.000 14,000 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 100% 0% 3009 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1635 ILLINOIS AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-133-211 01 LANSING WROE RUSSELL L&CHRISTINE M 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 1635 ILLINOIS AVE LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 14,781 14,781 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3010 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-271 01 LANSING KLEIN DAWN 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,191 1,191 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 3 of 6 3011 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: E GRAND RIVER AVE 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-10-410-281 KLEIN DAWN 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 1448 E GRAND RIVER AVE LANSING,MI.48906 TAXABLE: 1,409 1,409 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3012 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 125 N HAYFORD AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-153-281 01 LANSING JACKSON NANCY ANN 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 568 ARMSTRONG RD LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 19,144 19,144 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 100% 0% 3013 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-302-271 01 LANSING POTTER CHRISTOPHER J 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 212 S FAIRVIEW AVE LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 21,941 21,941 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3014 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 205 S HAYFORD AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-14-305-101 01 LANSING MILLER DOUGLAS L 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 205 S HAYFORD AVE LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 19,646 19,646 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3015 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 211 S EIGHTH ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-15-306-022 01 LANSING TAYLOR DAVID W&MARIAN 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED PO BOX 16099 LANSING,MI.48901 TAXABLE: 32,400 16,530 -15.870 REASON: RECAPPING HEV%: 0% 0% CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 4 of 6 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 218 LAHOMA ST 3016 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-258-031 01 LANSING 2 2002 WILSON ARTHUR ORIGINAL AL REVISED 53 WILLIAMSTOWNE CT APT#6 CHEEKTOWAGA,NY. 142272033 TAXABLE: 11,963 11,963 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 60% 3017 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1119 CHELSEA AVE PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-17-403-341 01 LANSING SMITH HOMER N&DORIS ANN 2 2002 ORIGG ININ AL REVISED 448 MCPHERSON AVE LANSING,MI.489151158 TAXABLE: 9,549 9,549 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1226 LATHROP ST 3018 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-258-181 01 LANSING 2 2002 MENDOZA JUAN F&INEZ ORIGINAL AL REVISED 1226 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 9,332 9,332 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3019 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1141 LATHROP ST PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-276-091 01 LANSING 2 2002 JONES BONNIE ORIGINAL AL REVISED 1141 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 20,380 20,380 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2421 STIRLING AVE 3020 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-29-277-041 01 LANSING 2 2002 LAHAINE GILBERT&DOROTHY(TRUSTEE) ORIGINAL AL REVISED 2401 STIRLING AVE LANSING,MI.48910 TAXABLE: 56,106 56,106 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 100% 100% CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 5 of 6 3021 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3110 W HOLMES RD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-30-381-051 WARD DONALD R 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 130 HALBERT ST GRAND LEDGE,MI.488371228 TAXABLE: 46,114 46,114 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 50% 0% 3022 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 3421 MAYBEL ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-352-241 MAXIE CHRISTOPHER A 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 3421 MAYBEL ST LANSING, MI.48911 TAXABLE: 28,168 28,168 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3023 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4907 RICHMOND ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-31-479-121 WILLHEART CECIL&ALLIE 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 4907 RICHMOND ST LANSING,MI.48911 TAXABLE: 27,400 27,400 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3024 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 5861 S M L KING JR BLVD 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-05-376-201 SNIDER.DONALD&DOROTHY 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 16343 CENTER RD EAST LANSING,MI.48823 TAXABLE: 18,116 18,116 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% 3025 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6641 KINGDON AVE 06 HOLT PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-05-10-426-211 RICHARDSON CHARLES A 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 5307 FIERA LANSING, MI.48917 TAXABLE: 37,445 37,445 0 REASON: HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% CITY OF LANSING 2005 JULY BOARD OF REVIEW for 2002 7/19/2005 12:21:07 PM Page 6 of 6 3026 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1120 LATHROP ST 01 LANSING PARCEL NUMBER: 33-01-01-22-254-163 SCHAEFER ARTHUR 0 2002 2002 ORIGINAL REVISED 1120 LATHROP ST LANSING,MI.48912 TAXABLE: 12,455 12,455 0 REASON:HOMESTEAD CHANGES HEV%: 0% 100% COUNT:26 �T1 S I CITY ASSESSOR'S OFFICE y G 3rd Floor, City Hall 124 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing, Mi. 48933-1687 (517) 483-4020 cHi � e, Tony Benavides, Mayor David Tijerina, Assessor Board of Review Minutes of March 14, 2005 through March 23, 2005 Members Present Eddie Thomas, Chairperson Curtis McKinnon, Jr. Sonya Moore Staff Present David Tijerina, City Assessor Mary Lou Andrews, Assessing Supervisor The board members reviewed the proposed revisions to the Bylaws and Rules of Procedure for the Board of Review that were distributed to board members at the Organizational Meeting held March 8, 2005. Eddie Thomas approved to approve the Bylaws and Rules of Procedure for the board of Review as submitted with noted amendments. (Attached). Sonya Moore supported the motion. Motion Carried Unanimously. The Board began board hearings and board adjustments. (Attached). The March Board of Review completed hearing on Monday, March 21, 2005 and completed board decisions on Wednesday, March 23, 2005. "Equal Opportunity Employer" r Approved 3/14/2005 CITY OF LANSING BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW I. MEETINGS Pursuant to Public Act 257 of 1976, all meetings shall be open to the public and the public shall have a reasonable opportunity to be heard. Organization Meeting First meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held the Tuesday following the first Monday in March each year. Time of the meeting as determined by the Secretary will be held in the office of the City Assessor, 3`d Floor, City Hall, or at a designated meeting place held in the City, and indicated to and approved by each Board of Review member by written communication. cv Regular Meeting Second meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held beginning the second Monday of March in the board room, 3`d Floor, City Hall, and continuing until the completion of business on that day. Regular meetings shall continue on a daily basis for at least five calendar days. No owner/taxpayer initiated appointment shall be made to meet with the Lansing Board of Review unless the resident or nonresident taxpayer has contacted the Assessor's Office, Yd Floor, City Hall, on or before 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review, or a nonresident taxpayer has submitted a written request by mail which is received no later than 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review. Special Meeting Special meeting may be called by the Chairperson or Secretary for the 3`d Monday in March and subsequent days until the conclusion of all necessary and proper business. Assessor staff recommended changes submitted after the Assessor's assessment roll is certified(1"Monday of March), due to required assessment corrections,will be reviewed, considered, and acted upop by the Board of Review. Board of Review assessment change notices will be sent to each owner/taxpayer of such property, and an appointment shall be made available to meet with the Board of Review during the regular meeting if possible. 1 i July Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the third Monday in July,the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall. December Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the 2nd Monday in December, the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall. Notice of Meetings In accordance with the requirements of Public Act 267 of 1976,the Secretary shall post a notice of all meetings in the office of the City Assessor,the City Clerk's Office,the City Council reception area, and on the bulletin board in the lobby of City Hall. All public notices required shall contain the name of the Board, and the address, and telephone number of the Assessor's Office. In addition to the posted notices, an ad noting time, place and days of the regular meeting of the Board shall appear in a newspaper of general circulation for three successive issues at least one week prior to the meeting. Membership In accordance with Sec 211.28 (2)MCL,the Board shall consist of three members for the purpose of hearing and deciding issues protested. Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson are allowed to make motions and support motions. Quorum All business transacted by the Board shall be conducted only at a meeting at which a quorum is present. A quorum shall consist of at least two members of the Board. Any items, or business coming before the Board shall be approved only by the affirmative vote of a least a quorum of the members of the Board. Whenever a quorum of two of the Board members is not present at a regular or special meeting, the day's hearings or business shall be rescheduled by the Secretary, and all appellants notified. Disqualification Any member of the Board of Review having a direct, or indirect financial interest in any matter before the Board; who may stand to gain or lose, financially or otherwise, due to 2 action of the Board on any matter; or who shall be related by blood or marriage to a person having a proprietary interest in any matter before the Board shall indicate such interest or relationship to the Board and shall be disqualified from voting on such a matter. Attendance Board members shall regularly attend all Board meetings. In the event a Board member is absent, (un-excused absence, only) from three regular meetings without a substantial reason; the Board may, by a vote of at least two members, recommend to the Mayor and the City Council that the subject Board member be removed from office. Excused Absences An excused absence shall be for a substantial reason. A member of the Board of Review shall request an excused absence by contacting either the Chairperson or the Secretary of the Board prior to the meeting in question. Approval of a request for an excused absence shall be determined by the Board of Review. All other absences shall be considered as un- excused absences. II. ORDER OF BUSINESS AAgenda The Secretary shall prepare a schedule of hearings or order of business for each meeting. The order of business shall be as follows: 1. Roll Call. 2. Excused Absence. 3. Assessments appeal hearings per schedule. 4. Committee of the Whole as time permits. 5. All business other than hearings. 6. Adjournment. Individuals, other than scheduled appellants, desiring to speak may be heard at the discretion of the Chairperson. They will be limited to three minutes unless limitation is waived by the Board. 3 Non Residential Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A nonresident taxpayer shall be permitted to file his or her appearance,protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall not be required. Resident Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A resident taxpayer will not be permitted to file his or her appearance,protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall be required. It will be assumed that reasonable attempts will be made by the Assessor to notify such resident taxpayers that either a personal appearance must be made, or an authorized agent must make a personal appearance for Board of Review consideration. Owner/Taxpayer Authorized Agent Representation An owner/taxpayer of record(per current City records, or by new evidence presented) may be represented at the Lansing Board of Review,by an owner/taxpayer authorized agent. The authorization must be in writing, must contain an owner/taxpayer current dated signature, must identify the property by address and/or assessment parcel number, must identify the name of the agent, or the agent firm or company, and must identify the tax year applicable for the representation before the Board of Review. Minutes of Meetings The Secretary shall record the minutes of each meeting of the Board of Review. The minutes of all meetings shall be filed by the Secretary in the office of City Clerk as a public record. III. ORGANIZATION AND ELECTION OF OFFICERS Election and Term of Office The Board shall, at its Organization Meeting in March, elect a Chairperson and a Vice- Chairperson from among the voting members. The Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson so elected shall each hold his or her term of office one year. All elective officers are eligible for re-election. The Assessor shall be the Secretary of the Board. The Committee of The Whole shall elect a Chair and Vice-Chair for each committee. Vacancy of Office In the event the office of the Chairperson becomes vacant,the Vice-Chairperson shall become Chairperson of the Board for the unexpired term. 4 r Duties of Officers - COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE The Chairperson shall preside at all meetings. In the absence of the Chairperson, the Vice- Chairperson shall act in the capacity of the Chairperson. In the absence of both the Chairperson and the Vice-Chairperson,the Board shall select a successor. IV. AMENDMENTS TO BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE Amendments of the bylaws and rules of procedure may be initiated by any member of the Board of Review by presenting the amendment(s) in writing at any regular meeting of the Committee of the Whole,to be voted upon at the next regular meeting. All Board members must be notified of such amendment(s)by mail at least five days before voting upon said amendment(s). The affirmative vote of at least two members of the Board shall be required to amend the bylaws and rules of procedure. V. In all matters of procedure not covered by these rules,the provisions of the Michigan Statutes and the Lansing City Charter shall prevail. BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW AS PROPOSED MARCH 8,2005,AMENDED AND APPROVED MARCH 14,2005. 5 cgs Approved 3/14/2005 CITY OF LANSING BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW I. MEETINGS Pursuant to Public Act 257 of 1976, all meetings shall be open to the public and the public shall have a reasonable opportunity to be heard. Organization Meeting First meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held the Tuesday following the first Monday in March each year. Time of the meeting as determined by the Secretary will be held in the office of the City Assessor, ) Floor, City Hall, or at a designated meeting place held in the City, and indicated to and approved by each Board of Review member by written communication. Regular Meeting Second meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held beginning the second Monday of March in the board room, 3`d Floor, City Hall, and continuing until the completion of business on that day. Regular meetings shall continue on a daily basis for at least five calendar days. No owner/taxpayer initiated appointment shall be made to meet with the Lansing Board of Review unless the resident or nonresident taxpayer has contacted the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall, on or before 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review, or a nonresident taxpayer has submitted a written request by mail which is received no later than 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review. Special Meeting Special meeting may be called by the Chairperson or Secretary for the 3`d Monday in March and subsequent days until the conclusion of all necessary and proper business. Assessor staff recommended changes submitted after the Assessor's assessment roll is certified (1"Monday of March), due to required assessment corrections, will be reviewed, considered, and acted upon by the Board of Review. Board of Review assessment change notices will be sent to each owner/taxpayer of such property, and an appointment shall be made available to meet with the Board of Review during the regular meeting if possible. 1 July Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the third Monday in July, the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3 d Floor, City Hall. December Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the 2"d Monday in December, the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3 d Floor, City Hall. Notice of Meetings In accordance with the requirements of Public Act 267 of 1976, the Secretary shall post a notice of all meetings in the office of the City Assessor, the City Clerk's Office, the City Council reception area, and on the bulletin board in the lobby of City Hall. All public notices required shall contain the name of the Board, and the address, and telephone number of the Assessor's Office. In addition to the posted notices, an ad noting time, place and days of the regular meeting of the Board shall appear in a newspaper of general circulation for three successive issues at least one week prior to the meeting. Committees MEMBERSHIP In accordance with Ordinance 858, which increased the membership of the Board of Review to six (6)public members, the Board has been increased to six members. In accordance with Sec 211.28 (2) MCL, the Board shall divide into committees consistiLg of three members each for the purpose of hearing and deciding issues protested. Committee A - 3 Members, quorum is two members Committee B - 3 Members, quorum is two members Committee Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson are allowed to make motions and support motions. Quorum All business transacted by the Board shall be conducted only at a meeting at which a quorum is present. A quorum shall consist of at least our two members of the Board. and two members of the committee. Any items, or business coming before the Board shall be approved only by the affirmative vote of a least a quorum of the members of the Board. Whenever a quorum of our two 2 of the Board, or if hvo of the Committee members is not present at a regular or special meeting, the day's hearings or business shall be rescheduled by the Secretary, and all appellants notified. Disqualification Any member of the Board of Review having a direct, or indirect financial interest in any matter before the Board; who may stand to gain or lose, financially or otherwise, due to action of the Board on any matter; or who shall be related by blood or marriage to a person having a proprietary interest in any matter before the Board shall indicate such interest or relationship to the Board and shall be disqualified from voting on such a matter. Attendance Board members shall regularly attend all Board meetings. In the event a Board member is absent, (un-excused absence, only) from three regular meetings without a substantial reason; the Board may, by a vote of at least our two members, recommend to the Mayor and the City Council that the subject Board member be removed from office. Excused Absences An excused absence shall be for a substantial reason. A member of the Board of Review shall request an excused absence by contacting either the Chairperson or the Secretary of the Board prior to the meeting in question. Approval of a request for an excused absence shall be determined by the Board of Review. All other absences shall be considered as un- excused absences. II. ORDER OF BUSINESS Amanda The Secretary shall prepare a schedule of hearings or order of business for each meeting. The order of business shall be as follows: 1. Roll Call. 2. Excused Absence. 3. Assessments appeal hearings per schedule. 4. Committee of the Whole as time permits. 5. All business other than hearings. 6. Adjournment. Individuals, other than scheduled appellants, desiring to speak may be heard at the discretion of the Chairperson. They will be limited to three minutes unless limitation is waived by the Board. Non-Residential Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A nonresident taxpayer shall be permitted to file his or her appearance, protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall not be required. Resident Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A resident taxpayer will not be permitted to file his or her appearance, protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall be required. It will be assumed that reasonable attempts will be made by the Assessor to notify such resident taxpayers that either a personal appearance must be made, or an authorized agent must make a personal appearance for Board of Review consideration. Owner/Taxpayer Authorized Agent Representation An owner/taxpayer of record (per current City records, or by new evidence presented) may be represented at the Lansing Board of Review, by an owner/taxpayer authorized agent. The authorization must be in writing, must contain an owner/taxpayer current dated signature, must identify the property by address and/or assessment parcel number, must identify the name of the agent, or the agent firm or company, and must identify the tax year applicable for the representation before the Board of Review. Minutes of Meetings The Secretary shall record the minutes of each meeting of the Board of Review. The minutes of all meetings shall be filed by the Secretary in the office of City Clerk as a public record. III. ORGANIZATION AND ELECTION OF OFFICERS Election and Term of Office The Board shall, at its Organization Meeting in March, elect a Chairperson and a Vice- Chairperson from among the voting members. The Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson so 4 elected shall each hold his or her term of office one year. All elective officers are eligible for re-election. The Assessor shall be the Secretary of the Board. The Committee of The Whole shall elect a Chair and Vice-Chair for each committee. Vacancy of Office In the event the office of the Chairperson becomes vacant, the Vice-Chairperson shall become Chairperson of the Board for the unexpired term. Duties of Officers - COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE The Chairperson shall preside at all meetings. In the absence of the Chairperson, the Vice- Chairperson shall act in the capacity of the Chairperson. In the absence of both the Chairperson and the Vice-Chairperson, the Board shall select a successor. IV. AMENDMENTS TO BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE Amendments of the bylaws and rules of procedure may be initiated by any member of the Board of Review by presenting the amendment(s) in writing at any regular meeting of the Committee of the Whole, to be voted upon at the next regular meeting. All Board members must be notified of such amendment(s) by mail at least five days before voting upon said amendment(s). The affirmative vote of at least our two members of the Board shall be required to amend the bylaws and rules of procedure. V. In all matters of procedure not covered by these rules, the provisions of the Michigan Statutes and the Lansing City Charter shall prevail. BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW AS PROPOSED MARCH S,2005,AMENDED AND APPROVED MARCH 14,2005. 5 03/W/2005 11:47:54 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 1 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6001 23-50-40-33-101-801 305 DELTA TOWNSHIP UTILITIES II 0 2,557,400 2,131,100 -426,300 0 2,557,400 2,131,100 -426,300 A 9001 23-50-40-36-177-001 401 USSERY LILLIE B 38,900 39,900 9,800 -30,100 32,331 33,074 9,800 -23,274 A 8001 23-50-40-36-226-011 201 GUPTA SHAM L 714,000 714,000 714,000 0 696,937 712,966 712,966 0 A 6002 23-50-40-36-276-071 401 WHITFORD FARIN D&CATHERINE S 56,500 60,000 50,000 -10,000 47,090 60,000 50,000 -10,000 A 6003 23-50-40-36-405-131 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 72,700 77,100 61,900 -15,200 67,518 69,070 61,900 -7,170 A 8002 23-50-40-36-405-141 201 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 805,700 805,700 805,700 0 755,084 772,450 772,450 0 A 8003 23-50-40-36-407-011 201 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 1,076,100 1,076,100 1,076,100 0 972,235 994,596 994,596 0 A 8004 23-50-40-36-407-021 201 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 903,900 903,900 903,900 0 887,888 903,900 903,900 0 A 8005 23-50-40-36-429-032 201 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 555,500 555,500 555,500 0 555,500 555,500 555,500 0 A 8006 23-50-40-36-476-001 201 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 11266,200 1,266,200 1,266,200 0 1,266,200 1,266,200 1,266,200 0 A 8007 23-50-80-01-201-004 201 SUN SECURED FINANCING L L C 1,297,600 1,361,600 1,361,600 0 1,009,274 1,032,487 1,032,487 0 A 8008 23-50-80-01-201-011 201 EDWARD ROSE ASSOCIATES INC 21,700 22,600 22,600 0 11,499 11,763 11,763 0 A I 8009 23-50-80-0.1-226-022 201 EDWARD ROSE ASSOCIATES INC � 1,400,600 1,400,600 1,400,600 0 1,274,848 1,304,169 1,304,169 0 A 8010 23-50-80-01-226-142 201 EDWARD ROSE ASSOC!AT,ES INC 1,499,600 1,499,600 1,499,600 0 1,377,350 1,409,021? 1,409,029 0 A 8011 23-50-80-01-2.76-001 201 EDWARD ROSE ASSOCIATES INC 1,672,200 1,672,2.00 1,672,200 0 1,540,811 1,576,249 1,576,249 0 A 8012 23-50-80-01-282-151 402 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 50,600 50,400 50,400 0 18,536 18,962 18,962 0 A 11001 33-01-01-02-351-021 401 CALABRASE ROSE M 122,900 128,900 128,900 0 79,408 128,900 81,234 -47,666 A 6270 33-01-01-02-378-271 401 ARGALL GREGG&HUNT TOMMIE 84,400 88,000 80,700 -7,300 59,344 88,000 80,700 -7,300 A 45 33-01-01-03-126-052 202 DAGGETT SAND&GRAVFL INC 114,900 153,2001 153,200 0 16,737 17,121 17,121 0 A 6004 33-01-01-03-151-161 401 FABRY MATTHEW T 55,500 58,500 46,100 -12,400 55,500 58,500 46,100 -12,400 A 9002 33-01-01-03-306-091 401 SHUSHTARI DONNA 6,300 23,800 6,600 -17,200 6,300 11,065 6,600 -4,465 A 6271 33-01-01-03-306-171 202 FRIEDLAND SYLVIA&BERNARD 3,200 4,200 3,200 -1,000 54 55 55 0 A 8013 33-01-01-03-351-055 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 4,200 4,600 4,600 0 2,803 2,867 2,867 0 A 6323 33-01-01-03-352-062 201 M&S CHILDERS L L C 120,400 123,600 123,600 0 77,234 123,600 123,600 0 A 6272 33-01-01-03-352-131 401 M&S CHILDERS L L C 48,600 51,500 41,200 -10,300 25,982 51,500 41,200 -10,300 A 6005 33-01-01-03-353-072 1 401 EATON RYAN R&SPAULDING 26,500 27,900 22,500 -5,400 13,988 27,900 22,500 -5,400 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 2 of 35 03/30/2005 11:47:55 AM PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE PARCEL NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE BOARD NUMBER q 29 33-01-01-03-377-342 401 VELICU CONSTANTIN 11,300 19,100 11,500 7,600 11,300 15,686 11,500 -3,486 A 9003 33 01-01-03-380-121 401 ALEXANDER EUGENE R 8,400 20,300 8,200 -12,100 8,400 13,686 8,200 -5,486 A 6006 33-01-01-04-103 182 401 HOGLE RICHARD D 45,400 47,800 38,400 -9,400 31,974 47,800 38,400 -9,400 A 8014 33-01-01-04-126-001 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 8,200 9,800 5,600 0 5,600 0,645 5,600 0 045 A 9004 33-01-01-04-126-181 401 WILLIAM E LEE&CONNIE RAE 5,600 33,700 5,600 -28,100 5,600 16,100 5,000 --6,100 q 6273 33-01 01-04-126 431 402 BABCOCK DARRYN&ROBIN 16,000 16,100 10,000 -6,100 16,000 16,100 10,000 6,100 700 A 6007 33-01-01-04-154-361 401 COOK JAMES S&DEBRA J 27,300 52,100 27,300 -24,800 18,107 33,223 34,200 --2,321 A 6008 33-01-01-04-155-041 401 KEYSER DUSTIN D 35,700 37,600 34,200 -3,400 35,700 36,521 34,200 -2,321 A 8015 33 01 01-04 230 260 201 AUTO ZONE(MICHIGAN) INC 303,900 318,700 318,700 0 270,447 276,667 276,667 0 A 6009 33-01-01-04-278-171 401 DEXTER HOWARD C&CHERYL L 24,900 26,300 18,500 -7,800 18,849 26,300 18,500 -7,800 -2,900 100,000 102,300 100,000 2,300 A 6324 33-01-01-04-278-283 201 DPD INC 100,000 102,900 100,000 A 11002 33-01-01-04-328-011 201 ROOTS A MICHIGAN PARTNERSHIP 118,400 124,100 124,100 0 78,250 124,100 80,049 -44,051 A 6274 33-01-01-04-328-171 402 D B&H RENT ACCOUNT 200 600 200 400 173 176 176 0 A 6010- 3301-01-U4.405-22I I 401 VERMEERSCH MARK M 38;500 40,300 36,600 -3,700 38,500 39,385 �fi,600 2,785 q 4 33 01-01-04 457-041 401 RHYNDRESS RONACD R&LISA L. 31,300 33,200 33,200 0 22,573 33,200 33,200 0 A 6325 33 01-01 05 102-032 201 S V APOLLO DRIVE L L C& . 172,000 -122,000 192,346 294,000 172,000 122,000 286,700 294,000 297,200 307;900 266;700 -41,200 297,200 307,900 266,700 -41,200 A 6011 33-01-01-05-102-U62 201 IBK L L C A 8016 33-01-01-05-251-011 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 12,500 12,500 12,500 0 11,984 15,09 15,101 0 2 4;984 5,098 5,098 0 A 8017 33-01-01-05-301-303 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 18,800 5,100 25,100 0 q 11003 33-01-01-05-401-191 401 SAUNDERS LEO M 36,600 42,300 42,300 0 20,908 42,300 21,388 -20,912 q 13 33-01-01-05-451-070 202 KARSLAKE PATRICK D 415,900 432,700 432,700 0 315,431 322,685 322,685 0 q 21 33-01-01-05-476-021 201 KOWALSKI ZIG 60,600 65,400 57,500 -7,900 58,147 59,484 57,500 -1,984 A 22 33-01-01-05-476-031 201 KOWALSKI ZIG 39,000 40,200 40,200 0 39,000 39,897 39,897 0 A 6012 33-01-01-05-477-131 401 WEATHERS KARL R&MARY D 88,700 103,500 88,700 -14,800 62,124 63,552 63,552 0 A 49 33-01-01-06-102-013 201 H&H CAR WASHES L L C 158,800 169,500 150,000 -19,500 111,413 169,500 150,000 -19,500 A 8018 33-01-01-06-104-070 201 COMERICA BANK 160,800 161,500 161,500 0 146,084 149,443 149,443 0 03/30/2005 11:47:55 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 3 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6111 33-01-01-06-152-051 401 LAM LIEN N 60,000 63,000 55,300 -7,700 60,000 61,380 55,300 -6,080 A 6013 33-01-01-06-159-031 401 SMITH ALICIA 41,900 43,800 30,000 -13,800 31,300 43,800 30,000 -13,800 A 14 33-01-01-06-177-031 401 ARENS GLORIA& 23,900 24,600 24,600 0 20,125 20,587 20,587 0 A 6326 33-01-01-06-179-001 401 MILEKOVICH JAMES A 51,800 53,500 48,900 -4,600 34,473 53,500 48,900 -4,600 A 6014 33-01-01-06-201-022 201 RENRA PROPERTIES L L C 0 285,800 216,000 -69,800 0 285,800 216,000 -69,800 A 6015 33-01-01-06-378-031 401 NELSON NICHOLAS A&KELLEY S 81,000 84,700 70,800 -13,900 63,091 84,700 70,800 -13,900 A 10001 33-01-01-06-429-091 401 HUNTER RONDA F 47,000 49,300 49,300 0 36,137 36,968 49,300 12,332 A 8019 33-01-01-06-456-021 401 LENTZ THEODORE D 85,100 88,400 88,400 0 52,393 53,598 53,598 0 A 9005 33-01-01-06-477-131 401 SEBRELL LAURINE 40.900 42,800 7,700 -35,100 32,872 33,628 7,700 -25,928 A 8020 33-01-01-08-101-802 207 AAT COMMUNICATIONS CORP 71,600 72,300 72,300 0 71,600 72,300 72,300 0 22,000 23,500 23,000 -500 19,641 20,092 20,092 0 A 6343 33-01-01-08 202-291 401 FOLKERTSMA DAVID A A 6112 33-01-01-08-231-011 401 GONZAELS NOEL L&PULIDO 36,300 39,200 31,800 -7,400 25,653 39,200 31,800 -7,400 A 10002 33-01-01-08-251-221 401 DIPPEL MICHELLE 36,700 39,900 39,900 0 32,736 33,488 39,900 6,412 A -.9006 33-01-01-08-256-15, 401 MARRISON EDITH. � 5,700 29,800 � 5,600 -24,000 5,700 24:005 5,800 18,205 A 73 33-01-01-08-278-1.31 401 MOORE CHARLES L 20,100 23,400 23,400 0 20,100 23,400 23,400 0 A 27, 33-01-01-08-282-233 201 ALIZADEH HASAN& 61,600 63,500 60,000 -3,500 44,454 63,500 60,000 -3,500 A 34 33-01-01-08-326-041 401 PATTERSON MARGARET-REVOC LIV 62,500 64,500 64,500 0 45,891 64,500 46,946` 17,554 A 6113 33-01-01-08-331=161 401 GILREATH MARTIN B&JEAN E 44,100 49,400: 46,000 -3,400 44,1.00 45,114 41,636 -3,478 A 47 33-01-•01-08-333-181 401 KILPATRICK GEOFFREY 35,800 40,000 30,500 -9,500 32,429 40,000 30,500 -9,500 A 9007 33-01-01-08-355-062 401 CULPEPPER DOROTHY H 5,500 41,700 4,900 -36,800 5,500 31,813 4,900 -26,913 A 9008 33-01-01-08-376-271 401 SPENCER ANNIE L 25,700 28,700 4,000 -24,700 16,646 17,028 4,000 -13,028 A 6275 33-01-01-08-379-112 201 AUSTIN DOUGLAS 112,900 93,600 81,500 -12,100 95,104 93,600 81,500 -12,100 A 9009 33-01-01-08-406-071 401 GRAY JUDY 31,300 34,300 4,900 -29,400 31,300 32,019 4,900 -27,119 A 12 33-01-01-08-426-031 401 HORN JAMES H&CARMEN E 23,600 25,800 22,500 -3,300 23,600 24,142 22,500 -1,642 A 6114 33-01-01-08-428-341 401 TAN YIP H 44,700 49,000 38,800 -10,200 44,700 45,728 38,800 -6,928 A 9010 33-01-01-08-428-371 401 BAEZA KIMBERLY 14,600 44,900 13,300 -31,600 14,600 28,500 13,300 -15,200 03/30/2005 11:47:56 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 4 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6115 33-01-01-08-453-071 401 HOLEY SHERYL L 25,700 28,100 17,000 -11,100 16,179 28,100 17,000 -11,100 A 6116 33-01-01-08-479-201 401 MAHER SETH A 42,000 46,000 40,900 -5,100 24,991 46,000 40,900 -5,100 A 71 33-01-01-08-479-301 401 DITTENHOEFER ALLEN C JR 26,100 28,600 28,600 0 12,931 28,600 28,600 0 A 77 33-01-01-08-481-001 401 LAND RODNEY L 36,300 39,800 30,000 -9,800 21,278 39,800 30,000 -9,800 A 6016 33-01-01-08-484-061 401 DUELL MICHAEL D 46,600 51,000 42,800 -8,200 27,755 51,000 42,800 -8,200 A 8021 33-01-01-09-101-001 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 8,600 8,600 8,600 0 674 689 689 0 A 9011 33-01-01-09-126-141 401 SEMRAU KATHYG 26,300 27,600 5,700 -21,900 26,300 26,904 5,700 -21,204 A 8022 33-01-01-09-152-002 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 14,400 17,300 17,300 0 11,463 11,726 11,726 0 A 8023 33-01-01-09-152-013 201 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 2,625,600 2,233,200 2,233,200 0 2,445,174 2,233,200 2,233,200 0 A 9012 33-01-01-09-155-042 401 MCLOUTH JOYCE 5,400 29,400 5,500 -23,900 5,400 13,470 5,500 -7,970 A 9013 33-01-01-09-156-041 401 ANDREWS TAMMY 6,900 23,500 7,100 -16,400 6,900 10,942 7,100 -3,842 A 6017 j 33-01-01-09-180-071 401 POLLACK JAMES W&CHRISTINE M 14,200 24,700 24,700 0 12,787 21,281 13,081 -8,200 A 6117 33-01-01-09-201-061 401 MATHERS DAVID J 32,800 34,600 27,200 -7,400 23,145 34,600 27,200 -7,400 A 81 33-01-01-09-203-083 301 DPD INC 32,600 99,100 99,100 0 15,662 99,100 99,100 0 A 30 33-01-01-09-252-101 401 FEIER DENNIS L&FOX BARBARA J, 38,700 45,800 38,700 -7,100 28,533 33,989 33,989 0 A 6018 33-01-01-09-252-181 401 BUONO JAMES G 21,600 21,900 10,000 -11,900 11,825 11,761 6,160 -5,601 A 8024 33-01-01-09-257-152 201 COMERICA INCORPORATED 80,300 83,300 83,300 0 67,456 69,007 69,007 0 A 18 33-01-01-09-280-023 201 YOUNG BERNADINE 77,800 80,000 50,000 -30,000 54,434 55,685 50,000 -5,685 A 9014 33-01 01-Q9-304-171 401 POTTER MARY L 31,700 38,600 5,500 33,100 -17,869 18,279 5,500 -12,779 A 6118 33-01-01-09-326-121 201 ING-DEM CORPORATION 80,600 84,700 70,800 -13,900 80,600 82,453 70,800 -11,653 A 6276 33-01-01-09-330-141 401 RIFKIN RANDOLPH A 21,700 26,100 21,700 -4,400 19,904 20,361 20,361 0 A 6119 33-01-01-09-352-041 401 LABEN GERALD 43,400 47,400 41,000 -6,400 17,576 47,400 41,000 -6,400 A 6019 33-01-01-09-353-031 401 DUNAVANT JUANITA 31,200 37,900 34,800 -3,100 17,352 37,900 34,800 -3,100 A 10003 33-01-01-09-353-211 401 DEWEY GORDON L&COVELLO 20,900 25,300 25,300 0 10,875 11,125 25,300 14,175 A 6020 33-01-01-09-355-021 401 WHITCOMB DAVID&JOAN 41,200 45,100 28,500 -16,600 14,537 45,100 28,500 -16,600 A 6120 33-01-01-09-357-131 401 O'BERRY DOUGLAS J 59,600 65,300 56,000 -9,300 17,352 65,300 56,000 -9,300 03/30/2005 11:47:56 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 5 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 9015 33-01-01-09-360-052 401 SIMMONS HOLLY D 38,000 46,200 5,300 -40,900 23,687 24,231 5,300 -18,931 A 6021 33-01-01-09-362-101 401 DUMENEY GARY L&CONNIE L 45,400 49,700 35,700 -14,000 27,313 49,700 35,700 -14,000 A 6121 33-01-01-09-362-241 401 ABDULJABER MOHOMAD 44,100 53,100 44,100 -9,000 30,007 53,100 44,100 -9,000 A 8025 33-01-01-09-377-041 401 RIDEOUTT MICHAEL W&SECORY 41,500 50,400 45,200 -5,200 41,500 42,454 42,454 0 A 6277 33-01-01-09-406-081 401 RIFKIN RANDOLPH A 22,900 27,200 22,900 -4,300 21,010 21,493 21,493 0 A 8026 33-01-01-09-426-001 202 COMERICA INCORPORATED 9,400 10,900 10,900 0 7,210 8,275 8,275 0 A 6278 33-01-01-09-429-051 402 BASS-RIFKIN PROPERTIES LTD 2,200 3,000 2,200 -800 786 804 804 0 A 6279 33-01-01-09-429-061 401 BASS RIFKIN PROPERTIES LTD 23,700 24,900 23,700 -1,200 21,292 21,781 21,781 0 A 6280 33-01-01-09-429-081 401 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 11,900 13,100 11,900 -1,200 11,900 12,173 11,900 -273 A 6281 33-01-01-09-429-091 401 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 15,400 16,700 15,400 -1,300 15,400 15,754 15,400 -354 A 6282 33-01-01-09-429-101 402 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITITES INC 2,800 5,000 2,800 -2,200 1,575 1,611 1,611 0 A 6283 33-01-01-09-429-121 202 BASS-RIFKIN PROPERTIES LTD 7,200 9,600 7,200 -2,400 6,230 6,373 6,373 0 A 6284 33-01-01-09-429-162 401 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 11,700 11,800 9,700 -2,100 7,057 7,219- 7,219 0 A 6285 33-01-01-09-431-211 401 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 15,000 15,400 15,000 -400 15,000 15,345 15,000 -345 A 51 33-01-01-09-478-053 201 GALLAGHER INVESTMENTS 151,600 '154,300 154,300 0 148,641 152,059 152,059 0 A 8027 33-01-01-10-101-101 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,300 3,300 3,300 0 3,300 3,300 3,300 0 A 10004 33-01-01-10-131-191 401 WISE JUDD W 28,700 31,700 31,700 0 20,345 20,812 31,700 10,888 A 9016 33-01-01-10-132-241 401 GODDARD LOIS 6,400 30,500 3,800 -26,700 6,400 20,152 3,800 -16,352 A 35 33-01-01-10-157-281 401 CONRAD JON G 31,900 34,700 31,900 -2,800 19,457 34,700 31,900 -2,800 A 9017 33-01-01-10-178-121 401 KIRSTEN BEVERLY J 8,500 29,800 8,600 -21,200 8,500 22,731 8,600 -14,131 A 9018 33-01-01-10-178-151 401 GAGNON CLAIRE Y 39,300 42,100 42,100 0 38,362 39,244 39,244 0 A 6327 33-01-01-10-181-311 401 MILLER EDMUND F&GLENNA J 17,700 19,500 19,500 0 16,476 16,854 18,107 1,253 A 74 33-01-01-10-182-201 401 C L MOORE PROPERTIES L L C 26,200 28,500 23,200 -5,300 15,489 28,500 23,200 -5,300 A 75 33-01-01-10-182-211 402 C L MOORE PROPERTIES L L C 3,500 5,300 5,300 0 1,350 5,300 5,300 0 A 6122 33-01-01-10-183-091 401 STAR JESSIE L JR&CAROLYN R 27,800 30,300 25,000 -5,300 27,800 28,439 25,000 -3,439 A 8028 33-01-01-10-226-802 207 AAT COMMUNICATIONS CORP 56,400 57,000 57,000 0 56,400 57,000 57,000 0 03/30/2005 11:47:56 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 6 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 1 33-01-01-10-251-131 401 HARRIS D CHARLIE&VERNICE R 36,500 41,600 41,600 0 32,811 33,565 33,565 0 A 10005 33-01-01-10-306-151 401 JUDD DANIAL 26,700 32,300 32,300 0 20,766 21,243 32,300 11,057 A 6123 33-01-01-10-326-441 401 FITZPATRICK RYAN 15,800 19,500 15,800 -3,700 8,462 19,500 15,800 -3,700 A 9019 33-01-01-10-326-471 401 TANNER WANDA M 5,500 23,100 5,700 -17,400 5,500 9,614 5,700 -3,914 A 6328 33-01-01-10-327-131 402 BAKER RALPH 2,800 4,700 4,700 0 1,012 1,035 2,864 1,829 A 6329 33-01-01-10-327-141 401 BAKER RALPH 4,900 7,100 7,100 0 3,124 3,195 5,012 1,817 A 78 33-01-01-10-330-291 401 LAND RODNEY L 24,100 29,700 22,300 -7,400 18,897 29,700 22,300 -7,400 A 6 33-01-01-10-354-261 401 ROWLEY GERALD J&LINDA S 33,900 43,500 43,500 0 19,868 20,324 20,324 p A 6124 33-01-01-10-376-121 401 STEPANOVICH DENNIS 19,100 25,100 19,500 -5,600 15,367 15,720 15,720 0 A 7 33-01-01-10-378-002 202 ROWLEY GERALD J 15,700 17,600 17,600 0 7,186 7,351 7,351 p A 5 33-01-01-10-378-311 401 ROWLEY GERALD J&LINDA S 15,000 20,100 20,100 0 11,142 11,398 11,398 p A 6022 33-01-01-10-408-261 401 SNIDER LARRYJ 28,900 31,800 23,600 -8,200 13,163 13,465 23,600 10,135 A 11004 33-01-01-10-410-021 401 LARCHE LOUIS B 25,200 27,500 27,500 0 20,144 27,500 20,607 -6,893 A 6023 133-01-01-11-1*01-071 401 DOWSETT DANIEL W& LOUISE A- 90,500 99,900 87,000 -12,900 75,300 79,631 79,631 p A 6286 33-01-01-11-151-271 401 MCCARTNEY MARY B 75,100 83,800 82,800 -1,000 60,917 67,218 66,218 -1,000 A 6125 33-01-01-11-202-321 401 GARVIE JAMES&SUE ANNE 97,400 101,400 93,200 -8,200 72,813 101,400 93,200 -8,200 A 24 33-01-01-11.203-041 401 YEAGER PAUL A&DIANE M 83,000 89,200 89,200 0 70,410 74,629 74,629 p A 15 33-01-01-11-204-191 401 PALMER DENNIS G&JANET M 113,500 108,300 108,300 0 83,461 108,300 108,300 p A 6024 33-01-01-11-204-261 401 SCODELLER RAYMOND&MARY 107,000 111,700 55,100 -16,600 78,194 79,992 79,992 0 A 11005 33-01-01-11-353-231 401 SPADAFORE ANTHONY M 38,500 39,800 39,800 0 37,544 39,800 39,385 -415 A 8029 33-01-01-11-476-031 201 LANSING HOTEL ASSOCIATES L.L.C. 1,020,600 1,035,500 1,035,500 0 734,883 751,785 751,785 p A 8030 33-01-01-11-476-071 201 WG SAGINAW LANSING MI L.L.C. 969,200 1,016,900 1,016,900 0 865,252 885,152 885,152 p A 16 33-01-01-11-476-111 401 PALMER DENNIS G&JANET M 74,600 81,600 81,600 0 55,962 60,849 60,849 p A 63 33-01-01-13-151-002 201 E MICHIGAN(3301)PARTNERS 1,848,100 1,877,500 1,877,500 0 1,566,120 1,602,140 1,602,140 0 A 64 33-01-01-13-151-038 201 3301 EAST MICHIGAN PARTNERSHIP 677,900 697,600 697,600 0 579,204 592,525 592,525 p A 59 33-01-01-14-102-431 201 MAIDLOW NANCY A 200 32,900 16,500 -16,400 106 32,808 16,408 -16,400 03/30/2005 11:47:57 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 7 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6126 33-01-01-14-107-131 401 BLOCKBUYERS L L C 55,900 58,300 45,800 -12,500 35,410 58,300 45,800 -12,500 A 6287 33-01-01-14-144-041 401 ADDUCI SALLY 64,200 66,600 63,100 -3,500 63,732 65,197 63,100 -2,097 A 8031 33-01-01-14-226-071 201 RED LOBSTER INNS OF AMERICA IN 484,300 502,000 502,000 0 383,890 392,719 392,719 0 A 8032 33-01-01-14-256-022 201 COMERICA BANK 299,500 301,100 301,100 0 293,396 300,144 300,144 0 A 6127 33-01-01-14-301-071 401 BLOCKBUYERS L L C 35,000 48,000 35,000 -13,000 35,000 48,000 35,000 -13,000 A 6128 33-01-01-14-304-021 401 HOLEY SHERYL L 20,700 22,200 21,000 -1,200 14,817 22,200 21,000 -1,200 A 6288 33-01-01-14-304-141 401 MJB EQUITIES III L L C 36,700 39,200 35,600 -3,600 27,412 39,200 35,600 -3,600 A 6129 33-01-01-14-304-341 401 TAN YIP 57,300 60,500 42,800 -17,700 57,300 58,617 42,800 -15,817 A 11006 33-01-01-14-326-421 201 CARR JANET S 91,100 93,200 93,200 0 87,607 93,200 89,621 -3,579 A 10006 33-01-01-14-327-222 401 TRAGESER MARIA L 29,500 31,800 31,800 0 27,109 27,732 31,800 4,068 A 6289 33-01-01-14-329-001 401 JUDD DANIAL 29,800 33,300 29,800 -3,500 22,946 33,300 29,800 -3,500 A 6130 33-01-01-14-356-021 401 LANE ENOCH E II&MAUREEN A 48,600 50,500 38,600 -11,900 36,200 50,500 38,600 -11,900 A 6290, 33-01-01-14-359-092 401 BUCKLEYTHOMAS W 38,700 53,000 38,000 -15,000 38,700 51,890 38,000 -13,890 A 9020 33-01-01-14-362-191 401 FRAZIER EUGENE E 27,400 27,800 12,400 -15,400 21,971 22,476 12,400 10,076 A 8033 33-01-01-14-426-803 207 AAT COMMUNICATIONS CORP 57,400 56,200 56,200 0 57,400 56,200 56,200 0 A 11 33-01-01-15-104-451 401 JACKSON AARON 25,200 27,700 27,700 0 18,466 27,700 27,700 0 A 8034 33-01-01-15-126-121 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 2,400 2,300 2,300 0 2,400 2,300 2,300 0 A 9021 33-01-01-15-152-061 401 JOHNSON QUINCY L JR 20,200 22,100 2,300 -19,800 15,047 15,393 2,300 -13,093 A 6291 33-01-01-15-152-261 201 EXODUS ONE L L C 226,600 238,200 120,500 -117,700 181,581 238,200 120,500 -117,700 A 9022 33-01-01-15-154-091 401 ELLENWOOD KATHLEEN A 5,500 31,600 5,500 -26,100 5,500 15,999 5,500 -10,499 A 6292 33-01-01-15-156-002 201 EDWARD W SPARROW HOSPITAL 0 0 578,600 578,600 0 0 578,600 578,600 ASSOC A 6293 33-01-01-15-253-131 401 BASS-RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 24,300 27,400 24,300 -3,100 24,300 24,858 24,300 -558 A 6294 33-01-01-15-259-251 401 BASS&RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 27,000 30,300 27,000 -3,300 24,690 25,257 25,257 0 A 6131 33-01-01-15-304-092 401 CHRIST EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN 40,900 42,900 0 -42,900 25,746 42,900 0 -42,900 A 8035 33-01-01-15-326-003 201 FIVE SISTERS COMPANY 108,900 108,900 108,900 0 59,629 61,000 61,000 0 A 8036 33-01-01-15-326-801 205 RITE AID OF MICHIGAN INC 485,500 521,800 521,800 0 414,433 423,964 423,964 0 03/30/2005 11:47:57 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 8 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6295 33-01-01-15-331-061 401 BASS/RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 18,500 19,200 18,500 -700 14,422 14,753 14,753 0 A 6296 33-01-01-15-331-241 401 BASS RIFKIN EQUITIES INC 23,600 24,500 23,600 -900 21,398 21,890 21,890 0 A 10007 33-01-01-15-353-021 401 COLE GREGORYA 12,400 13,700 13,700 0 10,843 12,685 13,700 1,015 A 6297 33-01-01-15-358-111 401 BUCKLEY THOMAS 36,400 39,300 35,700 3,600 14,694 39,300 35,700 -3,600 A 6298 33-01-01-15-382-002 201 FROCK DAVID D 48,300 48,300 33,300 -15,000 36,093 48,300 33,300 -15,000 A 8037 33-01-01-15-382-171 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,200 3,200 3,200 0 3,200 3,200 3,200 0 A 6299 33-01-01-15-403-101 401 THOMAS BRYAN P 57,700 62,100 50,600 -11,500 37,550 62,100 50,600 -11,500 A 6025 33-01-01-15-427-522 401 WATKINS DUWAYNE H 62,100 65,400 61,600 -3,800 62,100 63,528 61,600 -1,928 A 6026 33-01-01-15-451-072 401 ERWIN STACY L 77,300 83,100 60,400 -22,700 59,051 83,100 60,400 -22,700 A 6300 33-01-01-16-108-022 401 OSBORN D J II&RENEE S 22,800 26,800 21,900 -4,900 14,247 26,800 21,900 -4,900 A 6027 33-01-01-16-110-221 401 GALBRAITH SCOTT&MICHELLE 36,300 43,100 32,800 -10,300 24,881 43,100 32,800 -10,300 A 6301 33-01-01-16-129-011 401 BURK MARVIN 35,900 42,700 35,900 -6,800 18,536 42,700 35,900 -6,800 A 8038 33-01-01-16-156-041 201 LANSING TOWERS 1,525,200 1,525,200 1,525,200 0 1,394,379 1,426,449 1,426,449 0 A 82 33-01-01-i6-181-011 201 208 PARTNERS 1,680,100 1,705,400 11705,400 0 1,462,169 1,495,798 1,495,798 0- A 68 33-01-01-16-181-063 201 VICTOR II PARTNERSHIP 9,054,200 9,630,500 9,630,500 0 8,736,311 8,937,246 8,937,246 0 A 8039 33-01-01-16-183-012 201 CAPITAL CENTER ASSOCIATES L L C 4,411,300 4,560,800 4,560,800 0 4,411,300 4,512,759 4,512,759 0 A 8040 33-01-01-16-183-031 201 COMERICA INCORPORATED 2,448,000 2,459,400 2,459,400 0 1,240,615 1,269,149 1,269,149 0 A 48 33-01-01-16-183-113 201 SPIRIT OF DOWNTOWN LANSING 770,400 817,700 767,700 -50,000 519,321 571,365 547,272 -24,093 A 8041 33-01-01-16-203-056 201 RIVERFRONT LIMITED DIVIDEND 1,225,800 1,225,800 1,225,800 0 1,208,266 1,225,800 -1,225,800 0 A 79 33-01-01-16-254-001 201 230 N WASHINGTON SQ L L C 1,175,400 1,228,500 887,500 -341,000 889,473 909,930 887,500 -22,430 A 8042 33-01-01-16-255-003 201 PGRS MICHIGAN AVE L L C 7,125,600 7,020,000 7,020,000 0 7,125,600 6,956,400 6,956,400 0 A 8043 33-01-01-16-255-012 201 BLK 100 LTD/PARTNERSHIP 5,951,500 6,052,000 6,052,000 0 5,450,192 5,575,546 5,575,546 0 A 60 33-01-01-16-276-801 206 LANSING LUGNUTS 675,700 688,600 519,700 -168,900 586,782 600,277 498,025 -102,252 A 32 33-01-01-16-325-031 201 PETROFF ENTERPRISES L L C 2,874,100 2,915,300 1,994,500 -925,800 2,295,149 2,347,937 1,994,500 -353,437 A 65 33-01-01-16-325-081 201 GENTILOZZI PAUL 1,644,200 1,669,600 1,669,600 0 1,644,200 1,669,600 1,669,600 0 A 58 33-01-01-16-327-002 201 BOJI GROUP OF LANSING LLC 137,300 6,188,600 5,320,000 -868,600 137,300 6,153,057 5,284,457 -868,600 03/30/2005 11:47:57 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 9 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6132 33-01-01-16-328-171 201 WASHINGTON PLAZA LTD 2,426,900 2,461,700 1,578,200 -883,500 1,760,663 1,801,158 1,578,200 -222,958 A 19 33-01-01-16-331-112 201 EYDE CONSTRUCTION CO 1,350,000 1,673,300 1,673,300 0 1,350,000 1,381,050 1,381,050 0 A 6302 33-01-01-16-358-111 201 JULITA PROPERTIES LLC 0 35,500 27,100 -8,400 0 35,500 27,100 -8,400 A 6303 33-01-01-16-378-130 201 EEW L L C 155,900 167,100 116,200 -50,900 155,900 167,100 116,200 -50,900 A 66 33-01-01-16-401-002 201 VLAHAKIS COMPANIES INC 2,427,800 2,918,200 2,918,200 0 2,427,800 2,918,200 2,918,200 0 A 37 33-01-01-16-401-021 201 SPIRIT PARTNERSHIP 102,100 109,300 109,300 0 54,201 55,447 55,447 0 A 38 33-01-01-16-401-031 201 SPIRIT PARTNERSHIP 131,500 141,200 141,200 0 41,855 42,817 42,817 0 A 39 33-01-01-16-401-054 201 SPIRIT PARTNERSHIP 62,100 62,700 62,700 0 38,349 37,525 37,525 0 A 40 33-01-01-16-401-106 201 SPIRITGOLD L L C 120,600 125,800 125,800 0 73,907 75,606 75,606 0 A 41 33-01-01-16-401-107 201 SPIRITGOLD L L C 120,500 125,800 125,800 0 73,907 75,606 75,606 0 A 42 33-01-01-16-401-108 201 SPIRITGOLD L L C 41,300 43,100 43,100 0 34,007 34,789 34,789 0 A 6028 33-01-01-16-402-032 201 MSK MANAGEMENT LLC 160,200 159,700 125,000 -34,700 160,200 159,700 125,000 -34,700 A 8044 33-01-01-16-404-001 201 NBD BANK 262,200 268,200 268,200 0 210,468 215,308 215,308 0 A 67 33-01-01-16-404-031 201 ATRIUM ASSOCIATES 2,283,000 2,392,700 2,392,700 - 0 2,283,000 2,335,509 2,335,509 0 A 8045 33-01-01-16-404-203 201 THE CAPITAL GANG L L C 1,378,200 1,400,900 1,400,900 0 1,297,515 1,327,357 1,327,357 0 A 6029 33-01-01-16-451-010 202 KARP&ASSOCIATES LLC 0 0 85,800 85,800 0 0 85,800 85,800 A 6030 33-01-01-16-451-012 202 KARP&ASSOCIATES LLC 0 81,300 0 -81,300 0 81,300 0 -81,300 A 6031 33-01-01-16-451-013 201 MICHIGAN STATE AFL-CIO 832,200 843,000 0 -845,000 578,852 592,165 0 -592,165 A 6032 33-01-01-16-451-014 202 MICHIGAN STATE AFL-CIO 0 0 840,700 845,700 0 0 590,385 590,385 A 62 33-01-01-16-452-001 201 BARYAMES FAMILY LLC 254,800 219,100 219,100 0 222,645 219,100 219,100 0 A 6033 33-01-01-16-457-041 202 507 S GRAND L L C 0 17,700 9,500 -8,200 0 17,700 9,500 -8,200 A 10008 33-01-01-16-479-221 401 SMORRA ADRIENNE M 15,300 17,000 17,000 0 13,810 14,127 17,000 2,873 A 8046 33-01-01-17-176-011 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 4,500 4,500 4,500 0 3,829 3,917 3,917 0 A 6304 33-01-01-17-187-131 401 JUDD DANIAL L&SANDRA J 94,400 99,500 90,100 -9,400 66,350 67,876 67,876 0 A 6034 33-01-01-17-205-011 401 LAMBRIGHT DAVID 81,300 89,000 65,900 -23,100 81,300 83,169 65,900 -17,269 A 6035 33-01-01-17-218-051 401 TOMAN PAUL A&BARBARA J H 59,400 64,800 50,300 -14,500 43,056 43,452 43,452 0 03/30/2005 11:47:58 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 10 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8047 33-01-01-17-226-001 202 OTTOMAN INVESTMENTS LTD 12,600 15,200 15,200 0 9,351 9,566 9,566 0 A 8048 33-01-01-17-226-011 202 V.P. INVESTMENTS 3,700 4,000 4,000 0 3,010 3,079 3,079 0 A 8049 33-01-01-17-226-021 202 V.P. INVESTMENTS 4,300 4,600 4,600 0 3,633 3,716 3,716 0 A 8050 33-01-01-17-226-291 201 VP INVESTMENTS L.L.C. 349,600 374,600 374,600 0 248,081 253,786 253,786 0 A 6133 33-01-01-17-227-171 401 MATHERS DAVID J 29,300 32,400 32,100 -300 24,961 25,535 25,273 -262 A 6036 33-01-01-17-228-192 401 COCHRAN THOMAS D 67,700 74,200 55,800 -18,400 67,700 74,200 55,800 -18,400 A 6037 33-01-01-17-228-203 401 FRANK JOSEPH&SHELBY S 65,500 71,800 55,800 -16,000 65,500 71,800 55,800 -16,000 A 10009 33-01-01-17-228-351 401 MATA GRACIELA&HERNANDEZ 29,400 32,500 32,500 0 20,235 20,700 32,500 11,800 A 6305 33-01-01-17-231-172 201 CREWS KEVIN T&STELLA 49,400 51,900 41,000 -10,900 49,400 50,536 41,000 -9,536 A 9023 33-01-01-17-257-021 401 GRANT NOEL E 23,900 26,300 5,500 -26,800 16,144 16,515 5,500 -11,015 A 6038 33-01-01-17-276-111 401 ZWEIBACK DAMITA J&LANE JULIE A 56,300 62,300 47,500 -14,800 38,576 62,300 47,500 -14,800 A 6039 33-01-01-17-377-031 401 HUSBAND SHAWNETTE L 10,600 90,300 61,500 -28,800 3,941 90,300 61,500 -28,800 A 6330 33-01-01-17-379-131 401 COVERDELL GLEN A&JOY A 72,600 81,000 69,000 -12,000 49,354 50,489 50,489 0 A 9024 33-01-01-17-451-201 401 HUSBAND HENRIETTA 10,700 41,300 10,000 -31,300 10,700 28,988 10,000 -18,988 A 6134 33-01-01-17-476-212 401 MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS INC 72,400 90,700 62,500 -28,200 48,767 49,888 49,888 0 A 8051 33-01-01-17-477-132 099 CAPITOL COMMONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 A 8052 33-01-01-17-477-192 099 CAPITOL COMMONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 A 8053 33-01-01-17-481-162 099 CAPITOL COMMONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 A 6040 33-01-01-19-376-051 401 GASPER JOSEPH&NICOL M 137,400 142,700 119,500 -23,200 137,400 140,560 119,500 -21,060 A 6135 33-01-01-19-401-071 401 SLATER ARLEEA 116,600 121,100 103,100 18,000 85,935 121,100 103,100 -18,000 A 6041 33-01-01-19-428-001 401 HUGGLER BRIAN T 443,200 459,200 443,800 -15,400 152,727 459,200 443,800 -15,400 A 6042 33-01-01-19-428-033 401 HOISINGTON THOMAS J& 322,200 338,600 295,000 -43,600 303,524 310,505 295,000 -15,505 A 6043 33-01-01-19-451-291 401 HILL HENRY L&DIANNE 136,200 142,400 105,000 -37,400 126,055 128,954 105,000 -23,954 A 6331 33-01-01-20-128-022 401 ALLINGTON TRACY&STOLL JULIA M 46,700 59,100 54,500 -4,600 27,313 59,100 54,500 -4,600 A 8054 33-01-01-20-203-092 402 CONSUMERS ENERGY 4,300 4,800 4,800 0 2,026 4,800 4,800 0 A 6136 33-01-01-20-330-011 1 401 STILES DANIEL 1 67,000 70,200 55,400 -14,800 67,000 68,541 55,400 -13,141 03/30/2005 11:47:58 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Pagel 1 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 28 33-01-01-20-378-021 401 BEAVERS TERESA A 44,200 46,300 46,300 0 31,181 46,300 46,300 0 A 6044 33-01-01-20-379-151 401 RINCKEY DAVID L&JILL M 63,800 67,000 55,700 -11,300 60,766 67,000 55,700 -11,300 A 6045 33-01-01-20-401-061 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 52,500 59,900 46,400 -13,500 49,827 50,973 46,400 -4,573 A 6306 33-01-01-20-451-011 401 MAIER BRIAN A 41,700 43,600 41,900 -1,700 21,146 21,632 21,632 0 A 8055 33-01-01-20-457-065 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 6,500 6,500 6,500 0 5,295 5,416 5,416 0 A 3 33-01-01-20-457-232 401 SUMMERVILLE LOIS 44,000 67,700 47,500 -20,200 44,000 49,112 47,500 -1,612 A 6332 33-01-01-20-483-011 401 JENKS WILLIAM S&DAWN M 47,500 50,700 39,900 -10,800 47,500 48,592 39,900 -8,692 A 8056 33-01-01-21-132-001 201 FOUNTAIN PLACE 1,365,600 1,387,200 1,387,200 0 918,850 939,983 939,983 0 A 9025 33-01-01-21-205-040 401 KAHLKE ANDREW J&ALICE U 16,800 17,900 4,500 -13,400 12,688 12,979 4,500 -8,479 A 8057 33-01-01-21-256-032 201 UNION BUILDING CORP 108,700 110,600 110,600 0 105,441 107,866 107,866 0 A 23 33-01-01-21-257-020 201 CADILLAC CLUB REAL ESTATE L L C 173,400 511,900 402,800 -109,100 173,400 511,900 402,800 -109,100 A 8058 33-01-01-21-257-160 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 4,400 4,400 4,400 0 2,026 2,072 2,072 0 A 8059 33-01-01-21-276-003 201 GRAYBAR ELECTRIC INC 378,100 399,200 399,200 0 316,083 323,352 323,352 0 A 6307 33-01701-21-328-281 401 JUDD DANIAL L 42,400 46,200 44,050 -2,150 21,044 46,200 44,050 -2,150 A 6308 33-01-01-21-360-141 401 GREATHOUSE JERRY L 33,800 37,800 33,800 -4,000 30,527 31,229 31,229 0 A 8060 33-01-01-21-377-061 401 RIDEOUTT MICHAEL W&SECORY 47,600 54,100 45,000 -9,100 28,451 54,100 45,000 -9,100 A 8061 33-01-01-21-379-131 401 RIDEOUTT MICHAEL W&SECORY 40,000 45,700 45,700 0 40,000 40,920 40,920 0 A 9026 33-01-01-21-402-231 401 LIGHTFOOT NANCY L&LIGHTFOOT 3,100. 20,200 7,600 -12,600 3,100 12,505 7,600 -4,905 JERRI A 43 33-01-01-21-451-001 202 SPAGNUOLO ORLANDO&GLORIA 13,900 15,500 15,500 0 13,196 13,499 13,499 0 A 44 33-01-01-21-451-045 201 SPAGNUOLO ORLANDO&GLORIA 87,900 91,500 91,500 0 78,846 80,659 80,659 0 A 8062 33-01-01-21-456-034 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,200 3,200 3,200 0 3,200 3,200 3,200 0 A 9027 33-01-01-21-459-012 401 FRIAR MARVIN D&LINDA 5,400 18,500 5,600 -12,900 5,400 14,309 5,600 -8,709 A 9028 33-01-01-21-479-025 401 ARMSTRONG THERESA 5,900 25,900 5,900 -20,000 5,900 16,837 5,900 -10,937 A 9029 33-01-01-21-480-120 401 CARR(DANIELS)DOROTHY L 5,500 16,900 5,800 -11,100 5,500 11,904 5,800 -6,104 A 6046 33-01-01-21-480-130 401 WALKER WILLIAM 40,200 44,000 30,500 -13,500 40,200 41,124 30,500 -10,624 A 72 33-01-01-21-480-145 401 C L MOORE PROPERTIES L LC 25,900 28,400 28,400 0 21,966 28,400 28,400 0 03/30/2005 11:47:58 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 12 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE U BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8063 33-01-01-21-482-091 401 MT HOPE UNITED METHODIST 16,600 18,200 18,200 0 16,600 16,981 16,981 0 A 45 33-01-01-22-127-101 401 DHUD 39,200 43,200 43,200 p 33,003 33,762 33,762 p A 86 33-01-01-22-132-301 401 SIMPSON THOMAS H 42,900 47,200 42,900 -4,300 34,834 35,635 35,635 0 A 2 33-01-01-22-134-061 401 BOSSLER GEORGE W 29,700 31,900 29,700 -2,200 24,179 24,735 24,735 p A 6047 33-01-01-22-135-201 401 AMERIQUEST MORTGAGE CO 36,600 39,500 34,000 -5,500 31,957 39,500 34,000 -5,500 A 70 33-01-01-22-176-281 401 SHEIKH ABUKAR&YUSUF KHADIJA 46,6 00 52,600 40,000 -12,600 46,600 47,671 40,000 -7,671 A 8064 33-01-01-22-226-141 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,500 3,500 3,500 p 962 984 984 p A 6309 33-01-01-22-226-361 401 ALEXANDER JOSEPH&CYNTHIA 21,600 24,400 18,000 -6,400 13,745 24,400 18,000 -6,400 A 6137 33-01-01-22-231-032 401 WIGG REGINALD O 0 24,600 19,600 -5,000 p 14,118 14,118 p A 9030 33-01-01-22-257-102 401 WILLIAMS MICHAEL&ETHEL 19,800 22,3 00 2,600 -19,700 13,069 13,369 2,600 -10,769 A 10010 33-01-01-22-258-111 401 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY E&KELLY L 19,800 22,400 22,400 0 15,886 16,251 22,400 6,149 A 6048 33-01-01-22-280-082 4 11 JONES JAMIE H 62,700 72,100 54,600 -17,500 26,550 27,160 27,160 0 A 33 33-01-01-22-280-133 401 BACON STEVEN&KARIE S 40,600 58,000 41,000 -17,000 40,800 52,833 41,000 -11,833 A 8065 33-01-01-22-282-201 401 STEWART PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 22,900 25,800 25,800 0 20,987 21,469 .21,469 0 A 6138 33-01-01-22-304-161 401 WENK BRIAN K 23,200 25,300 20,600 -4,700 23,200 23,733 20,600 -3,133 A 6049 33-01-01-22-328-061 4 11 HASSLER HELEN M 88,000 102,700 88,000 -14,700 65,607 67,115 67,115 0 A 6050 33-01-01-22-328-071 401 ANDERSON OWEN C 84,400 96,400 79,800 -16,600 64,078 86,341 79,800 -6,541 A 6139 33-01-01-22-328-1.21 401 STACHWICK MARCELLA E 88,500 103, 000 80,700 -22,500 63,138 64,590 64,590 0 6051 33-01-01-22-328-131 401 EA052 RAHE ANDREW C 92,600 107,000 84,800 -22,200 61,726 63,145 63,145 0 33-01-01-22-328-151 401 MILES DAVID W&CHRISTINE T 59,300 76,200 59,300 -16,900 48,204 49,312 49,312 p A 6053 33-01-01-22-329-001 401 FORD MARILYN 59,500 67,000 60,800 -6,200 40,560 41,492 41,492 p A 6140 33-01-01-22-329-131 401 LEYRER BRIAN E MELANIE A E125,800 145,500 109,200 -36,300 93,997 96,158 96,158 p A 10011 33-01-01-22-352-271 401 MENDOZA KATHY 13,700 14,900 14,900 0 10,109 10,341 14,900 4,559 A 6333 33-01-01-22-353-051 401 HAGAN KERRY D&SMORRA 15,800 17,300 17,300 0 12,931 13,228 16,163 2,935 A 6141 33-01-01-22-451-121 401 STEPANOVICH DENNIS/BEETHAM 79,300 91,400 85,000 -6,400 62,037 63,463 63,463 VIRGINIA0 A 6054 33-01-01-22-451-181 401 MCCOMB BEN W&JOAN E 76,100 88,000 77,000 -11,000 56,671 57,974 57,974 0 03/30/2005 11:47:59 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 13 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8066 33-01-01-23-106-001 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 6,400 6,400 6,400 0 2,046 2,093 2,093 0 A 8067 33-01-01-25-301-022 201 MONTELL USA INC 3,928,400 4,011,500 4,011,500 0 3,874,854 3,963,975 3,963,975 0 A 6142 33-01-01-26-180-011 401 FAWAZ IMAD&JOSEPHINE 92,800 101,600 84,100 -17,500 63,195 101,600 84,100 -17,500 A 8068 33-01-01-26-280-001 201 HUNT CLUB LTD HOUSING ASSOC 2,800,700 2,800,700 2,800,700 0 2,800,700 2,800,700 2,800,700 0 A 10012 33-01-01-26-326-261 401 HOLT KATHLEEN M 61,400 66,700 66,700 0 56,265 57,559 66,700 9,141 A 84 33-01-01-26-326-322 401 ROCHFORD DONALD T JR 70,700 74,100 74,100 0 70,700 72,326 72,326 0 A 6310 33-01-01-26-353-131 401 SCHMITZ STANLEYA II 40,300 64,600 52,500 -12,100 33,040 54,799 38,902 -15,897 A 6055 33-01-01-26-404-082 401 RYANSCOTTJ 83,800 87,700 80,000 -7,700 71,015 87,700 80,000 -7,700 A 6334 33-01-01-26-405-041 401 WIEGAND MARK E&BELINDA J& 140,700 147,900 127,100 -26,800 103,342 147,900 127,100 -20,800 A 6143 33-01-01-27-101-111 401 NOLAN BRENTA 83,200 87,500 65,900 -21,600 83,200 85,113 65,900 -19,213 A 6056 33-01-01-27-114-119 401 KING DARRELL&DAVIS-KING 66,300 69,000 59,300 -9,700 66,300 67,824 59,300 -8,524 A 6057 33-01-01-27-128-132 401 HEATHMAN SARAN J 58,800 60,600 53,800 -6,800 43,873 60,600 53,800 -6,800 A 83 33-01-01-27-.129-011 401 MEDLOCK MICHAEL B 42,700 44,900 44,900 0 33,959 44,900 44,900 0 A 8069 33-01-01-27.158-341 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 8,200 8,200 8,200 0 8,200 8,200 8,200 0 A 85 33-01-01-27-201-141 401 CASTILLO JUANITA 65,500 68,900 63,300 -5,600 65,062 66,558 63,300 -3,258 A 6311 33-01-01-27-203-011 402 GENTGES JEREMY E 11,300 11,500 9,000 -2,500 2,026 11,500 9,000 -2,500 A 8070 33-01-01-27-301-262 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 13,800 13,800 13,800 0 13,094 13,395 13,395 0 A 6144 33-01-01-27-327-042 201 LANSING MED OFFICE CENTER LLC 0 1,674,700 1,458,500 -216,200 0 1,674,700 1,458,500 -216,200 A 6145 33-01-01-27-352-381 401 EDWARDS MAVIS L 62,300 68,400 63,800 -4,600 47,283 68,400 63,800 -4,600 A 6186 33-01-01-27-354-161 201 HART KENNEDY HOUSE INC 115,800 114,600 95,200 -19,400 113,859 114,600 95,200 -19,400 A 6146 33-01-01-27-356-061 401 DOEPKER MARCIA ANN 72,700 80,300 65,000 -15,300 62,093 63,521 63,521 0 A 6147 33-01-01-27-357-002 201 THE DART BANK 344,200 361,800 310,100 -51,700 320,255 327,620 310,100 -17,520 A 8071 33-01-01-27-359-052 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 5,200 6,900 6,900 0 2,475 2,531 2,531 0 A 6148 33-01-01-27-428-118 401 KUE SIMON&ELEANORE 74,200 90,500 68,300 -22,200 74,200 75,906 68,300 -7,606 A 50 33-01-01-27-428-132 202 GRANGER KEITH B 85,500 128,300 128,300 0 10,902 128,300 128,300 0 A 8072 33-01-01-28-102-131 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 2,800 2,800 2,800 0 2,800 2,800 2,800 0 03/30/2005 11:47:59 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 14 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6058 33-01-01-28-104-022 401 HENGESBACH AMBER 62,700 67,200 59,000 -8,200 26,347 67,200 59,000 -8,200 A 69 33-01-01-28-126-062 201 KELLAMS WALTER R&VIRGINIA 696,700 702,600 702,600 0 648,965 663,891 663,891 0 A 6149 33-01-01-28-202-423 201 EYDE LOUIS J&EYDE GEORGE F 1,644,700 2,103,000 1,476,800 -626,200 1,316,001 1,346,269 1,346,269 0 A 6059 33-01-01-28-203-141 401 REIFFER SIMON JR 27,300 30,500 27,700 -2,800 19,575 30,500 27,700 -2,800 A 6312 33-01-01-28-205-020 201 2316 S CEDAR PROFESSIONAL BLDG 0 870,200 830,800 -39,400 0 870,200 830,800 -39,400 LLC A 6313 33-01-01-28-228-101 401 REGAN BRIAN 45,300 62,600 61,800 -800 37,816 50,085 49,402 -683 A 6187 33-01-01-28-254-101 401 GLENNON ROBERT C 51,600 57,900 48,800 -9,100 47,058 48,140 48,140 0 A 6060 33-01-01-28-255-021 401 DELACRUZ JESUS S 74,600 82,600 66,700 -15,900 67,006 82,600 66,700 -15,900 A 6150 33-01-01-28-328-222 201 GREENLAWN PRO OFFICE BLDG LLC 0 1,729,000 1,273,200 -455,800 0 1,729,000 1,273,200 -455,800 A 6061 33-01-01-28-328-801 206 INGHAM REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER 1,447,800 1,455,500 0 -11455,500 1,381,955 1,413,739 0 -1,413,739 A 10013 33-01-01-28-330-131 401 BYWATER BERNETTA 34,400 37,400 37,400 0 16,810 17,196 37,400 20,204 A 9031 33-01-01-28-331-101 401 HILLEY LINDA 6,800 39,300 7,100 -32,200 6,800 27,827 7,100 -20,727 A 9032 33-01-01-28-334-201 401 SHIREY MARGARET J 3,700 22,100 5,700 -16,400 3,700 16,902 5,700 -11,202 A 6314 33-01-01-28-379-101 401 PORTILLO SOCORRO& 59,000 64,100 52,000 -12,100 30,535 64,100 52,000 12,100 - A 10014 33-01-01-28-403-122 402 INGHAM REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER 10,800 11,200 11,200 0 8,356 8,548 11,200 2,652 A 8073 33-01-01-28-426-003 201 RITE AID OF MICHIGAN INC 612,300 638,800 638,800 0 466,088 476,808 476,808 0 A 6062 33-01-01-28-426-112 401 GONZALES MARIO 64,100 70,300 63,000 -7,300 39,154 70,300 63,000 -7,300 A 6315 33-01-01-28-435-091 401 SAND JEFFREY W 40,800 46,500 40,000 -6,500 34,057 35,740 35,740 0 A 6151 33-01-01-28-452-023 401 MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS INC 56,100 62,300 56,500 -5,800 46,725 62,300 56,500 -5,800 A 8074 33-01-01-29-126-001 201 LANSING CENTER LTD PARTNERS 1,150,600 1,206,000 1,206,000 0 1,044,180 1,068,196 1,068,196 0 A 8075 33-01-01-29-126-111 201 VILLAGE MARKET COMPANY 1,800 1,800 1,800 0 933 954 954 0 A 8 33-01-01-29-155-081 401 PINO-MARQUEZ VICENTE 56,700 58,800 58,800 0 41,150 58,800 58,800 0 A 6152 33-01-01-29-204-011 401 EASEY CAMERON L 56,500 62,600 52,100 -10,500 48,899 62,600 52,100 -10,500 A 6316 33-01-01-29-204-081 401 BUCKLEY THOMAS 57,700 65,200 50,900 -14,300 41,015 65,200 50,900 -14,300 A 6317 33-01-01-29-204-091 401 BUCKLEYTHOMAS 42,600 47,800 41,900 -5,900 28,804 47,800 41,900 -5,900 A 6063 33-01-01-29-205-031 401 BREVARD CONNIE L 50,500 56,700 52,500 -4,200 44,544 56,700 52,500 -4,200 03/30/2005 11:48:00 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 15 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 46 33-01-01-29-252-081 401 BK EXPRESS PROPERTIES L L C 34,100 37,300 37,300 0 26,217 37,300 37,300 0 A 6153 33-01-01-29-252-181 402 KEMPPAINEN GREGORY S& 10,000 10,400 3,500 -6,900 5,814 10,400 3,500 -6,900 A 6154 33-01-01-29-252-191 401 KEMPPAINEN GREGORY S 46,E-0 52,600 35,000 -17,600 40,183 41,107 35,000 -6,107 A 6064 33-01-01-29-258-182 401 BOZZO STEPHEN&ROSALINDA 84,000 77,600 69,600 -8,000 74,033 75,735 69,600 -6,135 A 6318 33-01-01-29-280-272 201 FD HAYES ELECTRIC CO 48,600 62,500 37,700 -24,800 42,255 43,226 33,531 -9,695 A 6065 33-01-01-29-329-011 401 SEPPALA BRADLEY M 70,600 73,100 58,600 -14,500 51,833 73,100 58,600 -14,500 A 6066 33-01-01-29-376-172 401 GREER ALFRED R&PATRICIA M 45,100 57,700 50,000 -7,700 42,052 43,019 43,019 0 A 25 33-01-01-29-427-002 201 CASA NOVA INC 325,800 335,300 275,000 -60,300 325,800 333,293 275,000 -58,293 A 6155 33-01-01-29 428-035 401 PURVES MATTHEW J 54,100 49,600 46,800 -2,800 48,074 49,600 46,800 -2,800 A 8076 33-01-01-29-451-013 201 MERAM PROPERTIES L L C 2,937,800 1,426,500 1,426,500 0 2,937,800 1,426,500 1,426,500 0 A 8077 33-01-01-29-451-032 201 COMERICA INCORPORATED 285,800 234,200 234,200 0 254,327 234,200 234,200 0 A 807E 33-01-01-29 451-041 201 MERAM PROPERTIES L L C 81,800 91,500 91,500 0 81,800 83,681 83,681 0 A 8079 33-01-01-29-451-051 201 MERAM PROPERTIES L L C 63,500 60,400 60,400 0 63,500 60,400 60,400 0 A 6156 33-0TO1-29-476- 771 401 MCBRIDE SARA D&MERCER 37,000 39,700 37,000 2,700 35,388 36,201 36,201 0 A 8080 33-01-01-2S-477-006 201 STANDARD FEDERAL BANK N A 217,200 218,300 218.300 0 213,221 218,125 218,125 0 A 6319 33-01-01-30-151-201 401 MAGERS LUKE A&ERICA L 88,900 91,200 79,000 -12,200 58,739 91,200 79,000 -12,200 A 6067 33-01-01-30-231-031 401 SIMMONS DAVID&BLONSHINE 99,100 102,600 90,200 -12,400 76,234' 102,600 90,200 12,400 A 8081 33-01-01-30-278-019 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 5,900 7,400 7,400 0 3,682 3,766 3,766 0 A 6335 33-01-01-30-278-051 401 MANGE DAVID M&DEBORAH L 83,000 87,200 71,600 -15,600 60,172 87,200 71,600 15,600 A 6157 33-01-01-30-305-091 401 CUNNINGHAM NANCY 88,300 92,300 82,300 -10,000 60,449 92,300 82,300 -10,000 A 26 33-01-01-30-355-011 401 SCRUGGS JULIA M 43,400 51,000 51,000 0 43,272 44,267 44,267 0 A 6068 33-01-01-30-380-031 401 SEARS MICHAEL J& NANCY R 46,500 52,900 48,800 -4,100 39,975 40,894 40,894 0 A 6069 33-01-01-30-380-061 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY 47,600 54,000 49,800 -4,200 40,806 41,744 41,744 0 A 6070 33-01-01-30-381-041 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 53,000 60,900 54,200 -6,700 45,582 46,630 46,630 0 A 9033 33-01-01-30-427-1-1 401 BYWATER EYVONNE M 5,000 16,800 5,600 -11,200 5,000 9,644 5,600 -4,044 A 9034 33-01-01-30-428-071 401 DICKSON RITA A 17,700 24,700 5,700 -19,000 17,700 24,700 5,700 -19,000 03/30/2005 11:48:00 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 16 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 87 33-01-01-30-480-062 201 SAMCO LAND CO 299,500 299,500 299,500 0 214,094 219,018 219,018 0 A 6071 33-01-01-31-104-001 401 RUMMINS LESLIE E 55,200 57,200 54,500 -2,700 55,200 56,469 54,500 -1,969 A 6336 33-01-01-31-127-141 401 THOMAS HENRY&YOLANDA 36,400 41,000 41,000 0 26,804 31,334 27,420 -3,914 A 6072 33-01-01-31-178-081 401 ROPER ALBERTV 44,800 57,200 41,500 -15,700 44,800 55,130 41,500 -13,630 A 9035 33-01-01-31-254-171 401 REED GARY F&BETTY L 5,200 23,200 5,300 -17,900 5,200 15,457 5,300 -10,157 A 31 33-01-01-31-279-001 401 LUTZ MARY 20,200 23,900 16,000 -7,900 16,179 16,551 16,000 -551 A 8082 33-01-01-31-279-061 201 STONE CREST TOWNHOMES OF 160,100 188,100 188,100 0 119,050 121,788 121,788 0 LANSING A 9036 33-01-01-31-305-031 401 HUNT HEATHER L 5,500 34,600 5,600 -29,000 5,500 24,848 5,600 -19,248 A 9037 33-01-01-31-354-221 401 WILLIAMS WILBERT G&ERNESTINE 44,000 45,700 6,500 -39,200 26,347 26,952 6,500 -20,452 A 8083 33-01-01-31-403-041 201 STONE CREST TOWNHOMES OF 998,300 998,300 998,300 0 805,981 824,518 824,518 0 LANSING A 8084 33-01-01-31-426-001 201 STONE CREST TOWNHOMES OF 187,200 204,600 204,600 0 146,536 149,906 149,906 0 A 6073 33-01-01-31-428-182 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 52,000 98,500 59,700 -38,800 51,917 53,111 53,111 0 A 6158 33..01-01-31-452-021 401 CARSON CHRISTINA M 36,300 41,500 41,500 0 28,502 41,500 41,500 0 A 6074 33-01-01-31-452-081 401 SINCLAIR BRETT D&MICHELLE R 60,900 69,500 55,400 -14,100 36,748 37,593 37,593 0 A 9038 33-01-01-31-478-160 401 SWEET PATRICIA A 4,600 28,400 5,700 -22,700 4,600 14,988 5,700 -9,288 A 8085 33-01-01-32-201-242 201 S&J MIGALDI L L C 749,600 784,900 784,900 0 698,504 714,569 714,569 0 A 6320 33-01-01-32-203-252 201 VENUS ENTERPRISES 251,400 25.8,700 200,400 -58,300 207,264 212,031 200,400 -11,631 A 8086 33-01-01-32-251-205 201 CAVANAUGH WEST APARTMENTS 256,700 256,700 256,700 0 238,532 244,018 244,018 0 A 8087 33-01-01-32-252-122 201 REALTY INCOME CORP 327,900 343,700 288,500 -55,200 293,042 299,781 288,500 -11,281 A 8088 33-01-01-32-276-030 201 GOOD WILL INC 441,900 453,500 453,500 0 348,337 356,348 356,348 0 A 9039 33-01-01-32-304-121 401 ELLIS BARBARA M 61700 39,400 6,800 -32,600 6,700 22,131 6,800 -15,331 A 6321 33-01-01-32-353-481 401 ROBBINS BOBBY L 3,600 62,200 49,300 -12,900 1,575 62,200 49,300 -12,900 A 6159 33-01-01-32-353-491 401 DAWSON GARY M&FITCHETT RICK 3,600 62,200 45,400 -16,800 1,575 62,200 45,400 -16,800 A 6075 33-01-01-32-426-042 401 SEARS MICHAEL J& NANCY R 60,000 71,500 62,100 -9,400 50,931 52,102 52,102 0 A 9040 33-01-01-32-427-141 401 WILSON-GIBBONS CARRIENVILSON 6,300 9,700 9,500 -200 6,300 6,904 9,500 2,596 A 6076 33-01-01-32-451-031 1 401 STEVENSON MELVIN&SYLVIA 56,900 88,200 62,000 -26,200 56,265 79,259 61,559 -17,700 03/30/2005 11:48:00 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 17 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6160 33-01-01-32-477-071 401 PETERSON REVOCABLE TRUST 24,000 24,700 20,500 4,200 20,677 24,700 20,500 -4,200 A 6161 33-01-01-32-477-081 401 PETERSON REVOCABLE TRUST 32,300 33,300 26,100 -7,200 20,834 33,300 26,100 -7,200 A 9041 33-01-01-32-480-051 401 RIKER CHARLES R&LAURICE 1 31,200 32,300 6,300 -26,000 31,200 31,917 6,300 -25,617 A 6077 33-01-01-32-481-162 401 NETTLEMAN HEATHER M 61,300 69,200 50,000 -19,200 36,282 69,200 50,000 -19,200 A 6078 33-01-01-33-128-071 401 MEZA MELECIO R&RACHEL 83,800 87,500 60,100 -27,400 67,595 87,500 60,100 -27,400 A 6079 33-01-01-33-154-001 401 JACKSON MICHAEL E&TONYA D 100,700 105,000 90,200 -14,800 100,700 103,016 90,200 -12,816 A 6080 33-01-01-33-205-001 401 SCHOPPER CHAD M&HEATHER L 68,200 70,900 62,500 -8,400 42,577 70,900 62,500 -8,400 A 6337 33-01-01-33-205-051 401 SMITH RICHARD 42,600 53,000 42,500 -10,500 31,325 32,045 32,045 0 A 6081 33-01-01-33-226-002 201 KESTO NATHAN L L C 209,300 220,700 200,000 -20,700 158,689 220,700 200,000 -20,700 A 6082 33-01-01-33-231-221 401 CHAVEZ ERIN M 60,300 62,400 56,100 -6,300 60,300 61,686 56,100 -5,586 A 52 33-01-01-33-254-112 201 MOMENTUM REAL ESTATE L L C 117,300 122,500 122,500 0 107,572 110,046 110,046 0 A 8089 33-01-01-33-256-021 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 6,700 6,800 6,800 0 5,856 5,990 5,990 0 A 9042 33-01-01-33-351-141 401 GRAHAM PATRICIA J&DOROTHY 45,400 44,000 5,600 -38,400 32,226 32,967 5,600 -27,367 A 6083 33-01-01-33-403-001 401 THOMPSON CHRISTOPHER J& 59,300 61,400 47,500 -13,900 59,300 60,663 47,500 -1'3,163 A 6162 33-01-01-33-405-051 401 ACU NA CYNTHIA A 72,700 75,700 62,500 -13,200 72,700 74,372 62,500 41,872 A 53 33-01-01-33-407-245 202 CCPL REAL ESTATE GROUP LLC 59,600 68,100 68,100 0 7,460 68,100 68,100 0 A 8090 33-01-01-33-452-030 201 RITE AID OF MICHIGAN INC 530,900 557,500 557,500 0 412,596 422,085 422,085 0 A 8091 33-01-01-33-476-032 201 AUTOZONE INC 367,800 381,800 381,800 0 263,408 269,466 269,466 0 A 9043 33-01-01-34-110-151 401 FISCHER DANIEL 29,900 30,900 8,000 -22,900 27,202 27,827 8,000 -19,827 A 11007 33-01-01-34-180-081 401 CANNARILE FRANK L&JENNIFER L 46,600 48,100 48,100 0 37,422 48,100 38,282 -9,818 A 9044 33-01-01-34-229-081 401 SMITH-WAGNER ALTA 40,400 39,500 4,400 -35,100 29,971 30,660 4,400 -26,260 A 11008 33-01-01-34-352-031 401 EDGAR PHILLIP J&LINDA K 44,600 49,800 49,800 0 35,690 49,800 36,510 -13,290 A 6338 33-01-01-34-353-121 401 SMITH RICHARD W 45,500 50,800 42,500 -8,300 36,061 36,890 36,890 0 A 6163 33-01-01-34-354-071 401 JONES MICHAEL A&KISHA R 49,600 55,400 52,400 -3,000 34,418 35,209 34,647 -562 A 6339 33-01-01-34-355-121 401 SMITH RICHARD 43,400 48,500 40,000 -8,500 36,061 36,890 36,890 0 A 6164 33-01-01-34-355-241 401 DOWRICKTODD 41,000 45,500 30,500 -15,000 30,591 45,500 30,500 -15,000 03/30/2005 11:48:01 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 18 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6084 33-01-01-34-378-241 401 DUNN WENDELL E JR&HILARY A 82,100 86,000 69,000 -17,000 82,100 83,988 69,000 -14,988 A 8092 33-01-01-34-401-031 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 23,800 23,800 23,800 0 15,242 15,592 15,592 0 A 6085 33-01-01-34-425-031 201 JOHNSTON TRUCKING INC 0 175,300 124,500 -50,800 0 141,288 124,500 -16,788 A 6165 33-01-01-34-426-142 201 A&R DEVELOPMENT II L L C 811,700 836,400 400,000 -436,400 412,350 836,400 400,000 -436,400 A 8093 33-01-01-35-180-021 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 87,000 87,000 87,000 0 47,777 48,875 48,875 0 A 6166 33-01-01-35-301-051 401 LUNA GUILLERMO&LOURDES D 79,400 82,800 66,500 -16,300 69,257 70,849 66,500 -4,349 A 11009 33-01-01-35-378-071 401 CHILDERS BRIAN S&SANDRAJ 86,600 90,200 90,200 0 60,499 90,200 61,890 -28,310 A 8094 33-01-01-35-401-015 201 TRAPPERS COVE LTD PARTNERS 6,629,700 6,629,700 6,629,700 0 5,902,828 6,038,593 6,038,593 0 A 6341 33-01-01-35-401-040 201 MARKHAM RANDOLPH G ELIZABETH 0 0 558,800 558,800 0 0 352,774 352,774 A 6342 33-01-01-35-401-050 201 MARKHAM RANDOLPH G ELIZABETH 0 0 180,800 180,800 0 0 117,591 117,591 A 36 33-01-01-35-401-052 201 MARKHAM RANDOLPH G ELIZABETH 655,700 675,900 0 -675,900 459,790 470,365 0 -470,365 A 8095 33-01-01-35-451-003 201 TRAPPERS COVE LTD PARTNERS 4,235,500 4,235,500 4,235,500 0 3,613,750 3,696,866 3,696,866 0 A 8096 I33-01-01-35-476-002 201 TRAPPERS COVE LTD PARTNERS 2,333,000 2,333,000 2,333,000 0 1,949,735 1,994,578 1,994,578 0 A 8097 . 33-01-01-36-101-011 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 5,500 5,500 5,500 0 1,801 1,842 1,842 0 A 6086 33-01-01-36-102-062 201 EYDE LOUIS J&EYDE GEORGE F 3,493,300 3,495,500 0 -3,495,500 3,095,931 3,167,137 0 -3,167,137 A 6087 33-01-01-36-102-063 201 EYDE LOUIS J&EYDE GEORGE F 0 0 3,447,500 3,447,500 0 0 3,118,033 3,118,033 A 6088 33-01-01-36-102-091 201 EYDE LOUIS J&EYDE GEORGE F 538,000 625,400 0 -629,400 482,451' 562,247 0 -562,247 A 6089 33-01-01-36-102-092 201 EYDE LOUIS J&EYDE GEORGE F 0 0 696,900 696,900 0 0 611,350 611,350 A 8098 33-01-02-32-275-199 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 16,700 17,200 17,200 0 6,705 6,859 6,859 0 A 10015 33-01-05-03-126-026 201 BUCKLES TOMMY&MARILYN 56,400 57,800 57,800 0 43,348 44,345 57,800 13,455 A 8099 33-01-05-03-126-072 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 7,500 11,200 11,200 0 2,284 2,336 2,336 0 A 8100 33-01-05-03-151-061 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 246,900 267,300 267,300 0 171,738 175,687 175,687 0 A 6090 33-01-05-03-176-011 201 MAGUIRE B J JR TRUST 97,500 109,100 93,800 -15,300 53,686 54,920 46,302 -8,618 A 8101 33-01-05-03-177-131 402 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 1,300 1,300 1,300 0 1,300 1,300 1,300 0 A 8102 33-01-05-03-201-001 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 100,500 100,500 100,500 .0 98,310 100,500 100,500 0 A 8103 33-01-05-03-201-011 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 81,600 122,300 122,300 0 46,555 47,625 47,625 0 03/30/2005 11:48:01 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 19 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8104 33-01-05-03-201-022 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 62,900 62,900 62,900 0 36,930 37,779 37,779 0 A 8105 33-01-05-03-220-001 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 19,400 19,400 19,400 0 13,094 13,395 13,395 0 A 8106 33-01-05-03-220-061 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 33,700 33,700 33,700 0 29,667 30,349 30,349 0 A 17 33-01-05-03-251-002 201 ELJON REALTY LLC 0 1,059,300 995,300 -64,000 0 1,059,300 995,300 -64,000 A 6091 33-01-05-03-351-421 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 65,000 83,700 67,700 -16,000 60,328 61,715 61,715 0 A 6092 33-01-05-03-351-441 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 65,000 78,600 67,800 -10,800 56,256 57,549 57,549 0 A 6093 33-01-05-03-351-451 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 67,500 83,400 67,400 -16,000 57,108 58,421 58,421 0 A 6094 33-01-05-03-351-481 401 SEARS MICHAEL J&NANCY R 65,000 77,300 67,600 -9,700 49,354 50,489 50,489 0 A 6095 33-01-05-03-352-121 401 LENNEMAN BRAD 76,700 83,400 62,500 -20,900 56,729 83,400 62,500 -20,900 A 6096 33-01-05-03-352-191 201 TSC PROPERTIES L L C 127,200 139,600 100,700 -38,900 91,047 139,600 100,700 -38,900 A 6097 33-01-05-03-352-201 201 TSC PROPERTIES L L C 127,200 139,600 100,700 -38,900 91,047 139,600 100,700 -38,900 A 6098 33-01-05-03-352-211 201 TSC PROPERTIES L L C 127.200 139,600 100,700 -38,900 91,047 139,600 100,700 -38,900 A 6099 33-01-05-03-352-221 201 TSC PROPERTIES L L C 127,200 139,600 100,700 -38,900 91,047, 139,600 100,700 -38,900 A 6100 33-01-05-03-352-231 201 DICICCO FRANCIS A&DEBORAH 127,200 139,600 100,700 38,900 78,654 80,463 80,463 0 A 6101 33-01-05-03-352-241 201 DICICCO FRANCIS A&DEBORAH 129,600 129,600 100,700 -28,900 78,654 80,463 80,463 0 A 8107 33-01-05-03-352-491 201 REALVEST&ASSOCIATES L.L.C. 174,800 192,000 167,100 24,900 153,984 157,525 157,525 0 A 8108 33-01-05-03-376-004 201 FRANKS NURSERY&CRAFTS INC 604,900 634,000 634,000 0 413,154 422,656 422,656 0 A 8109 33-01-05-03-377-091 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 22,200 22,200 22,200 0 14,309 14,638 14,638 0 A 8110 33-01-05-03-378-012 201 BANK ONE MICHIGAN 210,900 268,600 268,600 0 210,900 215,750 215,750 0 A 6167 33-01-05-04-103-161 401 CAMPBELL ANTHONY L&EVELYN D 55,700 61,800 56,700 -5,100 45,998 47,055 47,055 0 A 8111 33-01-05-04-151-041 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 36,500 36,500 36,500 0 23,324 23,860 23,860 0 A 8112 33-01-05-04-201-121 201 COMERICA BANK 228,400 232,200 232,200 0 217,872 222,883 222,883 0 A 8113 33-01-05-04-201-150 201 GLENAGAIN L.L.C. 800,500 839,800 839,800 0 764,634 782,220 782,220 0 A 61 33-01-05-04-202-011 201 JOLLY DEVELOPMENT L L C 1,382,700 1,395,400 1,395,400 0 1,324,254 1,395,400 1,395,400 0 A 8114 33-01-05-04-202-021 201 A&W GERSHENSON CORP 1,132,400 1,132,400 1,132,400 0 1,132,400 1,132,400 1,132,400 0 A 8115 33-01-05-04-226-012 202 FORD LEASING DEVELOPMENT CO 323,900 358,500 358,500 0 216,018 220,986 220,986 0 03/30/2005 11:48:01 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 20 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8116 33-01-05-04-226-371 202 FORD LEASING DEVELOPMENT CO 28,100 31,000 31,000 0 13,711 14,026 14,026 0 A 8117 33-01-05-04-226-382 201 FORD LEASING DEVELOPMENT CO 470,300 490,700 490,700 0 336,702 344,446 344,446 p A 8118 33-01-05-04-251-001 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 148,500 148,500 148,500 0 147,312 148,500 148,500 p A 6102 33-01-05-04-251-181 401 BLOOD LARRY G 55,700 65,100 60,000 -5,100 42,866 43,851 43,851 p A 6103 33-01-05-04-452-041 401 KEMPF JILL 87,700 87,900 70,000 -17,900 47,615 87,900 70,000 -17,900 A 6168 33-01-05-04-476-012 401 FINEIS GERARD M 58,400 62,600 51,500 -11,100 43,016 62,600 51,500 -11,100 A 6104 33-01-05-05-103-002 401 FLAGG NONA 67,500 67,100 41,500 -25,600 65,826 67,100 41,500 -25,600 A 8119 33-01-05-05-126-031 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 45,100 45,100 45,100 0 32,531 33,279 33,279 p A 8120 33-01-05-05-126-161 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 6,800 6,800 6,800 0 2,138 2,187 2,187 0 A 8121 33-01-05-05-151-041 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 29,000 29,000 29,000 0 5,180 5,299 5,299 0 A 8122 33-01-05-05-152-061 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 25,200 25,200 25,200 0 2,252 2,303 2,303 p A 6169 33-01-05-05-201-051 401 ABDULJABER MOHAMAD H 53,200 63,900 59,500 74,400 47,971 49,074 49,074 p A 8123 33-01-05-05-202-181 301 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 8,000 8,000 8,000 0 8,000 8,000 8,000 p A 6170 33-01-05-05-276-072 401 D& K REAL ESTATE 60,800 69,200 44,700 -24,500 58,115 59,451 44,700 -14,751 A 8124 33-01-05-05-277-231 202 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 139,100 156,000 156,000 0 55,665 56,945 56,945 p A 6171 33-01-05-05-302-003 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 59,700 61,100 49,900 11,200 58,270 59,610 49,900 -9,710 A 6172 33-01-05-05-302-007 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 59,700 61,100 49,900 11,200 58,270 59,610 49,900 -9 710 A 6173 33-01-05-05-302-013 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 57,800 58,800 44,800 -14,000 56,256 57,549 44,800 -12,749 A 6174 33-01-05-05-302-019 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 62,100 62,300 49,400 -12,900 60,649 62,043 49,400 -12,643 A 6175 33-01-05-05-302-280 402 D&K REAL ESTATE 800 3,400 1,000 -2,400 800 818 818 0 A 10016 33-01-05-05-306-081 401 CENTURY PARTNERS L L C 26,800 27,900 27,900 0 23,145 23,677 27,900 4,223 A 6176 33-01-05-05-426-081 401 CHARLOW MICHAEL J&TANYA L 74,900 71,900 59,400 -12,500 74,900 71,900 59,400 -12,500 A 9045 33-01-05-05-428-202 401 HEPPINSTALL JAMES 0 35,800 6,800 -29,000 0 32,884 6,800 -26,084 A 6177 33-01-05-05-431-353 401 VANCE JAMES A 63,300 61,700 44,700 -17,000 63,300 61,700 44,700 -17,000 A 6188 33-01-05-05-431-382 401 HEIN STEPHEN L 66,600 78,800 j 61,500 -17,300 66,600 78,800 61,500 -17,300 A 8125 33.01-05-06-101-012 201 R&J WAVERLY LLC 571,600 604,100 604,100 0 438,079 448,154 448,154 0 03/30/2005 11:48:02 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 21 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 8126 33-01-05-06-151-111 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 17,400 17,400 17,400 0 4,713 4,821 4,821 0 A 8127 33-01-05-06-151-121 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 17,400 17,400 17,400 0 3,491 3,571 3,571 0 A 8128 33-01-05-06-188-301 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 29,800 29,800 29,800 0 12,480 12,767 12,767 0 A 6178 33-01-05-06-201-051 401 PETERSON RICHARD&ROBERTA 49,200 50,500 42,000 78,500 40,183 41,107 41,107 0 A 9046 33-01-05-06-226-002 401 WAGER LESLEE R 26,400 33,700 4,000 -29,700 21,120 21,605 4,000 -17,605 A 8129 33-01-05-06-251-032 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 48,200 48,200 48,200 0 28,950 29,615 29,615 0 A 6340 33-01-05-06-301-087 401 STEWARD YVONNE 62,100 63,100 56,900 -6,200 57,288 58,605 56,900 -1,705 A 9047 33-01-05-06-377-071 401 ROGERS GEORGIA B 7,400 36,700 7,500 -29,200 7,400 23,211 7,500 -15,711 A 6179 33-01-05-06-379-121 401 LUNA LOURDES D&GUILLERMO 69,900 74,100 65,400 -8,700 64,858 66,349 65,400 -949 A 6180 33-01-05-06-433-039 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 42,200 43,000 41,000 72,000 36,632 37,474 37,474 0 A 6105 33-01-05-06-478-031 401 THOMAS-MODERN COMPANIES L L C 4,500 41,500 25,500 -16,000 4,500 41,500 25,500 -16,000 A 6106 33-01-05-06-481-061 401 TREADWELL THERESA M 62,800 64,100 58,900 -5,200 59,808 64,100 58,900 -5,200 A 8130 33-01-05-07-225-801 207 AAT COMMUNICATIONS CORP 63,300 61,900 61,900 0 63,300 61,900 61,900 0 A 9048 33-01-05-07-228-141 401 ORTIZ MANUEL&FRANCISCA_ 46,600 45,000 10,500 -34,500 34,095 34,879 10,500 24,379 A 6107 33-01-05-08-101-279 401 TRAVIS JOHN&HEATHER 87,500 80,900 63,400 -17,500 46,911 80,900 63,400 -17,500 A 6181 33-01-05-08-208-030 401 D&K REAL ESTATE 4,100 22,000 51,200 -10,800 1,687 53,825 51,200 -2,625 A 9 33-01-05-08-280-021 202 JADAOUN HICHAM R&GEDAOUN 0 74,700 63,500 -11,200 0 74,700 63,500 11,200 A 10 33-01-05-08-280-031 202 JADAOUN HICHAM R&GEDAOUN 0 31,100 26,500 -4,600 0 31,100 26,500 4,600 A 6182 33-01-05-08-427-021 401 LY CHAY&KUE AE 77,400 85,500 61,400 -24;100 77,400 85,500 61,400 -24,100 A 8131 33-01-05-09-226-016 201 WOODBRIDGEAPARTMENT 3,410,900 3,430,200 3,430,200 0 3,200,364 3,273,972 3,273,972 0 A 6183 33-01-05-09-226-052 201 KESTOINC 340,000 356,700 340,400 -16,300 339,240 347,042 340,400 -6,642 A 8132 33-01-05-09-251-107 201 TG APARTMENTS L.L.C. 574,500 585,100 585,100 0 560,910 573,810 573,810 0 A 9049 33-01-05-09-302-002 401 WIEGAND LYDIA 5,500 24,700 4,300 -20,400 5,500 20,942 4,300 -16,642 A 6189 33-01-05-09-326-232 401 BAKER JAMES M&LOUVERNAA 73,200 79,500 55,700 -23,800 61,726 63,145 55,700 -7,445 A 9050 33-01-05-09-352-191 401 HODGMAN CONSTANCE 5,600 43,000 3,400 -39,600 5,600 31,750 3,400 -28,350 A 8133 33-01-05-09-376-801 207 AAT COMMUNICATIONS CORP 70,300 68,800 68,800 0 70,300 68,800 68,800 0 03/30/2005 11:48:02 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 22 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 9051 33-01-05-09-377-151 401 BOX SHARON E 5,000 39,900 5,000 -34,900 5,000 37,089 5,000 -32,089 A 8134 33-01-05-09-403-001 202 RAMCO-GERSHENSON PROPERTIES 78,400 89,600 89,600 0 57,281 58,598 58,598 0 A 8135 33-01-05-09-403-051 201 TARGET CORPORATION T-0361 3,034,600 3,204,500 3,204,500 0 2,887,028 2,953,429 2,953,429 0 A 8136 33-01-05-09-403-081 201 RAMCO-GERSHENSON PROPERTIES 4,253,900 4,488,700 4,488,700 0 2,956,820 3,024,826 3,024,826 0 A 8137 33-01-05-10-101-003 201 MEIJER INC 4,645,600 4,768,300 4,768,300 0 3,116,308 3,187,983 3,187,983 0 A 8138 33-01-05-10-101-071 201 STANDARD FEDERAL SAVINGS BNK 301,100 346,400 346,400 0 301,100 308,025 308,025 0 A 8139 33-01-05-10-101-091 202 GOOD WILL CO INC 41,200 46,300 46,300 0 28,418 29,071 29,071 0 A 8140 33-01-05-10-101-101 202 GOOD WILL CO INC 36,000 41,200 41,200 0 22,780 23,303 23,303 0 A 8141 33-01-05-10-126-046 302 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 1,500 1,500 1,500 0 427 436 436 0 A 8142 33-01-05-10-126-145 201 STOP&LOCK IV 1,044,700 1,089,500 1,089,500 0 804,256 822,753 822,753 0 A 8143 33-01-05-10-151-032 201 FORD LEASING DEVELOPMENT CO 1,223,000 1,265,200 1,265,200 0 1,007,674 1,030,850 1,030,850 0 A 8144 33-01-05-10-152-008 201 AGREE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 489,300 420,600 420,600 0 387,051 420,600 420,600 0 A 54 33-01-05-10-152-020 201 BALDINO LUIGI G& IRENE L 448,800 471,800 471,800 0 342,665 471,800 471,800 0 A 55 !33-01-05-10-152-023 201 BALDINO LUIGI G& IRENE L 570,800 61.7,900- 617,900 0 378,501 617,900 617,900 0 A 56 33-01-05-10-152-050 202 BALDINO LUIGI G& IRENE L 17,200 18,800 18,800 0 9,633 18,800 18,800 0 A 76 33-01-05-10-152-060 201 ROMIL INC 802,300 829,300 829,300 0 520,813 532,791 532,791 0 A 20 33-01-05-10-176-002 201 FAWAZ FAWAZ F 313;100 331,900 300,000 -31,900 307,869 314,949 300,000 -14,949 - 7 CANCELLE 33-01-05-10-176-211 201 MICHIGAN INNS 993,700 1,058,400 1,058,400 0 911,671 932,639 932,639 0 A 6190 33-01-05-10-2277001 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 A 6191 33-01-05-10-227-002 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 A 6192 33-01-05-10-227-003 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6193 33-01-05-10-227-004 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 -CONDOMINIUMS LLC A 6194 33-01-05-10-227-005 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6195 33-01-05-10-227-006 401 LEDESMA VICKIE L 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6196 33-01-05-10-227-007 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,600 49,400 41,200 -8,200 13,353 49,400 41,200 -8,200 A 6197 33-01-05-10-227-008 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,900 49,700 41,400 -8,300 13,508 49,700 41,400 -8,300 03/30/2005 11:48:02 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 23 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6198 33-01-05-10-227-009 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6199 33-01-05-10-227-010 401 BAKER ELIZABETH 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 A 6200 33-01-05-10-227-011 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6201 33-01-05-10-227-012 401 MILLER PKTOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6202 33-01-05-10-227-013 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6203 33-01-05-10-227-014 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6204 33-01-05-10-227-015 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 A 6205 33-01-05-10-227-016 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 A 6206 33-01-05-10-227-017 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 -CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6207 33-01-05-10-227-018 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6208 33-01-05-10-227-019 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 A 6209 1 33-01-05-10-227-020 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 A 6210 33-01-05-10-227-021 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 _ CONDOMINIUMS A 6211 33-01-05-10-227-022 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6212 33-01-05-10-227-023 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6213 33-01-05-10-227-024 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6214 33-01-05-10-227-025 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,500 -8,000 13,353 49,500 41,500 -8,000 A 6215 33-01-05-10-227-026 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6216 33-01-05-10-227-027 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6217 33-01-05-10-227-028 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 A 6218 33-01-05-10-227-029 401 POTTER ANDREW W 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6219 33-01-05-10-227-030 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6220 33-01-05-10-227-031 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 47,700 49,500 41,300 -8,200 13,353 49,500 41,300 -8,200 LLQ A 6221 33-01-05-10-227-032 401 CONDRIC GORDANA&VIDOSAVA 48,000 49,800 41,500 -8,300 13,508 49,800 41,500 -8,300 A 6222 33-01-05-10-227-033 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6223 33-01-05-10-227-034 1 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 -9,100 03/30/2005 11:48:03 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW PARCEL NUMBER ORDER Page 24 of 35 APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT A 6224 33-01-05-10-227 ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE -035 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 A 6225 33-01-05-10-227-036 401 SANDERS CALVIN i�DINGMAN RENEE -6,600 42,500 44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 A 6226 33-01-05-10-227-037 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME -6,600 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 A 6227 33-01-05-10-227-038 401 WILKE WENDY L -9,100 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 A 6228 33-01-05-10-227-039 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME -9,200 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 A 6229 33-01-05-10-227-040 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME -9,200 50,500 52,400 43,300 9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 A 6230 33-01-05-10-227-041 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME -9,100 42,500 44,100 37,50076,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6231 33-01-05-10-227-042 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 44,100 37 A 6232 33-01-05-10-227-043 401 MILL 11 ER PK TOWNHOME ,500 -6,600 50,500 52,400 43,300 79,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 -9,100 A 6233 33-01-05-10-227-044 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME LLQ50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6234 33-01-05-10-227-045 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME ON 50,700 52,600 43,400 9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6235 33-01-05-10-227-046 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 50,500 52,400 43,300 9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 -9,100 A 6236 33--01-05-10-227-047 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 6,600 A 6237 33-01-05-10-227-048 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 �44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 A 6238 33-01-05-10-227-049 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 44,100 37,500 -6,600 42,500 44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 A 6239 33-01-05-10-227-050 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME A 44,100 37,500 -6,600 COND 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 6240 33-01-05-10-227-051 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 6,600 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 A 6241 CONDOMINIUMS33-01-05-10-227-052 401 MILLERPKTOWNHOME 52,400 43,300 -9,100 NDOMINIQMSj.LQ50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 A 6242 33-01-05-10-227-053 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 52,600 43,400 -9,200 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 A 6243 33-01-05-10-227-054 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 52,600 43,400 -9;200 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 A 6244 33-01-05-10-227-055 401 MILLERPKTOWNHOME -9,100 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 A 6245 33-01-05-10-227-056 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 44,100 37,500 6,600 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 A 6246 33-01-05-10-227-057 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 44,100 37,500 6,600 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 A 6247 33-01-05-10-227-058 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 52,400 43,300 -9,100 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 A 6248 33-01-05-10-227-059 401 MEADE JANICE 52,600 43,400 -9,200 50,700 52,600 43,400 9,200 13,508 A 6249 33-01-05-10-227-060 401 KOPPENHOEFER DANIEL&AM Y 52,600 43,400 -9,200 50.500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 -9,100 03/30/2005 11:48:03 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 25 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE NUMBER BOARD NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6250 33-01-05-10-227-061 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6251 33-01-05-10-227-062 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6252 1 33-01-05-10-227-063 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6253 33-01-05-10-227-064 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6254 33-01-05-10-227-065 401 SCHWALM EZRA J&NANCY J 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 52,400 43,300 -9,100 A 6255 33-01-05-10-227-066 401 RUSSELL TAMELA 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6256 33-01-05-10-227-067 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,300 43,900 37,300 -6,600 13,202 43,900 37,300 -6,600 A 6257 33-01-05-10-227-068 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLO A 6258 33-01-05-10-227-069 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6259 33-01-05-10-227-070 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6260 33-01-05-10-227-071 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6261 33-01-05-10-227-072 401 M I LLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 A 6262 33-01-05-10-227-073 40'I MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 6,600 A 6263 33-01-05-10-227-074 401 MILLER PKTOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6264 33-01-05-10-227-075 401 CH IV CAROL A 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6265 33-01-05-10-227-076 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,354 52,400 43,300 -9,100 CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6266 33-01-05-10-227-077 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 6,600 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 -CONDOMINIUMS LLC A 6267 33-01-05-10-227-078 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 42,500 44,100 37,500 -6,600. 13,202 44,100 37,500 -6,600 CONDOMINIUMS LLC A 6268 33-01-05-10-2.27-079 401 MILLER PK TOWNHOME 50,500 52,400 43,300 -9,100 13,353 " 52,400 43,300 -9,100 -CONDOMINIUMS LLQ A 6269 33-01-05-10-227-080 401 BERRY FREDERICK G&ANN K 50,700 52,600 43,400 -9,200 13,508 52,600 43,400 -9,200 A 6184 33-01-05-10-251-211 401 HARDEN SHAY 69,200 70,200 64,400 -5,800 69,200 70,200 64,400 -5,800 A 8145 33-01-05-10-301-034 201 DENNY'S INC 321,800 328,100 315,400 -12,700 277,681 284,067 284,067 0 A 6108 33-01-05-10-328-010 201 LOWE'S HOME CENTERS INC 5,009,500 5,181,100 4,871,900 -309,200 4,869,527 4,981,526 4,871,900 -109,626 A 57 33-01-05-10-426-092 401 SPARKS DOREEN M 50,300 55,400 55,400 0 50,300 51,456 51,456 0 A 6109 33-01-05-10-427-291 401 SANDBERG MARK 89,100 91,000 77,500 -13,500 89,100 91,000 77,500 -13,500 A 6322 1 33-01-05-10-428-031 1 401 WELTER JAYSON 91,300 93,200 76,500 -16,700 91,300 93,200 76,500 -16,700 P ' 03/30/2005 11:48:04 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW PARCEL NUMBER ORDER Page 26 of 35 APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S BOARD NUMBER NUMBER PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6110 33-01-05-10-432-003 401 MILLER JORDAN L 8 ELAINE B 82,700 86,600 78,300 -8,300 82,700 86,600 78,300 A 8146 33-01-05-10-451-002 201 MILL POND COMPANY L.L.C. -8,300 2,237,400 2,892,900 2,892,900 0 1,689,313 1,739,667 1,739,667 A 7001 90-23-50-02-010-000 251 BRINKER CONSTRUCTION 0 0 10,000 13,100 3,100 0 10,000 13,100 A 7057 90-23-50-14-695-000 251 CONTRACTORS WALL REPAIR 3,100 4,300 4,700 3,900 -800 4,300 A 7002 90-23-50-29-371-000 251 HARRIS STEEL INC 4,700 3,900 -800 0 10,000 0 -10,000 A 7058 90-23-50-32-105-000 251 DACS ELECTRICAL LTD 0 10,000 0 -10,000 0 10,000 000 0 A 7003 90-23-50-58-520-000 251 PACIFIC RIM CAPITAL, INC. -10,000 0 10, 0 -10,000 p 0 24,400 A 8147 90-23-50-78-029-000 251 ARBOR POINTE ONE L L C 3 24,400 p 0 24,400 24,400 ,600 .3,100 3,100 0 3,600 A 8148 90-23-50-78-030-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,100 3,100 p 84,100 84,400 84,400 0 84,100 A 7059 90-23-50-78-039-000 251 HAIR TOUCH BEAUTY SUPPLY 84,400 84,400 p 3,500 3,900 600 -3,300 3,500 A 7192 90-23-50-78-045-000 251 CHINA PALACE 2 3,900 600 -3,300 5,300 5,800 4,700 -1,100 5,300 A 7060 90-23-50-78-049-000 251 WAVERLY CHIROPRACTIC CENTER 5,800 4,700 -1,100 3,700 0 3,800 3,800 3,700 A 8149 90-23-50-78-050-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 0 9,800 3,800 _ 41,200 39,700 39,700 0 41,200 39,700 39,700 A 8150 90-23-50-78-055-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 0 21,800 23,400. 23,400 400 0 21;800 23, A 7061 90-23-50-7&072-000 251 SCHECK MECHANICAL 23,400 p 0 12,500 0 -12,500 - A 7062 90-23-50-78-073-000 251 SME 0 12,500 0 -12,500 0 10,000 0 A 7063 90-23-50-78-091-000 251 SMITH HAM M -10,000OND 0 10,000 0 -10,000 0 10,000 0 -10,000 0 10,000 A 7064 90-23-50-78-100-000 251 STEPHENSON 8P SONS ROOFING INC 0 10,000 3,800 4,200 0 -4,200 3,800 A 7004 90-23-50-85-105-000 351 GENERAL MOTORS CORP 4,200 0 -4,200 0 0 16,700 16,700 p A 7162 90-33-01-00-134-000 251 ABOOD PROPERTIES 0 16,700 16,700 5,200 5,700 6,500 800 5,200 A 7065 90-33-01-01-210-000 251 ADVANCE TRUCK CAPS 5,700 6,500 800 5,500 6,100 1,900 -4,200 5,500 A 7005 90-33-01-01-618-000 251 ALLIANCE OB GYN 6,100 1,900 -4,200 102,500 107,600 88,200 -19,400 102,500 107,600 A 7163 90-33-01-01-625-000 251 ALLIED DISPOSAL CO 88,200 -19,400 11,900 13,100 0 -13,100 11,900 A 7006 90-33-01-01-835-000 251 AMERICAN FIRE SUPPRESSION, INC 13,100 0 13,100 2,500 0 1,000 1,000 2,500 A 7007 90-33-01-02-020-000 251 ADT SECURITY SYSTEM INC 0 1,000 1,000 36,500 40,200 48,600 8,400 36,500 A 7008 90-33-01-02-063-000 251 AMERICAN FIRE PROTECTION CO 40,200 48,600 8,400 91,100 100,200 108,600 8,400 91,100 100,200 108,600 8,400 03/30/2005 11:48:04 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 27 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7066 90-33-01-02-155-000 251 AMERICA ONLINE INC 0 0 2,600 2,600 p p 2,600 2,600 A 7067 90-33-01-02-700-000 251 GLOBE BUSINESS RESOURCES INC 3,000 1,300 1,300 0 3,000 1,300 1,300 0 A 7009 90-33-01-02-739-000 251 APPLEBEES INTERNATIONAL INC 92,300 101, 000 89,600 -11,900 92,300 101,500 89,600 -11,900 A 7068 90-33-01-02-912-000 251 ARBOR LAWN CARE 4,900 5,400 8,900 3,500 4,900 5,400 8,900 3,500 A 7069 90-33-01-03-350-000 251 SONUS USA INC 24,500 27,0 00 33,100 6,100 24,500 27,000 33,100 6,100 A 7010 90-33-01-03-360-000 351 AUTO AIR COMPOSITES INC 252,900 265,500 363,700 98,200 252,900 265,500 363,700 98,200 A 7011 90-33-01-03-390-000 351 PRATT& WHITNEY AUTO-AIR 906,100 951,400 879,500 -71,900 906,100 951,400 879,500 -71,900 A 7012 90-33-01-03-394-000 251 ASSESSMENT SERVICES CENTER, 0 1LLC ,500 500 -1,000 0 1,500 500 1,000 A 7013 90-33-01-03-537-000 351 PRATT&WHITNEY AUTO AIR 194,400 204,100 194,200 -9,900 194,400 204,100 194,200 -9,900 A 7212 90-33-01-03-935-000 251 BAILEY SAND&GRAVEL CO 0 0 87,500 87,500 p 0 87,500 87,500 A 7070 90-33-01-05-110-000 251 BEANERS GOURMET COFFEE 24,200 26,600 18,900 7,700 24,200 26,600 18,900 -7,700 A 7071 90-33-01-07-390-000 251 BOOKMARKTHE 19,900 21,900 21,300 -600 19,900 21,900 21,300 -600 A 7072 90-33-01-07-800-000 251 BRADFORD PRINTING, INC 261,800 344,100 288,000 -56,100 261,800 344,100 288,000 56,100 A 7164 90-33-01-08-085-000 251 BRINKS HOME SECURITY, INC. 1,900 2,100 1,700 -400 1,900 2,100 1,700 -400 A 7014 90-33-01-09-100-000 251 BURAN KATHLEEN A, MD 15,000 16,500 13,600 -2,900 15,000 16,500 13,600 -2,900 A 7073 90-33-01-09-1597000 251 BYBLOS MIDDLE EASTERN CUISINE 10,100 11,100 9,100 -2,000 10,100 11,100 9,100 -2,000 A 7074 90-33-01-09-165-000 251 BURLESON&O'NEILL PLLC 0 0 3,500 3,500 p 0 3,500 3,500 A 7075 90-33-01-09-545-000 251 C&J TAX SERVICE 2,800 3,100 3,700 600 2,800 3,100 3,700 600 A 7076 90-33-01-09-575-000 251 C&T BODY SHOP INC 20,000 22,000 26,400 4,400 20,000 22,000 26,400 4,400 A 8151 90-33-01-09-980-000 251 CANDLEWOOD SUITES HOTEL 353,700 371,400 371,400 0 353,700 371,400 371,400 0 A 7077 90-33-01-11-130-000 251 CAPITOL FUR CO 4,200 4,606 0 -4,600 4,200 4,600 p -4,600 A 7165 90-33-01-11-296-000 251 CAPITIOL MECHANICAL 0 4,000 2Ir. NTRACTORS IN ,500 -1,500 0 4,000 2,500 -1,500 A 7078 90-33-01-11-614-000 251 CARDTRONICS INC 0 3,000 400 -2,600 p 3,000 400 -2,600 A 7015 90-33-01-12-059-000 251 CASHLAND FINANCIAL SERVICES, 0 0 60,800 60,800 p C. 0 60,800 60,800 A 7193 90 33-01-12-310-000 251 EL AZTECO TWO INC 11,700 12,900 15,300 2,400 11,700 12,900 15,300 2,400 A 8152 90-33-01-13-201-000 251 CITIZENS ALLIANCE ON PRISONS 0 1,300 2,300 1,000 0 1,300 2,300 1,000 03/30/2005 11:48:04 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 28 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE NUMBER BOARD NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7079 90-33-01-13-225-000 251 BAYER CORPORATION 19,000 20,900 16,200 7,700 19,000 20,900 16,200 -4,700 A 7166 90-33-01-13-316-000 251 CHR SERVICES PROFESSIONAL 8,900 9,800 0 -9,800 8,900 9,800 0 -9,800 RFMnD A 8153 90-33-01-13-378-000 251 CIT GROUP/EQUIPMENT FIN INC 166,700 170,100 170,100 0 166,700 170,100 170,100 0 A 7080 90-33-01-13-410-000 251 UNIVERSITY CLUB OF MSU 12,100 10,800 0 -10,800 12,100 10,800 0 -10,800 A 7081 90-33-01-13-775-000 251 CLARK LIFT OF DETROIT 36,500 40,200 0 -46,200 36,500 40,200 0 -40,200 A 7016 90-33-01-13-981-000 251 COBE CARDIOVASCULAR INC 40,300 44,300 35,400 -8,900 40,300 44,300 35,400 -8,900 A 7017 90-33-01-14-145-000 251 COMPUTER SCIENCES 29,000 31,900 33,600 1,700 29,000 31,900 33,600 1,700 CORPORATIO A 7082 90-33-01-14-360-000 251 COMPUTEL COMPUTER SYSTEMS INC 1,400 1,500 0 -1,500 1,400 1,500 0 -1,500 A 8154 90-33-01-14-630-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY CO 17,430,500 17,585,500 17,585,500 0 17,430,500 17,585,500 17,585,500 0 A 7206 90-33-01-14-684-000 251 CONTINENTAL RSOURCES INC 8,400 7,600 0 -7,600 8,400 7,600 0 -7,600 A 7083 90-33-01-14-693-000 251 CONRAD YELVINGTON 479,800 503,800 162,700 -341,100 479,800 503,800 162,700 -341,100 A 7084 90-33-01-15-130-000 251 LANS INTERNAL MEDICINE ASSOC 43,200 47,500 50,600 3,100 43,200 47,500 50,600 3,100 A 7085 90-33-01-16-150-000 251 TNT LOGISTICS NORTH AMERICA INC 102,000 107,100 81,300 25,800 102,000 107,100 81,300 -25,800 A 7086 90-33-01-16-274-000 551 DETROIT EDISON COMPANY 24,300 26,700 22,100 -4,600 24,300 26,700 22,100 -4,600 A 7167 90-33-01-16-383-000 251 DAGGETT RECYCLING CO. 0 2,500 0 -2,500 0 2,500 0 -2,500 A 7168 90-33-01-17-540-000 351 DEMMER CORPORATION 1,668,400 1,683,900 1,569,000 -114,900 1,668,400 1,683,900 1,569,000 -114,900 A 7087 90-33-01-17-735-0.00 251 DETROIT FREE PRESS 8,800 9,700 20,000 10,300 8,800 9,700 20,000 10,300 A 7169 90-33-01-18-304-000 251 DISCOUNT TIRE CO. INC. 24,600 22,300 2,300 -201000 24,600 22,300 2,300 -20,000 A 7088 90-33-01-18-767-000 251 LIZ'SALTERATION, 1,200 1,300 1,200 -100 1,200 1,300 1,200 -100 A 7089 90-33-01-18-774-000 251 DOUBLE DEUCE 2,600 2,900 3,100 200 2,600 2,900 3,100 200 A 7170 90-33-01-19-821-000 251 ECHOSTAR SATELLITE LLC 122,300 98,400 60,600 -37,800 122,300 98,400 60,600 -37,800 A 7171 90-33-01-19-822-000 251 ECHOSTAR SATELLITE LLC 114,200 238,300 90,000 -148,300 114,200 238,300 90,000 -148,300 A 7090 90-33-01-19-906-000 251 ELECTRO RENT CORPORATION 500 600 0 -600 500 600 0 -600 A 7172 90-33-01-19-934-000 251 ELECTRONIC DATA SYSTEMS CORP 500 4,100 500 -3,600 500 4,100 500 -3,600 A 7091 90-33-01-19-961-000 251 EDS INFORMATION SERVICES LLC 1,000 1,100 0 -1,100 1,000 1,100 0 -1,100 A 7018 90-33-01-20-641-000 251 CIT TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION 22,900 146,200 258,200 112,000 22,900 146,200 258,200 112,000 03/30/2005 11:48:05 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 29 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 92 90 70 -33-01-20-785-000 251 ERVIN LEASING 165,200 275,800 157.600 -118,200 165,200 275,800 157,600 -118,200 A 7093 90-33-01-21-571-0 00 251 FAMILY MOTORCYCLE CLUB OF 600 700 500 LANSING -200 600 700 500 -200 A 7094 90-33-01-21-579-000 251 FAMILIY VIDEO 5,300 5,800 25,600 19,800 5,300 5,800 25,600 19,800 A 7019 90-33-01-21-762-000 251 FASHION BUG#2399 INC 8,100 8,900 9,800 900 8,100 8,900 9,800 900 A 7095 90-33-01-21-853-000 251 FAWAZ ENTERPRISE INC 1,000 1,100 1,000 -100 1,000 1,100 1,000 -100 A 7096 90-33-01-22-339-000 251 FIRST AMERICAN COMMERCIAL 317,100 BAUICORP 0 256,400 256,400 317,100 0 256,400 256,400 A 7173 90-33-01-24-040-000 351 FRIEDLAND IN INC 180.500 160,500 88,300 -72,200 180,500 160,500 88,300 -72,200 A 7020 90-33-01-24-299-000 251 FUTURE TRENDS MACHINERY& 45,000 49,500SULTIN 17,900 -31,600 45,000 49,500 17,900 -31,600 A 7174 90-33-01-24-485-000 251 VERIZON CORPORATE SERVICES 100 100 GR UP0 -100 100 100 0 -100 A 7021 90-33-01-24-610-000 251 SAL GANI G, PC 0 5,700 3,200 -2,500 p 5,700 3,200 -2,500 A 7175 90-33-01-24-630-000 251 GREGORYS FOOD DRINK 16,700 18,400 15,400 -3,000 16,700 18,400 15,400 -3,000 A 7097 90-33-01-25-134-000 251 GENESIS OHS(MEDICAL SUPPLY& 3FoLul ,000 3,300 800 -2,500 3,000 3,300 800 -2,500 A . 176 90-33-01-26-921-000 251 GRANGER CONTAINER SERVICE INC 327,400 382,200 395.300 13,100 327,400 382,200 395,300 13,100 A 7213 90-33-01-27-354-000 251 GREATER BAY CAPITAL 0 0 1 22,100 1121100 p 0 112,100 112,100 A 7098 90-33-01-28-266-000 251 SEMCO ENERGY, INC. 1,200 1,300 1,000 -300 1,200 1,300 1,000 -300 A 7099 90-33-01-28-370-000 551 MR TOAD'S PAPER COMPANY 3,100 3,400 2,100 -1,300 3,100 3,400 2,100 -1,300 A 7207 90-33-01-30-075-000 351 HERTZ EQUIPMENT RENTAL 539,100 566,100 563,500 -2,600 539,100 566,100 563,500 -2,600 A 7100 90-33-01-30-255-000 251 HICKS, MULLETT&GREGG 0 0 7,500 7,500 p 0 7,500 7,500 A 7101 90-33-01-30-935-000 251 HOLMES RD BARBER SHOP 0 3,000 0 -3,000 0 3,000 0 -3,000 A 7162 90-33-01-30-940-000 251 HOLY SPIRIT INSTITUTE 0 1,000 p -1,000 0 1,000 0 -1,000 A 8155 90-33-01-31-100-000 251 HONIGMAN,MILLER 142,600 160,800 160,800 0 142,600 160,800 160,800 p A 7177 90-33-01-31-303-000 251 HOT LIGHT PRODUCTIONS 8,000 8,800 1,500 -7,300 8,000 8,800 1,500 -7,300 A 7103 90-33-01-32-735-000 251 IBM CREDIT LLC 2,161,000 1,125,200 897,500 -227,700 2,161,000 1,125,200 897,500 -227,700 A 7022 90-33-01-33-111-000 251 J STROLLE CO 4,600 5,100 2,900 -2,200 4,600 5,100 2,900 -2,200 A 7023 90-33-01-33-361-000 251 KEEPS JIFFY MART 13,000 14,300 12,500 -1,800 13,000 14,300 12,500 -1,800 A 7104 90-33-01-33-830-000 251 KAMPBO CHINESE CARRY-OUT 3,000 3,300 2,300 -1,000 3,000 3,300 2,300 -1,000 03/30/2005 11:48:05 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 30 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL BOARD NUMBER CLASTKATHRYN OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7178 90-33-01-33-875-000 251 MENINGA, PLC 0 2,5000 -2,500 0 2,500 0 -2,500 A 7105 90-33-01-34-643-000 251CR 151,6 00 159,200 113,100 -46,100 151,600 159,200 113,100 -46,100 A 7024 90-33-01-34-870-000 251 KIM NAILS 0 800 2,300 1,500 p 800 2,300A 7106 1,5009 - - 251 L A BURCH DENTAL STUDIO INC 2,500 2,800 10,200 7,400 2,500 2,800 10,200 7,400 A 7107 90-33-01-36-660-000 251 AUTOSHINE UNLIMITED INC 2,000 2,200 1,000 1,200 2'500 2,200 1,200 -1,400 A 7108 90-33-01-38-733-000 251 LAPIS JEWELERS 3,200 3,500 p -3,500 3,200 3,500 0 -3,500 A 7109 90-33-01-39-052-000 251 LARRY AUTO SERVICE 6,000 6,600 10,200 3,600 6,000 6,600 10,200 3,600 A 7110 90-33-01-39-190-000 251 LEAVENWORTHS PHOTOGRAPHICS 1Irlif, ,900 2,100 1,500 -600 1,900 2,100 1,500 -600 A 7025 90-33-01-40-450-000 251 LISKEYS PROF WHEEL SERV 62,100 68,300 56,800 711,500 62,100 68,300 56,800 -11,500 A 7111 90-33-01-40-463-000 251 LIQUI-BOX CORPORATION 8,000 8,800 0 -8,800 8,000 8,800 0 -8,800 A 7194 90-33-01-40-575-000 251 SERVICE EMPLOYEES INT UNION 105,900 111,200 92,200 -19,000 105,900 111,200 92,200 -19,000 A 7195 90-33-01-40-685- 000 251 LONG DEVELOPMENT INC 1,700 1,900 0 -1,900 1,700 1,900 0 -1,900 A 7112 90-33-01-40-695-000 251 LOOMIS EWERT PARSLEY DAVIS 61,900 68,100 68,800 700 61,900 68,100 68,800 700 A 7026 90-33-01-41 470-000 251 M&M VEHICLE&EQUIPMENT 4,100 4,500 3,100 -1,400 4,100 4,500 3,100 -1,400 A 7208 90-33-01-42-530-000 251 BONNIE'S PLACE INC 23,000 25,300 64,000 38,700 23,000 25,300 64,000 38,700 A 7179 90-33-01-42-559-000 251 MARK D. EYSTER ATTORNEY AT LAW 2,800 3,100 0 -3,100 2,800 3,100 0 -3,1100 A 7027 90-33-01-42-566-000 251 MARKERBOARD PEOPLE INC. 7,800 8,600 8,600 0 7,800 8,600 8,600 p A 7028 90-33-01-42-670-000 351 MARTIN BLOCK CORP 266,000 279,300 252,600 -26,700 266,000 279,300 252,600 -26,700 A 7180 90-33-01-43-154-000 551 MATERIAL SERViCE CORPORATION 1,400 400 0 -400 1,400 400 0 -400 RA 90-33-01-43-341-000 251 MCCELLAND&ANDERSON PC 41,100 45,200 39,600 -5,600 41,100 45,200 39,600 -5,600 90-33-01-45-040-000 251 NAT'L ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS 32,200 35,400 40,200 4,800 32,200 35,400 40,200 4,800 90-33-01-45-155-000 251 MICHIGAN CONSOLIDATED GAS CO 300 300 200 -100 300 300 200 -100 90-33-01-45-193-000 551 AFSCME AFL-CIO 95,800 105,400 80,300 -25,100 95,800 105,400 80,300 -25,100 90-33-01-45-826-0 00 251 BOJI TOWER L.L.C. 71,100 78,200 101,300 23,100 71,100 78,200 101,300 23,100 90-33-01-45-911-000 251 TEACHERS STORE 170,000 100,000 110,600 10,600 170,000 100,000 110,600 10,600 A 7181 90-33-01-47-060-000 251 DADE BEHRING INC. 5,700 0 5,300 5,300 5,700 0 5,300 5,300 03/30/2005 11:48:05 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 31 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7030 90-33-01-47-355-000 251 MIKES DRIVE THRU MARKET 1,800 2,000 1,700 -300 1,800 2,000 1,700 -300 A 7117 90-33-01-47-887-000 251 MR TACO OF LANSING INC 6,800 27,300 6,600 -20,700 6,800 27,300 6,600 -20,700 A 7118 90-33-01-47-965-000 251 MOBILE STORAGE GROUP INC 0 0 1,100 1,100 p 0 1,100 1,100 A 8156 90-33-01-48-215-600 251 MONTELL USA INC 0 1,000 0 -1,000 0 1,000 p -1,000 A 7182 90-33-01-48-700-000 251 MT HOPE MONUMENT CO 7,500 8,300 1,100 -7,200 7,500 8,300 1,100 -7,200 A 7119 90-33-01-48-821-000 251 MUFFINS-N-MORE 0 2,500 800 -1,700 0 2,500 800 -1,700 A 8157 90-33-01-48-851-000 251 RITE AID CORPORATION 61,300 92,300 92,300 0 61,300 92,300 92,300 p A 7120 90-33 01-48-876-000 251 MUNCHIES 6,000 6,600 5,000 -1,600 6,000 6,600 5,000 -1,600 A 7121 90-33-01-48-904-000 251 MOWRY JAMES A 4,800 5,300 4,000 -1,300 4,800 5,300 4,000 -1,300 A 7122 90-33-01-49-768-000 251 NATIONAL CITY COMMERCIAL 0 0 19,400 19,400 p -CAPITAL0 19,400 19,400 A 7183 90-33-01-50-210-000 251 NEW CHINA RESTAURANT 6,800 7,500 6,600 -900 6,800 7,500 6,600 -900 A 7123 90-33-01-50-252-000 251 NEW EQUIPMENT LEASING INC 36,200 46,800 35,600 -11,200 36,200 46,800 35,600 -11,200 A 7124 90-33-01-50-355-000 251 NEXTEL WEST CORP 0 0 2,300 2,300 0 0 2,300 2,300 A 7125 . 90-33-01-50-806-000 251 NORTHERN LEASING SYSTEMS INC 32,200 46,900 39,100 77,800 32,200 46,900 39,100 -7,800 A 7197 90-33-01-51-346-000 251 OFFICE OF WORKFORCE 0 2,500 0 -2,500 0 IDFVELOPMFNT2,500 0 -2,500 A 7031 90-33-01-51-735-000 251 OLYMPIA BROIL DRIVE IN REST 1,500 1,700 1,500 -200 1,500 1,700 1,500 -200 A 7126 90-33-01-51-860-000 251 MICHIGAN FOOD GROUP INC 16,500 18,200 6,900 -11,300 16,500 18,200 6,900 - 11,300 A 7127 90-33-01-52-161-000 251 PPG AUTOGLASS LLC 26,200 23,900 23,900 0 26,200 23,900 23,900 p A 7128. 90-33-01-52-544-000 251 PARADISE BEAUTY PARLOR&ART 0 2,500 2,000 -500 0 GALLERY2,500 2,000 -500 A 7198 90-33-01-53-040-000 251 PAULS AIRPORT BAR INC 27,800 30,600 24,000 -6,600 27,800 30,600 24,000 -6,600 A 7032 90-33-01-53-789-000 251 PERSONAL GROWTH UNLIMITED 4,200 4,600 700 -3,900 4,200 4,600 700 -3,900 A 7129 90-33-01-54-750-000 251 PIERCE ENGINEERING 28,000 30,800 0 -30,800 28,000 30,800 p -30,800 A 7130 90-33-01-54-854-000 251 PLAYING PICASSO 0 1,000 0 71,000 0 1,000 p -1,000 A 7033 90-33-01-55-210-000 251 POLLACK GLASS CO 7,000 7,700 6,500 -1,200 7,000 7,700 6,500 -1,200 A 7131 90-33-01-55-742-000 251 PROFESSIONAL FLEET SERVICE 4,200 4,600 4,300 -300 4,200 4,600 4,300 -300 A 7132 90-33-01-55-780-000 251 DIRECT TV INC 4,200 2,800 500 -2,300 4,200 2,800 500 2,300 03/30/2005 11:48:06 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 32 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE BOARD NUMBER NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7133 90-33-01-56-135-000 251 PROPERTY SOLUTIONS 800 900 600 -300 800 900 600 MANAGEMENT GO, -300 A 7209 90-33-01-56-205-000 251 PUBLIC POLICY ASSOCIATES 45,000 49,500 49,100 -400 45,000 49,500 49,100 -400 A 7185 90-33-01-56-403-000 251 PX STORE 6,500 7,200 3,800 -3,400 6,500 7,200 3,800 -3,400 A 7134 90-33-01-56-615-000 251 QUALITY FIRE EQUIPMENT 11,600 12,800 10,400 -2,400 11,600 12,800 10,400 -2,400 A 7135 90-33-01-56-671-000 251 QA GROUP LLC 8,200 6,100 0 76,100 8,200 6,100 p -6,100 A 8158 90-33-01-56-907-000 251 RADISSON INN OF LANSING 509,700 777,800 477,800 0 509,700 477,800 477,800 0 A 7034 90-33-01-57-225-000 251 MICHIGAN AVE PRINTING INC. 70,000 77,000 14,800 -62,200 70,000 77,000 14,800 -62,200 A 7199 90-33-01-57-769-000 251 REID REAL ESTATE&MANAGEMENT 0 1,500 0 -1,500 0 1,500 p -co -1,500 A 7136 90-33-01-57-790-000 251 NETBANK 45,500 47,0 00 44,200 -2,800 45,500 47,000 44,200 -2,800 A 7035 90-33-01-58-105-000 251 BRIAN RICHARDS 0 0 300 300 p 0 300 300 A 8159 90-33-01-58-565-000 251 RITE AID OF MICHIGAN INC 67,400 71,400 71,400 0 67,400 71,400 71,400 0 A 8160 90-33-01-58-566-000 251 RITE AID CORPORATION 94,400 87,700 87,700 0 94,400 87,700 87,700 0 A 8161 90-33-01-58-787-000 251 RITE AID CORPORATION 15,500 15,300 15,300 0 15,500 15,300 15,300 0 A 7137 90-33-01-59-568-000 251 ROSENQUIST CPA- 2,500 2,800 2,500 -300 2,500 - 2,800 2,500 -300 A 7138 90-33-01-60-805-000 251 SAWIS PANERA 722 0 0 1,100 1,100 p 0 1,100 1,100 A 7036 90-33-01-60-813-000 251 SENSORMATIC ELECTRONICS CORP 32,200 35,400 14,400 -21,000 32,200 35,400 14,400 -21,000 A 7037 90-33-01-61-319-000 251 VIASAT, INC. 200 200 0 -200 200 200 - 0 -200 A 7139 90-33-01-61-595-000 251 LINC CREDIT PROPERTY V LLC 0 0. 2,800 2,800 p 0 2,800 2,800 A 7210 90-33-01-62-510-000 251 SHOLTYS BAR 11,500 12,700 9,500 3,200 11,500 12,700 9,500 -3,200 A 7038 90-33-01-62-544-000 251 SHOVA'S KITCHEN 2,800 3,100 2,500 -600 2,800 3,100 2,500 -600 A 7039 90-33-01-63-992-000 251 SOCCER ZONE 8,500 9,400 4,900 -4,500 8,500 9,400 4,900 -4,500 A 7140 90-33-01-64-070-000 251 GUARDIAN ALARM CO OF MICH INC 300 300 600 300 300 300 600 300 A 7141 90-33-01-64-088-000 251 SOPHISICATED STYLES 3,000 3,300 1,500 7,800 3,000 3,300 1,500 -1,800 A 7200 90-33-01-64-100-000 251 SOUND EFX PRODUCTION 45,000 49,500 0 -49,500 45,000 49,500 p -49,500 A 7201 90-33-01-64-373-000 251 SOUTH TOWN RESTAURANT 25,000 27,500 5,000 -22,500 25,000 27,500 5,000 -22,500 A 7040 90-33-01-64-484-000 251 SPARTAN AUTO INSURANCE 900 1,000 700 -300 900 1,000 700 -300 03/30/2005 11:48:06 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW Page 33 of 35 PARCEL NUMBER ORDER APPEAL PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S BOARD NUMBER MARCH BOR ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE NUMBER NAME ASSMT ASSMT ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 7142 90-33-01-64-501-000 551 SPARTAN IRRIGATION INC 34,300 37,700 29,600 -8,100 34,300 37,700 29,600 -8,100 A 7041 90-33-01-64-505-000 251 SPARTAN INSURANCE AGENCY 1,100 1,200 900 -300 1,100 1,200 900 -300 A 7143 90-33-01-64-762-000 251 SPARTAN OIL CORP-BAY 8,800 9,700 10,000 300 8,800 9,700 10,000 300 A 7144 90-33-01-64-781-000 251 SPARTAN SERVICES INC 12,400 13,600 11,600 -2,000 12,400 13,600 11,600 -2,000 A 7145 90-33-01-64-785- 000 251 SPARTAN STORES INC 1,800 2,000 1,600 -400 1,800 2,000 1,600 - 00 A 7146 90-33-01-65-700-000 251 STEAK N'SHAKE, INC 70,800 31,900 68,100 36,200 70,800 31,900 68,100 36,200 A 7147 90-33-01-65-840-000 551 STEVES PRODUCE 8,500 9,400 1,900 -7,500 8,500 9,400 1,900 -7,500 A 7148 90-33-01-66-435-000 251 SUMMIT FUNDING GROUP INC 1,700 1,900 1,500 -400 1,700 1,900 1,500 -400 A 7202 90-33-01-66-552-000 251 SUPERWHEELERAUT-SALES 1,000 1,100 400 -700 1,000 1,100 400 700 A 7149 90-33-01-66-569-000 251 SYMBOLEASE 10,400 8,000 1,800 -6,200 10,400 8,000 1,800 -6,200 A 8162 90-33-01-66-652- 000 251 RITE AID CORPORATION 81,600 72,500 72,500 0 81;600 72,500 72,500 p A 7150 90-33-01-66-913-000 251 PINES HEALTH CARE CENTER 55,000 60,500 58,000 2,500 55,000 60,500 58,000 -2,500 A 7151 90-33-01-67-545-000 251 TECHNOLOGY INVESTMENT 0 0 10PARNTFR�Ill ,900 10,900 _ p 0 10,900 10,900 A. 7187 90-3:3-01-u7-594-000 251 TERMINAL COURT LLC 0 1,300 0 -1,300 0 1,300 0 -1,300 P, 7152 90-33-01-67-696-000 251 TEXAS ROAD HOUSE 143,900 551,100 128,500 -22,600 143,900 151,100 128,500 22,600 A 7153 90-33-01-67-701-000 251 TEXTRON FINANCIAL CORPORATION 10,100 11,100 0 11,100 10,100 11,100 0 11,100 A 7203 90-33-01-67-770- 000 251 THAI BINH MARKET 6,400 7,000 7,000 p 6,400 7,000 7,000 p A 7042 90-33-01-67-821- 000 251 THE SOCCER LOCKER 16,400 18,000 24,200 6,200 16,400 18,000 24,200 6,200 A 7154 90-33-01-68-207-000 251 TODAY'S MOBILE OFFICE-LANSING 900 1,000 p -1,000 900 1,000 0 -1,000 A 7155 90-33-01-68-792-000 251 TRANSACTION NETWORK SERVICES 90,9 00 100,000 311,000 211,000 90,900 100,000 311,000 211,000 A 7156 90-33-01-68-793-000 251 TRANSACTION NETWORK SERVICES, 3,400 3,700 1,700 -2,000 3,400 3,700 1,700 -2,000 A 7157 90-33-01-69-069-000 251 TRI-STATE INVESTIGATIVE SECURITY 12,500 13,800 3,000 -10,800 12,500 13,800 3,000 10,800 A 7043 90-33-01-69-590-000 251 ZIEBART TIDY CAR 12,000 8,800 7,200 1,600 12,000 8,800 7,200 -1,600 A 7188 90-33-01-69-750-000 251 UNION BUILDING CORPORATION 1,700 1,500 1,500 p 1,700 1,500 1,500 p A 8163 90-33-01-69-982-000 251 UNION BUILDING CORP 29,400 25,700 25,700 0 29,400 25,700 25,700 p A 7189 90-33-01-70-065-000 251 COINMACH CORPORTATION 15,000 16,500 60,300 43,800 15,000 16,500 60,300 43,800 03/36/2005 11:48:06 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW APPEAL PARCEL NUMBER ORDER Page 34 of 35 NUMBER BOARD PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR N R En 'S MARCH BOR ASSMT ASSMT UMBE A 7044 90-33-01-70-310-000 251 UNITED WHOLESALGROCERY CO ASSMT ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR TAXABLE DIFFERENCE 18,600 20,500 13,600 TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE 6 A 7045 90-33-01-71-626-000 251 WLAJ CHANNEL 53 - ,900 18,600 20,500 753,300 791,000 13,600 A 7204 90-33-01-71-638-000 251 WNEL 12 769,300 -6,900 JRT CHAN -21,700 ,300 791,000 769,300 -21,700 A 7158 90-33-01-71-655-000 251 WABASHA LEASING LLC 1,700 1,700 0 753 -1,700 1,700 1,700 A 7190 90-33-01-71-925-000 251 WALKER-DALLAS CHIROPRACTIC 0 0 10,500 10,500 0 0 -1,700 45,000 0 10 500 10,500 A 7211 90-33-01-73-010-000 251 VIC IZZO'S PUB 49,500 5,600 -43,900 , 1,600 1,800 -43,900 A 7046 90-33-01-73-080-000 251 WESTERN FINANCE&LEASE INC 1,500 -300 4 1,600 5,000 49,500 5,600 14,100 1,800 1,500 A 7047 90-33-01-74 493-000 251 WING ZONE 15,500 12,400 -3,100 14,100 15,500 12,400 -300 A 7159 90-33-01-74-955-000 251 WOOD TLELVISION INC 0 30,500 29,000 -3,100 -1,500 0 30,500 29,000 0 -1,500 A 7048 90-33-01-75-543-000 251 YURPLE&JOJO'S FUN TIME PALACE 0 4,500 4,500 0 0 4,500 25,100 27,600 20,700 4,500 A 7049 90-33-01-75-551-000 251 QUE HUONG CAFE -6,900 25,100 27,600 28,000 30,800 20,700 A 8164 90-33-01-76-029-000 251 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 3,300 -27,500 28,000 -6,900 36,300 ,800 3,300 -27,500 A 7050 90-33-01-76-088-000 251 LOS GRINGOS 36,300 36,300 300 36,300 36,300 36,300 A 7191 90-33-01-76-315-000 251 B&J MOVING&STORAGE INC 3,200 3,500 2,800 0 -700 3,200 3,500 28,200 31,000 2,800 -700 A 8165 90-33-01-76-370-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY _ 26,100 -4,900 28,200 145,400 31,000 26,100 -4,900 A 7160 90-33-01-77-052-000 251 COMMUNITY NEWSCENTER 147,200 147,200 0 145,400 147,200 147,200 A 8166 90-33-01-77-053-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 6,000 6,600 10,900 0 4,300 6,000 6,600 73,000 71,700 10,900 4,300 A 8167 90-33-01-77-104-000 251 FASHION BUG OF LENSING#165 71,700 0 73,000 90,900 71,700 - 71,700 0 A 7051 90-33-01=77-160-000 251 GMRI, INC 83,500 83,500 0 90,900 83,500 83,500 A 7205 90-33-01-77-180-000 251 HOBBY HUB INC THE 107,700 113,100 111.500 0 -1,600 107,700 113,100 25,000 111,500 A 8168 90-33-01-77-230-000 251 LANSING HOTEL ASSOC 27,500 8,000 -19,500 112,600 101,300 101,300 25,000 27,500 8,000 -1,600 A 7052 90-33-01-77-340-000 251 ONE DAY DENTAL SERVICE 0 112,600 23,200 101,300 101,300 -19,500 0 A 7053 90-33-01-77-440-000 251 THOMPSONS JEWELERS 25,500 20,900 -4,600 23,200 25,500 20,900 A 7054 90-33-01-77-499-000 251 ZOGLIO DAVID ATTY 2,300 2,500 2,600 1,000 800 100 2,300 -4,600 900 2,500 2,600 100 A 8169 90-33-01-78-01 ENER 12 0-000 551 CONSUMERS GY COMPANY -200 900 1,000 800 A 8170 90-33-01-78-020-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY 0,300 118,600 118,600 -200 0 120,300 118,600 3,100 3,100 118,600 0 3,100 0 3,100 3,100 3,100 0 03/30/2005 11:48:07 AM 2005 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW APPEAL PARCEL NUMBER ORDER Page 35 of 35 NUMBER PARCEL CLASS OWNER'S PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR BOARD NUMBER ASSMT PRIOR YEAR ASSESSOR'S MARCH BOR A 7161 90-33-01-78-024-000 551 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY ASSMT ASSMT TAXABLE ASSMT DIFFERENCE TAXABLE TAXABLE TAXABLE DIFFERENCE A 6185 91-33-01-09-258-016 930 JOSEPH IFIELD P 3,300 3,600 0 -3,600 3,300 3,600(NEZ) 81,000 0 -3,600 A 7055 95-33-01-80-085-000 981 AUTO AIR COMPOSITES INC 95,500 81,600 -13,900 64,896 66,388 66,388 191,100 173,000 163,900 0 A 7056 95-33-01-80-286-000 981 GENERAL MOTORS CORP IFT 96-666 -9,100 191,100 173,000 ( ) 11,200,400 163,900 -9,100 888 PARCELS 7,775,600 8,698,600 923,000 11,200,400 7,775,600 8,698,600 923,000 219,547,700 237,110,600 224,880,250 12,230,350 194,208,592 214,566,805 206,358,659 -8,208,146 C��KC�� File: br\05MINORG LANSING BOARD OF REVIEW MARCH 8, 2005 - ORGANIZATIONAL MEETING MINUTES BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS ATTENDING ASSESSORS STAFF Eddie Thomas, Present David Tijerina, Assessor Curtis G. McKinnon Jr. ML Andrews, Assessing Sup. Sonya Moore, Present Diane Lee, PrincipalAppr. Mike Payne, Principal Appr -------------------------------------------------------- MINUTE Eddie Thomas called the meeting to order at 10 : 10 a.m. David Tijerina, City Assessor welcomed board members and reviewed meeting dates . Election of Officers Chairperson Sonya Moore nominated Eddie Thomas for the position of Chairperson. Curtis McKinnon, Jr. supported the nomination. CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Vice-Chairperson Eddie Thomas nominated Curtis McKinnon, Jr. for the position of Vice-Chairperson. Sonya Moore supported the motion. CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Status of the Assessment Roll Diane. Lee reviewed the status of the Commercial Assessment Roll (see attachment 1) . Mike Payne reviewed the status of the Residential Assessment Roll (see attachment #2) . Mary Lou Andrews distributed proposed amended by-laws (attachment #3, to the board members . The Board members will review the proposed changes and vote on the by-laws at their next meeting, March 14, 2005 . Board members also received a copy of the 2005 poverty guidelines (attachment #4) . Mary Lou Andrews also reviewed hearing procedures . Procedures are the same except the evening meeting which will be held Tuesday, March 15th from 6-9 pm. David Tijerina reviewed the 2002-2003 Assessors Work program, Eddie Thomas adjourned the meeting at 11 : 45 . C le'r k5 oo 4File: br\05agenda LANSING BOARD OF REVIEW MARCH 8 , 2005 - ORGANIZATIONAL MEETING Roll Call/Excused absence BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS ATTENDING ASSESSORS STAFF Eddie Thomas David Tijerina, Assessor Curtis McKinnon ML Andrews, Assessing Supervisor Sonya Moore Diane Lee, Prin. Com. Appraiser Michael Payne Prin. Res . Appraiser ---------------------------------------------------------------- AGENDA 1 . Public Comment on Agenda Items, three (3) minutes per speaker 2 . Introductory Comments (David) 3 . Election of Officers (Chairperson & Vice-Chairperson) 4 . Status of 2005 Roll (Diane - Commercial) Status of 2005 Roll (Mike -Residential) S . Board of Review By Laws - Copy enclosed (Mary Lou) 6. Hearing Procedures: (Mary Lou) a. Conflict of Interest : relative, financial/business, close neighbor. b. Poverty Exemptions 1) Follow Procedures Adopted in 1995 for Hardship C. Current Letter of Authorization - (tax agents) required for all appeals (commercial & residential hearings, letter and factor appeals) . d. Time allotment for appeals . e. Hours 8 : 30 a.m. - 4 : 30 p.m. Tuesday 3/15 1 : 30-4 : 30 & 6-9 pm 7 . Items for Discussion and Comment : a. Parking arrangements have been made in N. Grand Ramp 8 . Review 2004-2005 Assessors Work Program etc. (David) a. Staffing b. Real Property C. Personal Property 9. Procedure for Board Adjustments, by motion. (Mary Lou) a. Review Changes proposed by appraisers . 10 . Public Comment on Non-Agenda Items, three (3) minutes per speaker. 12 . Adjournment. Legal References Michigan Compiled Laws 211.28 though 211.33 City of Lansing Charter, Article 7, chapter 2,Section 7-204 & 205 Codified Ordinances - Part two - Administrative Code, Title Eight, Chapter 257 2005 file: BR\2005mail BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS BOARD MEMBERS , TERM EXPIRES Eddie L. Thomas 6/30/06 1520 W. Ionia Street Lansing, MI 48915 Home Phone: 484-8738 Work Phone: 484-8738 Curtis G. McKinnon, Jr. 6/30/07 3517 Lucie Lansing, MI 48911 Phone: 393-2914 Home: 285-7038 Cell: 285-7038 Sonya R. Moore 6/30/05 3971 #3 Hunters Ridge . Lansing, MI 48911 Home: 393-6465 work: 410-4257 Meeting Dates Organizational Meeting - March 8, 2005 Board Hearings - March 14 through 18 8 : 30 a.m. - 4 : 30 p.m. , except for Tuesday, March 15t`' 1 : 30 -4 : 30 p.m. & 6: 00 - 9: 00 p.m. July Board Meeting - July 19, 2005 - 10 : 00 a.m. December Board Meeting - December 13, 2005 - 10 : 00 a.m. U6/U Ilzuuo 4UVaR.U111C1Uj. 1 - -Actual figures from L4021 as of 03/04/2005 INGHAM COUNTY EATON COUNTY CLASS COMMERCIAL RATIO FOR 2005 ASSESSMENTS 0.4815 0.4865 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 50% 1.0384 1.0277 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 49% 1.0177 1.0072 MINIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED 14,674,125 106,766 MAXIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED 31,720,154 411,774 PARCEL COUNT w/o exempts 2,772 22 2004 ASSESSMENT 840,874,200 14,839,100 LOSS ASSESSMENT 15,292,900 0 ADJUSTMENT ASSESSMENT 28,330,700 322,000 NEW ASSESSMENT 321056,300 0 2005 ASSESSMENT 885,968,300 15,161,100 CLASS INDUSTRIAL RATIO FOR 2005 ASSESSMENTS 0.4972 0.4942 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 50% 1.0056 1.0117 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 49% 0.9855 0.9915 MINIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED (1,026,776) (95,430) MAXIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED 399,302 131,784 PARCEL COUNT w/o exempts 276 4 2004 ASSESSMENT 74,570,400 11,310,100 LOSS ASSESSMENT 3,665,800 81,200 ADJUSTMENT ASSESSMENT (320,400) . 0. NEW ASSESSMENT 1,891,200 2,557,400 - 2005 ASSESSMENT 72,475,400 13,786,300 _ CLASS RESIDENTIAL F. -I RATIO FOR 2005 ASSESSMENTS 0.4599 0.4007 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 50% 1.0872 1.0853 FACTOR FOR 2005 AT 49% 1.0654 1.0636 MINIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED 99,494,805 2,334;403 MAXIMUM ADJUSTMENT NEEDED 132,649,557 3,131,927 PARCEL COUNT w/o exempts 37,058 814 2004 ASSESSMENT 1,526,520,967 36,78$,100 LOSS ASSESSMENT 6,332,900 _ 781000 ADJUSTMENT ASSESSMENT 120,610,833 2E,8721800 NEW ASSESSMENT 16,669,500 265.100 2005 ASSESSMENT 1,657,468,400 39,843,000 2005total.123 03/07/2005 COMMERICAL&INDUSTRIAL 2005 ASSESSMENT CHANGES-REAL PROPERTY PRIOR TO BOARD OF REVIEW PARCEL 2004 2005 ASSM'T %CHG %OF 2005 COUNT S.E.V. ASSM'T %CHG. LOSS NEW ADJ. ADJ.ONLY WAS NEW Apartments 312 A200-A280 272 139,652,700 139,883,500 0.17% 1,909,800 148,400 1,992,200 1.45% 0.11 Exempt 40 1,028,555 Average True Cash Value Miscellanous 1,100 M200-M280 696 84,080,200 95,518,000 13.60% 860,400 5,451,500 6.846,700 8.23% 5.71% Exempt 404 274,477 Average True Cash Value Retail 758 R200-R280 741 187,078,200 195,016,900 4.24% 2,584,100 2,943,000 7,579,800 4.11% 1.51% Exempt 17 526,361 Average True Cash Value Office 721 0200-0280 586 324,771,700 346.052,200 6.55% 3,083,900 16,598,300 7,766,100 2.41% 4.80% Exempt 135 1,181,066 Average True Cash Value Warehouse 548 W200-W280 504 119,409,100 126,603,600 6.03% 4,685,500 7,059,700 4,820,300 4.20% 5.58% Exempt 44 502,395 Average True Cash Value Industrial 412 1300-1315 293 176,601,600 181,794,300 2.94% 3,742,400 9,059,600 (124,500) -0.07% 4.98% Exempt 119 1,240,917 Average True Cash Value TOTAL 3,092 1 031 593 500 1 089 622 271 5.63% 16 866 100 41 260 500 28,880,600 2.85% 3,79% ASSESSED Total Exempts 759 TOTAL PARCELS 3,851 COMMERICAL&INDUSTRIAL 2005 TAXABLE CHANGES-REAL PROPERTY PRIOR TO BOARD OF REVIEW PARCEL 2004 2005 TAXABLE TAXABLE %CHG • %OF 2005 COUNT TAXABLE TAXABLE %CHG. LOSSES ADDITION ADJ. ADJ./UNCAP WAS NEW Apartments A200-A280 272 119,942,573 120,951,299 0.84% 1,693,162 148,400 2,763,488 2.33% 0.12% 444,674 Average Taxable Value Miscellanous M200-M280 696 65,234,486 71,913,234 10.24% 88,588 4,539,200 2,684,570 4.12% 6.31% 103,324 Average Taxable Value Retail R200-R280 741 148,802,430 153,100,127 2.89% 387,847 1,675,900 4;048,005 2.73% 1.09% 206,613 Average Taxable Value Office 0200-0280 586 280,669,219 299,955,821 6.87% 2,048,330 15,344,200 6,545,,455 2.35°70 : 5.12% 511,870 Average Taxable Value _ Warehouse W200-W280 504 89,103,020 94,408,535 5.95% 643,510 3,002,100 857 6.13% 3.18% 187,319 Average Taxable Value Industrial-North 1300 293 173,838,707 179,037,585 2.99% 2,511,407 4,875,900 1,284,$55 0.715% 2.72% 611,050 Average Taxable Value TOTALS 3,092 877 590 435 921 0%431 450 5.0 7 572 844 29 585 700 22,739,230 2.61% 3.21 TAXABLE comecf2005.123 o3/u r/Zuu5 E.C.F. LISTING COMMERICAL PROPERTY NBH 2O02 2003 2004 2005 NBH 2O02 2003 2004 2005 NBH 2O02 2003 2004 2005 A200 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R200 1.16 1.20 1.25 1.36 W200 1.20 1.30 1.36 1.47 A205 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R205 1.14 1.20 1.25 1.36 W205 1.20 1.30 1.36 1.47 A210 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R210 1.40 1.45 1.50 1.63 W210 1.20 1.12 1.31 1.28 A215 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R215 1.40 1.45 1.50 1.63 W215 1.06 1.12 1.17 1.28 A220 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R220 1.30 1.45 1.50 1.63 W220 1.22 1.30 1.36 1.47 A225 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R225 1.25 1.45 1.50 1.63 W225 1.22 1.30 1.36 1.47 A230 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R230 1.16 1.25 1.33 1.44 W230 1.22 1.28 1.33 1.44 A235 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R235 1.22 1.30 1.39 1.51 W235 1.34 1.38 1.44 1.56 A240 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 W240 1.34 1.38 1.43 1.56 A245 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R245 1.10 1.20 1.27 1.38 W245 1.34 1.42 1.45 1.56 A250 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R250 1.30 1.40 1.47 1.60 W250 1.34 1.45 1.49 1.61 A255 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R255 1.08 1.16 1.23 1.33 W255 1.22 1.30 1.36 1.46 A260 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R260 1.33 1.40 1.47 1.60 W260 1.14 1.22 1.27 1.37 A265 1.04 1.10 1.10 1.10 R265 1.39 1.47 1.54 1.67 W265 1.14 1.22 1.27 1.37 A270 1.00 1.10 1.10 1.10 R270 1.03 1.05 1.10 1.15 W270 1.03 1.05 1.10 1.18 NBH 2O02 2003 2004 2005 NBH 2O02 2003 2004 2005 NBH 2O02 : 2003 2004 2005. 0200 1.02 1.03 1.10 1.13 M200 1.05 1.08 1.14 1.17 1300 1.02 1.05 1.04 1.09 0205 1.02 1.03 1.10 1.13 M205 1.05 1.08 1.14 1.17 1305 1.01 1.06 1.04 1.06 0210 1.02 1.04 1.10 1.13 M210 1.05 1.08 1.14 1.17 1310 1.05 1.10 1.07 1.05 0215 1,14 1.16 .- 1.17 1.22 M215 1.30 1.32 1.40 1.44 1315 1.00 1.02 1.03 1:04 0220 1'.31 1.32 1.28 1.33 M220 1.30 1.32 1.40 1.44 0225 1.31 1.32 1.28 1.31 M225 1.30 1.35 1.40 1.44 0230 1.23 1.25 1.25 1.28 M230 1.30 1.35 1.36 1.40 0235 1.12 1.14 1.18 1.21 M235 1.30 1.35 1.40 1.44 0240 1.12 1.14 1.18 1.21 M240 1.20 1.25 1.32 1.35 0245 1.12 1.14 1.18 1.21 M245 1.20 1.25 1.32 1.35 0250 1.12 1.14 1.18 1.21 M250 1.20 1.25 1.32 1.35 0255 1.12 1.14 1.20 1.23 M255 1.22 1.28 1.34 1.37 0260 1.08 1.10 1.14 1.17 M260 1.22 1.25 1.32 1.37 0265 1.08 1.10 1.14 1.17 M265 1.22 1.25 1.32 1.37 0270 1.03 1.08 1.10 1.13 M270 1.03 1.08 1.12 1.15 0275 1.03 1.03 1.06 1.09 M275 1.02 1.02 1.08 1.11 0280 1.03 1.03 1.06 1.09 M280 1.02 1.02 1.08 1.11 For 2005 land values were also adjusted in many neighborhoods ' ' ).3/07/2005 2005 BOARD OF REVIEW APPOINTMENTS APPRAISERS PERSONAL BOARD MET OR PROPERTY OF REVIEW APPOINTMENTS MADE HANDLED LATE FILES #of pdrcels appealed BD ADJ. 3/14 - MONDAY 9 2/28 0 0 37 23 3/15 - TUESDAY 1 3/1 1 1 83 33 3/16 - WEDNESDAY ' 1 312 2 2 99 21 3117 - THURSDAY 0 3/3 5 5 3/18 - FRIDAY 1 3/4 4 4 WEEK ONE TOTAL 12 3/21 - MONDAY 0 3/7 0 0 0 0 3/22 - TUESDAY 0 3/8 0 0 0 0 0 3/9 0 0 0 0 0 3/10 0 0 0 0 0 3/11 0 0 0 0 WEEK TWO 0 0 3/14 0 0 0 0 0 3/15 0 0 0 0 0 3/16 0 0 0 0 3/17 0 0 0 0 3/18 0 0 0 0 BD OF REVIEW 12 HEARING TOTAL BOTH BOARDS 12 0 0 0 BD ADJ. (APPRAISERS DECISIONS) 143 0 0 0 LETTER APPEALS (APPRAISERS) 0 0 0 - .0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL ACTEQ. PON (Inc. bd adj.) 165 t•'' APPT TOTAL 12 219 77 GRAND TOTAL 165 BD ADJ 143 BOTH BOARDS&APPRAISERS LETTER APPEALS 0 TRANSFERS 0 TOTAL 155 APPRAISERS HAVE ACTED ON 143 APPEALS BESIDES THOSE APPEARING BEFORE BOARD AND HAVE TALKED WITH ANOTHER 208 TAXPAYERS CONCERNING ASSESSMENT NOTICE TOTAL APPRAISERS WORK 351 2005 AVERAGE PERCENT CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PROPERTY RESIDENTIAL AVERAGE PERCENT NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGE 4.00% 11A - ------ 4.00% 11B 4.00% 11C 5.00% 11D 4.00% 11E 4.00% 11F ---- 4.00% 11G 4.00% 11H --- ---- 4.00% 111 - -- - --- - -- 4.00% 12A 4.00% 12B 4.00% 12C 6.00% 12D 4.00% 12E 12F BARDAVILLE CONDOS 4.00% 15.00% 13A -- ---- 15.00% 13B ---- 16.00% 13C 13D MARQUETTE ST CONDOS 15.00% 4.00% 14A 6.00% 14B 4.00% 14C 4.00% 14D - ------ 8.00% 15A 4.00% 15B --- ------ 4.00% 15C -- 4.00% 16A - 6.00% 16B 4.00% 16C 16D ON THE GRAND CONDOS 4.00% 21A-- 4.00% 10.00% 21B -- 4.00% 21C --- ----- 10.00% 21D - ---- -- 4.00% 21E 21 F 10.00% 5.00% 22A - 9.00% 22B 8.00% 22C ---- - 15.00% 22D __.. .._.._....-- -------- 8.00% 23 21.00% 24 --- -- 17.00% 25 4.00% 25A OLD COVENANT CONDOS 2005 AVERAGE PERCENT CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PROPERTY RESIDENTIAL AVERAGE PERCENT NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGE 10.00% 26 --- - 25.00% 27 x, , --- --- - 25.00% 28 13.00% 28A -- ------ 25.00% 29 31A -- ------- 4.00% 31B -- 10.00% 31C -------- 25.00% 31D 7.00% 31E 31 F PERE MARQUETTE PLACE CONDOS 10.00% 25.00% 32A- ----- - 12.00% 328 ------ 12.00% 32C 12.00% 32D 12.00% 32E 4.00% 33A -- -- 4.00% 33B _.- - ----- 4.00% 33C --.... --- 4.00% 33D -�- -- 4.00% 33E - 4.00% 33F 4.00% 33G 4.00% 34A 4.00% 34B ----- - 0.00% 34C ----------- 25.00% 35A ------ 11.00% 35B 10.00% 36A 9.00% 36B 9.00% 36C 9.00% 37A 4.00% 37 B ----- 8.00% 38A 8.00% 38B _.. - -- --- 8.00% 38C - -- 8.00% 38D - 8.00% 38E 8.00% 38F 14.00% 39A 13.00% 39B ------- 14.00% 41A -- -- - 7.00% 41B ----- - 4.00% 42A 2005 AVERAGE PERCENT CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PROPERTY RESIDENTIAL AVERAGE PERCENT NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGE 4.00% 42B 42C :r '. 6.00% 11.00% 42D - ---- 6.00% 42E 42F WELLINGTON ARMS CONDOS 4.00% 42G CHATEAU LOUISE CONDOS 4.00% ----- 4.00% 43A 43B 4.00% 43 C 4.00% 43D 4.00% 43E 4.00% 44A 4.00% 44B ------- 4.00% -- --'-- 4.00% 44C 44D RIVER PARK ESTATES CONDOS 4.00% 44E RIVER PARK ESTATES CONDOS 4.00% 44F RIVER PARK ESTATES CONDOS 4.00% 4GD RIVER PARK ESTATES CONDOS 4.00% 45A 6.00% 45B 4.00% 45C 4.00% 45D ----- -- 4.00% 45E MOORES RIVER ESTATE CONDOS 4.00% 46A...---- -- -- 15.00% 46B 4.00% 46C 14.00% 46D 4.00% 46E 9.00% 46F ---. --- 5.00% 47A 14.00% - ._.. --- ---- -47 B 15.00% 47C... ----------- 16.00% 47D 14.00% 47E 4.00% 47F 15.00% 47G--- ---- 4.00% 47H._...------ - - 8.00% --- -----...--- 4.00% 471 ----._..-..--.....- 8.00% 47J 47K APPLE JACK CONDOS 4.00% 51 10.00% 10.00% 51A 10.00% 52A 52B 15.00% 2005 AVERAGE PERCENT CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PROPERTY RESIDENTIAL AVERAGE PERCENT NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGE 12.00% 52C 4.00% 52D -;*--.52E 4.00% 1 4.00% 53B 11.00% 53C 11.00% 53D -- - --- ---- 4.00% ---53E 11.00% 54A -- -- 6.00% 54B 54C---- 9.00% 54D 4.00% 54E 4.00% 54F 4.00% 54G --- - 25.00% 55A - ---------- 4.00% 55B_._......_-...-------- 13.00% 55C-- ---- 4.00% 55D 4.00% 55E 4.00% 55F TWIN OAKS CONDOS 4.00% 56A 4.00% 56B--- 6.00% 56C SOUTHLAND CONDOS 4.00% 56D JOLLY PROF CTR CONDOS 4.00% 57A --- 4.00% 57B - --- 12.00% 57C 5.00% 61 A 21.00% 61 B 4.00% 61C HAMILTON CONDOS 4.00% 62 ARBORS CONDOS 4.00% 62A-- 4.00% 628 -- 6.00% 62C'----------- 4.00% 62D---- 8.00% 62E 10.00% 62F 4.00% 62G 4.00% 62H OAKBROOK CONDOS 4.00% 621 TAMMANY HILLS CONDOS 4.00% 62J MANHATTAN CONDOS 4.00% 71A 71 B ------ -- 4.00% 2005 AVERAGE PERCENT CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PROPERTY RESIDENTIAL AVERAGE PERCENT NEIGHBORHOOD CHANGE 10.00% 71C 71D fit* 4.00% 71E _ ._-- ---- 4.00% 71F -- - - -- - - 4.00% 72A - - - ----=- 4.00% 72B - ------------- 4.00% 72C - 12.00% 72D - 11.00% 72E ---- 4.00% 72F 72G -------- 12.00% 72H -- --- 4.00% 721 ----- 15.00% 73A 15.00°/. 73B 4.00% 73C 4.00% 73D 73E FAIRFIELD CONDOS 4.00% 73F EDEN GLEN CONDOS 4.00% 73G GREENTREE CONDOS 10.00°/. -- - --- 4.00% 74A ---- 4.00% 74B- 4.00% 75A 5.00% 75B -- 7.00% 75C ------ -------- 4.00% 75D - - ------ 6.00% 75E 75F BRENTWOOD CONDOS 4.00% 84A HUNTERS RIDGE CONDOS 3.00% 11.00% 848 9.00% 84C 3.00% 84D 12.00% 85A -- - ---- 3.00% 85B ---- 3.00% 85C - -..._....-..._ -- 4.00% 91 MERIDIAN TWP 92 ALAIENDON TWP 1' ■ . 1r � K Grlf��. i �� 1 are t■In kL-. M� .' . ••' . �.■■®ram: �� ®Tr- on ter■ �'Vi■Nowt a?ie■® mill MA_N �1 um a;�C _ 1 _ �•'�" ` ll��i��lirrrr�■wI��1�1®i11 Elam �� 1 . �■s�■� Mww < �■.rr■ 11®P��,,. � M � �� ■row '"��; rr -- - - ■ of ,1. aka t G a $i 'A F 1, City Of Lansing rix}a 2005 March e � Board o 11 Residential q^f+ Land Changes Major changes in land values in the following neighborhoods s�xs1 • 'y'f 9Y4� '� . ' I changesLand Value neighborhood influences and traffic and should not require other adjustments. 11 Residential Increases Large :. Neighborhoods21 % or Y Neighborhoods Y�f 1 ri.s Y �^� i �+c %LA i Y.!tyP 1 O +.µam: r ��.• TF� � 11 � Residential K Boys Training S Condominiums 3/4/2005 5 q Residential Y ,3 New Homes ♦ In 2002 there were - 69 new home permits with only 2 listed.. as modular dwellings. ♦ In 2003 there were 57new :home permits with 13 listed as manufactured dwelling. ♦ In 2004 there were 38 new home permits with 7 listed as -manufactured dwelling. 3/8/2005 6 � ,f Re 1 entia b j.a/Yrt 1 J+l7 `,•. ��JR New Homes Al ♦ 2002 there were 69 new homepermits In with only 2 listed as modular dwellings. ♦ In 2003 there were 57 new home permits with 13 listed as manufactured dwelling. ♦ In 2004 there were 3Z new home permits with -2 listed as manufactured dwelling. t _ 7 3/4/2005 6 m Residential Long Term Assessment Goal s I Adjusting land values to market. 2 ECF-Based on Newer House instead of older houses . J 0 3 Market Derived Depreciation tY 4 Reappraisal 11 let Approved 3/14/2005 CITY OF LANSING BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW I. MEETINGS Pursuant to Public Act 257 of 1976, all meetings shall be open to the public and the public shall have a reasonable opportunity to be heard. Organization Meeting First meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held the Tuesday following the first Monday in March each year. Time of the meeting as determined by the Secretary will be held in the office of the City Assessor, 3`d Floor, City Hall, or at a designated meeting place held in the City, and indicated to and approved by each Board of Review member by written communication. Regular Meeting Second meeting of the City of Lansing Board of Review shall be held beginning the second Monday of March in the board room, 3`d Floor, City Hall, and continuing until the completion of business on that day. Regular meetings shall continue on a daily basis for at least five calendar days. No owner/taxpayer initiated appointment shall be made to meet with the Lansing Board of Review unless the resident or nonresident taxpayer has contacted the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall, on or before 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review, or a nonresident taxpayer has submitted a written request by mail which is received no later than 4:00 p.m. of the Friday immediately following the second Monday in March in regards to scheduling an appointment with the Board of Review. Special Meetiag Special meeting may be called by the Chairperson or Secretary for the 3`d Monday in March and subsequent days until the conclusion of all necessary and proper business. Assessor staff recommended changes submitted after the Assessor's assessment roll is certified (1"Monday of March), due to required assessment corrections,will be reviewed, considered, and acted upon by the Board of Review. Board of Review assessment change notices will be sent to each owner/taxpayer of such property, and aw#Oointment shall be made available to meet with the Board of Review during the regular meeting if possible. 1 ` July Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the third Monday in July, the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall. December Meeting According to Michigan Compiled Law, Sec 53B, Tuesday following the 2"Monday in December, the Secretary may call a meeting at 10:00 a.m. in the Assessor's Office, 3`d Floor, City Hall. Notice of Meetings In accordance with the requirements of Public Act 267 of 1976, the Secretary shall post a notice of all meetings in the office of the City Assessor,the City Clerk's Office,the City Council reception area, and on the bulletin board in the lobby of City Hall. All public notices required shall contain the name of the Board, and the address, and telephone number of the Assessor's Office. In addition to the posted notices, an ad noting time, place and days of the regular meeting of the Board shall appear in a newspaper of general circulation for three successive issues at least one week prior to the meeting. Committees MEMBERSHIP In accordance with Ordinance 858 which increased the membership of the Board of Review to six (6) public members the Board has been increased to six members. In accordance with Sec 211.28 (2)MCL,the Board shall divide into committees consisti_g of three members each for the purpose of hearing and deciding issues protested. Committee A - 3 Members quorum is two members Committee B - 3 Members quorum is two members Committee Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson are allowed to make motions and support motions. uorum All business transacted by the Board shall be conducted only at a meeting at which a quorum is present. A quorum shall consist of at least our two.members of the Board. and two members of the committee. Any items, or business coming before the Board shall be approved 6*by the affirmative vote of a least a quorum of the members of the Board. Whenever a quorum of our two 2 peci of the Board, or if two of the Committee members is not present atSec regular s all al meeting,the day's hearings or business shall be rescheduled by the azY, appellants notified. Disqualification Any member of the Board of Review having a direct, or financially or otherwises due todirect financial interet in matter before the Board; who may stand to gam or lose, action of the Board on any matter; or who shall be related by blood or marriage to a person having a proprietary interest in any matter before the Board shall indicate such interest or relationship to the Board and shall be disqualified from voting on such a matter. Attu Board members shall regularly attend all Board meetinIgthe event a Board member is meetings absent, (un-excused absence,only) from three regular gh without ial reason;the Board may,by a vote of at least our two members,recommend to the Mayor and the City Council that the subject Board member be removed from office. Excused Absences An excused absence shall be for a substantial reason. �member Chairperson or the Secroard of etary of eview shall request an excused absence by contacting either the Board prior to the meeting in question. Approval of a request for an excused absence shall be determined by the Board of Review. All other absences shall be considered as un- excused absences. H. ORDER OF BUSINESS Agenda The Secretary shall prepare a schedule of hearings or order of business for each meeting. The order of business shall be as follows: 1. Roll Call. 2. Excused Absence. 3. Assessments appeal hearings per schedule. 4. Committee of the Whole as time permits. w 5. All business other than hearings. 3 6. Adjournment. Individuals, other than scheduled appellants, desiring to speak may be heard at the discretion of the Chairperson. They will be limited to three minutes unless limitation is waived by the Board. Non Residential Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A nonresident taxpayer shall be permitted to file his or her appearance, protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall not be required. Resident Taxpayer Filing by Letter Appeal A resident taxpayer will not be permitted to file his or her appearance, protest, and papers in support thereof by letter and his or her personal appearance shall be required. It will be assumed that reasonable attempts will be must be made, or an authorized agent sessor to notify such resident taxpayers that either a personal appearance must make a personal appearance for Board of Review consideration. Owner/Taxpayer Authorized Agent Representation An owner/taxpayer of record(per current City records, or by new evidence.presented) may be represented at the Lansing Board of Review,by an owner/taxpayer authorized agent. The authorization must be in writing, must contain an owner/taxpayer current dated signature, must identify the property by address and/or assessment parcel number, must identify the name of the agent, or the agent firm or company, and must identify the tax year applicable for the representation before the Board of Review. Minutes of Meetings The Secretary shall record the minutes of each meeting of e Bo f Re The as e public minutes of all meetings shall be filed by the Secretary in the e of City Clerk record. III. ORGANIZATION AND ELECTION OF OFFICERS Election and Term of Office The Board shall, at its Organization Meeting in March, elect a Chairperson and a Vice- Chairperson from among the voting members. The Chairperson and'Vice-Chairperson so 4 elected shall each hold his or her term of office one year. Board.llelective Officers aee eligible for re-election. The Assessor shall be the Secretary o f The Whole shall elect a Chair and Vice-Chair for each committee. Vacancy of Office In the event the office of the Chairperson becomes vacant,the Vice-Chairperson shall become Chairperson of the Board for the unexpired term. Duties of Officers - COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE The Chairperson shall preside at all meetings. In the absence of the Chairperson,the Vice- Chairperson shall act in the capacity of the Chairperson. shall select a su Gesso sence of both the Chairperson and the Vice-Chairperson,the Boa IV. AMENDMENTS TO BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE Amendments of the bylaws and rules of procedure may be initiated by any member of the meeting of the Board of Review by presenting the amendment(s) in writing any g Committee of the Whole,to be voted upon at the next regular meeting. All Board members must be notified of such amendment(s) by mail at least five days before voting upon said amendment(s). The affirmative vote of at astLor two members of the Board shall be required to amend the bylaws and rules procedure. V. In all matters of procedure not covered by these rules,the provisions of the.Michigan Statutes and the Lansing City Charter shall prevail. BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE BOARD OF REVIEW AS PROPOSED MARCH 8,2005,AMENDED AND APPROVED MARCH 14,2005. 5 POVERTY GUIDELINES RESOLUTION WHEREAS, the adoption of guidelines for poverty exemptions is within the preview of the City Council ; and WHEREAS, the homestead of persons who, in the judgement of the assessor and Board of Review, by reason of poverty, are unable to contribute to the public charges is eligible for exemption in whole or part from taxation under Public Act 390 , 1994 (MCL 211 . 7u) ; and WHEREAS, pursuant to PA 390, 1994 the City of Lansing, Ingham County adopts the following guidelines for the assessor and Board of Review to implement . The guidelines shall include but not be limited to the specific income and asset levels of the claimant and all persons residing in the household, including any property tax credit returns, filed in the current or immediately preceding year; to be eligible, a person shall must meet all of the following on an annual basis : 1) Be an owner of and occupy as a homestead the property for which an exemption is requested. 2) File a claim with the assessor or Board of Review, accompanied by federal and state income tax returns for all persons residing in the homestead, including any property tax credit returns filed in the immediately preceding year or in the current year. 3) Produce a valid drivers ' license or other form of identification if requested. 4) Produce a deed, land contract, or other evidence of ownership of the property for which an exemption is requested. 5) Meet the federal poverty income standards as defined and determined annually by the United States office of management and budget . 6) Homestead have a true cash value which is less than the average true cash value of all homestead properties in the city, based on the previous year values . 7) File an application for an exemption after January 1, but before the day prior to the last day of the Board of Review. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED that the Board of Review shall follow the above stated policy and guidelines in granting or denying an exemption, unless the Board of Review determines there are substantial and compelling reasons why there should be a deviation from the guidelines and these are communicated in writing to the claimant . Be it further resolved that if a poverty exemption is granted, that the assessed value will be reduced to a point where it would generate a tax, based on last years tax rates, of no more than 3 . 50 of the taxpayer' s previous year income . Approved for placement on Council agenda James Smiert.ka, City Atty. Date : Tax Year 2005 Filing of this form is necessary to determine if you qualify for a Homestead Hardship exemption. The following questions are necessary in order to determine poverty status and asset status. You are required to answer each question. If you do not answer each question, sufficient information will not be available to 11 grant an exemption. CITY OF LANSING HOMESTEAD HARDSHIP APPLICATION I the owner and occupant of the property listed below, am applying for tax relief under MCL 211 . 7u of the General Property Tax Act, which states that the homestead of persons who, in the judgement of the Assessor and the Board of Review, by reason of poverty, are unable to contribute to the public charges is eligible for exemption in whole or part from taxation under Public Act 390, 1994 . Parcel Number: Property Address : 1 . Attached federal and state income tax return for all persons residing in the homestead, including any property tax credit returns filed in the immediately preceding year or in the current year. YES or NO 2 . Attached copy of valid drivers license . YES or NO 3 . Attached copy of deed, land contract, or other evidence of ownership of the property for which the exemption is requested. YES or NO 4 . Do you meet the federal poverty income standards as defined and determined annually by the United States Office of Management and Budget . YES or NO (See attachment A) 5 . State Equalized Value of property for which the exemption is requested is The average true cash value of all homestead properties in the city, based on the previous year' s values is 90 , 840 (TCV) and 45 , 420 (AV) . 6 . Phone ( ) 7 . Marital Status : 8 . Age of Applicant : Age of Spouse : 9 . Number of Dependents Age of Dependents 10 . Have you applied for a Principal Residence Exemption from some school operating expense (18 mills) . YES or NO 11 . Have you applied for Homestead Property Tax Credit this Year? YES or NO 12 . How much was your Property Tax Credit? 13 . Real Estate : Is home paid for Unpaid balance Name of Mortgage Company Monthly Payment 14 . How long have you lived at this residence? 15 . Do you own, or are you buying other property? If so, list below: PROPERTY ADDRESS NAME OF OWNER ASSESSED VALUE AMOUNT & DATE OF LAST TAXES PAID 16 . Income earned from above property $ 17 . Name of Employer Address Phone : ( ) 18 . If unemployed, state reason: 19 . List all household income including government pensions, claims, judgements from lawsuits, and any other source . Be sure to include both spouses ' income . If your household income is more than the Federal Poverty Income Standards (attachment A) , you are not eligible for a credit . SOURCE OF INCOME ANNUAL INCOME Wages, salaries tips, sick, strike and sub pay, etc . All interest and dividend income (including non-taxable interest) . Net rent, business or royalty income . Retirement pension and annuity benefits . Name of payer: Net farm income . Capital gains less capital losses . Alimony and other taxable income . Describe : Social Security, SSI or railroad retirement benefits . Child support . Unemployment comp. and TRA benefits . Other non-taxable income . Describe : Workers ' comp . , veterans ' disability compensation and pension benefits . ADC and other DSS benefits . TOTAL INCOME 20 . SAVINGS AND INVESTMENTS : List all savings owned by you or your spouse, including savings accounts, postal savings, credit union shares, certificates of deposit, cash, stocks, bonds or similar investments . NAME OF AMOUNT ON DEPOSIT NAME ON ACCOUNT VALUE OF FINANCIAL INVESTMENT INSTITUTION OR INVESTMENTS 21 . LIFE INSURANCE: List all policies held by you and your spouse . INSURED AMOUNT OF AMOUNT PAID UP NAME OF RELATIONSHIP POLICY PAID POLICY BENEFICIARY TO INSURED MONTHLY 22 . MOTOR VEHICLES IN HOUSEHOLD: MAKE YEAR MONTHLY PAYMENT BALANCE OWED 23 . LIST ALL PERSONS LIVING IN HOUSEHOLD: LAST NAME FIRST NAME AGE RELATIONSHIP PLACE OF CONTRIBUTION TO CLAIMANT EMPLOYMENT TO FAMILY INCOME 24 . PERSONAL DEBTS : CREDITOR PURPOSE OF DATE. OF ORIGINAL MONTHLY BALANCE DEBT DEBT BALANCE PAYMENT OWED 25 . MONTHLY EXPENSES : UTILITIES FOOD PHONE CLOTHING HEAT CAR EXPENSE OTHER (Specify) : 26 . OTHER ASSETS : List all other assets and their values that are owned or controlled by you. (For example, boats, coin collection, antiques, silver) . TYPE OF ASSET VALUE OWNER REASON FOR REQUESTING EXEMPTION NOTICE: Any willful misstatements or misrepresentations made on this form may constitute perjury, which, under the law, is a felony punishable by fine or imprisonment . NOTICE: A copy of your latest federal income tax return, state income tax return (MI-1040) and your Homestead Property Tax Credit claim (MI-1040CR 1, 2 , 3 or 4) must be attached as proof of income . NOTE: Do not sign until witnessed by the Assessor or the Assessor ' s representative or the Board of Review Member: STATE OF MICHIGAN COUNTY OF: The undersigned, being duly sworn, deposes and says that the statements made in the foregoing application are true and that he/she has no money, income or property other than mentioned herein. Petitioner Subscribed and sworn this day of 20 Assessor, or Assessor' s Representative, or Board of Review Member This application must be returned no later than the second Monday in March to the Board of Review of Address : For BOARD OF REVIEW use: Disposition by Board of Review Date Denied: Approved: Assessment reduced to Chairperson 2nd Member 3rd Member Decisions may be appealed to Michigan Tax Tribunal_ . To be completed by Assessing staff. Hardship Calculation Form Applicant Parcel Number Property Address Annual Income X 3 . 50 = Divide by Homestead millage . 04308620 = (Hardship Value) Staff Notes : Documentation Complete Documentation Incomplete Staff Recommendation Approved Denied Staff Date Assessor' s Review & Comments Approved Denied Assessor Date 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 1 of 8 N B H 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 11A 4.00 8.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 8.66 4.71 5.75 1.51 1.51 2.06 6.43 3.53 4.00 11 B 4.00 4.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.81 8.24 5.01 3.88 3.88 2.04 6.42 3.00 4.00 11 C 3.00 6.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 3.00 7.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 6.95 6.95 5.27 10.10 4.40 4.00 11 D 8.00 7.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 3.00 3.00 8.96 7.42 3.39 7.16 7.16 1.77 6.98 3.00 5.00 11 E 8.00 6.00 0.00 5.00 4.00 1.00 5.00 2.51 0.00 0.00 7.02 7.02 4.75 6.77 7.94 4.00 11 F 5.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 4.00 4.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 5.01 8.06 8.06 5.32 7.34 4.40 4.00 11G 3.00 1.00 0.00 5.00 4.00 1.00 0.00 3.21 7.65 7.67 7.14 7.14 4.13 7.99 13.63 4.00 11 H 0.00 9.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 3.92 7.51 6.33 5.17 5.17 3.43 8.86 4.46 4.00 111 1.00 8.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 8.24 11.90 7.99 7.99 2.19 8.91 4.40 4.00 12A 10.00 6.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 9.34 8.24 15.76 5.70 5.70 2.03 7.99 4.40 4.00 12B 2.00 3.00 0.00 13.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 5.56 9.41 7.67 6.99 6.99 8.47 7.09 8.34 4.00 12C 5.00 5.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 7.51 8.24 15.46 2.10 2.10 5.95 8.12 3.86 4.00 12D 8.00 4.00 0.00 9.00 4.00 0.00 1.00 1.23 7.49 4.13 7.23 7.23 12.70 6.15 4.40 6.00 12E 10.00 6.00 0.00 4.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 3.56 0.00 3.72 6.94 6.94 10.44 14.81 4.40 4.00 13A 5.00 5.00 0.00 13.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 5.69 9.41 1.21 6.88 6.88 2.37 7.38 14.06 15.00 13B 5.00 7.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 5.80 9.41 10.46 6.19 6.19 6.31 6.08 15.61 15.00 13C 5.00 6.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 9.41 10A6 7.84 7.84 7.28 10.14 14.06 15.00 14A 0.00 5.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 5.88 8.55 7.67 8.68 8.68 2.70 23.54 17.45 4.00 14B 0.00 10.00 0.00 9.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.24 17.99 9.79 9.79 7.59 6.65 13.10 6.00 14C 5.00 6.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 1.00 1.00 5.51 9.41 17.99 10.07 10.07 12.23 10.25 3.00 4.00 14D 5.00 9.00 0.00 8.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.56 8.24 14.12 8.39 8.39 3.94 8.24 10.01 4.00 15A 0.00 5.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 3.00 6.00 5.88 0.00 7.60 5.34 5.34 8.17 13.68 4.40 8.00 15B 0.00 5.00 0.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 3.00 20.33 2.35 11.49 6.22 6.22 10.14 9.14 3.00 4.00 15C 3.00 4.00 0.00 13.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 7.06 13.37 6.95 6.95 8.13 17.18 3.00 4.00 16A 4.00 4.00 0.00 13.00 0.00 3.00 3.00 6.76 8.24 16.42 8.16 8.16 12.93 21.88 13.10 4.00 16B 0.00 5.00 0.00 2.00 2.00 4.00 0.00 3.29 7.06 0.00 9.94 9.94 14.54 22.81 3.00 5.00 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 2 of 8 NBH 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 16C 10.00 10.00 0.00 2.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 9.41 17.99 10.28 10.28 13.90 22.20 13.10 4.00 21A 3.00 6.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 7.00 11.78 4.71 0.00 5.54 5.54 6.21 13.30 5.61 4.00 21 B 8.00 4.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 5.00 5.88 4.71 0.00 7.06 7.06 14.14 14.37 13.10 10.00 21 C 10.00 3.00 0.00 2.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 4.32 5.88 16.42 8.86 8.86 13.96 17.26 13.10 4.00 21 D 5.00 10.00 0.00 9.00 3.00 0.00 1.00 11.30 9.41 12.71 7.16 7.16 4.70 6.20 13.10 10.00 21 E 10.00 6.00 0.00 4.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 3.70 9.41 17.99 8.51 8.51 8.78 23.81 6.35 4.00 21 F 8.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 3.69 8.82 9.05 7.48 7.48 13.84 8.08 5.94 10.00 22A 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 3.00 2.00 23.53 9.41 10.46 6.04 6.04 2.59 8.34 3.00 5.00 22B 2.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 8.82 7.13 5.72 5.72 12.96 11.40 15.03 9.00 22C 0.00 1.00 0.00 5.00 2.00 3.00 2.00 6.46 5.88 1.48 6.13 6.13 13.12 8.05 16.14 8.00 22D 0.00 7.00 0.00 7.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.46 5.88 7.13 3.34 3.34 13.71 20.98 13.10 15.00 23 0.00 4.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.27 5.88 5.01 7.11 7.11 13.65 22.66 21.80 8.00 24 5.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 5.88 10.62 5.04 5.04 13.92 17.52 15.13 21.00 25 10.00 1.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.12 9.41 10.00 6.80 6.80 5.05 12.10 22.83 17.00 26 1.00 2.00 0.00 5.00 2.00 0.00 4.00 9.38 9.41 11.90 6.12 6.12 13.45 14.63 20.10 10.00 27 1.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 30.00 0.00 8.24 0.00 7.18 7.18 13.16 15.64 17.88 25.00 28 0.00 0.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 5.88 2.35 10.46 9.58 9.58 -0.46 7.75 22.18 25.00 28A 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 2.00 3.29 2.35 5.01 7.36 7.36 8.41 23.71 21.80 13.00 29 3.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.88 0.00 4.49 5.16 5.16 14.11 22.41 27.42 25.00 31 A 8.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 12.04 5.78 5.78 12.63 18.29 3.00 10.00 31 B 8.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 31 C 8.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 2.35 17.99 2.54 2.54 8.11 18.40 13.10 10.00 31 D 0.00 1.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.84 8.84 6.86 18.70 16.00 25.00 31 E 0.00 1.00 0.00 8.00 4.00 4.00 47.00 9.21 0.00 0.00 5.93 5.93 4.51 11.99 10.23 7.00 32A 0.00 6.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 3.00 1.00 3.61 9.41 10.46 5.78 5.78 2.64 21.12 4.40 25.00 32B 4.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 0.00 1.00 8.70 0.00 2.45 8.59 8.59 7.46 22.20 5.27 12.00 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 3 of 8 NBH 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 32C 5.00 3.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.32 2.35 0.00 7.04 7.04 13.24 23.39 4.40 12.00 32D 5.00 6.00 0.00 10.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 6.89 2.35 5.53 6.15 6.15 3.02 10.40 4.40 12.00 32E 8.00 5.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 7.00 14.85 7.06 0.00 7.80 7.80 8.20 6.93 3.00 12.00 33A 9.00 6.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 5.94 8.24 4.12 5.40 5.40 3.39 7.40 3.00 4.00 33B 8.00 4.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 5.07 7.06 11.90 5.64 5.64 7.11 7.24 5.99 4.00 33C 5.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.02 9.41 17.99 4.66 4.66 4.23 6.17 3.00 4.00 33D 5.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 2.54 0.00 14.34 4.38 4.38 6.90 7.34 3.00 4.00 33E _ 5.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.08 9.41 6.54 4.55 4.55 3.31 8.53 4.40 4.00 33F 4.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 1.76 10.46 4.43 4.43 6.57 8.14 4.40 4.00 33G 5.00 5.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 4.00 2.00 7.00 5.88 9.19 1.52 1.52 6.70 6.80 4.40 4.00 34A 5.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 1.49 9.41 10.43 6.50 6.50 6.75 7.18 3.00 4.00 34B 8.00 4.00 0.00 9.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 1.81 8.24 6.63 5.53 5.53 12.85 6.87 3.00 4.00 34C 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 ;13.85 0.00 0.00 0.00 35A 5.00 2.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 7.65 16.42 7.12 7.12 15.88 13.10 25.00 35B 4.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 2.00 4.00 0.00 2.29 0.00 6.35 9.24 9.24 12.52 7.84 11.00 36A 4.00 3.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.37 9.41 1.21 7.05 7.05 3.95 22.99 13.10 10.00 36B 4.00 3.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.59 8.24 2.45 6.18 6.18 14.08 19.21 17.48 9.00 36C 7.00 6.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 12.00 16.61 0.00 0.00 6.50 6.50 7.14 6.81 9.99 9.00 37A 8.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 4.00 15.00 12.32 4.71 0.00 6.22 6.22 8.97 7.55 3.00 9.00 37B 5.00 5.00 0.00 12.00 0.00 1.00 4.00 9.74 4.12 8.42 5.61 5.61 13.30 12.68 7.64 4.00 38A 10.00 3.00 0.00 9.00 4.00 4.00 5.00 0.00 2.35 4.95 7.06 7.06 11.28 17.02 13.84 8.00 4.00 4.00 6.86 1.76 5.01 6.99 6.99 8.64 12.19 16.14 8.00 38B 0.00 0.00 0.00 13.00 4.00 38C 7.00 9.00 0.00 12.00 2.00 3.00 3.00 5.16 0.00 2.45 6.37 6.37 14.15 24.01 11.06 8.00 E38 3.00 8.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.44 0.00 5.01 6.82 6.82 14.00 17.69 13.10 8.00 3.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 11.00 11.43 3.53 0.00 8.71 8.71 3.30 21.83 13.30 8.00 3.00 2.00 0.00 12.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.29 0.00 0.00 7.00 7.00 7.02 8.29 13.10 8.00 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 4 of 8 NBH 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 39A 5.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.77 6.77 14.00 13.33 13.10 14.00 39B 0.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.94 3.72 8.69 8.69 11.84 21.35 17.45 13.00 41A 10.00 10.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 0.00 4.71 1.83 7.16 7.16 11.04 15.56 24.17 14.00 41 B 8.00 5.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 16.57 8.24 7.27 6.98 6.98 14.09 15.22 21.44 7.00 42A 10.00 3.00 0.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 7.85 8.24 17.58 4.92 4.92 9.05 7.30 9.55 4.00 42B 5.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 2.00 3.00 6.00 6.72 3.53 2.36 6.34 6.34 13.54 7.70 11.62 4.00 42C 10.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 4.00 0.00 2.00 6.10 3.53 6.65 6.91 6.91 3.23 11.10 13.90 6.00 42D 8.00 5.00 0.00 9.00 3.00 0.00 2.00 2.25 9.41 13.37 5.72 5.72 2.45 6.70 13.29 11.00 42E 5.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.84 7.06 5.79 8.68 8.68 13.49 14.98 18.13 6.00 43A 5.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 2.00 1.00 2.00 0.00 5.88 5.79 7.15 7.15 9.55 6.31 10.12 4.00 43B 8.00 6.00 0.00 5.00 3.00 3.00 6.00 1.67 0.00 5.79 6.19 6.19 6.95 7.12 8.37 4.00 43C 5.00 8.00 0.00 8.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 5.88 9.95 5.30 5.30 8.61 7.82 6.66 4.00 43D 10.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 8.88 7.67 4.65 4.65 7.73 8.32 5.10 4.00 43E 5.00 5.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.88 7.67 5.49 5.49 8.78 7.73 13.27 4.00 44A 8.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 29.00 28.24 0.00 0.00 6.77 6.77 13.14 12.05 3.00 4.00 44B 8.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 2.00 3.00 9.37 7.06 5.53 5.62 5.62 1.96 6.89 5.97 4.00 44C 10.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 2.22 5.29 16.42 1.48 1.48 8.55 8.77 3.00 4.00 45A 5.00 10.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 12.54 7.06 5.22 3.08 3.08 6.97 6.24 3.00 6.00 45B 3.00 1.00 0.00 4.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 4.62 6.47 2.45 6.41 6.41 6.91 8.07 7.48 4.00 45C 3.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 4.25 9.09 10.46 2.92 2.92 2.01 7.54 4.34 4.00 45D 3.00 3.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 13.00 2.67 0.00 0.00 6.22 6.22 4.21 8.05 17.53 4.00 46A 3.00 5.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.80 2.80 6.16 9.55 3.00 15.00 46B 3.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 1.55 2.94 9.38 3.84 3.84 10.09 7.97 3.00 4.00 46C 5.00 9.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 4.00 7.00 6.45 1.76 2.45 3.21 3.21 11.57 7.62 9.43 14.00 46D 3.00 6.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 3.41 2.35 10.46 6.75 6.75 13.07 14.65 4.28 4.00 46E 3.00 5.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 1.64 8.82 5.01 7.03 7.03 12.28 7.29 3.00 9.00 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 5 of 8 NBH 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 46F 3.00 3.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.20 8.82 10.46 4.71 4.71 10.60 7.86 9.95 5.00 47A 5.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 0.00 3.00 6.00 0.82 7.25 8.27 5.95 5.95 3.73 7.69 3.00 14.00 47B 5.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 10.00 12.72 0.00 0.00 4.38 4.38 2.10 7.76 3.00 15.00 47C 5.00 5.00 0.00 7.00 3.00 4.00 10.00 6.93 5.88 0.00 2.30 2.30 5.06 6.51 15.14 16.00 47D 5.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 2.94 10.46 7.10 7.10 12.43 17.03 3.00 14.00 47E 3.00 5.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 3.53 3.72 6.27 6.27 12.76 14.54 17.45 4.00 47F 5.00 3.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 2.91 2.35 17.99 4.92 4.92 7.99 8.23 17.45 15.00 47G 8.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.35 0.00 2.10 6.76 6.76 14.49 21.67 13.20 4.00 47H 3.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 4.00 12.00 6.23 0.00 0.00 6.86 6.86 9.08 7.09 15.58 8.00 471 5.00 0.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 4.90 0.00 0.00 2.61 2.61 12.62 7.20 18.73 4.00 47J 5.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 3.00 1.00 6.16 4.71 2.05 5.58 5.58 12.47 9.39 3.20 8.00 51 4.00 2.00 0.00 12.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.82 7.67 2.50 2.50 5.00 10.57 8.95 10.00 51A 3.00 3.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.69 6.67 6.00 6.00 13.30 23.58 15.28 10.00 52A 5.00 3.00 0.00 12.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 10.55 9.41 6.43 4.11 4.11 6.15 9.01 16.75 10.00 52B 10.00 10.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 0.00 7.91 10.46 4.96 4.96 7.00 6.84 11.73 15.00 52C 8.00 3.00 0.00 6.00 4.00 2.00 1.00 11.00 9.41 0.00 7.13 7.13 5.13 6.30 5.26 12.00 52D 4.00 4.00 0.00 11.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 0.65 8.30 3.52 5.47 5.47 9.07 6.53 5.92 4.00 52E 10.00 10.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 5.58 9.41 11.71 3.53 3.53 12.77 7.26 4.40 4.00 53A 9.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.55 5.88 14.87 5.57 5.57 10.35 6.17 4.40 4.00 53B 3.00 2.00 0.00 11.00 2.00 3.00 6.00 5.50 7.06 2.45 7.36 7.36 6.56 8.62 14.57 11.00 53C 3.00 3.00 0.00 11.00 4.00 2.00 1.00 3.14 7.65 5.93 7.30 7.30 13.58 6.34 8.17 11.00 53D 10.00 5.00 0.00 11.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.92 2.35 2.88 6.81 6.81 12.13 14.88 12.46 4.00 53E 5.00 5.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 9.20 8.82 6.33 4.14 4.14 2.33 7.37 14.46 11.00 54A 5.00 10.00 0.00 6.00 4.00 3.00 1.00 8.40 8.82 9.05 6.35 6.35 13.69 7.32 9.27 6.00 54B 0.00 1.00 0.00 13.00 4.00 4.00 6.00 2.49 9.41 16.42 5.18 5.18 3.04 7.13 17.82 11.00 54C 5.00 10.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 7.45 5.88 0.00 5.56 5.56 4.01 17.34 4.52 9.00 3/4/2005 5:53:08 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 6 of 8 NBH 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 54D 4.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 10.79 5.88 17.99 2.58 2.58 2.02 8.59 8.75 4.00 54E 4.00 8.00 0.00 6.00 2.00 0.00 2.00 5.60 8.24 5.51 6.44 6.44 5.24 6.64 20.26 4.00 54F 10.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 22.00 17.11 5.88 0.00 4.87 4.87 8.62 7.38 6.53 4.00 54G 8.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 3.00 9.00 5.27 9.41 5.01 6.82 6.82 2.66 9.12 21.80 25.00 55A 8.00 5.00 0.00 11.00 2.00 0.00 2.00 1.93 0.00 14.00 6.81 6.81 1.77 15.09 4.40 4.00 55B 3.00 4.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 2.75 6.77 6.77 12.45 7.25 15.92 13.00 55C 8.00 4.00 0.00 6.00 4.00 4.00 2.00 0.00 5.97 5.57 6.36 6.36 12.69 8.67 9.47 4.00 55D 8.00 3.00 0.00 13.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 5.76 3.66 5.74 5.74 12.90 20.06 17.08 4.00 55E 5.00 0.00 0.00 10.00 4.00 4.00 4.00 1.05 3.53 12.28 3.47 3.47 2.08 6.22 10.35 4.00 56A 5.00 6.00 0.00 9.00 3.00 0.00 1.00 1.21 8.24 14.64 6.10 6.10 5.93 6.51 3.00 4.00 56B 10.00 6.00 0.00 12.00 2.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 7.77 7.59 7.59 13.43 7.03 15.94 6.00 57A 8.00 3.00 0.00 9.00 4.00 3.00 3.00 9.22 0.00 0.00 5.59 5.59 12.55 6.44 3.00 4.00 57B 3.00 8.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 4.00 7.00 6.88 0.00 0.00 2.82 2.82 3.85 7.58 13.13 12.00 57C 10.00 8.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 0.00 1.00 4.56 2.35 5.01 4.94 4.94 1.86 7.50 18.50 5.00 61A 5.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 2.00 0.00 7.00 14.72 7.65 2.45 7.15 7.15 4.58 12.53 3.00 21.00 61 B 5.00 1.00 0.00 10.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.19 9.41 17.99 5.80 5.80 12.49 17.39 15.20 4.00 61 C 0.00 8.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 6.75 6.75 14.52 8.87 3.00 4.00 62A 5.00 4.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 2.00 3.00 5.68 7.74 0.00 5.95 5.95 2.83 7.67 3.00 4.00 62B 5.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 3.00 5.00 0.00 7.10 5.81 4.34 4.34 4.19 6.17 11.65 6.00 62C 10.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 4.00 15.00 4.09 5.23 0.00 1.70 1.70 12.62 17.16 3.00 4.00 62D 4.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 2.00 2.00 1.87 5.88 16.23 1.36 1.36 2.05 7.14 11.46 8.00 62E 7.00 6.00 0.00 5.00 4.00 4.00 7.00 3.67 2.94 2.60 6.91 6.91 3.64 7.21 15.18 10.00 62F 5.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 4.00 2.81 0.00 0.00 7.10 7.10 7.05 6.90 6.43 4.00 62G 3.00 4.00 0.00 5.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 4.05 0.00 0.00 6.56 6.56 7.44 15.59 15.65 4.00 71A 0.00 5.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 3.00 7.00 9.39 2.94 0.00 6.92 6.92 6.70 6.92 12.02 9.00 71 B 5.00 5.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 1.19 8.24 7.67 3.15 3.15 13.26 17A 2 17.45 4.00 3/4/2005 5:53:09 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 7 of 8 N B H 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 71 C 5.00 5.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 0.00 9.41 2.45 6.58 6.58 9.39 6.12 3.00 10.00 71 D 5.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 4.00 4.00 7.00 2.52 2.94 0.00 5.97 5.97 2.35 13.70 9.83 10.00 71 E 0.00 1.00 0.00 3.00 4.00 0.00 5.00 7.03 2.35 2.45 5.71 5.71 9.60 11.05 9.62 4.00 71 F 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 3.29 1.18 2.45 3.81 3.81 8.49 16.68 13.28 4.00 72A 4.00 5.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 5.88 12.16 4.57 4.57 9.97 9.94 10.32 4.00 72B 3.00 3.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 6.34 9.41 14.34 6.21 6.21 2.07 7.30 7.31 4.00 72C 3.00 2.00 0.00 7.00 4.00 0.00 2.00 1.44 7.06 7.26 5.23 5.23 2.16 7.12 15.97 4.00 72D 0.00 3.00 0.00 13.00 4.00 0.00 7.00 5.17 0.00 0.00 7.14 7.14 11.56 12.01 7.01 12.00 72E 3.00 3.00 0.00 8.00 4.00 0.00 7.00 12.39 2.35 0.00 2.34 2.34 6.05 12.05 12.45 11.00 72F 4.00 3.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 5.00 4.39 7.06 7.93 4.79 4.79 9.71 6.75 5.65 4.00 72G 3.00 3.00 0.00 9.00 2.00 0.00 8.00 8.39 8.24 3.68 6.41 6.41 2.11 7.18 14.65 14.00 72H 3.00 2.00 0.00 5.00 4.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 2.45 6.62 6.62 6.39 6.36 16.91 12.00 721 3.00 5.00 0.00 5.00 3.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 7.65 11.23 5.02 5.02 2.88 7.71 5.36 4.00 73A 5.00 8.00 0.00 5.00 0.00 4.00 10.00 6.57 7.65 0.00 5.37 5.37 1.92 6.98 8.48 15.00 73B 2.00 10.00 0.00 9.00 2.00 4.00 4.00 1.79 0.00 0.00 10.15 10.15 11.59 6.39 13.66 15.00 73C 3.00 1.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 2.38 8.24 10.98 3.06 3.06 1.98 8.15 13.28 4.00 73D 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 3.53 17.99 1.80 1.80 3.92 8.14 13.10 4.00 73E 0.00 -6.28 -6.28 -4.61 8.31 3.00 4.00 73F 0.00 1.48 1.48 7.04 6.30 3.00 4.00 74A 8.00 5.00 0.00 6.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 0.00 3.53 2.45 5.73 5.73 12.44 11.28 7.20 4.00 74B 8.00 3.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 9.41 8.77 5.78 5.78 8.33 8.07 3.90 4.00 75A 5.00 6.00 0.00 10.00 3.00 2.00 3.00 2.99 9.41 14.86 3.44 3.44 8.77 6.99 10.21 4.00 75B 5.00 3.00 0.00 7.00 0.00 3.00 3.00 0.00 9.41 12.98 6.93 6.93 9.15 6.80 3.00 5.00 75C 5.00 8.00 0.00 2.00 0.00 4.00 24.00 9.09 0.00 0.00 10.97 10.97 10.98 6.62 13.07 7.00 75D 5.00 1.00 0.00 3.00 0.00 0.00 2.00 2.17 8.24 9.09 2.85 2.85 6.81 8.10 3.00 4.00 75E -1.00 1.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 4.00 4.00 3.29 0.00 0.00 1.62 1.62 6.66 6.48 3.00 6.00 3/4/2005 5:53:09 PM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD PERCENT CHANGE HISTORY Page 8 of 8 N B H 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE %CHGE 84A 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.72 8.72 4.61 21.47 10.11 3.00 84B 0.00 3.00 0.00 6.00 6.00 0.00 7.00 5.69 4.71 6.56 6.56 3.46 6.79 7.23 11.00 84C 0.00 3.00 0.00 5.00 2.00 0.00 0.00 3.42 4.71 8.22 8.22 7.88 6.56 0.00 9.00 84D 0.00 10.00 0.00 6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 20.00 .7.06 7.19 7.19 5.37 5.38 3.00 3.00 85A 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.00 6.00 0.00 7.00 3.29 0.00 6.92 6.92 10.46 6.27 8.29 12.00 85B 3.00 5.00 0.00 6.00 4.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.80 8.80 14.53 7.87 9.10 3.00 85C 5.00 0.00 11.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4.95 7.06 8.89 8.89 10.78 10.65 12.87 3.00 91 0.00 0.22 0.36 2.12 3.00 4.00 92 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00