Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1992 Board of Police Commissioners Minutes - All LANSIN POLICE DEPARTMENT" POLICE BOARD EVAL UA TION REPORT 1992 r: . 38 1 ,9�� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. ii Lansing, Michigan 48933 * — * (517)372-9400 t♦ rr f oI"fff �CRIGQ' November 23 , 1992 Mayor Terry J. McKane City of Lansing City Hall, 9th Floor 124 W. Michigan Avenue Lansing, MI 48933 Dear Mayor McKane: The Administrative Staff of the Police Department has been involved in a strategic planning process. The draft plan identified many areas which needed attention. One area of immediate concern was the lack of a Departmental vision statement and realistic goals. The Administrative Staff, in conjunction with the Board of Police Commissioners and the Union, undertook the task of preparing these statements early in 1992 . After an exhaustive effort, they all agreed upon the attached vision, mission and goal statements. These statements were presented to the Board of Police Commissioners at their March meeting. At the April meeting, the Board formally approved the statements and submitted them to the Mayor's office for review and approval. In accordance with the Board of Police Commissioners' recommendation and the approval of the Mayor and City Council, these statements truly represent the base for which the Police Department will work for the next several years. As the Department continues to study operations and recommend changes to align resources for policing the City in the 1990's and beyond, the Department's vision, mission and goal statements will serve as its "road map" . The Board of Police Commissioners, again, wants to commend the Chief of Police and his staff and officers for their efforts toward making our community a safe place to live and work. We look forward to a continued excellent relationship with the Department, your office, City Council and the citizens of Lansing. Respectfully, Willard K. Walker Chairperson "Equal Opportunity Employer" CONTENTS Vision and Mission Statements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Goals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 FIELD SERVICES Uniform Division . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 K-9 Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Special Tactics And Rescue Team . . . . . . 5 Underwater Recovery Unit / Dive Team . . . . . 6 Community Policing Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Crime Suppression Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Traffic Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Uniform Service Desk . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Park Police Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Investigations Division . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Crime and Assignment Statistics . . . . . . . . 13 Special Operations Division . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Regional Enforcement Against Crack Houses . . . 14 Tri-County Metro Narcotics Squad . . . . . . . 16 Analysis Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 STAFF SERVICES Administrative Support Division . . . . . . . . . . 19 Administrative Services Bureau . . . . . . . . 19 Personnel and Training Bureau . . . . . . . . . 21 Technical Services Division . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Automated Data Operations . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Community Services Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Detention Bureau . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 Quartermaster Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Radio Maintenance Bureau . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Records Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 OTHER SERVICES Internal Affairs Unit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Legal Advisor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 VISION STATEMENT OF THE LANSING POLICE DEPARTMENT: POLICE AND COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS FOR PROGRESS AND EXCELLENCE. MISSION STATEMENT OF THE LANSING POLICE DEPARTMENT: The Lansing Police Department's mission is to maintain order, preserve public safety, and foster a better quality of life. It is our intent to make our City a better place to live, work, and visit. To accomplish this mission, we must, as a Law Enforcement Agency, Acknowledge the citizens as the source of police authority, Administer the law without bias, Recognize the dignity and worth of all people, Solicit cooperation and support at the neighborhood level as well as with the .greater community, Provide services in a sensitive and effective manner, and Seek to gain the respect of all people; as an Employer, Provide a work environment which stresses teamwork, recognizes the value of diversity, and encourages professional development, and Employ progressive management techniques emphasizing ethical behavior, leadership by example, and a standard of excellence. 1 GOALS OF THE LANSING POLICE DEPARTMENT Deliver quality police service in a lawful, sensitive, and professional manner in order to protect life, property, and maintain public peace. Prevent crime and maintain order through police action, targeting specific problems. Achieve organizational excellence through education, training, and technology. Identify and analyze problems, explore alternative solutions, and solicit regional cooperation. Create and maintain open lines of communication to promote partnerships with our community. Encourage and support citizen involvement and leadership to improve the quality of life at the neighborhood level. Employ personnel that meet standards of professional excellence and represent the diversity of our community. Promote job satisfaction through employee participation in decision making. Evaluate programs to maximize the use of available resources. 2 UNIFORM DIVISION During the first nine months of 1992 , the Uniform Division Patrol has continued to focus on a police and community partnership within the city. The Uniform Division has created a set of goals that places emphasis on problem solving within the neighborhood. A new direction has been initiated requiring both District Officers and Command Officers from each Platoon to attend community meetings. The demand on police service and the time spent by officers handling calls continues to reduce their overall patrol time (from 42 , 284 hours in 1991 to 34 , 444 hours in the first nine months of 1992) . Effective July 1, 1992 , the Park Police Unit funding was stopped, and the many of the Park Unit' s responsibilities have been taken over by Uniform Division Patrol Units. The following are some of the Division's overall statistics during the first nine months of 1992 . dispatched and self-initiated calls for service 108 , 224 special duty time, hours . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 , 179 felony arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 991 misdemeanor arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 , 127 appearance tickets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 436 adult and juvenile contacts . . . . . . . . . . 11, 981 house and bar checks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36, 193 UDAA recoveries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 381 investigative reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 , 355 moving and nonmoving violations . . . . . . . . 14 , 558 radar violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4, 080 accident reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 , 693 3 K-9 UNIT In 1992 , the number of dogs working in the Canine Unit has fluctuated during the first months due to injuries and retirements. Two additional dogs will be graduated in November 1992 , bringing the total number of working dogs to eight. The Canine Unit continues to play an important part of the Uniform Division on a daily basis, including one dog specially trained to handle the detection of bombs and other explosive devices. The Unit no longer has a dog trained for drug detection. The Canines have responded to 804 calls for service in the first nine months of the year. The Canine Unit's activity during the first nine months included: building searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 315 tracks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 214 area searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 weapon searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 demonstrations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 explosive searches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 unfounded calls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 apprehensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 4 SPECIAL TACTICS AND RESCUE TEAM S.T.A.R.T. has been activated 109 times during the first nine months of 1992. The team has been utilized most often for drug raids and has the responsibility for securing the residence so that R.E.A.C.H. members and Metro members may safely process the scene. Incidents during the first nine months of the year included: drugraids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 hostages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 barricaded gunman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 searchwarrants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 mentals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 buy bust . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 other . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 5 UNDERWATER RECOVERY UNIT / DIVE TEAM The Dive Team responds to all water incidents within the City and a portion of Eaton County. This unit is also responsible for conducting water patrol during such special events as. the Fourth of July and Riverfest activities that are held at Riverfront park. The Dive Team has responded to the following incidents in 1992 : evidence dives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 drownings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 vehicles recoveries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 specialevents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 6 COMMUNITY POLICING UNIT The Community Police program has expanded to nine areas and is working on expanding to ten in November 1992 . The Uniform Division is looking into reorganization and the development of a Community Bureau which would encompass three units within the Department: Community Policing, Suppression, and Community Services. The Bureau would have one lieutenant, three sergeants and approximately 25 officers focusing on neighborhoods and the continued growth of Neighborhood/Police Networking. The program is a proactive approach to law enforcement in the community to provide a long-term intervention directed towards a community and police partnership in solving problems within specific neighborhoods. The nine Community Policing positions include one Transportation Center Footbeat Grant (bus station) , two General Fund positions, two COPS Grant positions, three HUD Grant positions, one Community Partnership Grant and one ADAA Sergeant position. Overall activity for the nine Community Policing areas included: answering machine calls . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 , 561 calls for service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 349 misdemeanor arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 219 felony arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 traffic violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 parking violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 investigative reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 373 intelligence reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 building code violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61 7 CRIME SUPPRESSION UNIT The Crime Suppression Unit has been expanded to work more closely with Community Policing, the Platoons, and Special Operations to solve problems within the neighborhoods. The Unit has been assigned the task of visiting the Community Centers on a daily basis, with emphasis on building a relationship between the Department and a contact person at each Center. The Crime Suppression Unit, the Uniform Division's multi-purpose unit, is responsible for handling a wide variety of complaints affecting the quality of life in neighborhoods. These complaints include targeting neighborhoods that have high crime rates, prostitution, abandoned vehicles, trash complaints, wanted drug suspects, gathering information on suspects drug houses and complainants that are channeled to the Department from the Mayor/ City Council office. The Unit also provides Uniform security at drug raids conducted by the S.T.A.R.T. and R. E.A. C.H. teams. The Unit's activity during the first nine month of 1992 : drug raids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 neighborhood canvas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 special assignments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 self-initiated calls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 860 felony arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 misdemeanor arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376 parking violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 adult and juvenile contacts . . . . . . . . . . . 166 8 TRAFFIC UNIT The Traffic Unit' s special events continue to grow from 1, 690 hours in 1991 to 2 , 851 hours in 1992 . These include runs, road races, parades, festivals, and other outdoor events. Approximately 25% of the Unit's total staffing hours is spent on special duty time. The primary goal of the Traffic Unit is accident reduction through traffic control and enforcement. In 1991, 750 accidents were reported; during the first nine months of 1992 , there have been 782 accidents. The number of officers assigned to the unit consists of one Sergeant and twelve officers (ten assigned to motorcycles and two to traffic follow-up) . During the first nine months of 1992 , the number of officers working on motorcycles has fluctuated due to injuries; at the present time, eight officers are assigned to the motorcycle unit. Activity during the first nine months of 1992 includes: special duty time, hours . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 , 851 accident reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 782 accident violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 592 incomplete accidents . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 131 total moving violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 919 total nonmoving violations . . . . . . . . . . . . 606 total radar violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 , 412 parking violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 597 9 UNIFORM SERVICE DESK The Uniform Service Desk program was designed to assist citizens coming into the Police Station between 8:00 a.m. and 5: 00 p.m. This allows district officers to stay on the road and handle calls for service, and citizens do not have to wait for an officer to respond from the field. The Service Desk Officer's role as been expanded to handle URR follow-up investigations and closure of cases that come from district patrol. Service Desk activity for the first nine months of the year includes: citizen assists . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 , 313 NRF reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 465 written reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175 H&R accidents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 sign-off on tickets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 441 10 PARK POLICE UNIT The Park Police Unit's funding was stopped and deleted from the City of Lansing Budget on July 1, 1992 . The goal of the Unit was to provide a safe environment within the City parks. This included protection of all park facilities and equipment, responding to calls for service, building security, and crime investigation. In addition to motorized patrols working two shifts of ten hours each, the Unit also used two horses to patrol the parks and riverwalk. One sergeant and six officers were assigned to the Unit. The six officers were hired by the Lansing Police Department, and the sergeant retired. The following activity was recorded by the Park Police Unit during the first six months of 1992 . calls for service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 443 property checks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 , 532 felony arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 misdemeanor arrests . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 moving violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 non-moving violations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112 building secured . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 investigative reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 adult and juvenile contacts . . . . . . . . . . 1, 281 11 INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION In 1992 , because of constant and increasing demands on personnel resources, case assignment guidelines were established to assist supervisors in the assignment of cases. Sergeants now assign cases according to the following criteria: (1) seriousness of the crime, (2) solvability factors, and (3) availability of personnel. As in the past, our efforts are focused on service delivery, primarily aimed at providing quality follow-up investigations on criminal cases and maintaining a high clearance rate. The Uniform Crime report reflects that our clearance rate for Part I crimes is well above the state and national averages. Following are several programs which have been initiated to assist the Division in our attempt to deliver service in a more responsive and sensitive manner. The Mail Survey continues for the purpose of soliciting opinions from victims as to how they view the quality and effectiveness of our investigative efforts. OPU Letters. Everyday cases are forwarded to the Division for follow-up investigation; however, many of these cases do not meet the criteria for assignment and therefore are not assigned to an investigator. In February 1992 , we began mailing letters explaining to victims why their cases were not assigned. This program seems to be well received by the public, and we receive fewer calls concerning case status. Community Policing Detective. On October 5 , 1992 , the Division began a pilot program which provides an investigator to conduct all the criminal follow-up investigations that fall within two of our community policing areas. This investigator, in addition to working cases, will assist and direct community policing officers in areas relative to criminal follow-up investigations. The program is closely monitored to evaluate its effectiveness and value in criminal follow-up investigations. Trace Program. In March of 1992 , the Division and the Credit Bureau of Greater Lansing entered into an agreement by which the Department is provided a laptop computer and access to information in Credit Bureau files. In effect, this gives us nationwide access to information the pertains to the whereabouts of people who have had credit-related information entered into the database. This program has been very useful in locating some hard-to-find individuals. The Auto Theft Grant, which jointly funds an investigator from the Ingham County Sheriff' s Department and the Lansing Police Department, was renewed for 1992 and continues to address auto theft problems in the Lansing area. 12 CRIME AND ASSIGNMENT STATISTICS The following table illustrates that the case intake continues on the increase, along with the case assignment rate. The percentage of cases closed is falling somewhat as a result of these increases. Table 1 TOTAL NUMBER CASE TOTAL PERCENT OF CASE OF CASES ASSIGNMENT CASES ASSIGNED YEAR INTAKE ASSIGNED RATE CLOSED CASES CLOSED 1982 16, 441 4 , 285 26% 3 , 200 74% 1983 15, 513 4 , 323 27% 3 , 320 76% 1984 15, 173 4 , 822 32% 4 , 172 86% 1985 15, 921 5, 319 33% 4 , 607 86% 1986 18 , 641 6, 687 36% 5, 558 83% 1987 17 , 490 7 , 138 41% 6, 137 85% 1988 17, 124 7 , 298 43% 5, 902 81% 1989 17 , 344 7 , 581 44% 5, 870 77% 1990 18 , 178 7 , 791 42% 5, 790 72% 1991 18 , 165 7 , 668 42% 5, 564 72% 1992* 16, 461 7 , 103 43% 5 , 537 77% *1992 data is projected for the entire year. Table 2 below compares Part I crime statistics from January through September 1991 with the same period in 1992 . Table 2 Number of Crimes Percent Closed Part I Crimes 1991 1992 1991 1992 Murder/Manslaughter 13 4 69% 75% Rape 124 117 60% 63% Robbery 217 200 35% 44% Felonious Assault 986 963 70% 74% Burglary/Forced Entry 1, 329 1, 086 9% 13% Non-forced Entry 12 10 8% 10% Larceny 4, 855 3 , 903 16% 14% UDAA (Stolen Vehicle) 441 477 24% 27% Arson 58 77 17% 25% Total 8 , 035 6, 837 23% 25% 13 SPECIAL OPERATIONS DIVISION REGIONAL ENFORCEMENT AGAINST CRACK HOUSES One of the major target areas of the R.E.A. C.H. Team is the crack house that sells street-level quantities of controlled substances. This multi-faceted Team utilizes resources from all Divisions of the Lansing Police Department. Coordination of these activities is the key to their ultimate success. The R. E.A. C.H. Team has attained the following statistics from January 1, 1992 through September 30, 1992 . Criminal Cases - Violations of Controlled Substances total cases investigated opened . . . . . . . . . 864 cases closed by warrants . . . . . . . . . . . . . 539 other case closures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 No Further Investigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172 pending investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 Of the 768 cases that have been investigated and closed (excluding pending cases) , 596 cases, or 78%, have resulted in warrants or other case closures as of September 30, 1992 . During the first nine months of 1992 , R. E.A. C.H. conducted a total of 88 raids of residences. These raids were preceded by undercover purchases of controlled substances and the issuance of search warrants. Raids and Search warrants raids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 persons arrested . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 284 guns seized . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 The confiscation and forfeiture of drug dealers' monies and property is another essential responsibility of R. E.A. C.H. A total of 402 forfeitures, resulting in the seizure of $109 , 255 . 00, occurred between January and September 1992 . On October 10, 1990, the Landlord/Tenant Program was initiated. One detective, funded by grant monies, is responsible for confirming drug house activity, assisting landlords with evictions of known drug dealers, and presenting cases for prosecution against uncooperative landlords. The major objective is to attack drug dealing from a new front: Tenants prone to deal drugs from rental property now find it difficult to locate housing in Lansing. From January 1 through September 30, 1992 , a total of 562 tips have been received concerning suspected drug houses . A vast 14 majority of the R.E.A.C.H. raids are conducted on rental properties. Additional activity for the detective's position is as follows: tenant removals/evictions . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 contacts with property owners/managers . . . . . . 514 meetings attended with citizens . . . . . . . . . 112 inspections with Building Safety . . . . . . . . . . 43 testimony in civil cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 search warrants obtained . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 Finally, the coordinated efforts of the R. E.A. C.H. Team are not performed solely within the Lansing Police Department. The Probate Court, Prosecutor's Office, School Security, and Social Services agencies have been very cooperative in the overal objective of R.E.A.C.H. 15 TRI-COUNTY METRO NARCOTICS SQUAD This unit is one of the oldest of its kind in the state, having been in existence since 1970. Five Lansing police officers are assigned to this squad, which conducts undercover controlled substance investigations in Ingham, Eaton, and Clinton counties. Seven other local police departments contribute manpower to the unit, while numerous other agencies and municipalities support it through financial contributions that assist in paying officers' salaries. Two Lansing police detectives, two Ingham County prosecutors and a secretary comprise a Drug Asset Forfeiture Team which is attached to the Squad. Remaining operational costs are funded through forfeited drug proceeds. In the twelve months prior to September 1, 1992 , Metro Squad officers arrested 153 persons on drug offenses. Highlights include the following: February 1992 : A lengthy investigation by U. S. Customs, I.R. S. , MSP D. I.C.E. and Tri-County Metro Squad officers continued with the execution of five search warrants in the City of Lansing and Lansing Township in early February. At one location on Roosevelt Street, officers located and seized 210 pounds of high-quality processed marijuana. At another Roosevelt Street address, officers seized approximately $62 , 000 in cash. The investigation continues to look into connections between suspects in Texas and Mexico with those in central and southwest Michigan. Federal indictments and forfeiture actions are anticipated in the future. June 1992 (follow-up to February search warrants) : Metro Squad, City of Lansing, and Federal officers executed two document search warrants on residences in the City of Lansing. Officers seized drug and financial records. This brings the number of search warrants executed in connection with the investigation to six. In addition, nine real estate parcels have been seized for Federal forfeiture along with $62 , 000 in cash. Current Metro officers, along with several former Squad officers, are to be credited for a highly successful investigation of upper-level marijuana trafficking in central and southwest Michigan and Texas. 16 July 1992 : In the largest seizure of the month, Metro officers successfully surveilled a subject who was reportedly transporting large amounts of cocaine into Lansing from the Chicago area. Officers developed information on several individuals reportedly involved in a conspiracy to distribute cocaine and which involved the use of rental vehicles. A reported pattern of activity was verified through surveillance and a traffic stop by Lansing State Police resulted in one arrest and the seizure of approximately a kilogram of cocaine. The investigation is continuing. 17 ANALYSIS UNIT This Unit provides a variety of support services to the Department: crime analysis, research, and personal computer programming/training. Crime Analysis: During the first nine months of 1992 , the Analysis Unit disseminated 143 I-Bulletins. These bulletins contain information concerning individuals who commit serious crimes such as burglaries, narcotics trafficking, robberies, carrying concealed weapons, and sex crimes. Thirty-two individuals who were included in these bulletins were eventually arrested by the Lansing Police Department. Analyses of crime "hot spots" were also performed. Twenty- six Target Area Crime Reports were disseminated in 1992 . These analyses inform the Department of areas that are experiencing an increase in criminal activity. The Analysis Unit is also responsible for maintaining computer files on known offenders, parolees, residents of the New Way In, and other criminal-related information. Research: Requests for information were provided to Departmental members and other City Departments. A total of 115 special data requests were fulfilled. Data is used for a variety of purposes including grant writing, analysis of existing grants, speaking engagements, assisting City Council requests, allocation of Departmental members, and so forth. Two major projects have been initiated. The first consists of researching and implementing a mapping software that will be used to analyze crime data and census data. The second project consists of getting the necessary hardware/software installed so that direct access to the Building Safety Department's rental databases can be obtained. Personal Computer Programming/Training: The Analysis Unit is a major source of knowledge related to the Department' s computerized files. Departmental members frequently request assistance in obtaining information from the computer system and training in the various uses of the computers . New recruit officers are provided a two-hour training session on the Department's computer system. A number of databases located on the personal computers are also maintained by the Analysis Unit. 18 ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT DIVISION ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES BUREAU The Administrative Services Bureau's responsibilities include the following functions: Budget Development/Modifications Payroll Computation Timekeeping Accounts Payable* Procedure Preparation/Coordination Planning Staff Inspections Grant Coordination Operating Under the Influence Cost Recovery Program * Accounts Payable Clerk duties assigned in Personnel and Training Bureau are supervised by the Administrative Services Bureau. During the period January 1, 1992 , through September 30, 1992 , the following accomplishments were made in Bureau functions: Budget The FY92/93 budget process has been started with all department divisions/units. Budget modifications (transfers/change of intent) through the Finance/City Council . General Fund . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Metro/R. E.A. C.H. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Special budget reports/memos prepared . . . . . . . . . . 31 Payroll Bi-weekly payrolls prepared for 355 full-time employees (average payroll $512 , 400) . Weekly payroll prepared for 38 part-time employees (average payroll $4196. 49) . Timekeeping Timekeeping for 355 employees. 19 Accounts Payable Requisitions/invoices processed for all divisions. Procedures Committee meetings conducted . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Procedures developed and distributed (see list below) 4 Planning Planning Documents Prepared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Planning Meetings Attended . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Grant Coordination Budgets Developed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Grant Reports/Documents Prepared . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Grants Approved . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 OUIL Cost Recovery Cased Billed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 358 CasesClosed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 345 Amount Collected . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $32 , 054 . 00 Revised/New Procedures Distributed 79-51 Missing Person/Runaway 79-36 Minor Children 92-106 Police-Related Death or Serious Injury Procedure 92-107 Administrative Duty 20 PERSONNEL AND TRAINING BUREAU In 1992, the Bureau continued to strive for excellence in recruiting, screening, hiring and training of all police personnel. To better accomplish our recruiting objectives, recruiting has been made full-time position. Commitment of additional resources should result in an adequate number of applicants who meet the Department's standards of excellence while representing the diversity of our community. Employment Summary: The following statistical information reflects the activity generated by the Bureau between January 1 and September 30, 1992 . Police Pre-employment Civilian Officers Interviews Personnel Hired' (Police Officer I) Hired Majority Males 2 29 4 Majority Females 1 7 5 Minority Males 4 14 1 Minority Females 1 5 1 Total 8 55 11 'Of eight officers hired, 75. 0% are in protected classes. 2Of eleven civilians hired, 63 . 6% are in protected classes. Protected Class Employment: The Police Department currently employs 114 protected-class personnel in all classifications (32 . 6% of the total work force) . Training Summary: During the first nine months of 1992 the following training programs were conducted/coordinated by the Bureau: 5 Roll Call Training Programs 106 Firearms Sessions 201 In-Service Schools/Programs 25 Schools/Programs at Lansing Community College 7 Out-of-State Training Programs 40 Statewide Training Programs Communicable Disease Training Program: In October 1992 , the Bureau implemented a Communicable Disease training program for all sworn personnel and other non-sworn employees (Detention, Quartermaster) who are at risk for job-related exposure to communicable diseases. The program consists of a three-hour training session that provides education on how communicable diseases are passed from one person to another, prevention procedures, and barrier protection use. 21 TECHNICAL SERVICES DIVISION Major activities and changes over the past year: 911 Communication Center now reports directly to the Deputy Chief. Automated Data Operations now reports to this division. A major reorganization of the basement (old pistol range) storage room will provide storage for three more years of investigative files in the building. An experimental 12-hour work shift has been instituted for the sergeants working in the Detention Bureau. An additional three Detention Officers have been added to provide for additional prisoner safety and security. The Quartermaster personnel have disposed of over 2 , 000 more items than they have received this year. A new alarm ordinance has resulted in the Community Services Unit's ability to collect over $12 , 000 for false burglar alarms. The Radio Lab no longer has a contract with the Ingham County Sheriff to service their radios. The Radio Lab has completed installing new weather warning sirens in the city. Drug Abuse Resistance Education programs will be conducted this school year in all Lansing School District fifth grade classrooms and in five private schools. 22 AUTOMATED DATA OPERATIONS This Unit consists of two persons. Their activity over the past nine months breaks down as follows: Time Activity 16 . 4% project development 11. 3% hardware management and maintenance 16. 7% software and data maintenance 34 . 4% unit administration 4 . 0% produce special reports 9 . 9% assisting users 7 . 3% miscellaneous tasks Large blocks of time have been devoted to the Investigations Division's Survey of Quality, modification of UCR system, investigative report revision and traffic accident report form redesign. 23 COMMUNITY SERVICES UNIT The Community Services Unit provided the following programs and services during the first nine months , of 1992 : speaking engagements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 attendance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 , 989 security surveys residential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 business . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 alarmcontacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126 business cards updated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 198 B&E follow-ups residence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 397 business . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 crime victims, rights verification claim forms prepared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Victims Rights brochures . . . . . . . . . . . . 4, 372 time spent (hours) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177 . 9 senior citizens program programs presented . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 attendance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 242 follow-up visits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 alarms patrol response forms processed . . . . . . . . 1, 825 alarm investigations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 false alarm revenue . . . . . . . . . . . . $12 , 305 . 00 school activities programs attendees preschool . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 . . . . . 646 elementary . . . . . . . . . . . . . 721 . . . . 20, 965 middle school . . . . . . . . . . . 179 . . . . 5, 125 high school . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 . . . . . 890 D.A.R. E. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 190 . . . . 5, 786 crossing guards assignments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 checks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 658 Neighborhood Watch groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 households . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 , 535 contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 931 24 DETENTION BUREAU The Detention Bureau is staffed by one lieutenant, five sergeants and eighteen detention officers. High levels of LEIN traffic and inmates received have kept the Detention personnel extremely busy over the past nine months. The following activity has been recorded by the Detention personnel: Prisoners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 , 645 Prisoners Arraigned . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 , 905 Prisoners Transferred to Ingham County Jail . . . 3 , 242 Warrants/Complaints Obtained by Court Officer . . 8 ,180 LEIN Queries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 , 612 LEIN Administrative Messages . . . . . . . . . 10, 340 Criminal Histories Requested . . . . . . . . . 10, 112 Warrant Hits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 732 Meals Served . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20, 883 25 QUARTERMASTER UNIT The following activity has been recorded during the first nine months of 1992 : The Unit received 3, 353 articles of evidence or found property and has disposed of 5, 392 articles. 298 bicycles were prepared for auction. 311 illegal guns were tagged for destruction by the State Police. 119 articles were shipped to the warehouse for auction. 75 long guns will be auctioned later this year. A jewelry auction was held and 129 items were sold. An additional 745 drug cases were destroyed. 26 RADIO MAINTENANCE BUREAU The following activity has been recorded during the first nine months of 1992 : calls for service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1,709 installations Police . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Fire . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 removals Police . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Fire . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 The Radio Maintenance Bureau also performs radio service for two other law enforcement agencies under a service contract. These agencies are the Lansing Township Police and Lansing Community College. 27 RECORDS UNIT The following activities have been recorded from January to September 1992 : Criminal Records offense reports 17, 133 revenue money received $33 , 966.91 warrants processed 14 , 037 Traffic Records accident reports processed 4 , 361 traffic citations processed 19, 623 Quartermaster Section property received 3 , 353 property disposed 5, 392 Identification Section criminal fingerprints processed 1,858 civilians fingerprinted 1,217 handgun registrations 982 licenses to purchase handguns 880 licenses to purchase denied 36 applicants for CCW licenses 150 applicants for public driver 141 latent prints obtained 982 identifications from latent prints 3 Subpoena officers' Activities subpoenas processed 15,462 officers served 11, 538 civilians served 4, 360 Crime Scene Investigators complaints processed 460 part 1 complaints 306 investigation and court time 1,750 prints lifted 942 persons identified by CSI prints 1 photographs taken 4 , 999 warrants/summonses served 54 28 INTERNAL AFFAIRS UNIT During the period of January 2 , 1992 through September 30, 1992 , the Internal Affairs Unit received 130 formal complaints. These complaints were investigated and given the following dispositions (some cases had multiple dispositions) : Sustained . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 Not sustained . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 Exonerated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Unfounded . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Other misconduct . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 Cases pending . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Cases cancelled by complainant . . . . . . . . . . . 0 The following is a breakdown of the formal complaints for the first nine months of 1992 : Police-initiated complaints against police officers (excluding PD/PI accidents) . . . . . . . 24 Traffic Review Board-initiated complaints . . . . . 19 Civilian-initiated complaints against police officers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 Civilian-initiated complaints against civilian employees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Supervisory-initiated complaints against civilian employees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Civil rights complaints . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Human relations complaints . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 29 LEGAL ADVISOR The general function of the Legal Advisor is to identify specific areas of liability and continually assess the policies, procedures, and rules and regulations of the Department and to initiate solutions or responses to minimize or eliminate potential liability. The regular daily activities of the Legal Advisor include research, the issuance of legal opinions, and consultation with Police personnel on any legal issue having an impact on the law enforcement process. The Legal Advisor acts as liaison between the Police Department and other agencies and departments such as the City Attorney's Office, the Labor Relations Department, and the District Court. In addition, the Legal Advisor drafts responses to civil rights complaints; attends Police Board meetings; assists outside counsel in the defence of civil actions against the City, Department, and employees; and reviews Freedom of Information requests. The following programs and projects were also completed during the first nine months of 1992 : Conducted procedure orientation sessions for newly-hired police officers, detention officers, and newly-promoted supervisors. Drafted Training Bulletins on various topics including case law developments in the areas of arrest, search and seizure, interrogations, and civil liability and new legislation in the areas of firearms and domestic abuse bonding procedures. Represented the Police Department at three resolution conferences and one conciliation conference at the Department of Civil Rights. Drafted responses to all civil rights complaints. Participated in the Procedure Review Committee for the drafting of new and amended operational/administrative procedures. Participated in the program to upgrade suicide prevention efforts in the detention facility, including the development of suicide risk profiles as part of the booking process. 30 ,y. '�` BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ( 1 `Q� 120 W. Michigan Ave. v' Lansing, Michigan 48933 (517) 372-9400 x OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING DECEMBER 15, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL The following Commissioners were present: Canady, Kellogg, Owen, Valdez, Walker, Weis The following Commissioners were absent: Hicks, Osborn APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the November 17 , 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Chief Boles presented an overview of forfeitures. The civil process of forfeitures has been enacted to remove the profits from drug sellers and users. After notification of a property seizure, one can file a bond within 20 days. If they file a bond and follow the administrative steps, the case is referred to the Circuit Court docket. If they do not file a bond, the property or money is automatically forfeited to the jurisdiction that made the forfeiture. There are two full-time detectives assigned to the Metro Squad, under a grant, who are dedicated to asset histories and forfeitures. There are two attorneys who specifically try forfeiture cases through the Prosecutor's office. Also, there is an attorney dedicated to forfeitures in the City Attorney's office. The City Attorney's office handles forfeitures that our REACH team is involved in. The law is very specific on the fact that money and proceeds of real property that is seized and forfeited to a law enforcement agency must be used to enhance drug enforcement. It must impact the sale and delivery of illegal narcotics in the jurisdiction in which it was seized. Currently, we operate two forfeiture accounts. One is for the Tri-County Metro Squad and one is for REACH (Regional Enforcement Against Crack Houses) which is based inside the City of Lansing. The Tri-County Metro Squad averaged over $300, 000 per year in seizures (property and money) over the past five years. REACH averaged $140, 000 per year over the last four years. Since 1988, the City of "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- Lansing has received over $2 .5 million in federal grants to fund drug enforcement programs for the Metro Squad and the REACH team. A large portion of that requires a cash match. Commissioner Walker addressed issues discussed some time ago and suggestions made previously by former Commissioner Jewell. At the February 1992 meeting, a Meetings Committee was formed to: 1) develop alternate sites for special meetings, (2) develop a monthly calendar of activities, and (3) identify educational presentations to be given at monthly Board meetings. Regarding special meetings and sites, the Board is open and ready to respond to the needs as they arise. The educational presentations have been and will continue to be ongoing. There was also previous discussion on a Reports Committee. The Board requested the identification of Police Department documents/reports in which it either provides input, votes on directly or is in some way involved. This list was provided. Commissioner Kellogg suggested that the reports be flagged and brought to the Board's attention a few months in advance of their filing. The Board can then review the documents and decide whether it wants to provide further input. Commissioner Walker inquired as to whether the Special McConnell Task Force, which was set up by the Mayor to review the responsibilities of the various commissions and boards within the City, was still active. Chief Boles thought they were still meeting although not very often. Commissioner Walker clarified the members of the Police Board Committees. Awards & Citations: Commissioner Valdez, Chairperson Commissioners Canady, Osborn, Owen, and Weis Human Resource: Commissioner Hicks, Chairperson Commissioners Canady and Osborn Budget: Commissioner Kellogg, Chairperson Commissioners Hicks and Weis Chief Boles reported that while we are in the process of reviewing the Maguire Fund, it appears as though the fund is defunct and there is no need for the Board to have a representative. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O.P. Non-Supervisors Division. He reported that informal negotiations with the Chief and his Staff are progressing very well. -3- COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Chief Boles, Barb Cafineyer, Child Benefit Fund, Inc. , Harry Jack Davis, Dr. Hiram L. Davis, Mary E. Harris, Dr. R. Michael Holaday, Dennis M. McCarthy, Dr. Robert Trojanowicz, Michael Walsh, and Dale Wilson. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS RESIGNATIONS . RETIREMENTS The confirmations of Officer Susan Howell and Officer Stephen D. Klein were accepted. There were no resignations. The retirements of Officer Ronald Bogart, Sergeant James Gleason, Gayle LaCoursier, Sergeant Peter Loepke, Detention Officer Jacqueline McCook, Sergeant Ronald Middaugh, Officer Lowel Nash, Detective Charles Shawnee, Technician Donna Stout, and Technician James Wallace were accepted with regrets. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints against the Department. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Commissioner Walker asked that the Human Resource Committee be involved with recruiting efforts in the Personnel and Training Bureau. The Departmental Highlights Report for November 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards: The Awards Ceremony will take place tomorrow evening, Wednesday, December 16, 7 : 00 p.m. , at Lansing Community College, Dart Auditorium. Human Resource: No report. Budget: Commissioner Kellogg reported that the Budget Committee discussed and approved the budget as submitted. It now will go to the Mayor. Special McConnell Task Force: No report. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS Commissioner Walker addressed the suggestion of the citizen, Mr. Bernie Meissner, who attended the November Board meeting. Mr. Meissner suggested that the complainant be informed as each step of the complaint investigation occurs in L.P.D. He also suggested that there be an appeal process. Commissioner Walker met with Paul McComb and indicated that the current complaint process allows for any Board -4- member with a citizen's complaint to have the flexibility of following up based on information sought. A formal complaint is investigated, and the appropriate unit assigned the complaint does communicate with the complainant at the end of the process. If the complainant wants information. on the progression of the complaint, he/she can call in and get that information. Board members can engage in that process; however, in order to maintain credibility in the appeal process, the Board elects to stay out of the step-by-step process. Commissioner Walker is satisfied with the current procedure for handling complaints. Commissioner Kellogg inquired about the condition of Officer Bill Fabijancic. Chief Boles reported that he had started radiation, his spirits are good, and that we are hopeful. Members expressed their concern and that they often thought of him. Commissioner- Kellogg mentioned that Dr. Hiram Davis attended a City Council meeting, again raising the issue of the bus station search incident involving his son. He was complimentary of the Chief and Commissioner Walker for their help. It was thought that Dr. Davis wanted City Council to be aware of the policy and take a position on it. As this case was referred to the Human Relations Department, Chief Boles gave the Human Relations Board a synopsis of the action taken by the Police Board, Commissioner Walker, and himself. Chief Boles thought that the lack of contact between the Michigan State Police and the parties involved was a problem. He reiterated that L.P.D. no longer participates in that program. In relation to the responsibilities of the Board under Charter, Commissioner Weis expressed a concern for the possibility of underselling those responsibilities. Because of the number and highly publicized accusations of excessive force, Commissioner Weis is concerned that police officers will be afraid and may hesitate to respond in situations that necessitate immediate reactions. Commissioner Weis inquired as to what the Department is doing to balance the possibility of officers underreacting. Chief Boles said that the Department is aware of the fine line between overreacting and underreacting. Through ongoing, repetitive training and procedures, we can help officers make those decisions. L.P.D. has the most extensive firearms training in Michigan for this reason. Our officers are taught to react to good training in accordance with solid law and policy. Commissioner Weis asked for a presentation on the new Use of Force Procedure when it is complete. Commissioner Walker suggested that we review all the recommendations made as a result of the Torrez incident and perhaps make a public statement on what the Police Department has done. There was discussion on holding a Board meeting at another location perhaps Cristo Rey in an effort to be proactive in the community. -5- Commissioner Owen reminded the Board of its desire to sponsor a P.A.L. team. Each member should make their $31. 25 check payable to the Lansing Police Athletic League. The P.A.L. program continues to grow. Officer Kim Lawrence reported that an $8, 000 grant from the Lansing Housing Commission will be used in community housing projects. We have community policing officers in three of those areas. The Community Foundation will grant $3 , 400 directed toward intensive middle school programs. We might need girls' team coaches. Transportation to Eastern High School for games may be a problem. Commissioner Canady volunteered to provide van transportation. Commissioner Valdez suggested inquiring about the use of Cristo Rey buses. Commissioner Owen reaffirmed the popularity and need for P.A.L. He is on the Program Committee of the Lansing Foundation which has earmarked significant funds to P.A.L. Commissioner Owen also mentioned that someone involved with the Lansing Youth Recreation fund has leftover equipment which P.A.L. could use. This person is also a potential Board member. Commissioner Owen will contact Officer Kim Lawrence with that information. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles encouraged everyone to attend the Awards Ceremony tomorrow night. He will be making a special presentation to Sergeant Ron Middaugh as it will be his last program after several years. Chief Boles mentioned the L.P.D. reorganization attached to the Board packet. It will go before two Council committees this week and will hopefully be approved at the January 4 City Council meeting. For next month's presentation, Chief Boles suggested having Director Charles Bauer discuss the AT&T Language Line Services. Through the Communications Center, we are now able to interpret and communicate in 140 languages. OTHER BUSINESS Commissioner Walker and Chief Boles extended holiday greetings to the entire Board. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board . �iJUJrrlmiiu�r�i BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS Otic �� Q1\ I+�r�' 120 W. Michigan Ave. t. w Lansing, Michigan 48933 L) (517)372-9400 P �i�mrmnlm[J OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE ,. POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING NOVEMBER 17 , 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL The following Commissioners were present: Hicks, Kellogg, Owen, Walker, Weis The following Commissioners were absent: Canady, Osborn, Valdez APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the October 20, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Sergeant Ron Clevenger, Internal Affairs Unit, gave a presentation on the Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run.- The Law Enforcement Torch Run (L. E.T.R. ) began in Kansas City in 1982 . A group of officers organized a run and donated the money to Special Olympics. Currently, 48 states and approximately 14 countries are involved in the L.E.T.R. In 19851 the Michigan L.E.T.R. invited the Lansing Police Department to become involved. To date, Lansing has been responsible for raising over $75, 000 for Special Olympics. We have participated in a five-day run through 15 cities in the State to generate money. Over the last two years, $80, 000 was generated in those 15 cities. In 1985, the first year, $6, 000 was raised in the State of Michigan. The goal this year was to raise $325, 000. We have thus far raised $344 , 000 and we're still counting. Michigan was the number one state in the nation this year in money raised. Sergeant Clevenger thanked the Police Board, the Mayor, Chief Boles, and former Chiefs Gleason and Reifsnyder for their support. On behalf of Michigan Special Olympics, Sergeant Clevenger presented a plaque to Chief Boles for the Lansing Police Department's years of dedication. He also presented a plaque to Commissioner John Weis as a representative for Lansing General Hospital, a Silver Medal Sponsor ($500 donor) for the last two years. Ms. Dorothy Carr, Neighborhood Watch Coordinator for 233 East Central, received a plaque in recognition of the hard work and effort put forth "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- by her and others in her area. They raised $788 for the L. E.T.R. The Board applauded the efforts of Ms. Carr and all involved in helping raise money in that neighborhood. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC Mr. Bernie Meissner, 635 LaSalle Boulevard, Lansing, was present to comment on the procedure for filing citizen complaints against the Lansing Police Department. He suggested that the complainant be informed as each step of the investigation occurs. He asked if there was an appeal process and indicated that he thought there should be one. As a step toward good community/police relations, he would like a member of the Police Board to follow up with complainants to find out whether their complaints were handled properly. Commissioner Walker said that the Board would take Mr. Meissner's suggestion under advisement. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O.P. Non-Supervisors Division. He reported that they have filed with the City to open negotiations as their contract expires January 15, 1993 . They are waiting for a response in order to plan negotiations. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Anonymous Lansing man; Carol Alexander; Steve and Mary Babcock; Chief Boles; Mark Holliday; Diane Johnston; Dolly and Ron Lyon; M. S.U. , Dept. of Public Safety; Patricia Miller; Family of Dale Ostrander; Jerry Speedy; and Sheriff Wriggelsworth. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS, RESIGNATIONS, RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations or resignations. The retirements of Detention Officer David Benson and Dianna Emerson were accepted with regrets. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT Commissioner Walker acknowledged the Civil Rights Complaint of Dennis White. He said that the Board would, be appropriately informed as this case progresses. REPORTS OF OFFICERS There was discussion on forfeiture money and property and its use by the Lansing Police Department. Chief Boles said that the Lansing Police Department was the subject of a forfeiture review a short time ago by Stuart Dunnings, the attorney for the City Human Relations -3- Board. Mr. Dunnings concluded that L.P.D. forfeiture procedures are acceptable. The Departmental Highlights Report for October 1992 was accepted and placed on file.. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards: The Awards Ceremony will take place on Wednesday, December 16, 7 : 00 p.m. , at Lansing Community College, Dart Auditorium. Human Resources: No report. Budget: While Commissioner Kellogg was unable to attend, the Department's divisional budget review meetings took place the week of November 2 . On December 10, 1992 , 11: 30 a.m. , 2nd floor classroom, the Budget along with recommended new programs will be presented to the Board. Board members will receive the necessary budget material in advance for review before the meeting. Special McConnell Task Force: No report. Commissioner Walker assigned Commissioner Canady to the Human Resources Committee. Commissioner Weis was assigned to the Budget Committee. Both Commissioners Canady and Weis were assigned to the Awards and Citation Committee. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS Commissioner Owen personally thanked the Lansing police officers who participated in the Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run. Commissioner Owen's daughter has been involved in and benefited from various special Olympics activities. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that Officer Bill Fabijancic, who gave a Community Policing presentation to the Board a few months ago, has been diagnosed with a brain tumor. He is undergoing tests to determine treatment. We are all very concerned about him. Also, Geri Neil, a resident of Officer Fabijancic's neighborhood and an organizer of G.L.A.D. , was hospitalized in a coma last month. While she is now at home, it appears that she is mentally impaired as a result of the coma. It is anticipated that G.L.A.D. will be reorganizing and active again. Chief Boles, as a P.A.L. Board member, asked for assistance in obtaining adult role models to participate in some way with individual P.A.L. basketball teams during the season. While coaching and organizational tasks are taken care of, it would be extremely beneficial if the youth had positive adult role models to perhaps -4- provide transportation, etc. Commissioner Walker encouraged Board members to spread the word on this program as it is progressing and making a difference in the community. Commissioner Hicks suggested and agreed to coordinate the Police Board's sponsoring of a P.A.L. team. Chief Boles will provide a forfeiture update at next month's meeting. OTHER BUSINESS Commissioner Walker updated the Board on communications with Dr. Hiram Davis. Dr. Davis' son was involved in a search incident a few months ago on a Greyhound bus. Commissioner Walker and Chief Boles met with Dr. Davis. Commissioner Canady also communicated with him. We wanted to alleviate fears that Dr. Davis' son was targeted for any reason. We explained the drug search program and that if the program is continued, it would be carried out by L.P.D. officers. Dr. Davis seemed to be satisfied with our communications. Commissioner Walker asked the Board to review the Evaluation Report and present any questions or comments within the next week. It will be submitted to the Mayor in approximately one week. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board yy6(Oprrrrrtnr��rciii.,,,., � ' for_A BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ?0 120 W. Michigan Ave. r Lansing, Michigan 48933 (517) 372-9400 � - �-%:7II7ilI1iIflL�it� OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD E OF THE CITY OF LANSING G C SEPTEMBER 15, 1992 -" The meeting was called to order by Vice-Chairperson Kellogg. ROLL CALL The following Commissioners were present: Hicks, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez The following Commissioners were absent: Canady, Walker, Weis APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the August 18, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O. P. Non-Supervisors Division. He reported that the F.O. P. Supervisors will begin arbitration next week. Officer Baylis reported for P.A. L. that they have acquired another business sponsor, MC Sporting Goods. The soccer league is practicing now to begin games next week. Updates from P.A.L. are forthcoming. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Phyllis Ball, Chief Boles, John and Teressa Staten, Sergeant George, Neighborhood Watch Advisory Board, Patricia C. Uetz, Sheriff Wriggelsworth, Richard and Mary Alice Yeiter. All communications were accepted and placed on file. "Eaual O000rtunity Emnlover" -2= CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS The retirement of James A. Hepfer, Chief Radio Engineer, was accepted and placed on file. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints against the Department. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for August 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - No report. Special McConnell Task Force - No report. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS All Board members received a September 8 letter from Dr. Hiram L. Davis concerning a recent drug search incident involving his son on a Greyhound bus. Commissioner Owen inquired as to how the Department would be responding. Chief Boles explained that upon receipt of the letter on September 10, he called Dr. Davis. Commissioner Canady informed Chief Boles that he also contacted Dr. Davis to offer his services. In this particular incident, the Lansing Police Department was assisting the Michigan State Police (M.S.P. ) D. I . C.E. team in a drug interdiction effort at the bus station. While L. P. D. officers were at the bus station, L. P. D. officers did not make contact with Dr. Davis ' son or another African American male whose parents have complained. The officers involved are State Police command officers, not members of the Lansing Police Department. M.S. P. was in charge of the program. Since that time, we have asked M. S . P. not to come into our city until we 've evaluated whether we want to continue participation in the program. If we do, we want L.P. D. officers more involved as they have been trained in our techniques. Our officers do not have first-hand knowledge of the search on the bus as they were outside the bus. The searched occurred on the bus. The Chief will discuss Dr. Davis ' letter with Commissioner Walker and will report back at the next meeting. -3- CHIEF'S COMMENTS At the last meeting, it was requested that someone from Crime Analysis give a presentation tonight. No one was available. However, they reported that their Unit has not undergone any changes since their last presentation. As a reminder and for the benefit of new members, they have provided a handout on their duties/responsibilities and examples of a Crime Report and Intelligence Bulletin. Commissioner Hicks suggested that the area of drug enforcement be addressed at the next meeting. Chief Boles agreed to ask Captain Rapp, Special Operations Division, to attend the October 20 meeting. The Chief had nothing to report on the Budget. However, Dianna Emerson, Budget Control Supervisor, and Gayle LaCoursier, Payroll Clerk, are taking advantage of the early retirement package. We are beginning to train other employees to take over their responsibilities. City Council has confirmed a new Police Commissioner to replace Richard Jewell. John Weis, a Vice Preident at Lansing General Hospital, has assisted us in our strategic planning sessions. He, therefore, has some knowledge of the Police Department through that process. The Chief assured the Board that they would find him to be a concerned individual . The members that already know Commissioner Weis look forward to his participation. In follow up to Commissioner Walker' s request, Board records were researched and it was found that at the July 21, 1987 meeting, Commissioner McConnell made a motion to recognize ex-Commissioners Roush and McManus with plaques. The Minutes did not indicate that this would be an ongoing procedure. It was the general feeling of the Board that those members who provided extraordinary service should be recognized. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board :� 1►fr'" ....... '':;� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS WO W. Micl gmi nvc Ii I I wising, Miclii{Inn .189:13 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING AUGUST 18 , 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL All Commissioners were present: Canady, Hicks, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the June 16, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ELECTION OF OFFICERS Commissioner Walker called for the nomination of officers. Commissioner Kellogg nominated Commissioner Walker to another term as Chairperson. This single nomination was supported and carried unanimously. Commissioner Owen nominated Commissioner Kellogg as vice-Chairperson. With no further nominations, Commissioner Kellogg was unanimously elected as Vice Chairperson. At this time, Commissioner Walker elected to maintain the same members as 1991-92 for all Committees in 1992-93 . ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Author, Pat Heyden, introduced her book, "Behind the Badge: The History of the Lansing Police Department" . She gave an overview of the six years of research leading to its development. The book is available through 14 libraries or it may be purchased. Chief Boles added that Pat has also put together a narrated slide presentation on highlights of her book. In 1993 , the Lansing Police Department will be celebrating its Centennial . Pat will be working with the Department and the City on historical exhibitions and activities in this regard. The Board expressed interest in becoming involved in the celebration. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- Officer Loren Glasscock gave a presentation on Neighborhood Watch and National Night Out. There are currently 166 Neighborhood Watch groups. This equates to 13 , 000 residences or 40, 000 people. The emphasis is on building up weaker Neighborhood Watches and increasing the understanding that the Watches benefit all involved. To kick off National Night Out, City Council held an open-air meeting at Durant Park. Over 300 people were in attendance. Lansing, East Lansing, Eaton and Ingham Counties, and Meridian Township participated in this year' s National Night Out held on August 4 . Officers Marie Wolfe and Kim Lawrence spoke on the formation of the Police Athletic League (P.A. L. ) . As a non-profit organization, they have joined the National Police Athletic League in order to acquire necessary insurance. Bylaws have been written and will be discussed at the next meeting. The P.A. L. Board of Directors will include one member from the Board of Police Commissioners. After the next meeting, one of the Police Board members will be approached. P.A. L. is currently focused on implementing programs in Community Policing areas . The idea is to offer programs that these kids would not otherwise have an opportunity to participate in -- canoeing, camping, horseback riding, snow skiing, etc. Volunteer LPD sworn and civilian employees will help as coaches or referees. Commissioner Walker commended Chief Boles for his involvement in the gang/drug conferences and with P.A. L. He believes that the success of these activities is due to the Chief ' s efforts. Commissioner Hicks commended the officers and their undying efforts. Chief Boles also commended the officers involved in P.A. L. for their energy and commitment. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O. P. Non-Supervisors Division but had no business to report. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Officer Craig Baylis, Bill and Mary Ann Evert; Lisa Fisk, YMCA; Jo Flaherty; Resident Agent McCarthy, U. S . Secret Service; E. S . Starnes, Michigan National Bank; John and Teressa Staten; Hazel Trebilcock; Lt. J. M. Zelnik, U. S . Navy Security Office. Commissioner Walker expressed his personal regrets regarding the death of Officer Johnathan Staten. All communications were accepted and placed on file. -3- CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS RETIREMENTS The following were accepted and placed on file: the confirmation of Officers Robert Merritt and Steven Stafford; the resignation of Officers Joseph Diaz and Michael Ferland, and Detention Officer Joseph Eisfelder; and the retirement of Park Security Officer David Henderson and Detective Ronald Lyon. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT The Fiscal Year Summary of Civil Rights Complaints was accepted and placed on file. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Reports for June and July 1992 were accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. However, they are in need of another person. Budget - No report. See Chief ' s Comments. Special McConnell Task Force - See Commissioners ' Comments. COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS Commissoner Osborn inquired as to the outcome of the public forums implemented by the Special McConnell Task Force. Chief Boles reported that participation increased with each one held. He is extremely satisfied with the outcome. There was considerable discussion on all five forums and on future efforts to keep communications open. Commissioner Owen complimented the Mayor on his participation and input into the forums. Jo Flaherty commended Officer Danny King on his outstanding moderation of the gay/lesbian forum held at Club Paradise. Commissioner Kellogg asked if there is a standard type of recognition for outgoing Police Board members. Commissioner Walker and others recalled the presentation of a plaque for an outgoing member at the annual Awards Ceremony. As there was discussion at a previous Board meeting on this subject, Commissioner Walker requested that past minutes be researched to determine what was decided. CHIEF ' S COMMENTS Chief Boles asked the Board for direction on next month' s Departmental presentation. Commissioner Osborn expressed interest ih hearing from -4- the Crime Analysis Unit even though they gave a presentation approximately one year ago. Commissioner Hicks mentioned the juvenile area. Chief Boles defined the areas involving juveniles -- physical abuse of youth or juveniles accused of crimes in the Detective Bureau. Chief Boles reported that Budget directives are not out yet from the Finance Department. However, we are probably looking at a maintenance budget for next year. The various divisions are working on their goals, objectives, and mission statements in order to coincide with work plans. The Budget will then be more structured in terms of allocation to each Department program. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board �i111NInli7ltrljjj� .� qHs� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ti5`s i, c �iQ� 120 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing, Michigan 48933 6 (517) 372-9400 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING JUNE 16, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Vice-Chairperson Sharon Kellogg. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Canady, Jewell, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez Commissioners absent: Johnson, Walker ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Chief Boles gave a presentation on Grants. Most L.P. D. grants are from State-funded sources -- typically agencies that are screening vehicles for federal funds. Generally, the grants have been through the Office of Criminal Justice, Office of Highway ,Traffic Safety, the Department of Commerce, the Department of Education, and/or the Department of Transportation. Since the City Grants Coordinator position was eliminated in 1989, each department has been responsible for the administration of its own grants. Our Administrative Services Lieutenant monitors the administration of the grants, but does not actively seek available out-of-state funds as was previously done by the Grants Coordinator. While grants enable us to expand or explore new programs, they are a vexation when funds expire. Programs are not picked up under the General Fund Budget, because grant positions are in addition to the Department 's authorized strength. This year, we have nine (9) grant positions paid for by City match, drug match and grant monies programmed into our budget. The nine (9) grant positions include: 1. Two (2) Asset Seizure Detectives in the Metro Narcotics Unit to seize assets and convert property to cash. The cash is used to enhance drug enforcement, defray operational expenses of the Metro Unit, and pay cash match for grants. 2 . One (1) Police Officer under the Transportation Center grant who has Community Policing and bus station duties. This grant is paid for by the Transportation Department, State of Michigan, to patrol the arrival/departures of buses. 3 . Through the Office of Criminal Justice COPS grant, two (2) Community Police Officers. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- 4 . Under Street-Level Drug Enforcement, one (1) Landlord/Tenant Detective and one (1) Sergeant who coordinates the Community Policing effort and street-level drug enforcement. 5 . One (1) Detective currently. in jeopardy under the UDAA/Auto Theft Authority Grant. It was caught in the political wrangling of the no-fault bill to reestablish Auto Theft Authority. We are hoping . that it will be passed. If not, we're looking at the demotion of a detective and the elimination of an entry-level position, because these are in addition to our authorized strength. 6. One (1) Community Police Officer in a new area through the Community Partnership Grant. At renewal time, there is the possibility of expanding this program to allow for one more Community Police Officer. The Lansing Housing Commission was awarded a HUD grant to help residents and youth in housing developments. Because of this grant and through a unique contract with the Lansing Housing Commission, we have three (3) Community Police Officer positions that cover all major developments in the City. This program which is 100% funded through the Lansing Housing Commission has been very successful . In summary, we currently have the capability to fill twelve (12) positions to be funded by outside sources. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the May 20, 1992 Special Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O.P. Non-Supervisors Division. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Chief Jerry Boles; Dennis Dorin, Capitol Cadillac; Jo Flaherty; Catherine Haas; Ruth Hallman, Neighborhood Watch #120; Mark Lanier, M.S .U. ; Amy Magistro, Purchasing; John Metts, Lansing Twp. P. D. ; Neighborhood Youth & Parent Prevention Partnership; Paul Novak, Westside Neighborhood Association; Donald Owens, Ingham County Probate Judge; Jack Phillips, Bath Charter Twp. ; F/Lt. Robert Powers, Michigan State Police; Col . Michael Robinson, Michigan State Police; Councilmember Alfreda Schmidt; Terri Fore Sulton, Peckham Vocational Industries; Jane White/Janet Strahan, LCC-Criminal Justice & Law -3- Center; Chris Stuchell, Lansing Housing Commission; Paul and Sherri Wiegman, Cherry Hill Neighborhood; Ingham County Sheriff Gene Wriggelsworth. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS, RETIREMENTS The confirmation of Officer James Kraus as a Police Officer I and the retirements of Officer Robert Lee Jones, Lt. Robert McClean, and Georgians Viele were accepted and placed on file.. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Commissioner Jewell asked for an explanation of a toy gun incident mentioned in the May Highlights in which the Prosecutor refused to issue a felonious assault charge. Paul McComb agreed to research the incident with the Assistant Prosecutor and report back. The Departmental Highlights Reports for April and May 1992 were accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - No report. Special McConnell Task Force - This committee is comprised of representatives from the Mayor' s Police Community Relations Board, the Human Relations Board, the Board of Police Commissioners, and two staff members. Commissioners Jewell and Osborn have been the representatives from the -Police Board. Commissioner Jewell reported that the original assignment of the McConnell Task Force was to review and define the roles of each Board and to succinctly define the purpose of the Task Force. Members of the Police Board agreed that the differences, similarities and responsibilities of each Board should be defined. In an effort to find out what the community wants, the McConnell Task Force decided to hold five two-hour community forums. Each Board will have one or two representatives on each forum panel . Commissioner Jewell recommended that the Board agree to the five forums being coordinated by the Task Force. Commissioner Osborn moved that the Board approve and agree to participate in the five community forums. The motion was seconded and carried. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Osborn inquired about the enforcement of the noise ordinance in connection with vehicle owners playing their audio sound -4- systems so loudly that it affects ones quality of life. Chief Boles replied that it is a high priority with the first shift Traffic Unit. Community Policing officers are being bombarded with residents ' complaints on this issue. The idea was discussed of having .a newspaper reporter write a story on this problem and what the Police Department is doing about it. It was generally thought that this would have a positive effect on the number and frequency of offenders. It would also communicate to the community that the Police Department is aware and will be enforcing the noise ordinance. Commissioner Jewell said that he and Chief Boles would be developing a list of topics to be presented at future Board meetings. A reminder was made by Commissioner Kellogg that elections for the Chairperson and Vice Chairperson positions will be held at the July 21 meeting. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the meeting with the Parks Department Board is tomorrow night, June 17 . The purpose is to review the Parks patrol plan since the elimination of Parks Police. The Chief is very satisfied with the efforts of Captain James Cook, Uniform Division, in terms of the approach to those problems. He believes that Parks coverage will be quite satisfactory.. The voluntary reduction in the work force from early retirements will impact the Police Department as we anticipate 4-6 people leaving in a couple of key areas. The Cultural Diversity Program schedule was distributed. Chief Boles asked that interested members contact his office or Personnel and Training to schedule a session. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board �F"'LpAa BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing. Michigan 48933 �d CNIGP' OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING APRIL 21, 1992 � t' 4.= 1 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Johnson, Kellogg, Osborn, Walker Commissioners absent: Owen, Valdez Brinton Butler, Systems Analysis Manager, attended to give a presentation on Automated Data Operations. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Brinton Butler explained the operations of the Law Enforcement Management System (LEMS) data system. The major operations include: collection and dissemination of specific information; management information and summaries; crime analysis; and process control. The following items were mentioned as future goals: on-line mugshots; electronic mail; automated Quartermaster (dissemination of uniform supplies; maintenance/storage of property and evidence) ; and computerized report writing. We are currently looking for a new computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system for the Communications Center. The system will incorporate in- car terminals from which LEMS can be accessed. Therefore, the CAD system will need to be integrated with LEMS. Commissioner Osborn asked about the growth potential/life cycle of our current computer system. Brinton explained that we replaced the system in December 1990 and its expected life span is five years. At one and one-half years into that, the Hewlett Packard system is adequate. As our five-year lease/purchase agreement expires, it is expected that we will upgrade the system. Board members expressed their appreciation for Brinton ' s very informative presentation. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1 The Minutes of last month' s regular Board meeting were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no F.O.P. representatives present. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Joseph Borczak, Carol Bucher, Frank D. Holmes, Gloria Morris, D/Lt. J. Patrick, J. Plane, Councilmember Schmidt, Ralph Taylor, and Bob Trojanowicz . All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for March 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - See Chief' s Comments. Leonard McConnell Task Force - Commissioner Jewell reported that the Task Force met on April 13 . It was decided that the next meeting scheduled for May 18 , 5: 00 p.m. , in the 2nd floor classroom, would be focused on education and intervention. Meetings - Commissioner Osborn suggested that these Committee meetings be left open for any Commissioners able to attend. Commissioner Walker volunteered to be a member of this Committee. It was decided that the regular- meeting of the Board will be held -3- at the Neighborhood Watch Picnic, Francis Park on Tuesday, May 19, 5 : 00-8 : 00 p.m. Commissioner Jewell will obtain parking passes to be mailed to Board members for entrance to Francis Park. Chief Boles encouraged everyone to attend this worthwhile event. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Regarding the Torres Ad Hoc Committee, Commissioner Walker reported that the Committee has completed its work and would be submitting its report to the Mayor tomorrow, April 22 . The Mayor will determine how/if this information will be released. Commissioner Walker communicated that a great deal of time, pains, and effort went into the development of this report. CHIEF ' S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the Mayor' s proposed Police Department budget is $14 , 750, 000 for next year. The elimination of Parks Police translates to $70, 000 less than originally asked for. The Budget approval and future of Parks Police is presently at the Council level. On Monday, April 27, 7 : 00 p.m. , at Council Chambers, loth floor, City Hall, there will be a ceremony posthumously honoring Commissioner Leonard McConnell . A resolution and picture will be presented to the family by Commissioner Walker and the Mayor. As part of National Volunteer Week, Commissioner McConnell is also being recognized as an outstanding Board volunteer. The McConnell family members have been informed of the ceremony. Chief Boles encouraged all Board members to attend if possible. Chief Boles asked that the vision/mission statements, goals and strategies attached to last month' s and this month' s agenda be approved. They will then be forwarded to the Mayor and City Council . After final approval , the divisions can then develop work plans to address their objectives as they relate to the nine goals . The Board unanimously approved the statements, goals and strategies. A neighborhood office in the Cristo Rey Community Center has been opened for the use of a district officer. This is an initiative to expand the community policing concept without assigning a community policing officer. In order to spread the community policing philosophy, we anticipate increased utilization of existing resources for other areas of the City. OTHER BUSINESS Regarding the use of the chemical agent, Freeze, Commissioner Walker supported it. He thought that any instrument an officer can use that might prevent the use of firearms or the use of -4- night sticks would be a helpful instrument. There was general discussion on the guidelines for the use of Freeze. Commissioner Jewell moved that the Board support the Department' s use of Freeze on a trial basis. The motion was supported by Commissioner Johnson and carried. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, C�z)Ito Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board Tl ' :rl A�� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS s� o �� -_ 120 W. Michigan Ave. �� " Lansing, Michigan 48933 =_a ( :) (517)372-9400 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING NOVEMBER 17 , 1992 e•_ The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. t L'. I ROLL CALL The following Commissioners were present: Hicks, Kellogg, Owen, Walker, Weis The following Commissioners were absent: Canady, Osborn, Valdez APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the October 20, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Sergeant Ron Clevenger, Internal Affairs Unit, gave a presentation on the Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run.- The Law Enforcement Torch Run (L.E.T.R. ) began in Kansas City in 1982 . A group of officers organized a run and donated the money to Special Olympics. Currently, 48 states and approximately 14 countries are involved in the L. E.T.R. In 1985, the Michigan L.E.T.R. invited the Lansing Police Department to become involved. To date, Lansing has been responsible for raising over $75, 000 for Special Olympics. We have participated in a five-day run through 15 cities in the State to generate money. Over the last two years, $80, 000 was generated in those 15 cities. In 1985, the first year, $6, 000 was raised in the State of Michigan. The- goal this year was to raise $325, 000. We have thus far raised $344 , 000 and we're still counting. Michigan was the number one state in the nation this year in money raised. Sergeant Clevenger thanked the Police Board, the Mayor, Chief Boles, and former Chiefs Gleason and Reifsnyder for their support. On behalf of Michigan Special Olympics, Sergeant Clevenger presented a plaque to Chief Boles for the Lansing Police Department's years of dedication. He also presented a plaque to Commissioner John Weis as a representative for Lansing General Hospital, a Silver Medal Sponsor ($500 donor) for the last two years. Ms. Dorothy Carr, Neighborhood Watch Coordinator for 233 East Central, received a plaque in recognition of the hard work and effort put forth "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- by her and others in her area. They raised $788 for the L.E.T.R. The Board applauded the efforts of Ms. Carr and all involved in helping raise money in that neighborhood. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC Mr. Bernie Meissner, 635 LaSalle Boulevard, Lansing, was present to comment on the procedure for filing citizen complaints against the Lansing Police Department. He suggested that the complainant be informed as each step of the investigation occurs. He asked if there was an appeal process and indicated that he thought there should be one. As a step toward good community/police relations, he would like a member of the Police Board to follow up with complainants to find out whether their complaints were handled properly. Commissioner Walker said that the Board would take Mr. Meissner's suggestion under advisement. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O.P. Non-Supervisors Division. He reported that they have filed with the City to open negotiations as their contract expires January 15, 1993 . They are waiting for a response in order to plan negotiations. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Anonymous Lansing man; Carol Alexander; Steve and Mary Babcock; Chief Boles; Mark Holliday; Diane Johnston; Dolly and Ron Lyon; M. S.U. , Dept. of Public Safety; Patricia Miller; Family of Dale Ostrander; Jerry Speedy; and Sheriff Wriggelsworth. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS, RESIGNATIONS, RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations or resignations. The retirements of Detention Officer David Benson and Dianna Emerson were accepted with regrets. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT Commissioner Walker acknowledged the Civil Rights Complaint of Dennis White. He said that the Board would be appropriately informed as this case progresses. REPORTS OF OFFICERS There was discussion on forfeiture money and property and its use by the Lansing Police Department. Chief Boles said that the Lansing Police Department was the subject of a forfeiture review a short time ago by Stuart Dunnings, the attorney for the City Human Relations -3- I Board. Mr. Dunnings concluded that L.P.D. forfeiture procedures are acceptable. The Departmental Highlights Report for October 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS i Awards: The Awards Ceremony will take place on Wednesday, December 16, 7: 00 p.m. , at Lansing Community College, Dart Auditorium. Human Resources: No report. Budget: While Commissioner Kellogg was unable to attend, the Department's divisional budget review meetings took place the week of November 2 . On December 10, 1992 , 11: 30 a.m. , 2nd floor classroom, the Budget along with recommended new programs will be presented to the Board. Board members will receive the necessary budget material in advance for review before the meeting. Special McConnell Task Force: No report. Commissioner Walker assigned Commissioner Canady to the Human Resources Committee. Commissioner Weis was assigned to the Budget Committee. Both Commissioners Canady and Weis were assigned to the Awards and Citation Committee. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS Commissioner Owen personally thanked the Lansing police officers who participated in the Special Olympics Law Enforcement Torch Run. Commissioner Owen's daughter has been involved in and benefited from various Special Olympics activities. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that Officer Bill Fabijancic, who gave a Community Policing presentation to the Board a few months ago, has been diagnosed with a brain tumor. He is undergoing tests to determine treatment. We are all very concerned about him. Also, Geri Neil, a resident of Officer Fabijancic's neighborhood and an organizer of G.L.A.D. , was hospitalized in a coma last month. While she is now at home, it appears that she is mentally impaired as a result of the coma. It is anticipated that G.L.A.D. will be reorganizing and active again. Chief Boles, as a P.A.-L. Board member, asked for assistance in obtaining adult role models to participate in some way with individual P.A.L. basketball teams during the season. While coaching and organizational tasks are taken care of, it would be extremely beneficial if the youth had positive adult role models to perhaps -4- provide transportation, etc. Commissioner Walker encouraged Board members to spread the word on this program as it is progressing and making a difference in the community. Commissioner Hicks suggested and agreed to coordinate the Police Board's sponsoring of a P.A.L. team. Chief Boles will provide a forfeiture update at next month's meeting. OTHER BUSINESS Commissioner Walker updated the Board on communications with Dr. Hiram Davis. Dr. Davis' son was involved in a search incident a few months ago on a Greyhound bus. Commissioner Walker and Chief Boles met with Dr. Davis. Commissioner Canady also communicated with him. We wanted to alleviate fears that Dr. Davis' son was targeted for any reason. We explained the drug search program and that if the program is continued, it would be carried out by L.P.D. officers. Dr. Davis seemed to be satisfied with our communications. Commissioner Walker asked the Board to review the Evaluation Report and present any questions or comments within the next week. It will be submitted to the Mayor in approximately one week. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, o-��(c Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. f _ Lansing, Michigan 48933 F Z (517) 372-9400 t`1Q OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING OCTOBER 20, 1992 " The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. c? c- " ROLL CALL The following Commissioners were present: Canady, Kellogg, Osborn, Valdez, Walker, Weis The following Commissioners were absent: Hicks, Owen Commissioner Walker introduced and welcomed Commissioner Weis to the Board. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the September 15, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Captain James Rapp, Special Operations Division, gave an update on local drug operations. The Michigan State Police Crime Lab performs our drug analysis. We are in agreement with them that approximately 50 percent of current lab cases involve marijuana. We believe that marijuana is a gateway drug to the use of other drugs. Another prevalent drug is cocaine -- cocaine hydrochloride (10% of cases) and crack cocaine (24% of cases) . Crack cocaine is still the number one problem in our supply reduction programs. The use of heroin is increasing. The purity of white heroin has increased dramatically. It is not unusual to see a 15-30% purity level now. Five years ago, a 5% purity level was considered high. Blotter acid is still available. There is a new drug called C.A.T. It is a derivative of methamphetamine, produced readily in ones basement with the right chemicals. Federal legislation has been enacted in order to recognize these methamphetamine-derived drugs as controlled substances under the Controlled Substance Act. It is believed that Michigan legislation is ongoing. Captain Rapp recently learned that the drug ritalin, a stimulant, is being abused by older children stealing their siblings' prescriptions. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- We are seeing an overall decrease in drug use as the number of young users on the street has decreased. However, the hard core users, the 17-35 year age group, is the same. Captain Rapp mentioned that areas where we have community policing officers have had a high degree of success with eliminating or reducing drug activity. Commission Kellogg inquired as to the status of Geri Neil's anti-drug program. Chief Boles explained that L.P.D. asked her to postpone one of her planned vigils in a possibly high-tension area following the Rodney King incident in Los Angeles. Commissioner Kellogg will find out the status of her program and why the vigils have been discontinued. Chief Boles did not think that anyone at L.P.D. had discouraged her activities. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC Mr. Bernie Meissner, 635 LaSalle Boulevard, Lansing was present and requested a copy of the agenda. He inquired as to how complaints filed by citizens against the Department are resolved and to what extent the Board is involved in Internal Affairs investigations. Chief Boles explained that resolution of complaints depends on the point of intake (i. e. City Human Relations, Mayor's office, Internal Affairs, a supervisor) and the severity of the complaint. The complainant is always informed of the outcome of the complaint. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no representatives present. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Dr. Lynn A. Folkert, Lansing School District; Officer Larry Klaus; D/F/Lt. McCord, Tri-County Metro Narcotics; and Nola Thornburg. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS, RESIGNATIONS RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements for the month. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT Paul McComb explained the Withdrawal of the Civil Rights Complaint of Robert Allen. The original complaint came in two years ago. It was tried in March 1992 . The week-long trial resulted in Mr. Allen being convicted for assaulting a police officer with injury. He was placed on two-years probation. Mr. Allen then withdrew the complaint, and we have not heard anything further from him or his attorney. -3- REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for September 1992 was accepted and placed on file. Commissioner Walker mentioned that while he was unable to attend, the Police Athletic League (P.A.L. ) Board met for the first time last week. Chief Boles reported that as the soccer league is coming to a close, they are evaluating and preparing for the winter program. The next P.A. L. Board meeting will be a luncheon meeting where hopefully more people can attend. Invitations have been given to first-year P.A. L. Board members. Commissioner Canady explained his employer's citizen concern program. The president of that program board is expecting a request from L.P.D. for support of the P.A.L. program. Efforts for long-term fundraising will be discussed with the P.A.L. Board. The primary P.A. L. expenses will be equipment and insurance through the National Police Athletic League. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - No report. Commissioner Kellogg has received a schedule of upcoming budget meetings. With the early retirement incentive, it is anticipated that all civilian support staff in Administrative Services will be gone by January 1993 . Special McConnell Task Force - No report. Commissioner Walker will be assigning Commissioners Canady and Weis to committees in the near future. Also, there may be additional committee assignments after the Board determines how to move on recommendations initiated by former Commissioner Jewell. COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS Commissioner Canady participated in a ride-a-long recently with Officer Bob Kamphouse. He said that Officer Kamphouse was extremely informative. Also, he commended Kathryn Morgan, 911 Technician, for her caring attitude and professionalism. He thought that the back-up procedure used by the officers was effective, and everyone worked well together. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the Board's Evaluation Report is due December 1. We anticipate having preliminary divisional data for the Board's review at the November meeting. He asked the Board for their -4- areas of interest for the next Board meeting presentation. If there is not anything specific requested, something will be set up. Internal budget hearings are scheduled and Commissioner Kellogg has been advised of those dates. The two and one-half year 911 arbitration has been ruled on. Retroactive pay due those individuals is $172, 000. There is an outstanding, unsettled contract with the supervisiors unit of the F.O.P. There has not been funds set aside in this year's budget for these settlements. We are looking at significant shortfalls with no direction yet on how to handle them. The Chief will keep the Board updated. The Labor Relations Department was reorganized by the Mayor and approved by City Council. Mr. Richard Putney, Labor Relations Director, is no longer with the City. On a case-by-case basis, outside legal counsel will be hired at least through 312 artibrations, mandatory arbitrations the City is involved in. The remaining personnel in the Labor Relations Department have been reassigned to City Personnel to handle internal grievances and other negotiational labor items. Perhaps the City's new labor strategy will impact the length of these unsettled contracts. The City has approved the implementation of Voice mail, before the end of the year, in the Police Department. It is most necessary in the Investigations area in order for those in the field to access messages. With the reduction in clerical support staff, this system should prove to be beneficial. Chief Boles also welcomed Commissioner Weis. It was agreed that he will be an asset to the Board and the Police Department. The Chief also thanked Commissioners Canady and Weis for taking time for an orientation session one day last week. Commissioner Canady expressed his appreciation for the information and the opportunity. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board ..� ` Ns►,_ BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. F Lansing, Michigan 48933 R (Y/) 312 9400 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD (s) - OF THE CITY OF LANSING r"J � l �r SEPTEMBER 15, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Vice-Chairperson Kellogg. ROLL CALL G^•� ' vn The following Commissioners were present: Hicks, Kellogg, Osb ro n, Owen, Valdez The following Commissioners were absent: Canady, Walker, Weis APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the August 18 , 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O. P. Non-Supervisors Division. He reported that the F.O. P. Supervisors will begin arbitration next week. Officer Baylis reported for P.A.L. that they have acquired another business sponsor, MC Sporting Goods. The soccer league is practicing now to begin games next week. Updates from P.A.L. are forthcoming. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Phyllis Ball, Chief Boles, John and Teressa Staten, Sergeant George, Neighborhood Watch Advisory Board, Patricia C. Uetz, Sheriff Wriggelsworth, Richard and Mary Alice Yeiter. All communications were accepted and placed on file. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS The retirement of James A. Hepfer, Chief Radio Engineer, was accepted and placed on file. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints against the Department. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for August 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - No report. Special McConnell Task Force - No report. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS All Board members received a September 8 letter from Dr. Hiram L. Davis concerning a recent drug search incident involving his son on a Greyhound bus . Commissioner Owen inquired as to how the Department would be responding. Chief Boles explained that upon receipt of the letter on September 10, he called Dr. Davis. Commissioner Canady informed Chief Boles that he also contacted Dr. Davis to offer his services. In this particular incident, the Lansing Police Department was assisting the Michigan State Police (M.S.P. ) D. I.C.E. team in a drug interdiction effort at the bus station. While L. P.D. officers were at the bus station, L. P.D. officers did not make contact with Dr. Davis ' son or another African American male whose parents have complained. The officers involved are State Police command officers, not members of the Lansing Police Department. M.S .P. was in charge of the program. Since that time, we have asked M.S. P. not to come into our city until we 've evaluated whether we want to continue participation in the program. If we do, we want L. P.D. officers more involved as they have been trained in our techniques. Our officers do not have first-hand knowledge of the search on the bus as they were outside the bus. The searched occurred on the bus. The Chief will discuss Dr. Davis ' letter with Commissioner Walker and will report back at the next meeting. -3- CHIEF'S COMMENTS At the last meeting, it was requested that someone from Crime Analysis give a presentation tonight. No one was available. However, they reported that their Unit has not undergone any changes since their last presentation. As a reminder and for the benefit of new members, they have provided a handout on their duties/responsibilities and examples of a Crime Report and Intelligence Bulletin. Commissioner Hicks suggested that the area of drug enforcement be addressed at the next meeting. Chief Boles agreed to ask Captain Rapp, Special Operations Division, to attend the October 20 meeting. The Chief had nothing to report on the Budget. However, Dianna Emerson, Budget Control Supervisor, and Gayle LaCoursier, Payroll Clerk, are taking advantage of the early retirement package. We are beginning to train other employees to take over their responsibilities. City Council has confirmed a new Police Commissioner to replace Richard Jewell . John Weis, a Vice Preident at Lansing General Hospital, has assisted us in our strategic planning sessions. He, therefore, has some knowledge of the Police Department through that process. The Chief assured the Board that they would find him to be a concerned individual . The members that already know Commissioner Weis look forward to his participation. In follow up to Commissioner Walker's request, Board records were researched and it was found that at the July 21, 1987 meeting, Commissioner McConnell made a motion to recognize ex-Commissioners Roush and McManus with plaques. The Minutes did not indicate that this would be an ongoing procedure. It was the general feeling of the Board that those members who provided extraordinary service should be recognized. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, l G-kl(D Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ava. Lansing. Michigan 48933 (( R (51 I) 3i2 f)1100 r . t J OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD = OF THE CITY OF LANSING AUGUST 18 , 1992 —J ; The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL All Commissioners were present: Canady, Hicks, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the June 16, 1992 Regular Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. ELECTION OF OFFICERS Commissioner Walker called for the nomination of officers. Commissioner Kellogg nominated Commissioner Walker to another term as Chairperson. This single nomination was supported and carried unanimously. Commissioner Owen nominated Commissioner Kellogg as Vice-Chairperson. With no further nominations, Commissioner Kellogg was unanimously elected as Vice Chairperson. At this time, Commissioner Walker elected to maintain the same members as 1991-92 for all Committees in 1992-93 . ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Author, Pat Heyden, introduced her book, "Behind the Badge: The History of the Lansing Police Department" . She gave an overview of the six years of research leading to its development. The book is available through 14 libraries or it may be purchased. Chief Boles added that Pat has also put together a narrated slide presentation on highlights of her book. In 1993 , the Lansing Police Department will be celebrating its Centennial . Pat will be working with the Department and the City on historical exhibitions and activities in this regard. The Board expressed interest in becoming involved in the celebration. "Equal ODDOrtunity Emdover" -a- Officer Loren Glasscock gave a presentation on Neighborhood Watch and National Night Out. There are currently 166 Neighborhood Watch groups. This equates to 13 , 000 residences or 40, 000 people. The emphasis is on building up weaker Neighborhood Watches and increasing the understanding that the Watches benefit all involved. To kick off National Night Out, City Council held an open-air meeting at Durant Park. Over 300 people were in attendance. Lansing, East Lansing, Eaton and Ingham Counties, and Meridian Township participated in this year ' s National Night Out held on August 4 . Officers Marie Wolfe and Kim Lawrence spoke on the formation of the Police Athletic League (P.A. L. ) . As a non-profit organization, they have joined the National Police Athletic League in order to acquire necessary insurance. Bylaws have been written and will be discussed at the next meeting. The P.A. L. Board of Directors will include one member from the Board of Police Commissioners. After the next meeting, one of the Police Board members will be approached. P.A. L. is currently focused on implementing programs in Community Policing areas. The idea is to offer programs that these kids would not otherwise have an opportunity to participate in -- canoeing, camping, horseback riding, snow skiing, etc. Volunteer LPD sworn and civilian employees will help as coaches or referees. Commissioner Walker commended Chief Boles for his involvement in the gang/drug conferences and with P.A. L. He believes that the success of these activities is due to the Chief 's efforts. Commissioner Hicks commended the officers and their undying efforts. Chief Boles also commended the officers involved in P.A. L. for their energy and commitment. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O. P. Non-Supervisors Division but had no business to report. COT,1MUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Officer Craig Baylis, Bill and Mary Ann Evert; Lisa Fisk, YMCA; Jo Flaherty; Resident Agent McCarthy, U. S. Secret Service; E. S . Starnes, Michigan National Bank; John and Teressa Staten; Hazel Trebilcock; Lt. J. M. Zelnik, U.S . Navy Security Office. Commissioner Walker expressed his personal regrets regarding the death of officer Johnathan Staten. All communications were accepted and placed on file. -3- CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS The following were accepted and placed on file: the confirmation of Officers Robert Merritt and Steven Stafford; the resignation of Officers Joseph Diaz and Michael Ferland, and Detention Officer Joseph Eisfelder; and the retirement of Park Security Officer David Henderson and Detective Ronald Lyon. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT The Fiscal Year Summary of Civil Rights Complaints was accepted and placed on file. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Reports for June and July 1992 were accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. However, they are in need of another person. Budget - No report. See Chief ' s Comments. Special McConnell Task Force - See Commissioners ' � Comments. COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS Commissoner Osborn inquired as to the outcome of the public forums implemented by the Special McConnell Task Force. Chief Boles reported that participation increased with each one held. He is extremely satisfied with the outcome. There was considerable discussion on all five forums and on future efforts to keep communications open. Commissioner Owen complimented the Mayor on his participation and input into the forums. Jo Flaherty commended Officer Danny King on his outstanding moderation of the gay/lesbian forum held at Club Paradise. Commissioner Kellogg asked if there is a standard type of recognition for outgoing Police Board members. Commissioner Walker and others recalled the presentation of a plaque for an outgoing member at the annual Awards Ceremony. As there was discussion at a previous Board meeting on this subject, Commissioner Walker requested that past minutes be researched to determine what was decided. CHIEF 'S COMMENTS Chief Boles asked the Board for direction on next month' s Departmental presentation. Commissioner Osborn expressed interest ih. hearing from -4- the Crime Analysis Unit even though they gave a presentation approximately one year ago. Commissioner Hicks mentioned the juvenile area. Chief Boles defined the areas involving juveniles -- physical abuse of youth or juveniles accused of crimes in the Detective Bureau. Chief Boles reported that Budget directives are not out yet from the Finance Department. However, we are probably looking at a maintenance budget for next year. The various divisions are working on their goals, objectives, and mission statements in order to coincide with work plans. The Budget will then be more structured in terms of allocation to each Department program. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, {�- Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board �``•��� "'(`ANC►` BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. C) Lansing, Michigan 48933 (517)372-9400 v OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THEc,- POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING JUNE 16, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Vice-Chairperson Sharon Kellogg. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Canady, Jewell, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez Commissioners absent: Johnson, Walker ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Chief Boles gave a presentation on Grants. Most L.P. D. grants are from State-funded sources -- typically agencies that are screening vehicles for federal funds. Generally, the grants have been through the Office of Criminal Justice, Office of Highway Traffic Safety, the Department of Commerce, the Department of Education, and/.or the Department of Transportation. Since the City Grants Coordinator position was eliminated in 1989, each department has been responsible for the administration of its own grants. Our Administrative Services Lieutenant monitors the administration of the grants, but does not actively seek available out-of-state funds as was previously done by the Grants Coordinator. While grants enable us to expand or explore new programs, they are a vexation when funds expire. Programs are not picked up under the General Fund Budget, because grant positions are in addition to the Department ' s authorized strength. This year, we have nine (9) grant positions paid for by City match, drug match and grant monies programmed into our budget. The nine (9) grant positions include: 1. Two (2) Asset Seizure Detectives in the Metro Narcotics Unit to seize assets and convert property to cash. The cash is used to enhance drug enforcement, defray operational expenses of the Metro Unit, and pay cash match for grants. 2 . One (1) Police Officer under the Transportation Center grant who has Community Policing and bus station duties. This grant is paid for by the Transportation Department, State of Michigan, to patrol the arrival/departures of buses. 3 . Through the Office of Criminal Justice COPS grant, two (2) Community Police Officers. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- 4 . Under Street-Level Drug Enforcement, one (1) Landlord/Tenant Detective and one (1) Sergeant who coordinates the Community Policing effort and street-level drug enforcement. 5. One (1) Detective currently. in jeopardy under the UDAA/Auto Theft Authority Grant. It was caught in the political wrangling of the no-fault bill to reestablish Auto Theft Authority. We are hoping that it will be passed. If not, we're looking at the demotion of a detective and the elimination of an entry-level position, because these are in addition to our authorized strength. 6 . One (1) Community Police Officer in a new area through the Community Partnership Grant. At renewal time, there is the possibility of expanding this program to allow for one more Community Police Officer. The Lansing Housing Commission was awarded a HUD grant to help residents and youth in housing developments. Because of this grant and through a unique contract with the Lansing Housing Commission, we have three (3) Community Police Officer positions that cover all major developments in the City. This program which is 100% funded through the Lansing Housing Commission has been very successful . In summary, we currently have the capability to fill twelve (12) positions to be funded by outside sources. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the May 20, 1992 Special Meeting of the Board were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS Officer Craig Baylis was present as Trustee/Director for the F.O.P. Non-Supervisors Division. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Chief Jerry Boles; Dennis Dorin, Capitol Cadillac; Jo Flaherty; Catherine Haas; Ruth Hallman, Neighborhood Watch #120; Mark Lanier, M. S .U. ; Amy Magistro, Purchasing; John Metts, Lansing Twp. P. D. ; Neighborhood Youth & Parent Prevention Partnership; Paul Novak, Westside Neighborhood Association; Donald Owens, Ingham County Probate Judge; Jack Phillips, Bath Charter Twp. ; F/Lt. Robert Powers, Michigan State Police; Col . Michael Robinson, Michigan State Police; Councilmember Alfreda Schmidt; Terri Fore Sulton, Peckham Vocational Industries; Jane White/Janet Strahan, LCC-Criminal Justice & Law -3- Center; Chris Stuchell, Lansing Housing Commission; Paul and Sherri Wiegman, Cherry Hill Neighborhood; Ingham County Sheriff Gene Wriggelsworth. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS RESIGNATIONS RETIREMENTS The confirmation of Officer James Kraus as a Police Officer I and the retirements of Officer Robert Lee Jones, Lt. Robert McClean, and . Georgiaha Viele were accepted and placed on file.. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Commissioner Jewell asked for an explanation of a toy gun incident mentioned in the May Highlights in which the Prosecutor refused to issue a felonious assault charge. Paul McComb agreed to research the incident with the Assistant Prosecutor and report back. The Departmental Highlights Reports for April and May 1992 were accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - No report. Special McConnell Task Force = This committee is comprised of representatives from the Mayor' s Police Community Relations Board, the Human Relations Board, the Board of Police Commissioners, and two staff members. Commissioners Jewell and Osborn have been the representatives from the Police Board. Commissioner Jewell reported that the original assignment of the McConnell Task Force was to review and define the roles of each Board and to succinctly define the purpose of the Task Force. Members of the Police Board agreed that the differences, similarities and responsibilities of each Board should be defined. In an effort to find out what the community wants, the McConnell Task Force decided to hold five two-hour community forums. Each Board will have one or two representatives on each forum panel . Commissioner Jewell recommended that the Board agree to the five forums being coordinated by the Task Force. Commissioner Osborn moved that the Board approve and agree to participate in the five community forums. The motion was seconded and carried. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Osborn inquired about the enforcement of the noise ordinance in connection with vehicle owners playing their audio sound -4- systems so loudly that it affects ones quality of life. Chief Boles replied that it is a high priority with the first shift Traffic Unit. Community Policing officers are being bombarded with residents ' complaints on this issue. The idea was discussed of having a newspaper reporter write a story on this problem and what the Police Department is doing about it. It was generally thought that this would have a positive effect on the number and frequency of offenders. It would also communicate to the community that the Police Department is aware and will be enforcing the noise ordinance. Commissioner Jewell said that he and Chief Boles would be developing a list of topics to be presented at future Board meetings. A reminder was made by Commissioner Kellogg that elections for the Chairperson and Vice Chairperson positions will be held at the July 21 meeting. CHIEF'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the meeting with the Parks Department Board is tomorrow night, June 17 . The purpose is to review the Parks patrol plan since the elimination of Parks Police. The Chief is very satisfied with the efforts of Captain James Cook, Uniform Division, in terms of the approach to those problems. He believes that Parks coverage will be quite satisfactory. The voluntary reduction in the work force from early retirements will impact the Police Department as we anticipate 4-6 people leaving in a couple of key areas. The Cultural Diversity Program schedule was distributed. Chief Boles asked that interested members contact his office or Personnel and Training to schedule a session. OTHER BUSINESS There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ts' e� ♦a �� '�; 120 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing, Michigan 48933 (517) 372-9400 r CNISO SPECIAL MEETING BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS MAY 20, 1992 A Special Meeting was held at 5: 30 p.m. on Wednesday, May 20, 18.92, to discuss and respond to specific areas/recommendations of .the' Mayor' s Ad Hoc Review Committee Report as directed by the Mayor. The Committee was created by the Mayor to review the Cipriano Torres shooting incident of November 4, 1991. The following Commissioners were present: Walker, Kellogg, Canady, Jewell, Johnson, Osborn and Valdez . Commissioner Owen was unable to attend. As a member of the Mayor' s Ad Hoc Committee, Ms. Jo Flaherty of the Mayor' s office was present. Mr. Harold Singleton was also present. Chairperson Walker called the meeting to order. The minutes of the April 21, 1992 regular meeting of the Board were approved as written. Commissioner Walker explained that the purpose of this meeting is to respond to the Mayor' s request for the Board and Police Department to address certain areas of the Ad Hoc Review Committee Report. At Commissioner Walker' s request, the Police Department prepared the responses to the Ad Hoc Committee Report. After an item by item discussion/review, the Board and Police Department will present a joint report to the Mayor. There was considerable discussion on what approach should be taken in responding to the Ad Hoc Committee Report recommendations. Jo Flaherty explained that the Mayor intended to look collectively at the five City Department and Board responses, report back to the community, and then possibly ask City Departments to look into making some changes. It was then determined that it was appropriate to respond with an explanation of applicable, current procedures of the Police Department. While there were many questions, clarifications and comments regarding several items, changes were minor. The changes included: 1. Under Police Training, A) RESPONSE, last paragraph, last sentence: "Any system that is adopted must be compatible with the physical limitations of the firing range configuration. " 2 . Police Training, C) RESPONSE, last paragraph, last sentence: "It is expected that this training will begin within the next six months. " "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- 3 . Under Police Policy and Procedures, I) RESPONSE, population representation statistics (% OF CITY POPULATION) were changed to reflect the total population. Commissioners Osborn and Johnson expressed interest in participating in the two-day Cultural Diversity program. Chief Boles said we would ask Personnel and Training to provide that schedule in order to make arrangements. With the above changes, Commissioner Osborn moved that the Board approve the responses and that a joint letter of transmittal from the Police Department and the Board of Police Commissioners be sent to the Mayor with the approved responses. The motion was supported by Commissioner Johnson and unanimously approved. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board LAq •� �`�� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS ?��- a�, j�►�5 120 W. Michigan Ave. l = 1 5 Lansing, Michigan 48933 �y SPECIAL MEETING BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS MAY 20, 1992 A Special Meeting was held at 5: 30 p.m. on Wednesday, May 20, 1992 to discuss and respond to specific areas/recommendations of the Mayor' s Ad Hoc Review Committee Report as directed by the Mayor. The Committee was created by the Mayor to review the Cipriano Torres shooting incident of November 4 , 1991. The following Commissioners were present: Walker, Kellogg, Canady, Jewell, Johnson, Osborn and Valdez . Commissioner Owen was unable to attend. As a member of the Mayor' s Ad Hoc Committee, Ms . Jo Flaherty of the Mayor' s office was present. Mr. Harold Singleton was also present. Chairperson Walker called the meeting to order. The minutes of the April 21, 1992 regular meeting of the Board were approved as written. Commissioner Walker explained that the purpose of this meeting is to respond to the Mayor' s request for the Board and Police Department to address certain areas of the Ad Hoc Review Committee Report. At Commissioner Walker' s request, the Police Department prepared the responses to the Ad Hoc Committee Report. After an item by item discussion/review, the Board and Police Department will present a joint report to the Mayor. There was considerable discussion on what approach should be taken in responding to the Ad Hoc Committee Report recommendations. Jo Flaherty explained that the Mayor intended to look collectively at the five City Department and Board responses, report back to the community, and then possibly ask City Departments to look into making some changes . It was then determined that it was appropriate to respond with an explanation of applicable, current procedures of the Police Department. While there were many questions, clarifications and comments regarding several items, changes were minor. The changes included: 1. Under Police Training, A) RESPONSE, last paragraph, last sentence: "Any system that is adopted must be compatible with the physical limitations of the firing range configuration. " 2 . Police Training, C) RESPONSE, last paragraph, last sentence: "It is expected that this training will begin within the next six months. " "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- 3 . Under Police Policy and Procedures, I) RESPONSE, population representation statistics (% OF CITY POPULATION) were changed to reflect the total population. Commissioners Osborn and Johnson expressed interest in participating in the two-day Cultural Diversity program. Chief Boles said we would ask Personnel and Training to provide that schedule in order to make arrangements. With the above changes, Commissioner Osborn moved that the Board approve the responses and that a joint letter of transmittal from the Police Department and the Board of Police Commissioners be sent to the Mayor with the approved responses. The motion was supported by Commissioner Johnson and unanimously approved. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Cap►��� - Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board o.-L",4 , .��eo ��'�,� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS b♦,Q � ' ;;fir 120 W. Michigan ASe: Lansing, Michigan 48933 ,•� (517) 3 -9400 1238 UU 63 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING APRIL 21, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Johnson, Kellogg, Osborn, Walker Commissioners absent: Owen, Valdez Brinton Butler, Systems Analysis Manager, attended to give a presentation on Automated Data Operations. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Brinton Butler explained the operations of the Law Enforcement Management System (LEMS) data system. The major operations include: collection and dissemination of specific information; management information and summaries; crime analysis ; and process control. The following items were mentioned as future goals: on-line mugshots; electronic mail;automated Quartermaster (dissemination of uniform supplies; maintenance/storage of property and evidence) ; and computerized report writing. We are currently looking for a new computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system for the Communications Center. The system will incorporate in- car terminals from which LEMS can be accessed. Therefore, the CAD system will need to be integrated with LEMS . Commissioner Osborn asked about the growth potential/life cycle of our current computer system. Brinton explained that we replaced the system in December 1990 and its expected life span is five years. At one and one-half years into that, the Hewlett Packard system is adequate. As our five-year lease/purchase agreement expires, it is expected that we will upgrade the system. Board members expressed their appreciation for Brinton' s very informative presentation. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of last month's regular Board meeting were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no F.O.P. representatives present. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Joseph Borczak, Carol Bucher, Frank D. Holmes, Gloria Morris, D/Lt. J. Patrick, J. Plane, Councilmember Schmidt, Ralph Taylor, and Bob Trojanowicz. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS RESIGNATIONS RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for March 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget See Chief ' s Comments. Leonard McConnell Task Force - Commissioner Jewell reported that the Task Force met on April 13 . It was decided that the next meeting scheduled for May 18 , 5 : 00 p.m. , in the 2nd floor classroom, would be focused on education and intervention. Meetings - Commissioner Osborn suggested that these Committee meetings be left open for any Commissioners able to attend. Commissioner Walker volunteered to be a member of this Committee. It was decided that the regular meeting of the Board will be held -S- at the Neighborhood Watch Picnic, Francis Park on Tuesday, May 19 , 5 : 00-8 : 00 p.m. Commissioner Jewell will obtain parking passes to be mailed to Board members for entrance to Francis Park. Chief Boles encouraged everyone to attend this worthwhile event. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Regarding the Torres Ad Hoc Committee, Commissioner Walker reported that the Committee has completed its work and would be submitting its report to the Mayor tomorrow, April 22 . The Mayor will determine how/if this information will be released. Commissioner Walker communicated that a great deal of time, pains, and effort went into the development of this report. CHIEF 'S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the Mayor' s proposed Police Department budget is $14 , 750, 000 for next year. The elimination of Parks Police translates to $70, 000 less than originally asked for. The Budget approval and future of Parks Police is presently at the Council level. On Monday, April 27, 7 : 00 p.m. , at Council Chambers, 10th floor, City Hall, there will be a ceremony posthumously honoring Commissioner Leonard McConnell . A resolution and picture will be presented to the family by Commissioner Walker and the Mayor. As part of National Volunteer Week, Commissioner McConnell is also being recognized as an outstanding Board volunteer. The McConnell family members have been informed of the ceremony. Chief Boles encouraged all Board members to attend if possible. Chief Boles asked that the vision/mission statements, goals and strategies attached to last month' s and this month' s agenda be approved. They will then be forwarded to the Mayor and City Council. After final approval, the divisions can then develop work plans to address their objectives as they relate to the nine goals. The Board unanimously approved the statements, goals and strategies . A neighborhood office in the Cristo Rey Community Center has been opened for the use of a district officer. This is an initiative to expand the community policing concept without assigning a community policing officer. In order to spread the community policing philosophy, we anticipate increased utilization of existing resources for other areas of the City. OTHER BUSINESS Regarding the use of the chemical agent, Freeze, Commissioner Walker supported it. He thought that any instrument an officer can use that might prevent the use of firearms or the use of -4- night sticks would be a helpful instrument. There was general discussion on the guidelines for the use of Freeze. Commissioner Jewell moved that the Board support the Department' s use of Freeze on a trial basis. The motion was supported by Commissioner Johnson and carried. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board OF"'LA ` BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. Y Lansing, Michigan 48933 C—�-X�, (517)372-9400 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF Tn` SING APRIL 21, 1992 J The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walke_,L 1 ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Johnson, Kellogg, Osborn, Walker Commissioners absent: Owen, Valdez Brinton Butler, Systems Analysis Manager, attended to give a presentation on Automated Data Operations. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Brinton Butler explained the operations of the Law Enforcement Management System (LEMS) data system. The major operations include: collection and dissemination of specific information; management information and summaries; crime analysis; and process control . The following items were mentioned as future goals: on-line mugshots; electronic mail; automated Quartermaster (dissemination of uniform supplies; maintenance/storage of property and evidence) ; and computerized report writing. We are currently looking for a new computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system for the Communications Center. The system will incorporate in- car terminals from which LEMS can be accessed. Therefore, the CAD system will need to be integrated with LEMS. Commissioner Osborn asked about the growth potential/life cycle of our current computer system. Brinton explained that we replaced the system in December 1990 and its expected life span is five years. At one and one-half years into that, the Hewlett Packard system is adequate. As our five-year lease/purchase agreement expires, it is expected that we will upgrade the system. Board members expressed their appreciation for Brinton' s very informative presentation. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of last month' s regular Board meeting were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no F.O.P. representatives present. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: Joseph Borczak, Carol Bucher, Frank D. Holmes, Gloria Morris, D/Lt. J. Patrick, J. Plane, Councilmember Schmidt, Ralph Taylor, and Bob Trojanowicz . All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for March 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - See Chief ' s Comments . Leonard McConnell Task Force - Commissioner Jewell reported that the Task Force met on April 13 . It was decided that the next meeting scheduled for May 18 , 5 : 00 p.m. , in the 2nd floor classroom, would be focused on education and intervention. Meetings - Commissioner Osborn suggested that these Committee meetings be left open for any Commissioners able to attend. Commissioner Walker volunteered to be a member of this Committee. It was decided that the regular meeting of the Board will be held -S- at the Neighborhood Watch Picnic, Francis Park on Tuesday, May 19 , 5 : 00-8 : 00 p.m. Commissioner Jewell will obtain parking passes to be mailed to Board members for entrance to Francis Park. Chief Boles encouraged everyone to attend this worthwhile event. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Regarding the Torres Ad Hoc Committee, Commissioner Walker reported that the Committee has completed its work and would be submitting its report to the Mayor tomorrow, April 22 . The Mayor will determine how/if this information will be released. Commissioner Walker communicated that a great deal of time, pains, and effort went into the development of this report. CHIEF ' S COMMENTS Chief Boles reported that the Mayor' s proposed Police Department budget is $14 , 750, 000 for next year. The elimination of Parks Police translates to $70, 000 less than originally asked for. The Budget approval and future of Parks Police is presently at the Council level . On Monday, April 27, 7 : 00 p.m. , at Council Chambers, loth floor, City Hall, there will be a ceremony posthumously honoring Commissioner Leonard McConnell . A resolution and picture will be presented to the family by Commissioner Walker and the Mayor. As part of National Volunteer Week, Commissioner McConnell is also being recognized as an outstanding Board volunteer. The McConnell family members have been informed of the ceremony. Chief Boles encouraged all Board members to attend if possible. Chief Boles asked that the vision/mission statements, goals and strategies attached to last month ' s and. this month' s agenda be approved. They will then be forwarded to the Mayor and City Council . After final approval, the divisions can then develop work plans to address their objectives as they relate to the nine goals. The Board unanimously approved the statements, goals and strategies. A neighborhood office in the Cristo Rey Community Center has been opened for the use of a district officer. This is an initiative to expand the community policing concept without assigning a community policing officer. In order to spread the community policing philosophy, we anticipate increased utilization of existing resources for other areas of the City. OTHER BUSINESS Regarding the use of the chemical agent, Freeze, Commissioner Walker supported it. He thought that any instrument an officer can use that might prevent the use of firearms or the use of -4- night sticks would be a helpful instrument. There was general discussion on the guidelines for the use of Freeze. commissioner Jewell moved that the Board support the Department' s use of Freeze on a trial basis. The motion was supported by commissioner Johnson and carried. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board IIIIAOI/Illiipnr, .... g► BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. ii, � Lansing, Michigan 48933 a, L-) (517)372-9400 REC EIVED . o 2 092 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE - POLICE BOARD MAYOR'S OFFICE, OF THE CITY OF LANSING CITE! 0� r.ANgIN(� FEBRUARY 18, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Johnson, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez , Walker Commissioners absent: McConnell Sergeant George and Officer Fabijancic were present to give a Community Policing program update. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA A Community Policing presentation was given by Officer Fabijancic. He explained his job as one in which he motivates, organizes, and mobilizes people living in problem neighborhoods in order to drive out the troublemakers (i. e. drug houses) . Through the planning of neighborhood clean-ups, picnics, and various other activities, Community Policing officers strive to instill a sense of self-worth, pride and unity within the individuals and neighborhoods collectively. Officer Fabijancic described in detail some of the typical and atypical tasks his position entails. As every neighborhood' s problems are different, the solutions and the pace at which progress is made are different. Commissioner Valdez asked what criteria was used to determine the assignment of a Community Policing officer to a neighborhood. Assistant Chief Sinclair explained that crime statistics actually determine whether a neighborhood warrants the assignment of an officer. Officers are assigned to areas with the greatest need. Sergeant George added that budget constraints restrict the assignment of Community Policing officers to every neighborhood in need. Assistant Chief Sinclair suggested that a problem neighborhood without a Community Policing officer request an officer from the Community Services Unit to attend a neighborhood planning meeting. The Community Services officer could advise residents on possible actions to take, i. e. initiating a Neighborhood Watch. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- Board members expressed their appreciation for Officer Fabijancic ' s presentation. APPROVAL 'OF MINUTES The Minutes of last month' s regular Board meeting were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no representatives present from the Fraternal Order of Police. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by .members of the Department were received from the following individuals: R. E. Olds Anderson, Charles Bauer, James E. Hengstebeck, Randy Murdock, R. Eric Reickel, Fred Spearow, and Bob Trojanowicz . All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS The resignations of Gloria Gonzalez, Beth Lynn, and Juli Zakrajsek were tabled for inclusion in next month' s agenda. The Board requested information relative to the reasons for these resignations. There were no confirmations or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints against the Department. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for January 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - Commissioners Jewell and Johnson met Thursday, February 13 , and discussed the suggestions Commissioner Jewell made at the last meeting. See Other Business. Budget - See Chief ' s Comments. -3- - COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Walker cordially invited the Board to attend a Gang Conference to be held on Saturday, February 29, 8 : 30 a.m. -1: 00 p.m. , at the Kellogg Center. The Conference is co-sponsored by Meridian Professional Psychological Consultant Services, the Lansing Police Department, and the Lansing Association of Black Organizations. Invitees include: local sheriff ' s and police departments, Ingham County Court representatives, school district representatives, and Department of Social Services juvenile workers. The Conference will help define which agencies and organizations in the community have hands-on responsiblities for working with young people. It can then be determined what directign the community should take regarding gang problems. Subsequent conferences might include gang members, parents of gang members, and personnel from Lansing Schools, East Lansing Schools and possibly other school districts. CHIEF ' S COMMENTS Assistant Chief Sinclair reported that the Ingham County Law and Courts Committee net on February 13 . A few Community Policing officers and a number of their neighborhood citizens appeared to express their concern over the proposed resolution that would charge the City for the housing of ordinance violators in the County Jail. The resolution was not voted out of Committee. It was decided that more study on this issue was needed. Chief Boles will keep the Board advised on this issue. All Budget Administration Hearings have been held. The Board will be advised when the Mayor' s final Budget goes to Council. The mid-year adjustments to the Budget were submitted last week. The outcome is not yet known. Again, Chief Boles will keep the Board updated. It was decided that on March 12 , 5: 30 p.m. a Joint Meeting of the Police Board, Human Relations Board and the Mayor' s Police Community Relations Committee will be held. The location has not yet been determined. OTHER BUSINESS The recommendations for change in Board policies/procedures as presented by Commissioner Jewell at the last meeting were discussed. Commissioner Johnson made a motion for the establishment and appointment of a Meetings Committee for the purpose of: (1) developing alternate sites for special meetings, (2) developing a monthly calendar of activities, and (3) identifying educational .presentations to be given at monthly Board meetings. The motion was supported and carried unanimously. -4- Regarding Commissioner Jewell ' s recommendation for a Reports Committee, the Board requested identification of Police Department reports in which the Board either provides input, votes on directly, or is in some way involved. Chief Boles will provide that information at the next meeting. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, cc Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board �umo>1m„ "�� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS o li0°L 120 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing, Michigan 48933 (517)372-9400 ' CS "«%iiliUllfltll n OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING Cam - FEBRUARY 18 , 1992 � CD The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. " ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Johnson, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez , Walker Commissioners absent: McConnell Sergeant George and Officer Fabijancic were present to give a Community Policing program update. ADDITIONS TO AGENDA A Community Policing presentation was given by Officer Fabijancic. He explained his job as one in which he motivates, organizes, and mobilizes people living in problem neighborhoods in order to drive out the troublemakers (i. e. drug houses) . Through the planning of neighborhood clean-ups, picnics, and various other activities, Community Policing officers strive to instill a sense of self-worth, pride and unity within the individuals and neighborhoods collectively. Officer Fabijancic described in detail some of the typical and atypical tasks his position entails. As every neighborhood ' s problems are different, the solutions and the pace at which progress is made are different. Commissioner Valdez asked what criteria was used to determine the assignment of a Community Policing officer to a neighborhood. Assistant Chief Sinclair explained that crime statistics actually determine whether a neighborhood warrants the assignment of an officer. Officers are assigned to areas with the greatest need. Sergeant George added that budget constraints restrict the assignment of Community Policing officers to every neighborhood in need. Assistant Chief Sinclair suggested that a problem neighborhood without a Community Policing officer request an officer from the Community Services Unit to attend a neighborhood planning meeting. The Community Services officer could advise residents on possible actions to take, i. e. initiating a Neighborhood Watch. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- Board members expressed their appreciation for Officer Fabijancic ' s presentation. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of last month' s regular Board meeting were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of .the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no representatives present from the Fraternal Order of Police. COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by .members of the Department were received from the following individuals: R. E. Olds Anderson, Charles Bauer, James t. Hengstebeck, Randy Murdock, R. Eric Reickel, Fred Spearow, and Bob Trojanowicz. All communications were accepted and placed on file. CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS The resignations of Gloria Gonzalez, Beth Lynn, and Juli Zakrajsek were tabled for inclusion in next month' s agenda. The Board requested information relative to the reasons for these resignations. There were no confirmations or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT There were no complaints against the Department. REPORTS OF OFFICERS The Departmental Highlights Report for January 1992 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - Commissioners Jewell and Johnson met Thursday, February 13 , and discussed the suggestions Commissioner Jewell made at the last meeting. See Other Business. Budget - See Chief' s Comments. -3- COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Walker cordially invited the Board to attend a -Gang Conference to be held on Saturday, February 29 , 8 : 30 a.m. -1: 00 p.m. , at the Kellogg Center. The Conference is co-sponsored by Meridian Professional Psychological Consultant Services, the Lansing Police Department, and the Lansing Association of Black Organizations. Invitees include: local sheriff' s and police departments, Ingham County Court representatives, school district representatives, and Department of Social Services juvenile workers. The Conference will help define which agencies and organizations in the community have hands-on responsiblities for working with young people. It can then be determined what directign the community 'should take regarding gang problems. Subsequent conferences might include gang members, parents of gang members, and personnel from Lansing Schools, East Lansing Schools and possibly other school districts. CHIEF' S COMMENTS Assistant Chief Sinclair reported that the Ingham County Law and Courts Committee met on February 13 . A few Community Policing officers and a number •of their neighborhood citizens appeared to express their concern over the proposed resolution that would charge the City for the housing of ordinance violators in the County Jail . The resolution was not voted out of Committee. It was decided that more study on this issue was needed. Chief Boles will keep the Board advised on this issue. All Budget Administration Hearings have been held. The Board will be advised when the Mayor' s final .Budget goes to Council . The mid-year adjustments to the Budget were submitted last week. The outcome is not yet known. Again, Chief Boles will keep the Board updated. It was decided that on March 12 , 5: 30 p.m. a Joint Meeting of the Police Board, Human Relations Board and the Mayor' s Police Community Relations Committee will be held. The location has not yet been determined. OTHER BUSINESS The recommendations for change in Board policies/procedures as presented by Commissioner Jewell at the last meeting were discussed. Commissioner Johnson made' a motion for the establishment and appointment of a Meetings Committee for the purpose of: (1) developing alternate sites for special meetings, (2) developing a monthly calendar of activities, and (3) identifying educational presentations to be given at monthly Board meetings . The motion was supported and carried unanimously. -4- Regarding Commissioner Jewell ' s recommendation for a Reports Committee, the Board requested identification of Police Department reports in which the Board either provides input, votes on directly, or is in some way involved. Chief Boles will provide that information at the next meeting. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, r�/L�A-d� Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board 9 �•>1,� "' A�s►� BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 120 W. Michigan Ave. Lansing. Michigan 48933 (517) 372-9400 NIS OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE POLICE BOARD OF THE CITY OF LANSING JANUARY 21, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez , Walker Commissioners absent: Johnson, McConnell ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Commissioner Jewell distributed a list of recommended changes to the Board' s policies and procedures. Commissioner Owen explained that the revision of the City Charter adopted in 1978 changed the Board' s role to one that is more advisory in nature. He thought that Commissioner Jewell ' s recommended changes could only be accomplished' by changing the City Charter. Commissioner Jewell explained that his intent is to define and increase advisory responsibilities to allow for increased effectiveness and efficiency. Commissioner Osborn moved that we discuss recommendations for change at next month' s meeting. The motion was supported and carried. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the Special Meeting and regular Board meeting both held in December were approved as submitted. COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC There were no members of the public present. .t FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no representatives present from the Fraternal Order '�b'f �� Police. V V COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: John M. Dempsey, David T. Glecker, and David A. Lopez . All communications were accepted and placed on file. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -a- CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS, RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT Notification was received of the Dismissal of a Civil Rights Complaint filed by Rebecca Capetillo. This notification was accepted and placed on file. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Commissioner Jewell inquired about the Court overtime research project. Chief Boles explained that, especially with Budget restrictions, we are trying to identify the source of overtime and ways to reduce the amount of Court overtime. While the false alarm rate was down slightly from last month, it was determined that it is too soon to judge the effects of the new alarm ordinance. Commissioner Walker asked if the Department is developing new gang procedures to address that problem. Chief Boles explained that the Detective Bureau, Criminal Intelligence and REACH teams are working together on training bulletins and update communication. It was acknowledged that two departments (Michigan State University and Meridian Township) recently dropped out of the Tri-County Metro Narcotics Squad for economic reasons. There was an inquiry as to whether they would be replaced by other departments. Chief Boles was not aware of any additional investigators from any other departments joining the Metro Squad. The Departmental Highlights Report for December 1991 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - See Chief' s Comments. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Kellogg commented on the recent CBS News coverage of the Lansing Police Department' s Community Policing program. A tape of the story will be shown at the next Board meeting. An update on the Community Policing program will also be presented at the next meeting. -3- CHIEF 'S COMMENTS The Ingham County Law and Courts Committee has passed the resolution that would charge the City for the housing of ordinance violators in the County Jail. If the resolution is passed by the full County Board, the City will be charged as follows: 0-7 days-no charge; 7-14 days-$15 per day; 14+ days-$33 per day. It appears as though the proposal is moving forward. The Board of Review, after many hours, found that the actions of officers involved in the November 4 , 1991 shooting death of Cipriano Torrez were justified in conformance with applicable laws, procedures, and rules. Several procedures are being reviewed by various divisions as the result of their meetings. As this is an ongoing process, Chief Boles will update the Board as recommendations are made. The Department submitted alternative 5% and 10% reduced Budgets to the Finance Department. We have not been asked to alter the existing Budget approved by this Board. It is - anticipated that the Mayor will make recommendations in March. Chief Boles will be involved in administrative hearings with the Mayor next month and will report to the Budget Committee and Board Chairpersons. The administrative reorganization recommended by this Board to the Mayor was approved and will be reflected in the organizational chart. The Department has been given approval to update video monitoring equipment in the Detention area. This is the first of three phases necessary in the Detention unit. The second phase is an automated suicide-risk profile to identify high-risk inmates. The third phase is a request for three additional Detention Officers as recommended in the Budget proposal. Chief Boles discussed the Training Bulletin on Ethnic Intimidation Investigation Guidelines. The U. C.R. reporting (national reporting system) of an ethnic intimidation crime, now voluntary, will be mandatory within a few years. We are trying to comply voluntarily. Any ethnic intimidation crime receives mandatory follow-up investigation. The recent death in the City Jail was determined to be as the result of cardiac arrest due to intoxication from ingestion of windshield washer solvent. An investigation is underway to assure that procedures were followed. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board ASS BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIO E LL h'' 120 W. Michigan Ave. RECEIVE Lansin , Michi an 48933 _ I 9 9 (517) 372-9400 FEB 14 1992 ��Clalt�a� OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE MHYOR'S pFFlC� POLICE BOARD CITY OF LANSING OF THE CITY OF LANSING JANUARY 21, 1992 The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Willard Walker. ROLL CALL Commissioners present: Jewell, Kellogg, Osborn, Owen, Valdez, Walker Commissioners absent: Johnson, McConnell ADDITIONS TO AGENDA Commissioner Jewell distributed a list of recommended changes to the Board' s policies and procedures. Commissioner Owen explained that the revision of the City Charter adopted in 1978 changed the Board' s role to one that is more advisory in nature. He thought that Commissioner Jewell ' s recommended changes could only be accomplished by changing the City Charter. Commissioner Jewell explained that his intent is to define and increase advisory responsibilities to allow for increased effectiveness and efficiency. Commissioner Osborn moved that we discuss recommendations for change at next month' s meeting. The motion was supported and carried. APPROVAL OF MINUTES The Minutes of the Special Meeting and regular Board meeting both held in December were approved as submitted. co -. ry COMMENTS BY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC r - There were no members of the public present. FRATERNAL ORDER OF POLICE BUSINESS There were no representatives present from the Fraternal Olwerlof Police. w COMMUNICATIONS Letters of appreciation for services rendered by members of the Department were received from the following individuals: John M. Dempsey, David T. Glecker, and David A. Lopez . All communications were accepted and placed on file. "Equal Opportunity Employer" -2- CONFIRMATIONS , RESIGNATIONS , RETIREMENTS There were no confirmations, resignations, or retirements. COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DEPARTMENT Notification was received of the Dismissal of a Civil Rights Complaint filed by Rebecca Capetillo. This notification was accepted and placed on file. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Commissioner Jewell inquired about the Court overtime research project. Chief Boles explained that, especially with Budget restrictions, we are trying to identify the source of overtime and ways to reduce the amount of Court overtime. While the false alarm rate was down slightly from last month, it was determined that it is too soon to judge the effects of the new alarm ordinance. Commissioner Walker asked if the Department is developing new gang procedures to address that problem. Chief Boles explained that the Detective Bureau, Criminal Intelligence and REACH teams are working together on training bulletins and update communication. It was acknowledged that two departments (Michigan State University and Meridian Township) recently dropped out of the Tri-County Metro Narcotics Squad for economic reasons. There was an inquiry as to whether they would be replaced by other departments. Chief Boles was not aware of any additional investigators from any other departments joining the Metro Squad. The Departmental Highlights Report for December 1991 was accepted and placed on file. COMMITTEE REPORTS Awards - No report. Human Resources - No report. Budget - See Chief' s Comments. COMMISSIONERS ' COMMENTS Commissioner Kellogg commented on the recent CBS News coverage of the Lansing Police Department' s Community Policing program. A tape of the story will be shown at the next Board meeting. An update on the Community Policing program will also be presented at the next meeting. -3- CHIEF'S COMMENTS The Ingham County Law and Courts Committee has passed the resolution that would charge the City for the housing of ordinance violators in the County Jail. If the resolution is passed by the full County Board, the City will be charged as follows: 0-7 days-no charge; 7-14 days-$15 per day; 14+ days-$33 per day. It appears as though the proposal is moving forward. The Board of Review, after many hours, found that the actions of officers involved in the November 4, 1991 shooting death of Cipriano Torrez were justified in conformance with applicable laws, procedures, and rules. Several procedures are being reviewed by various divisions as the result of their meetings. As this is an ongoing process, Chief Boles will update the Board as recommendations are made. The Department submitted alternative 5% and 10% reduced Budgets to the Finance Department. We have not been asked to alter the existing Budget approved by this Board. It is - anticipated that the Mayor will make recommendations in March. Chief Boles will be involved in administrative hearings with the Mayor next month and will report to the Budget Committee and Board Chairpersons. The administrative reorganization recommended by this Board to the Mayor was approved and will be reflected in the organizational chart. The Department has been given approval to update video monitoring equipment in the Detention area. This is the first of three phases necessary in the Detention unit. The second phase is an automated suicide-risk profile to identify high-risk inmates. The third phase 'is .a request for three additional Detention Officers as recommended in the Budget proposal. Chief Boles discussed the Training Bulletin on Ethnic Intimidation Investigation Guidelines. The U.C.R. reporting (national reporting system) of an ethnic intimidation crime, now voluntary, will be mandatory within a few years. We are trying to comply voluntarily. Any ethnic intimidation crime receives mandatory follow-up investigation. The recent death in the City Jail was determined to be as the result of cardiac arrest due to intoxication from ingestion of windshield washer solvent. An investigation is underway to assure that procedures were followed. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. Respectfully submitted, Rhonda Yeo Secretary of the Board